SlideShare a Scribd company logo
But Were We Successful?
Using Online Asynchronous Focus Groups to Evaluate
Library Services
Rebekah Cummings
rebekah.cummings@utah.edu
Lindsay Ozburn
lindsay.ozburn@usu.edu
Andrea Payant
andrea.payant@usu.edu
Mike Shelton
michael.shelton@usu.edu
Ryan Bushman
ryan.bushman@usu.edu
Utah Library Association Conference - May 20, 2021
Why Was RDMS Created?
Why did Utah State University create a research data management services
program?
RDMS was created to comply with federal mandates stemming from the
2013 OSTP Memo on “Increasing Access to the Results of Federally
Funded Scientific Research.”
2013 OSTP Memo
In 2013 the Office of Science and Technology Policy issued a memorandum
titled:
“Increasing Access to the Results of Federally Funded Scientific Research”
• “The Administration is committed to ensuring that, to the greatest extent
and with the fewest constraints possible and consistent with law and the
objectives set out below, the direct results of federally funded scientific
research are made available to and useful for the public, industry, and the
scientific community. Such results include peer-reviewed publications and
digital data.”
• Stipulated that federal agencies with over $100M in R&D had to develop
plans to make publications and data that originated from federally funded
research freely available to the public.
What This Meant for Researchers:
● The need to maintain and make their data publicly
accessible, generally through data repositories.
● The need for their publications to be open access
and to generally have them listed in the funder’s
public access repository.
● The need to include information about any data
and publications created with their annual reports
to their funders.
● The inclusion of a data management plan with the
award applications.

Recommended for you

Oehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate StudentsOehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate Students

The presentation was provided by Angie Oehrli of the University of Michigan during the NISO Two-Part Webinar, Digital and Data Literacy, held on September 20, 2017

niso webinardigital literacydata literacy
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data ServicesRead Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services

This presentation was jointly given by Kevin Read and Alisa Surkis of New York University during the two-part NISO webinar, Digital and Data Literacy, held on September 20, 2017.

niso webinardata literacydigital literacy
Alexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
Alexander - Education in the Internet of EverythingAlexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
Alexander - Education in the Internet of Everything

This presentation was provided by consultant Bryan Alexander during a NISO webinar on the Internet of Things, held on October 19, 2016.

internet of thingstechnologyniso webinar
Utah State University recognized several needs necessary to help Primary Investigators (PI)
maintain compliance with funder mandates:
USU’s Response to the OSTP Memo:
• The need to create a Data Librarian position to assist researchers with their publications and data: Fulfilled in
Summer 2015.
• Bring campus stakeholders together to access needs and create a compliance program: In Autumn 2015 a cross-
campus group with members from the Office of Research and Graduate Studies (RGS), the Office of Information
Technology (IT), and the Merrill-Cazier Library started meeting to access how to best monitor and assist USU
researchers’ compliance.
• The needs to create and implement a University Research Data Policy and a process to create auditable records to
facilitate access to data and publications: By Autumn 2016 a plan was implemented that included the process for
award compliance tracking
USU’s Approach to Compliance:
USU decided to take an approach that facilitates the researchers’ ability to be in
Funder Compliance
USU worked to develop a compliance process that would:
• Demonstrate to Funders that the University is making good faith effort to comply with mandates.
• Emphasis to researchers that complying with funder mandates is an institutional priority.
• Demonstrate to researchers that resources are available to support them in meeting funder mandates to
make data openly accessible.
But Were We Successful: Using Online Asynchronous Focus Groups to Evaluate Library Services
Continued Support for RDMS from Administration
Both the Library and University administration recognizes that compliance to funder
mandates is an institutional priority. They continue to support RDMS in a variety of
ways:
• Monthly meetings of the University’s Research Data Management Committee, which is made up members from the Library
and the Office of Research. These meeting serve to discuss the needs of both RDMS and the researchers, news in the data
management field, and to develop instructional opportunities with the campus community.
• Once a semester the Library (via RDMS’s supervising Associate Dean) sponsors Data Club, a working lunch where PIs are
invited to visit with the RDMS staff and a representative from the Research Office to discuss their data concerns.
• In February 2020, the Library and Research office co-sponsored RDMS in conducting a half-day workshop called
“Datapalooza” geared toward teaching graduate students good data management practices. This was followed up in April
2021 with a second Zoom based Datapalooza event.

Recommended for you

NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...

1) E-book collections are a large part of many library collections but can be difficult for users to discover due to lack of metadata and disconnected management systems. 2) New opportunities exist to improve e-book discovery through unified knowledgebases, automated metadata feeds from publishers, and direct integration between knowledgebases and discovery services. 3) Libraries can benefit from reduced manual effort in managing e-book holdings and more timely access to e-books in discovery systems through automated processes for updating title lists and status changes.

Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"

This presentation was provided by Julie Goldman of Harvard University, during part two of the NISO two-part webinar "Building Data Science Skills: Strategic Support for the Work, Part Two," which was held on March 18, 2020.

niso webinardata scienceresearch
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning ProcessEnhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process

The document discusses enhancements to the DMPTool to further streamline the data management planning process. DMPTool2 will add new features like co-ownership of plans, self-service administration, and optional plan review. It will have improved governance and be jointly developed by additional partners. The goal is to better support the creation of data management plans, which are increasingly required for funding and publication.

data management plandmp
Establishing the Need for Program Assessment
•Association of American Universities (AAU) and the Association of Public & Land-Grant Universities
(APLU) working group conference
•Two members of RDMS, as well as the Interim Vice President of Research represented USU.
•Outcome: recognizing the need to assess the quality and effectiveness of the University’s
compliance program via RDMS’s efforts.
Assessing the compliance of federal mandates:
the library’s involvement
Early 2010’s…
• Federal organizations started requiring Data Management Plans to ensure research reproducibility
• Research reproducibility becomes a hot topic in LIS, with libraries examining what role they might play in
assisting their campus’ researchers with the reproducibility and accessibility of empirical research (Vitale,
2016)
o This led to a shift in academia = libraries become increasingly more engaged in campus research efforts and support.
• Emergence of RDMS programs and technical infrastructure as a support mechanism
Assessing the compliance of federal mandates:
the library’s involvement
Late 2010’s…
• Librarians and professional library orgs are more involved than ever in shaping policy and best practices for
RDMS in support of researchers
o Sparsely explored topic in LIS literature
• This research addresses the gap in literature and assessment of RDMS efforts
Our Assessment Methods
• Traditional survey coupled with an online asynchronous focus group (OAFG)
• Why two methods? Data triangulation
o Survey gave us a broad look at what works and what could be improved. OAFG dug
deeper into these questions to give us specifics for improvement
• OAFG discussion questions modeled after survey questions and results

Recommended for you

Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support servicesUsing the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support services

A presentation by David Millman, assistant dean for digital library technology services, New York University.

 
by Jisc
#jisccni18
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...

This presentation was provided by Colleen Cook of McGill University, during Session Seven of the NISO training series "Assessment Practices and Metrics in a 21st Century Pandemic," held on October 30, 2020.

niso training seriesassessment practices and metricslibrary assessment
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17

This talk was provided by Brian Lowe of Ontocale SRL during the NISO Virtual Conference, Using Open Source in Your Institution, held on February 17, 2016

open sourceniso virtual conference
Asynchronous Focus Groups as a Methodology: What are they?
• Focus groups conducted through online mediums where participants do not need
to be in the same place or online at the same time.
o Typically, they are given a time frame (2 day, for example) in which to participate
• Who uses them?
o Marketing- generating consumer insights that inform response to advertising
o Health - discussing healthcare issues with professionals across the globe (Han et al.,
2019; Ramo et al., 2019)
Pros and Cons of Asynchronous Focus Groups
Pros:
● Not bound in time and space as much; as
people can assemble to participate in
whatever time frame you give them
● Often, they have the potential to be
anonymous, which is helpful for sensitive
topics
● A lack of geographic boundaries helps increase
the diversity of a participant pool for specific
types of research projects
● In academia, busy faculty schedules are less of
a barrier for participation
Cons:
• Still dealing with the influence of social cues in
focus groups but in a much more presumptive
way (i.e., lack of vocal tone and eye contact can
lead to assumptions about someone’s answer).
• Previous forum posts can influence future posts
Why? While this is the case when speaking,
participants get more time to craft their answers
in online forums, leading to a higher potential
for influencing factors
• Ethical considerations of cyberspace: anonymity
could lead to people misrepresenting who they
are and/or sharing other participant’s responses
with others.
How did we use OAFG to assess our program?
• We used Canvas, an online learning platform that both USU and U of U had access
to.
• Of the team, we used the librarian at U of U as an outside moderator to encourage
honesty and to scrub data of identifiable information.
o Outside moderators are important with focus groups, in general, to prevent
unintentional biases in questions and to encourage honest answers from participants.
Hold Up.
You were assessing participants at one location
Why did you use an OAFG?

Recommended for you

Publisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
Publisher of the Community: We're All DoomedPublisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
Publisher of the Community: We're All Doomed

NISO Two Day Virtual Conference: Using the Web as an E-Content Distribution Platform: Challenges and Opportunities Oct 21-22, 2014 
 R. David Lankes, Dean’s Scholar for the New Librarianship at Syracuse University’s School of Information Studies; Director of the Information Institute of Syracuse

Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7

This presentation was provided by Jill Emery of Portland State University during a NISO webinar on the topic of OA and acquisitions, delivered on Sept 7, 2016

open accessniso webinarcollection development
Data Driven Libraries
Data Driven LibrariesData Driven Libraries
Data Driven Libraries

Melissa McLimans, a Community Liaison / Service Specialist who spends much of her time working in WiLS consulting services, traveled to Lake Geneva to present “Data Driven Libraries (link)” at the Lakeshore Library System’s Annual Trustees Dinner. As attendees enjoyed a lovely meal, Melissa shared examples of innovative and practical uses of data, including data dashboards and other methods to improve library decision-making process. Many of the examples came from WiLS’ strategic planning experiences or from libraries and library systems who are using data to make the best decisions possible. Many thanks to Lakeshore Library System’s Director, Steve Ohs, for the invitation and opportunity to talk data! If you have any questions or you're interested in learning more about Melissa's work, contact her at melissa@wils.org.

 
by WiLS
librariesdatapublic libraries
Pros and Cons of Asynchronous Focus Groups
Pros:
● Not bound in time and space as much; as
people can assemble to participate in
whatever time frame you give them
● Often, they have the potential to be
anonymous, which is helpful for sensitive
topics
● A lack of geographic boundaries helps increase
the diversity of a participant pool for specific
types of research projects
● In academia, busy faculty schedules are less of
a barrier for participation
Cons:
• Still dealing with the influence of social cues in
focus groups but in a much more presumptive
way (i.e., lack of vocal tone and eye contact can
lead to assumptions about someone’s answer).
• Previous forum posts can influence future posts
Why? While this is the case when speaking,
participants get more time to craft their answers
in online forums, leading to a higher potential
for influencing factors
• Ethical considerations of cyberspace: anonymity
could lead to people misrepresenting who they
are and/or sharing other participant’s responses
with others.
Qualities of Survey
• Population: 78 Researchers
• Sample: 28 Researchers
o Initial response of 32 researchers ( 41.03% of the population)
o Data cleaning determined 28 of respondents provided usable data (34.6% of population)
• Introduction of Bias
o We opted for a convenience sample rather than a randomized sample
The Survey
Two styles of question:
• Questions designed to determine the frequency of a behavior of the researcher often used the following
scale
o Never
o 0-3 times (a redundancy we would like to fix in further research projects)
o 4-7 times
o 8-10 times
o More than 10 times
• Questions designed to determines a researcher's response to USU’s efforts used the following scale
o Strongly Disagree
o Somewhat Disagree
o Neither Agree Nor Disagree
o Somewhat Agree
o Strongly Agree
Key Statistics
• 19 of the 27 (70.4%) respondents indicated they had three or fewer awards that
required deposit of publications into a public access repository
• 18 of the 27 (66.67%) respondents indicated they had three or fewer awards that
required deposit of data into a publicly accessible repository.
• “Could Sponsored Programs or the Library better facilitate efforts to meet agency
mandates?”
o 13 of 27 (48.15%) responded yes
o 14 (51.85%) responded no.
o When examined by years as a researcher, a higher percentage of respondents in the range of 11-20
years as a researcher responded “yes” to this question.

Recommended for you

Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data LiteracyWebb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy

This presentation was provided by Katy Kavanagh Webb of East Carolina University during the first portion of the NISO two-part webinar, Digital and Data Literacy, held on September 13, 2017

niso webinardigital literacystudent literacy
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...

This document discusses efforts by a research librarian at City University London to improve digital literacy support for researchers. The librarian conducted a questionnaire that informed the development of a Library Researcher Development Programme. A blog and case study resource were also created. Based on researcher feedback, workshops were held on topics like using social media and open access publishing. The librarian is now conducting further research to identify factors influencing researchers' digital literacy in order to guide future instruction. The conclusion emphasizes engaging researchers and using their work to enhance information literacy support through research-based practice.

infolitlilac16lilac
Reveal Digital: innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
Reveal Digital:  innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...Reveal Digital:  innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
Reveal Digital: innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...

Slides from a webinar held on 1 Dec 2016 by Jisc and Reveal Digital on Reveal Digital's library crowdfunding model for their Independent Voices digital collection. This includes information on pledging fees for UK universities as negotiated by Jisc Collections. A recording of the webinar is available at https://goo.gl/kEHRrD.

digitisedopen accessdigital collections
Key Statistics: Behavior of the Researcher
• Motive for making data publicly available
o 84.6% to comply with journal publishing requirements
o 92.6% to satisfy a funder
o 61.5% with the desire for their data to be public
• 92.59% of respondents indicated that they anticipated writing journal publications
up to 5 years after the close of their award
• 88.46% of respondents anticipated needing up to 4 years after the close of their
award to have final data ready for deposit in a public repository
Key Statistics: Response to USU’s Efforts
• The email from SPO was helpful
o 20 (74.07%) strongly agree
o 5 (18.52%) somewhat agree
• Researchers understand how to respond to the email
from SPO
o 13 (48.15%) strongly agree
o 7 (25.93%) somewhat agree
o 5 (18.52%) somewhat disagree
• The email from SPO explains how they could find more
help
o 16 (59.26%) strongly agree
o 8 (29.63%) somewhat agree
o 2 (7.41%) somewhat disagree
• The email from DL was helpful
o 11 (64.71%) strongly agree
o 5 (29.41 % somewhat agree
o 1 (5.88%) somewhat disagrees
• Researchers understand how to respond to email from
DL
o 11 (64.71%) strongly agree
o 4 (23.53%) somewhat agree
o 2 (11.76%) neither agree nor disagree
• The email from DL explains how they could find more
help
o 11 (64.71%) strongly agree
o 5 (29.41%) somewhat agree
o 1 (5.88%) somewhat disagree
Online Asynchronous Focus
Groups (OAFG)
SOCIALLY DISTANCED BEFORE IT
WAS COOL
• SECURE
• FAMILIAR
• ALLOWED FOR DISCUSSION
• RESPOND IN LINE
• TECHNICAL SUPPORT
Technology

Recommended for you

Varnum apr20-4
Varnum apr20-4Varnum apr20-4
Varnum apr20-4

This presentation was provided by Ken Varnum of the University of Michigan for a NISO Virtual Conference, held on April 20, 2016.

nisoniso virtual conferencelibrary assessment
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research ReputationWarren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation

This presentation was provided by Scott Warren and Anne Rauh of Syracuse University during the NISO virtual conference, Research Information Systems: The Connections Enabling Collaboration, held on August 16, 2017.

niso virtual conferenceresearch information managementinformation systems
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research servicesSlides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services

Slides from the Nov. 8, 2016 Library Connect webinar "Targeting the librarian’s role in research services" with Nina Exner, Amanda Horsman and Mark Reed. See the full webinar at: http://libraryconnect.elsevier.com/library-connect-webinars?commid=223121

librariansacademic librariansresearch services
Five Discussions
Introductions Response to funder
mandates
Researcher data
practices &
publication deposit
Research
Office and Library
program
What would help?
First Attempt
• Selected 15 participants at random
• VP for Research invited the fifteen participants
to join the OAFG at their convenience the
following day
• With only a single day’s notice, only two of the
fifteen participants responded, and they,
inexplicably, couldn’t get into the Canvas site.
Second Attempt
• Moved Canvas site from University of Utah to USU
• Gave participants several weeks of advance notice
• Confirmed attendance with five participants, but only three
showed up
• Good news! The three participants gave excellent, detailed
feedback, interacted with one another, and didn’t have any
technical issues
Qualitative Data Analysis
1. Praise for the Data Librarian, the library, and the research office (16
statements)
2. Data sharing challenges (6 statements)
3. Data resources (such as DMP Tool, FigShare, Digital Commons,
Metavist,Morpho) (10 statements)
4. Appropriate time to make data available (6 statements)
5. Open Access (7 statements)
6. Actionable steps USU can do to help researchers (6 statements)

Recommended for you

The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...

Led by Helen Blanchett, subject specialist, scholarly communications, Jisc. With contribution from Andrew Simpson, associate university librarian (procurement and metadata and systems), Portsmouth University. In this session you’ll hear in this session you’ll hear about the benefits and challenges of open access. Connect more in London, 28 June 2016

 
by Jisc
connectmore16
Qs1 group a
Qs1 group a Qs1 group a
Qs1 group a

This document summarizes the Library Impact Data Project, which aimed to show correlations between library usage data (books borrowed, e-resources accessed) and student attainment across multiple universities. Phase 1 found statistical significance between library usage and grades. Phase 2 added more student data points and found further correlations with demographics. The project aims to create a shared analytics service to allow libraries to analyze usage and benchmark against peers. Key areas for the next phase include developing an intuitive dashboard, addressing ethical issues around profiling individuals, and integrating additional data sources.

Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21

Athenaeum21 presents three case studies of assessment and evaluation programs in libraries--one past, one current, and one future. The cases use three different modes of data gathering and analysis to show the power of understanding user needs and how well your organization is meeting them.

strategyanalyticsassessment
Findings – Participants don’t love data sharing
“Honestly, when I first heard that Federal agencies required
researchers to make all the raw data available to the public I
thought: “Really? This is useless and opens the door for a lot of
plagiarism.” I still feel that way a little bit. It’s one thing to have open
access journals where everybody has the chance to download the
paper, but making data available (even after the paper has been
published) is a little bit too risky… I don’t make any data available
until after the paper has been published.”
Findings – Participants appreciate current services
“What helps me? Betty!!! She is great! As
[another participant] mentioned, when I have
to upload anything, Betty is my first point of
contact. I know that I get excellent information
from her.”
Findings – What could help?
• Meet with the Data Librarian after receiving an award
• Checking to see what publications can be uploaded and updating PI records
accordingly
• Depositing data and publications on behalf of researchers
• Custom support for any agency requirements
• Sending reminders beyond the close of the award, until the PI notified the Data
Librarian that all data and publications related to the award have been deposited
• Help paying open access fees.
Summary
• Pioneering the USU compliance tracking program
• Identifying the need for a program assessment
o Goals
 Understanding researcher behavior
 Evaluating response to USU’s compliance tracking program
o Methods
 Survey
 OAFG
• Qualitative data analysis and findings

Recommended for you

Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital ResourcesData-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources

This session will provide three case studies of assessment and evaluation programs in libraries--one past, one current, and one future. The cases use three different modes of data gathering and analysis and show the power of understanding user needs and how well your organization is meeting them.

librarieslibrary assessment
Case sStudy
Case sStudyCase sStudy
Case sStudy

This study evaluated the impact of an information literacy course on preservice teachers' skills. It compared a treatment group of 16 students who took the course to a comparison group of 10 students who did not. Both groups completed a questionnaire and thinking-aloud tasks involving finding articles, evaluating websites, and selecting Web 2.0 tools. Results showed the treatment group performed better on skills tests and demonstrated more familiarity with resources. However, neither group excellently completed all tasks. The study concluded that while the course helped, an enhanced long-term instruction program is needed to fully develop teachers' twenty-first century information literacy abilities.

digital information literacycase studyreview of articles
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...

This document summarizes a presentation about supporting quantitative methods teaching with large survey data. It discusses the UK Data Service, which provides access to social science data. Understanding Society, a large longitudinal survey of 40,000 UK households, is highlighted as a potentially useful teaching resource. The presentation describes creating short videos, guides, teaching datasets and materials to make Understanding Society more accessible for teaching. These resources aim to introduce students to large datasets and quantitative analysis in a straightforward way, providing a stepping stone to working with larger "Big Data" sources. Case studies show how other universities have successfully used survey data for methods teaching.

big datahigher educationquantitative research
Lessons Learned
• Survey
o Data representative of a portion of researchers
 Convenience vs. Randomized – taking a randomized sample makes the data more representative of
the population
o Work with someone that has statistical expertise
• OAFG
o Timing and buy in
o Platform needs
How our results will shape future services
• Clarification or requirements expected by individual funders
o Continue updating to data management services website
o Continue to tailor reminder emails to include links to resources for each PI’s agency information about
requirements​​
o The library is currently changing the workflow to include additional help post close-out of awards
o Improved communication from the USU Libraries and Sponsored Programs
• Further investigation and research
o Improving interaction with researchers less inclined to think Sponsored Programs/USU Libraries can help
them meet agency requirements to deposit publications and data
Future of the Project
• Developing a culture of responsible data stewardship
o Understanding research hesitancy to share data
o Further sessions
 When data should be released
 Data citation
 Data licensing
 Effective methods for describing research data
Read our article:
Rebekah Cummings, Lindsay Ozburn, Andrea Payant, Betty Rozum, Michael Shelton & Ryan Bushman
(2020) Assessing Research Compliance for Federally Funded Projects: The Good, the Bad, and the
Publicly Accessible, Journal of Library Administration, 60:7, 726-751, DOI:
10.1080/01930826.2020.1786985
Learn More

Recommended for you

Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016

This document provides an overview of Therese Kennelly Okraku's research prospectus on scientific collaboration and barriers at a university. The research will use mixed methods including surveys, interviews, social network analysis, and participant observation to identify barriers to collaboration, evaluate how tenure influences collaboration, develop metrics for impact beyond academia, and identify emerging research fields. The research is being conducted at the University of Florida and aims to provide recommendations to reduce barriers and better recognize team science in order to encourage collaboration.

Survey development
Survey developmentSurvey development
Survey development

Powerpoint on Survey Development in libraries by LIS 2830 students Dana Alsup, Katie DeRusso, Michele Farina, Sarah Loudenslager, Sara Tekavec (Spring 2011).

It resource needsassessment
It resource needsassessmentIt resource needsassessment
It resource needsassessment

This report summarizes the findings of a needs assessment conducted by the IT Resource Sharing Group regarding operational and reporting needs for student data at the University of Washington. The assessment found that while Schools share many common information needs, they also have unique needs. It also found a lack of awareness about existing central systems and a proliferation of "shadow systems" developed by individual units. The report concludes there is high frustration over access to and analysis of student data. It recommends acknowledging decentralized systems and creating processes to support secure and productive development across the university.

Thanks!
Do you have any questions?
Rebekah Cummings
rebekah.cummings@utah.edu
Lindsay Ozburn
lindsay.ozburn@usu.edu
Andrea Payant
andrea.payant@usu.edu
Mike Shelton
michael.shelton@usu.edu
Ryan Bushman
ryan.bushman@usu.edu

More Related Content

What's hot

MARC-y MARC and the Coding Bunch
MARC-y MARC and the Coding BunchMARC-y MARC and the Coding Bunch
MARC-y MARC and the Coding Bunch
Andrea Payant
 
Crowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USU
Crowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USUCrowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USU
Crowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USU
Andrea Payant
 
Relationship status: Libraries and linked data in Europe
Relationship status: Libraries and linked data in EuropeRelationship status: Libraries and linked data in Europe
Relationship status: Libraries and linked data in Europe
Diane Rasmussen Pennington
 
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate StudentsOehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data ServicesRead Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Alexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
Alexander - Education in the Internet of EverythingAlexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
Alexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning ProcessEnhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
University of California Curation Center
 
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support servicesUsing the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Jisc
 
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
Publisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
Publisher of the Community: We're All DoomedPublisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
Publisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Data Driven Libraries
Data Driven LibrariesData Driven Libraries
Data Driven Libraries
WiLS
 
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data LiteracyWebb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
 
Reveal Digital: innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
Reveal Digital:  innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...Reveal Digital:  innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
Reveal Digital: innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
PaolaMarchionni
 
Varnum apr20-4
Varnum apr20-4Varnum apr20-4
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research ReputationWarren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 

What's hot (20)

MARC-y MARC and the Coding Bunch
MARC-y MARC and the Coding BunchMARC-y MARC and the Coding Bunch
MARC-y MARC and the Coding Bunch
 
Crowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USU
Crowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USUCrowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USU
Crowdsourcing Metadata Practices at USU
 
Relationship status: Libraries and linked data in Europe
Relationship status: Libraries and linked data in EuropeRelationship status: Libraries and linked data in Europe
Relationship status: Libraries and linked data in Europe
 
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate StudentsOehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
Oehrli - Creating Data Literate Students
 
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data ServicesRead Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
Read Surkis Facilitating Development of Research Data Services
 
Alexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
Alexander - Education in the Internet of EverythingAlexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
Alexander - Education in the Internet of Everything
 
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
NISO/BISG Changing Standards Landscape: EBook Discovery and Requirements for ...
 
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
Goldman "Collaboratively Build Data Science Services and Skills"
 
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning ProcessEnhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
Enhancing DMPTool: Further Streamlineing Data Mangement Planning Process
 
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support servicesUsing the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
Using the research lifecycle to design technology and support services
 
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
Cook "Using Library Assessment Data in Senior Decision Making: A Perspective ...
 
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
Lowe NISO virtual conf feb17
 
Publisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
Publisher of the Community: We're All DoomedPublisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
Publisher of the Community: We're All Doomed
 
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
Emery - Buying Openly - NISO Sept 7
 
Data Driven Libraries
Data Driven LibrariesData Driven Libraries
Data Driven Libraries
 
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data LiteracyWebb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
Webb -- Libraries Supporting Media and Data Literacy
 
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
Expert engagement: practical researcher digital literacy provision at City - ...
 
Reveal Digital: innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
Reveal Digital:  innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...Reveal Digital:  innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
Reveal Digital: innovative library crowdfunding model for open access digita...
 
Varnum apr20-4
Varnum apr20-4Varnum apr20-4
Varnum apr20-4
 
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research ReputationWarren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
Warren & Rauh Creating a Culture of Research Reputation
 

Similar to But Were We Successful: Using Online Asynchronous Focus Groups to Evaluate Library Services

Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research servicesSlides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Library_Connect
 
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
Jisc
 
Qs1 group a
Qs1 group a Qs1 group a
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Megan Hurst
 
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital ResourcesData-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Christine Madsen
 
Case sStudy
Case sStudyCase sStudy
Case sStudy
Quratulain saleem
 
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
The Higher Education Academy
 
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Therese Kennelly Okraku
 
Survey development
Survey developmentSurvey development
Survey development
Jessica Danielle Smith
 
It resource needsassessment
It resource needsassessmentIt resource needsassessment
It resource needsassessment
MARIUM NASIR
 
Ps rwebinar january2019final
Ps rwebinar january2019finalPs rwebinar january2019final
Ps rwebinar january2019final
Margaret Henderson
 
Social science research methods for libraries
Social science research methods for librariesSocial science research methods for libraries
Social science research methods for libraries
CILIPScotland
 
SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...
SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...
SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...
Library_Connect
 
RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...
RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...
RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...
ASIS&T
 
Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...
Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...
Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited
6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited
6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited
Shawna Reibling
 
Virginia Power MmIT 2015
Virginia Power MmIT 2015Virginia Power MmIT 2015
Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013
Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013
Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013
Sanjeev Deshmukh
 
Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...
Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...
Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
 
RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...
RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...
RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...
ASIS&T
 

Similar to But Were We Successful: Using Online Asynchronous Focus Groups to Evaluate Library Services (20)

Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research servicesSlides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
Slides | Targeting the librarian’s role in research services
 
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
The benefits and challenges of open access: lessons from practice - Helen Bla...
 
Qs1 group a
Qs1 group a Qs1 group a
Qs1 group a
 
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
Data-Informed Decision Making for Libraries - Athenaeum21
 
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital ResourcesData-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
Data-Informed Decision Making for Digital Resources
 
Case sStudy
Case sStudyCase sStudy
Case sStudy
 
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
Stepping stones to ‘big data’: supporting quantitative methods teaching with ...
 
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
Okraku_Research Prospectus Outline_042016
 
Survey development
Survey developmentSurvey development
Survey development
 
It resource needsassessment
It resource needsassessmentIt resource needsassessment
It resource needsassessment
 
Ps rwebinar january2019final
Ps rwebinar january2019finalPs rwebinar january2019final
Ps rwebinar january2019final
 
Social science research methods for libraries
Social science research methods for librariesSocial science research methods for libraries
Social science research methods for libraries
 
SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...
SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...
SLIDES | High-impact library services and outreach: Student success * Systema...
 
RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...
RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...
RDAP 15 Co-circular RDM: A Pilot service for Graduate Students at the Univers...
 
Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...
Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...
Chu and Hensley "Strategic Planning and the Experience of the University of I...
 
6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited
6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited
6 oct15 writing kmb plan edited
 
Virginia Power MmIT 2015
Virginia Power MmIT 2015Virginia Power MmIT 2015
Virginia Power MmIT 2015
 
Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013
Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013
Trends in-connecting-research-sgd-2013
 
Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...
Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...
Reviewing the role of teaching librarians in supporting student's digital cap...
 
RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...
RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...
RDAP14 Poster: Samantha Guss Data management planning and responsible conduct...
 

More from Andrea Payant

Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...
Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...
Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...
Andrea Payant
 
On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!
On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!
On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!
Andrea Payant
 
Let's Get Digital!
Let's Get Digital!Let's Get Digital!
Let's Get Digital!
Andrea Payant
 
The Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for Everyone
The Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for EveryoneThe Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for Everyone
The Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for Everyone
Andrea Payant
 
Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...
Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...
Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...
Andrea Payant
 
Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...
Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...
Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...
Andrea Payant
 
Research Data Management at USU
Research Data Management at USUResearch Data Management at USU
Research Data Management at USU
Andrea Payant
 
liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...
liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...
liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...
Andrea Payant
 
Homeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote Work
Homeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote WorkHomeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote Work
Homeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote Work
Andrea Payant
 
Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...
Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...
Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...
Andrea Payant
 
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDs
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDsGiving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDs
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDs
Andrea Payant
 
VOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at Teamwork
VOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at TeamworkVOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at Teamwork
VOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at Teamwork
Andrea Payant
 
Retooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your Impact
Retooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your ImpactRetooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your Impact
Retooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your Impact
Andrea Payant
 
ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...
ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...
ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...
Andrea Payant
 

More from Andrea Payant (14)

Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...
Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...
Avoiding a Level of Discontent in Finding Aids: An Analysis of User Engagemen...
 
On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!
On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!
On Your MARC, Get Set, Code!
 
Let's Get Digital!
Let's Get Digital!Let's Get Digital!
Let's Get Digital!
 
The Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for Everyone
The Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for EveryoneThe Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for Everyone
The Missing Link: Metadata Conversion Workflows for Everyone
 
Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...
Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...
Mitigating the Risk: identifying Strategic University Partnerships for Compli...
 
Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...
Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...
Just Keep Cataloging: How One Cataloging Unit Changed Their Workflows to Fit ...
 
Research Data Management at USU
Research Data Management at USUResearch Data Management at USU
Research Data Management at USU
 
liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...
liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...
liwalaawiiloxhbakaa (How We Lived): The Grant Bulltail Absáalooke (Crow Natio...
 
Homeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote Work
Homeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote WorkHomeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote Work
Homeward Bound: How to Move an Entire Cataloging Unit to Remote Work
 
Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...
Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...
Memes of Resistance, Election Reflections, and Voices from Drug Court: Social...
 
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDs
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDsGiving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDs
Giving Credit Where Credit is Due: Author and Funder IDs
 
VOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at Teamwork
VOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at TeamworkVOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at Teamwork
VOCAB for Collaboration: How “Work Language” Can Help You Win at Teamwork
 
Retooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your Impact
Retooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your ImpactRetooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your Impact
Retooling Your Story: Using Visualizations to Demonstrate Your Impact
 
ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...
ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...
ARK de Triumph: Linking Finding Aids & Digital Libraries Using a Low-Tech App...
 

Recently uploaded

How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17
How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17
How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
SYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING
SYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISINGSYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING
SYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING
Dr Vijay Vishwakarma
 
AI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdf
AI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdfAI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdf
AI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdf
SrimanigandanMadurai
 
Ardra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and Remedies
Ardra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and RemediesArdra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and Remedies
Ardra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and Remedies
Astro Pathshala
 
The basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptx
heathfieldcps1
 
Front Desk Management in the Odoo 17 ERP
Front Desk  Management in the Odoo 17 ERPFront Desk  Management in the Odoo 17 ERP
Front Desk Management in the Odoo 17 ERP
Celine George
 
Principles of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptx
Principles of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptxPrinciples of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptx
Principles of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptx
ibtesaam huma
 
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
MysoreMuleSoftMeetup
 
"DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ...
"DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ..."DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ...
"DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ...
thanhluan21
 
Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17
Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17
Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERP
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERPThe membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERP
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERP
Celine George
 
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894
PECB
 
2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference
2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference
2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference
KlettWorldLanguages
 
Split Shifts From Gantt View in the Odoo 17
Split Shifts From Gantt View in the  Odoo 17Split Shifts From Gantt View in the  Odoo 17
Split Shifts From Gantt View in the Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?
Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?
Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?
Rakesh Jalan
 
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024
Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024
Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024
Elizabeth Walsh
 
ENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUM
ENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUMENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUM
ENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUM
HappieMontevirgenCas
 
NAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource Book
NAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource BookNAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource Book
NAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource Book
lakitawilson
 

Recently uploaded (20)

How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17
How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17
How to Handle the Separate Discount Account on Invoice in Odoo 17
 
SYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING
SYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISINGSYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING
SYBCOM SEM III UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO ADVERTISING
 
AI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdf
AI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdfAI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdf
AI_in_HR_Presentation Part 1 2024 0703.pdf
 
Ardra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and Remedies
Ardra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and RemediesArdra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and Remedies
Ardra Nakshatra (आर्द्रा): Understanding its Effects and Remedies
 
The basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptxThe basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptx
The basics of sentences session 9pptx.pptx
 
Front Desk Management in the Odoo 17 ERP
Front Desk  Management in the Odoo 17 ERPFront Desk  Management in the Odoo 17 ERP
Front Desk Management in the Odoo 17 ERP
 
Principles of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptx
Principles of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptxPrinciples of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptx
Principles of Roods Approach!!!!!!!.pptx
 
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
 
"DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ...
"DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ..."DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ...
"DANH SÁCH THÍ SINH XÉT TUYỂN SỚM ĐỦ ĐIỀU KIỆN TRÚNG TUYỂN ĐẠI HỌC CHÍNH QUY ...
 
Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17
Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17
Views in Odoo - Advanced Views - Pivot View in Odoo 17
 
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERP
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERPThe membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERP
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERP
 
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894
 
2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference
2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference
2024 KWL Back 2 School Summer Conference
 
Split Shifts From Gantt View in the Odoo 17
Split Shifts From Gantt View in the  Odoo 17Split Shifts From Gantt View in the  Odoo 17
Split Shifts From Gantt View in the Odoo 17
 
Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?
Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?
Is Email Marketing Really Effective In 2024?
 
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17
 
Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024
Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024
Howe Writing Center - Orientation Summer 2024
 
ENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUM
ENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUMENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUM
ENGLISH-7-CURRICULUM MAP- MATATAG CURRICULUM
 
“A NOSSA CA(U)SA”. .
“A NOSSA CA(U)SA”.                      .“A NOSSA CA(U)SA”.                      .
“A NOSSA CA(U)SA”. .
 
NAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource Book
NAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource BookNAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource Book
NAEYC Code of Ethical Conduct Resource Book
 

But Were We Successful: Using Online Asynchronous Focus Groups to Evaluate Library Services

  • 1. But Were We Successful? Using Online Asynchronous Focus Groups to Evaluate Library Services Rebekah Cummings rebekah.cummings@utah.edu Lindsay Ozburn lindsay.ozburn@usu.edu Andrea Payant andrea.payant@usu.edu Mike Shelton michael.shelton@usu.edu Ryan Bushman ryan.bushman@usu.edu Utah Library Association Conference - May 20, 2021
  • 2. Why Was RDMS Created? Why did Utah State University create a research data management services program? RDMS was created to comply with federal mandates stemming from the 2013 OSTP Memo on “Increasing Access to the Results of Federally Funded Scientific Research.”
  • 3. 2013 OSTP Memo In 2013 the Office of Science and Technology Policy issued a memorandum titled: “Increasing Access to the Results of Federally Funded Scientific Research” • “The Administration is committed to ensuring that, to the greatest extent and with the fewest constraints possible and consistent with law and the objectives set out below, the direct results of federally funded scientific research are made available to and useful for the public, industry, and the scientific community. Such results include peer-reviewed publications and digital data.” • Stipulated that federal agencies with over $100M in R&D had to develop plans to make publications and data that originated from federally funded research freely available to the public.
  • 4. What This Meant for Researchers: ● The need to maintain and make their data publicly accessible, generally through data repositories. ● The need for their publications to be open access and to generally have them listed in the funder’s public access repository. ● The need to include information about any data and publications created with their annual reports to their funders. ● The inclusion of a data management plan with the award applications.
  • 5. Utah State University recognized several needs necessary to help Primary Investigators (PI) maintain compliance with funder mandates: USU’s Response to the OSTP Memo: • The need to create a Data Librarian position to assist researchers with their publications and data: Fulfilled in Summer 2015. • Bring campus stakeholders together to access needs and create a compliance program: In Autumn 2015 a cross- campus group with members from the Office of Research and Graduate Studies (RGS), the Office of Information Technology (IT), and the Merrill-Cazier Library started meeting to access how to best monitor and assist USU researchers’ compliance. • The needs to create and implement a University Research Data Policy and a process to create auditable records to facilitate access to data and publications: By Autumn 2016 a plan was implemented that included the process for award compliance tracking
  • 6. USU’s Approach to Compliance: USU decided to take an approach that facilitates the researchers’ ability to be in Funder Compliance USU worked to develop a compliance process that would: • Demonstrate to Funders that the University is making good faith effort to comply with mandates. • Emphasis to researchers that complying with funder mandates is an institutional priority. • Demonstrate to researchers that resources are available to support them in meeting funder mandates to make data openly accessible.
  • 8. Continued Support for RDMS from Administration Both the Library and University administration recognizes that compliance to funder mandates is an institutional priority. They continue to support RDMS in a variety of ways: • Monthly meetings of the University’s Research Data Management Committee, which is made up members from the Library and the Office of Research. These meeting serve to discuss the needs of both RDMS and the researchers, news in the data management field, and to develop instructional opportunities with the campus community. • Once a semester the Library (via RDMS’s supervising Associate Dean) sponsors Data Club, a working lunch where PIs are invited to visit with the RDMS staff and a representative from the Research Office to discuss their data concerns. �� In February 2020, the Library and Research office co-sponsored RDMS in conducting a half-day workshop called “Datapalooza” geared toward teaching graduate students good data management practices. This was followed up in April 2021 with a second Zoom based Datapalooza event.
  • 9. Establishing the Need for Program Assessment •Association of American Universities (AAU) and the Association of Public & Land-Grant Universities (APLU) working group conference •Two members of RDMS, as well as the Interim Vice President of Research represented USU. •Outcome: recognizing the need to assess the quality and effectiveness of the University’s compliance program via RDMS’s efforts.
  • 10. Assessing the compliance of federal mandates: the library’s involvement Early 2010’s… • Federal organizations started requiring Data Management Plans to ensure research reproducibility • Research reproducibility becomes a hot topic in LIS, with libraries examining what role they might play in assisting their campus’ researchers with the reproducibility and accessibility of empirical research (Vitale, 2016) o This led to a shift in academia = libraries become increasingly more engaged in campus research efforts and support. • Emergence of RDMS programs and technical infrastructure as a support mechanism
  • 11. Assessing the compliance of federal mandates: the library’s involvement Late 2010’s… • Librarians and professional library orgs are more involved than ever in shaping policy and best practices for RDMS in support of researchers o Sparsely explored topic in LIS literature • This research addresses the gap in literature and assessment of RDMS efforts
  • 12. Our Assessment Methods • Traditional survey coupled with an online asynchronous focus group (OAFG) • Why two methods? Data triangulation o Survey gave us a broad look at what works and what could be improved. OAFG dug deeper into these questions to give us specifics for improvement • OAFG discussion questions modeled after survey questions and results
  • 13. Asynchronous Focus Groups as a Methodology: What are they? • Focus groups conducted through online mediums where participants do not need to be in the same place or online at the same time. o Typically, they are given a time frame (2 day, for example) in which to participate • Who uses them? o Marketing- generating consumer insights that inform response to advertising o Health - discussing healthcare issues with professionals across the globe (Han et al., 2019; Ramo et al., 2019)
  • 14. Pros and Cons of Asynchronous Focus Groups Pros: ● Not bound in time and space as much; as people can assemble to participate in whatever time frame you give them ● Often, they have the potential to be anonymous, which is helpful for sensitive topics ● A lack of geographic boundaries helps increase the diversity of a participant pool for specific types of research projects ● In academia, busy faculty schedules are less of a barrier for participation Cons: • Still dealing with the influence of social cues in focus groups but in a much more presumptive way (i.e., lack of vocal tone and eye contact can lead to assumptions about someone’s answer). • Previous forum posts can influence future posts Why? While this is the case when speaking, participants get more time to craft their answers in online forums, leading to a higher potential for influencing factors • Ethical considerations of cyberspace: anonymity could lead to people misrepresenting who they are and/or sharing other participant’s responses with others.
  • 15. How did we use OAFG to assess our program? • We used Canvas, an online learning platform that both USU and U of U had access to. • Of the team, we used the librarian at U of U as an outside moderator to encourage honesty and to scrub data of identifiable information. o Outside moderators are important with focus groups, in general, to prevent unintentional biases in questions and to encourage honest answers from participants.
  • 16. Hold Up. You were assessing participants at one location Why did you use an OAFG?
  • 17. Pros and Cons of Asynchronous Focus Groups Pros: ● Not bound in time and space as much; as people can assemble to participate in whatever time frame you give them ● Often, they have the potential to be anonymous, which is helpful for sensitive topics ● A lack of geographic boundaries helps increase the diversity of a participant pool for specific types of research projects ● In academia, busy faculty schedules are less of a barrier for participation Cons: • Still dealing with the influence of social cues in focus groups but in a much more presumptive way (i.e., lack of vocal tone and eye contact can lead to assumptions about someone’s answer). • Previous forum posts can influence future posts Why? While this is the case when speaking, participants get more time to craft their answers in online forums, leading to a higher potential for influencing factors • Ethical considerations of cyberspace: anonymity could lead to people misrepresenting who they are and/or sharing other participant’s responses with others.
  • 18. Qualities of Survey • Population: 78 Researchers • Sample: 28 Researchers o Initial response of 32 researchers ( 41.03% of the population) o Data cleaning determined 28 of respondents provided usable data (34.6% of population) • Introduction of Bias o We opted for a convenience sample rather than a randomized sample
  • 19. The Survey Two styles of question: • Questions designed to determine the frequency of a behavior of the researcher often used the following scale o Never o 0-3 times (a redundancy we would like to fix in further research projects) o 4-7 times o 8-10 times o More than 10 times • Questions designed to determines a researcher's response to USU’s efforts used the following scale o Strongly Disagree o Somewhat Disagree o Neither Agree Nor Disagree o Somewhat Agree o Strongly Agree
  • 20. Key Statistics • 19 of the 27 (70.4%) respondents indicated they had three or fewer awards that required deposit of publications into a public access repository • 18 of the 27 (66.67%) respondents indicated they had three or fewer awards that required deposit of data into a publicly accessible repository. • “Could Sponsored Programs or the Library better facilitate efforts to meet agency mandates?” o 13 of 27 (48.15%) responded yes o 14 (51.85%) responded no. o When examined by years as a researcher, a higher percentage of respondents in the range of 11-20 years as a researcher responded “yes” to this question.
  • 21. Key Statistics: Behavior of the Researcher • Motive for making data publicly available o 84.6% to comply with journal publishing requirements o 92.6% to satisfy a funder o 61.5% with the desire for their data to be public • 92.59% of respondents indicated that they anticipated writing journal publications up to 5 years after the close of their award • 88.46% of respondents anticipated needing up to 4 years after the close of their award to have final data ready for deposit in a public repository
  • 22. Key Statistics: Response to USU’s Efforts • The email from SPO was helpful o 20 (74.07%) strongly agree o 5 (18.52%) somewhat agree • Researchers understand how to respond to the email from SPO o 13 (48.15%) strongly agree o 7 (25.93%) somewhat agree o 5 (18.52%) somewhat disagree • The email from SPO explains how they could find more help o 16 (59.26%) strongly agree o 8 (29.63%) somewhat agree o 2 (7.41%) somewhat disagree • The email from DL was helpful o 11 (64.71%) strongly agree o 5 (29.41 % somewhat agree o 1 (5.88%) somewhat disagrees • Researchers understand how to respond to email from DL o 11 (64.71%) strongly agree o 4 (23.53%) somewhat agree o 2 (11.76%) neither agree nor disagree • The email from DL explains how they could find more help o 11 (64.71%) strongly agree o 5 (29.41%) somewhat agree o 1 (5.88%) somewhat disagree
  • 23. Online Asynchronous Focus Groups (OAFG) SOCIALLY DISTANCED BEFORE IT WAS COOL
  • 24. • SECURE • FAMILIAR • ALLOWED FOR DISCUSSION • RESPOND IN LINE • TECHNICAL SUPPORT Technology
  • 25. Five Discussions Introductions Response to funder mandates Researcher data practices & publication deposit Research Office and Library program What would help?
  • 26. First Attempt • Selected 15 participants at random • VP for Research invited the fifteen participants to join the OAFG at their convenience the following day • With only a single day’s notice, only two of the fifteen participants responded, and they, inexplicably, couldn’t get into the Canvas site.
  • 27. Second Attempt • Moved Canvas site from University of Utah to USU • Gave participants several weeks of advance notice • Confirmed attendance with five participants, but only three showed up • Good news! The three participants gave excellent, detailed feedback, interacted with one another, and didn’t have any technical issues
  • 28. Qualitative Data Analysis 1. Praise for the Data Librarian, the library, and the research office (16 statements) 2. Data sharing challenges (6 statements) 3. Data resources (such as DMP Tool, FigShare, Digital Commons, Metavist,Morpho) (10 statements) 4. Appropriate time to make data available (6 statements) 5. Open Access (7 statements) 6. Actionable steps USU can do to help researchers (6 statements)
  • 29. Findings – Participants don’t love data sharing “Honestly, when I first heard that Federal agencies required researchers to make all the raw data available to the public I thought: “Really? This is useless and opens the door for a lot of plagiarism.” I still feel that way a little bit. It’s one thing to have open access journals where everybody has the chance to download the paper, but making data available (even after the paper has been published) is a little bit too risky… I don’t make any data available until after the paper has been published.”
  • 30. Findings – Participants appreciate current services “What helps me? Betty!!! She is great! As [another participant] mentioned, when I have to upload anything, Betty is my first point of contact. I know that I get excellent information from her.”
  • 31. Findings – What could help? • Meet with the Data Librarian after receiving an award • Checking to see what publications can be uploaded and updating PI records accordingly • Depositing data and publications on behalf of researchers • Custom support for any agency requirements • Sending reminders beyond the close of the award, until the PI notified the Data Librarian that all data and publications related to the award have been deposited • Help paying open access fees.
  • 32. Summary • Pioneering the USU compliance tracking program • Identifying the need for a program assessment o Goals  Understanding researcher behavior  Evaluating response to USU’s compliance tracking program o Methods  Survey  OAFG • Qualitative data analysis and findings
  • 33. Lessons Learned • Survey o Data representative of a portion of researchers  Convenience vs. Randomized – taking a randomized sample makes the data more representative of the population o Work with someone that has statistical expertise • OAFG o Timing and buy in o Platform needs
  • 34. How our results will shape future services • Clarification or requirements expected by individual funders o Continue updating to data management services website o Continue to tailor reminder emails to include links to resources for each PI’s agency information about requirements​​ o The library is currently changing the workflow to include additional help post close-out of awards o Improved communication from the USU Libraries and Sponsored Programs • Further investigation and research o Improving interaction with researchers less inclined to think Sponsored Programs/USU Libraries can help them meet agency requirements to deposit publications and data
  • 35. Future of the Project • Developing a culture of responsible data stewardship o Understanding research hesitancy to share data o Further sessions  When data should be released  Data citation  Data licensing  Effective methods for describing research data
  • 36. Read our article: Rebekah Cummings, Lindsay Ozburn, Andrea Payant, Betty Rozum, Michael Shelton & Ryan Bushman (2020) Assessing Research Compliance for Federally Funded Projects: The Good, the Bad, and the Publicly Accessible, Journal of Library Administration, 60:7, 726-751, DOI: 10.1080/01930826.2020.1786985 Learn More
  • 37. Thanks! Do you have any questions? Rebekah Cummings rebekah.cummings@utah.edu Lindsay Ozburn lindsay.ozburn@usu.edu Andrea Payant andrea.payant@usu.edu Mike Shelton michael.shelton@usu.edu Ryan Bushman ryan.bushman@usu.edu