0
$\begingroup$

I've been trying to prove $$-a=(-1)\cdot a$$ for every $a\in\mathbb{R}$ using only axioms, however, every demonstration I found use one of these two properties: $$0\cdot a=0,\quad\forall a\in\mathbb{R}$$ or the uniqueness of $-a$ such that $$a+(-a)=0$$

Is there a way to not use them?

$\endgroup$
4

1 Answer 1

3
$\begingroup$

Both of those are simple consequences of the axioms. You could definitely give a proof that $-a = (-1)\cdot a$ from the axioms, but I would guess such a proof would implicitly prove those two facts.

For instance, one might write the following:

$$\begin{align*} (-1)\cdot a &= (-1)\cdot a + 0 \\ &= (-1)\cdot a + (a + -a) \\ &= ((-1)\cdot a + a) + -a \\ &= ((-1)\cdot a + 1\cdot a) + -a \\ &= (-1 + 1)\cdot a + -a \\ &= 0\cdot a + -a \\ &= (0\cdot a + 0) + -a \\ &= (0 \cdot a + (a + -a)) + -a \\ &= ((0 \cdot a + a) + -a) + -a \\ &= ((0\cdot a + 1\cdot a) + -a) + -a \\ &= ((0+1)\cdot a + -a) + -a \\ &= (1\cdot a + -a) + -a \\ &= (a + -a) + -a \\ &= 0 + -a \\ &= -a \end{align*}$$

where for illustrative purposes I've written out every... single... step.


Here's the deal though: The functional study of mathematics works on previously proven lemmas. The proof that $a+b = 0 \to b=-a$ simply follows from $$b = 0 + b = (-a + a) + b = -a + (a + b) = -a + 0 = -a,$$ which isn't bad even as I've shown every single step. Similarly, $0\cdot a = 0$ is shown by $$\begin{align*} 0\cdot a &= 0\cdot a + 0 \\ &= 0\cdot a + (a+-a) \\ &= (0\cdot a + a) + -a \\ &= (0\cdot a + 1\cdot a) + -a \\ &= (0+1)\cdot a + -a \\ &= 1\cdot a + -a \\ &= a + -a \\ &= 0\end{align*}$$ where again I've shown every single step, even though it's slightly more tedious to follow. (do you see where this proof appears in the middle of the first proof above?)

Once I have those two facts in my toolbox of theorems, I'm going to use them, without reproving them, because iteratively increasing the reach of your theorems is the only way we can reasonably reach anywhere useful in mathematics.

Just to finish this illustration, after I've added the above theorems to the axioms already in our toolbox, the proof is just $$a + (-1)\cdot a = 1\cdot a + (-1)\cdot a = (1+-1)\cdot a = 0\cdot a = 0$$ from which we conclude $(-1)\cdot a = -a$.

I personally prefer the latter derivation.

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .