The document summarizes a systematic literature review conducted by Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, and Marina Milosheva on the impacts of information literacy on society. The review analyzed over 5,000 papers and found research was most comprehensive in education, health, and some workplaces. However, key areas like citizenship, primary education, and the impacts of misinformation were understudied. The review also identified barriers like lack of funding and support, as well as enablers like national frameworks and collaboration between teachers and librarians. While effective methods couldn't be determined, information literacy education works best when structured, integrated, collaborative, and tailored to learners' needs.
This research proposal aims to investigate the factors motivating individuals to use social networks and the effects on individuals and families. The researcher plans to survey 500 college students aged 12-18 on their social media usage and whether it affects their relationships and personality. A literature review found that social media can both positively and negatively impact adolescents' social development. The proposal outlines research questions, hypotheses, objectives, methodology, ethics considerations, timeline, and references.
Media and Information Literacy: creative and critical engagement across the c...
Workshop presented by Sheila Webber and Bill Johnston at the "Transforming futures: International perspectives on Research-Based Education conference, University of Adelaide, Australia, 16 July 2019.
Information literacy and society: a systematic literature review - Bruce Ryan
Increasing the impact of information literacy (IL) requires raising awareness of what IL is, standardizing IL instruction across institutions and disciplines, introducing IL earlier in schools, illustrating its importance beyond education, making IL relevant to people's lives, and leveraging recognition that IL is needed to address information challenges in society.
This document summarizes the Community Health Assessment (CHA) project curriculum implemented by the University of Minnesota Rural Physicians Associate Program (RPAP). The CHA project, required since 2004, aims to improve the health of a specific population through community engagement. Students complete CHA proposals, implementation, and evaluations during their 9-month rural clinical placements. While most students find the projects valuable, some challenges exist around project continuity, expectations, and impact. The discussion explores experiences engaging students in authentic community partnerships and themes around CHA curriculum.
2a Understanding the Political and Institutional Conditions for Effective Pov...
This document summarizes a research project conducted by Dr. Maria Kett of the Leonard Cheshire Disability and Inclusive Development Centre and Mr. Richard Ngafuan of the University of Liberia. The project aims to understand poverty among persons with disabilities in Liberia through mixed methods research including policy review, secondary data analysis, and a survey of 1,200 households. The research is conducted in partnership with organizations of persons with disabilities in Liberia and intends to directly involve persons with disabilities in the research process and identify ways to improve their inclusion and social protection. The project expects to contribute to developing evidence on inclusive development and identify best practices to alleviate poverty and exclusion of persons with disabilities.
Celebrate Afterschool Partnerships with the 18th Annual “Lights On Afterschool!”
Libraries and afterschool programs make great partners. Every October, the afterschool field celebrates the important role these programs have in the lives of children, families, and communities. This year, on October 26, we want to make the celebration bigger and better than ever. Library-afterschool partnerships are an official theme of this year’s event—and we want to highlight the many ways libraries and afterschool programs are pairing up to provide engaging learning opportunities and critical supports to children and families across the country. Join us for this webinar to learn more about Lights On Afterschool, and how your library can participate.
Literacy in Fragile Environments: Guiding Principles and Real Examples
This document discusses literacy education in fragile environments and provides guiding principles and real examples. It introduces FHI 360 and outlines the fragility/development continuum. It then describes some key characteristics of students, teachers, governments/systems, and families/communities in fragile contexts. The document also discusses considerations for literacy programming, such as policy/governance, teachers, and communities. It provides examples from programs in the DRC, South Sudan, and Nigeria that have responded to challenges through strategies like teacher workshops, materials development, and community engagement.
Lessons learned from Health ed. and Promotion Minor
The document summarizes Year One of the Health Education & Promotion Minor at the University of Washington Bothell. It provides an overview of the curriculum developed, including courses on health education, program planning, evaluation, policy, and management. The curriculum uses a community problem-based model and partnered with various organizations. Lessons learned included benefits of community projects, importance of lead time, limiting project scope, and providing feedback. The curriculum team aims to further develop partnerships, research, conference presentations, and advocacy opportunities in upcoming years.
This document provides the schedule for the Teaching and Learning with Innovative Connections (TILC) 2018 conference taking place May 8-9 at Radford University. The schedule outlines the various presentations, keynotes, lightning talks, and social events during the two-day conference. On Wednesday May 9th, the keynote speaker Jennifer Ferretti will present on "Art is Information: Countering the 'Neutral' Classroom with Pop Culture and Social Justice". Presentation sessions are scheduled throughout the day in various classrooms covering topics such as using audience analysis in instructional design, incorporating poetry in teaching research skills, and exploring genre and scholarship as conversation.
PLNs "Friends Educating Each Other": Informal, Self-directed, and Social PD
This document summarizes a presentation given by Debbie Fucoloro at the MOREnet M3 Annual Conference on October 15, 2013. The presentation investigated educators who use social media for informal professional learning. Key findings included that Twitter was the favorite social media platform used, allowing educators to connect, share resources and ideas, and reduce isolation. Recommendations were provided for future researchers to examine successful programs supporting informal learning, and for educational leaders to make technology integration a priority and allow more self-directed professional development opportunities.
The document summarizes three articles related to service learning and community engagement:
1) The first article discusses how service learning can perpetuate "whiteness" through color-blind approaches and argues educators must examine their own biases.
2) The second article presents a study finding public engagement shaped graduate school and career choices for many scholars and outlines key elements of public engagement scholarship.
3) The third article reviews infrastructure of community engagement centers, finding evolution in characteristics like academic integration, institutional resources, and assessment. It provides a baseline for centers to evaluate structures.
- The workshop aimed to provide educators with tools and strategies for incorporating social justice themes into project-based science curricula through multimedia, driving questions, and lesson planning.
- Participants engaged with an audio story and photo essay on nuclear history before brainstorming essential questions and beginning to develop social justice-themed science lessons.
- Literature supports that project-based learning can boost underserved students' achievement and interest in science when implemented with clear goals, resources, and alignment to standards. Teacher experience and school culture also influence successful incorporation of social justice themes.
This document provides a literature review of project-based learning (PBL) in K-12 educational settings. It summarizes the core principles of PBL, how PBL has been implemented in schools, research on PBL implementation challenges for teachers, and the available evidence on PBL's effectiveness in improving student outcomes.
The review finds that there is no consensus definition of PBL. It identifies areas of debate around PBL principles, such as the role of student choice, collaborative learning, and assessment. It also describes different models for bringing PBL to schools, from externally-developed curricula to teacher-led approaches. Research indicates PBL poses implementation challenges for teachers in changing their roles and classroom practices. Evidence
A new model of information literacy education in school settings. Exceeding s...
This document proposes a new theoretical model for information literacy education in school settings that goes beyond skill-based approaches. It discusses how school pedagogy, information literacy, and communication theory converge. Specifically, it argues that a communicative pedagogical model is needed that incorporates theoretical perspectives like phenomenography, discourse analysis, and sociocultural theory. This model would address informational knowledge, operational knowledge, and motivational factors beyond just skills. It also examines the relationship between information literacy and media literacy as fields that are increasingly converging.
These slides present some of my EdD research findings (Sept 2016). My research highlights the complexity of open online social networks for professional learning and online activities of higher education professionals.
The document discusses the federal response in the United States to the findings from the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC). It notes that PIAAC found low skills levels across adults in the US and a lack of effective interventions. The document calls researchers to help address this issue through more rigorous and relevant research that engages stakeholders and works across disciplines. It provides new datasets and resources to support this research.
Harnessing Technology for Social Work ScholarshipLaurel Hitchcock
This presentation was created by myself and Melanie Sage of the University at Buffalo for our visit with the College of Social Work at the Ohio State University in August 2017, where we talked about how social work faculty can harness technology for their social work scholarship.
This research proposal aims to investigate the factors motivating individuals to use social networks and the effects on individuals and families. The researcher plans to survey 500 college students aged 12-18 on their social media usage and whether it affects their relationships and personality. A literature review found that social media can both positively and negatively impact adolescents' social development. The proposal outlines research questions, hypotheses, objectives, methodology, ethics considerations, timeline, and references.
Media and Information Literacy: creative and critical engagement across the c...Sheila Webber
Workshop presented by Sheila Webber and Bill Johnston at the "Transforming futures: International perspectives on Research-Based Education conference, University of Adelaide, Australia, 16 July 2019.
Increasing the impact of information literacy (IL) requires raising awareness of what IL is, standardizing IL instruction across institutions and disciplines, introducing IL earlier in schools, illustrating its importance beyond education, making IL relevant to people's lives, and leveraging recognition that IL is needed to address information challenges in society.
This document summarizes the Community Health Assessment (CHA) project curriculum implemented by the University of Minnesota Rural Physicians Associate Program (RPAP). The CHA project, required since 2004, aims to improve the health of a specific population through community engagement. Students complete CHA proposals, implementation, and evaluations during their 9-month rural clinical placements. While most students find the projects valuable, some challenges exist around project continuity, expectations, and impact. The discussion explores experiences engaging students in authentic community partnerships and themes around CHA curriculum.
2a Understanding the Political and Institutional Conditions for Effective Pov...The Impact Initiative
This document summarizes a research project conducted by Dr. Maria Kett of the Leonard Cheshire Disability and Inclusive Development Centre and Mr. Richard Ngafuan of the University of Liberia. The project aims to understand poverty among persons with disabilities in Liberia through mixed methods research including policy review, secondary data analysis, and a survey of 1,200 households. The research is conducted in partnership with organizations of persons with disabilities in Liberia and intends to directly involve persons with disabilities in the research process and identify ways to improve their inclusion and social protection. The project expects to contribute to developing evidence on inclusive development and identify best practices to alleviate poverty and exclusion of persons with disabilities.
Celebrate Afterschool Partnerships with the 18th Annual “Lights On Afterschool!”NCIL - STAR_Net
Libraries and afterschool programs make great partners. Every October, the afterschool field celebrates the important role these programs have in the lives of children, families, and communities. This year, on October 26, we want to make the celebration bigger and better than ever. Library-afterschool partnerships are an official theme of this year’s event—and we want to highlight the many ways libraries and afterschool programs are pairing up to provide engaging learning opportunities and critical supports to children and families across the country. Join us for this webinar to learn more about Lights On Afterschool, and how your library can participate.
Literacy in Fragile Environments: Guiding Principles and Real ExamplesFHI 360
This document discusses literacy education in fragile environments and provides guiding principles and real examples. It introduces FHI 360 and outlines the fragility/development continuum. It then describes some key characteristics of students, teachers, governments/systems, and families/communities in fragile contexts. The document also discusses considerations for literacy programming, such as policy/governance, teachers, and communities. It provides examples from programs in the DRC, South Sudan, and Nigeria that have responded to challenges through strategies like teacher workshops, materials development, and community engagement.
Lessons learned from Health ed. and Promotion MinorTodd Conaway
The document summarizes Year One of the Health Education & Promotion Minor at the University of Washington Bothell. It provides an overview of the curriculum developed, including courses on health education, program planning, evaluation, policy, and management. The curriculum uses a community problem-based model and partnered with various organizations. Lessons learned included benefits of community projects, importance of lead time, limiting project scope, and providing feedback. The curriculum team aims to further develop partnerships, research, conference presentations, and advocacy opportunities in upcoming years.
This document provides the schedule for the Teaching and Learning with Innovative Connections (TILC) 2018 conference taking place May 8-9 at Radford University. The schedule outlines the various presentations, keynotes, lightning talks, and social events during the two-day conference. On Wednesday May 9th, the keynote speaker Jennifer Ferretti will present on "Art is Information: Countering the 'Neutral' Classroom with Pop Culture and Social Justice". Presentation sessions are scheduled throughout the day in various classrooms covering topics such as using audience analysis in instructional design, incorporating poetry in teaching research skills, and exploring genre and scholarship as conversation.
PLNs "Friends Educating Each Other": Informal, Self-directed, and Social PDDebbie Fucoloro, Ph.D.
This document summarizes a presentation given by Debbie Fucoloro at the MOREnet M3 Annual Conference on October 15, 2013. The presentation investigated educators who use social media for informal professional learning. Key findings included that Twitter was the favorite social media platform used, allowing educators to connect, share resources and ideas, and reduce isolation. Recommendations were provided for future researchers to examine successful programs supporting informal learning, and for educational leaders to make technology integration a priority and allow more self-directed professional development opportunities.
The document summarizes three articles related to service learning and community engagement:
1) The first article discusses how service learning can perpetuate "whiteness" through color-blind approaches and argues educators must examine their own biases.
2) The second article presents a study finding public engagement shaped graduate school and career choices for many scholars and outlines key elements of public engagement scholarship.
3) The third article reviews infrastructure of community engagement centers, finding evolution in characteristics like academic integration, institutional resources, and assessment. It provides a baseline for centers to evaluate structures.
- The workshop aimed to provide educators with tools and strategies for incorporating social justice themes into project-based science curricula through multimedia, driving questions, and lesson planning.
- Participants engaged with an audio story and photo essay on nuclear history before brainstorming essential questions and beginning to develop social justice-themed science lessons.
- Literature supports that project-based learning can boost underserved students' achievement and interest in science when implemented with clear goals, resources, and alignment to standards. Teacher experience and school culture also influence successful incorporation of social justice themes.
This document provides a literature review of project-based learning (PBL) in K-12 educational settings. It summarizes the core principles of PBL, how PBL has been implemented in schools, research on PBL implementation challenges for teachers, and the available evidence on PBL's effectiveness in improving student outcomes.
The review finds that there is no consensus definition of PBL. It identifies areas of debate around PBL principles, such as the role of student choice, collaborative learning, and assessment. It also describes different models for bringing PBL to schools, from externally-developed curricula to teacher-led approaches. Research indicates PBL poses implementation challenges for teachers in changing their roles and classroom practices. Evidence
This document proposes a new theoretical model for information literacy education in school settings that goes beyond skill-based approaches. It discusses how school pedagogy, information literacy, and communication theory converge. Specifically, it argues that a communicative pedagogical model is needed that incorporates theoretical perspectives like phenomenography, discourse analysis, and sociocultural theory. This model would address informational knowledge, operational knowledge, and motivational factors beyond just skills. It also examines the relationship between information literacy and media literacy as fields that are increasingly converging.
Similar to Information literacy and society: a systematic literature review - Dr Bruce Ryan (20)
This document provides guidance on optional communication stickers that can be used during a session to indicate preferences for social interaction. It describes three sticker options: a green rectangle for being open to interaction, a yellow diamond for being open to either initiating or receiving interaction, and a red circle for preferring no interaction. This is an example of an activity used in a pre-enrollment session for autistic students.
This document summarizes a library instruction activity that aims to encourage learners to develop context-specific research plans. It does this by having learners unpack assumptions about what constitutes legitimate research and knowledge. Through discussion and reflection, learners consider how power shapes what is considered credible research and how mainstream institutions contribute to information hierarchies. The goal is for learners to contextualize academic institutions within broader information landscapes and consider ways of knowing that do not adhere to traditional academic paradigms in order to develop more equitable research practices.
This document outlines a creative library workshop aimed at liberating the library through information creation. The workshop includes several hands-on activities like collage making, blackout poetry, and fidget toy making. It also discusses learning outcomes around understanding the relationship between information creation and library liberation. The workshop is meant to establish collective hope for future library events and ends with participants sharing what they hope for in the coming months.
This document provides an overview of a session on accessibility in PowerPoint presentations. The session aims to explain the importance of accessibility, identify common issues, and provide tips for making PowerPoint presentations more accessible. It discusses common misconceptions about accessibility and the benefits of universal design. The session includes an activity for attendees to review examples and practice applying tips. These tips include using the accessibility checker, proper font sizes, color contrast, logical reading order, meaningful table formatting, alt text for images, and providing editable files. The session emphasizes an approach of prioritizing accessibility by default.
The document discusses April Manabat's experiences as an instruction librarian at Nazarbayev University in Astana, Kazakhstan. She outlines some of the challenges of the role, including teaching anxiety, imposter syndrome, and incorporating culturally responsive teaching into library instruction. She then provides practical tips for instruction librarians to thrive in their work, such as preparing well, communicating effectively, facilitating active learning, and engaging in reflection. The talk concludes with case studies to prompt discussion around handling challenging situations that instruction librarians may face.
This document discusses narrative inquiry as an approach for information literacy research. It defines narrative inquiry as understanding experience as a storied phenomenon through collaboration between researcher and participants over time. The document provides an example of a story from one of the author's pilot interviews. It discusses using narrative thinking to retell participants' stories and considering elements like interaction, continuity and situation. The author proposes using multiple approaches to storying data, including poetic transcription. Challenges of narrative inquiry include time, data volume and publishing conventions. The document argues narrative inquiry provides an opportunity for information literacy research by exploring lived experience as a storied phenomenon.
The document summarizes the results of a survey about integrating artificial intelligence (AI) literacy instruction in academic libraries. It was distributed to academic librarians via email lists from September to October 2023. The survey included demographic, instruction experience, and attitude questions. Most respondents were from doctoral universities and identified as mid-career. Respondents reported a moderate level of experience and comfort with teaching AI literacy. The "Research as Inquiry" and "Information Has Value" ACRL frames best aligned with AI literacy lessons. Topics covered included evaluating AI-generated text, ethics, and plagiarism detection. Qualitative analysis of open-ended responses found one librarian took an approach of educating others on AI instead
This document summarizes a co-creation project between university staff and students to create online guides for incoming students. Students helped plan and create content for a website about what a typical week is like at the university. The project aimed to give students ownership and share expertise between students and staff. Evaluation found high website usage and positive feedback from participants who felt they learned from each other. The reciprocal nature of co-creation allowed different perspectives to be shared and helped position all participants as both learners and teachers. Future co-creation would benefit from more guidance for students and collaborating across departments.
The document summarizes a presentation on linking information literacy and digital literacy in teaching. It discusses using AI tools like ChatGPT in a plagiarism workshop to make digital literacy aspects more explicit. The presentation defines information literacy and digital literacy, examines frameworks that link the two literacies, and provides an example workshop exploring how AI tools fit within definitions of plagiarism and scientific integrity. It encourages viewing the literacies as complementary and making digital aspects explicit as an initial step in education. The document concludes by inviting audience feedback on experimenting with AI tools.
This document discusses encouraging help-seeking behaviors in students related to information literacy. It begins by recognizing connections between help-seeking, dispositions in the Framework for Information Literacy, and pillars in the Seven Pillars of Information Literacy model. It then describes an online assignment created for first-year students to guide them through information-based scenarios to encourage positive help-seeking. Qualitative analysis of student responses found that students learned the importance of asking for help when needed and gained awareness of campus resources.
More from IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group) (20)
How to Create Sequence Numbers in Odoo 17Celine George
Sequence numbers are mainly used to identify or differentiate each record in a module. Sequences are customizable and can be configured in a specific pattern such as suffix, prefix or a particular numbering scheme. This slide will show how to create sequence numbers in odoo 17.
How to Store Data on the Odoo 17 WebsiteCeline George
Here we are going to discuss how to store data in Odoo 17 Website.
It includes defining a model with few fields in it. Add demo data into the model using data directory. Also using a controller, pass the values into the template while rendering it and display the values in the website.
(T.L.E.) Agriculture: Essentials of GardeningMJDuyan
(𝐓𝐋𝐄 𝟏𝟎𝟎) (𝐋𝐞𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐧 𝟏.𝟎)-𝐅𝐢𝐧𝐚𝐥𝐬
Lesson Outcome:
-Students will understand the basics of gardening, including the importance of soil, water, and sunlight for plant growth. They will learn to identify and use essential gardening tools, plant seeds, and seedlings properly, and manage common garden pests using eco-friendly methods.
The membership Module in the Odoo 17 ERPCeline George
Some business organizations give membership to their customers to ensure the long term relationship with those customers. If the customer is a member of the business then they get special offers and other benefits. The membership module in odoo 17 is helpful to manage everything related to the membership of multiple customers.
Credit limit improvement system in odoo 17Celine George
In Odoo 17, confirmed and uninvoiced sales orders are now factored into a partner's total receivables. As a result, the credit limit warning system now considers this updated calculation, leading to more accurate and effective credit management.
How to Add Colour Kanban Records in Odoo 17 NotebookCeline George
In Odoo 17, you can enhance the visual appearance of your Kanban view by adding color-coded records using the Notebook feature. This allows you to categorize and distinguish between different types of records based on specific criteria. By adding colors, you can quickly identify and prioritize tasks or items, improving organization and efficiency within your workflow.
AI Risk Management: ISO/IEC 42001, the EU AI Act, and ISO/IEC 23894PECB
As artificial intelligence continues to evolve, understanding the complexities and regulations regarding AI risk management is more crucial than ever.
Amongst others, the webinar covers:
• ISO/IEC 42001 standard, which provides guidelines for establishing, implementing, maintaining, and continually improving AI management systems within organizations
• insights into the European Union's landmark legislative proposal aimed at regulating AI
• framework and methodologies prescribed by ISO/IEC 23894 for identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks associated with AI systems
Presenters:
Miriama Podskubova - Attorney at Law
Miriama is a seasoned lawyer with over a decade of experience. She specializes in commercial law, focusing on transactions, venture capital investments, IT, digital law, and cybersecurity, areas she was drawn to through her legal practice. Alongside preparing contract and project documentation, she ensures the correct interpretation and application of European legal regulations in these fields. Beyond client projects, she frequently speaks at conferences on cybersecurity, online privacy protection, and the increasingly pertinent topic of AI regulation. As a registered advocate of Slovak bar, certified data privacy professional in the European Union (CIPP/e) and a member of the international association ELA, she helps both tech-focused startups and entrepreneurs, as well as international chains, to properly set up their business operations.
Callum Wright - Founder and Lead Consultant Founder and Lead Consultant
Callum Wright is a seasoned cybersecurity, privacy and AI governance expert. With over a decade of experience, he has dedicated his career to protecting digital assets, ensuring data privacy, and establishing ethical AI governance frameworks. His diverse background includes significant roles in security architecture, AI governance, risk consulting, and privacy management across various industries, thorough testing, and successful implementation, he has consistently delivered exceptional results.
Throughout his career, he has taken on multifaceted roles, from leading technical project management teams to owning solutions that drive operational excellence. His conscientious and proactive approach is unwavering, whether he is working independently or collaboratively within a team. His ability to connect with colleagues on a personal level underscores his commitment to fostering a harmonious and productive workplace environment.
Date: June 26, 2024
Tags: ISO/IEC 42001, Artificial Intelligence, EU AI Act, ISO/IEC 23894
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Find out more about ISO training and certification services
Training: ISO/IEC 42001 Artificial Intelligence Management System - EN | PECB
Webinars: https://pecb.com/webinars
Article: https://pecb.com/article
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join educators from the US and worldwide at this year’s conference, themed “Strategies for Proficiency & Acquisition,” to learn from top experts in world language teaching.
Configuring Single Sign-On (SSO) via Identity Management | MuleSoft Mysore Me...
Information literacy and society: a systematic literature review - Dr Bruce Ryan
1. Dr Bruce Ryan
Senior Research Fellow
Edinburgh Napier University
Email: b.ryan@napier.ac.uk
Telephone: withheld – email or Tweet me!
Twitter: @bruce_research
4. Discussion questions
Please use padlets (or post-its).
1.How do you define ‘IL impact’
in your work or practice?
https://bit.ly/LIL01
2.What are the impacts of IL on society?
https://bit.ly/LIL02
3.How can we increase the impact of IL?
https://bit.ly/LIL03
? ?
?
5. Project team
Bruce Ryan Marina Milosheva
Peter Cruickshank
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 5
6. Project aims
• Large-scale, systematic literature review of
socially impactful IL research
• Filling research gaps
in scale
in policy areas
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 6
7. Research questions
1. What is the core research that investigates
the role IL plays for different user groups
in society?
a) How comprehensive is this core research?
b) Which themes are absent from this core
research?
c) Which factors prevent these themes being
researched?
d) Which themes are overrepresented?
?
?
?
? ?
?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 7
8. Research questions (cont)
2. According to this core research, what are the
barriers and enablers of shaping
information literate populations?
3. What research methodologies in this core
research are most effective at delivering
impact/societal change, and why are these
methods effective?
?
?
?
? ?
?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 8
9. Methods
Search terms: assess, benefit, effect, evaluat*, impact,
indicator*, measur*, monitor*, outcome, output, result
Classification Number of items
everyday life 356
citizenship 118
education 2825
- tertiary 1993
- secondary 127
- primary 55
- not specified/more than one 650
workplace 296
health 378
none/out of scope 1131
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 9
12. Primary education findings
Enablers of information-literate societies
• delivering relevant facts to stimulate government action
and funding
• appropriate IL teaching frameworks and IT systems
• teaching of critical thinking
Barriers to information-literate societies
• inappropriate government action/lack of funding,
leading to loss of librarians teaching IL skills in
formative years
• other unwelcome human actions
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 12
13. Secondary education findings
Enablers of information literate societies
• spurs to undertake IL teaching
• supportive school leaderships
• ‘scaffolded’ teaching methods
• taking advantage of suitable relationships within and
outwith formal education
Barriers to information literate societies
• inappropriate teaching and examination policies and methods
• ‘contrary’ human characteristics
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 13
14. Tertiary education and
‘other’ education findings
Enablers of information literate societies
• supportive university leadership
• positive actions by university librarians and their colleagues
• education around critical thinking
• provision of suitable resources and staffing for IL teaching
• collaboration between librarians and their teaching
Barriers to information literate societies
• not teaching the full range of IL skills
• not using IL models
• lack of resources, university support and collaboration
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 14
15. Everyday life findings
Enablers of information literate societies
• national IL frameworks and other government
actions
• improvements to teaching methods and
programmes
• working around socio-cultural and religious
barriers
Barriers to information literate societies
• can be manifold
Library instruction and information literacy annual
series:
• geographical spread of IL research is increasing,
but ...
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 15
16. Citizenship findings
Enablers of information literate societies
• ‘good’ parenting
• national IL frameworks
• co-ordination of support for national policies
• advocacy of examination of new issues stemming from
evolving technology
Barriers to information literate societies
• lack of relevant government action and polices
• lack of updating IL teaching around modern developments and
social needs
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 16
17. Workplace findings
Enablers of information literate societies
• workplace or in-work IL training
• context-specific IL frameworks
• relevant communities of practice
Barriers to information literate societies
• poor presentation of information
• overwhelming other aspects of work roles
• lack of training, immediate resources and support
resources
• various demographic factors
• possibly over-generalised IL frameworks
Many papers covered the impact of already having IL.
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 17
18. Health findings
Enablers of information literate societies
• service-learning methods including group projects
• ‘scaffolded’ teaching methods
• collaboration between librarians and teaching colleagues
• compulsory undergraduate IL education
• socio-demographic factors
• demonstrating the relevance of IL to practice
Barriers to information literate societies
• lack of respect for librarians
• lack of university IL education
• lack of government action on misinformation
• socio-demographic factors such as being older or male
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 18
19. Answering RQ1
1. What is the core research that investigates the role IL
plays for different user groups in society?
a) How comprehensive is this core research?
policy and governance, education, digital/IT,
health, some professions, personal/citizenship
topics
b) Which themes are absent from this core research?
citizenship, primary education, public libraries,
mis/disinformation, longitudinal, non-textual
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 19
20. Answering RQ1 (cont)
1. What is the core research that investigates the role
IL plays for different user groups in society?
c) Which factors prevent these themes being
researched?
no robust answers
d) Which themes are overrepresented?
tertiary education
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 20
21. Answering RQ2
2. According to this core research, what are the
barriers and enablers of shaping information
literate populations?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 21
Some barriers
government inaction/underfunding
inappropriate teaching
overwhelming other aspects of work
poor information-presentation
socio-cultural barriers faced by
immigrants
Some enablers
• national IL frameworks
• improvements to teaching
• teacher-librarian collaboration
• overcoming cultural and
demographic barriers
• relevant government and
school leadership action
22. Answering RQ3
3. What research methodologies in this core research
are most effective at delivering impact/societal
change, and why are these methods effective?
no robust answers, but so IL education ‘how-to’s
IL education/training should be
• structured
• integrated
• collaborative
• take into account learners’ needs and
existing abilities
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 22
23. Discussion questions
1.How do you define ‘IL impact’
in your work or practice?
https://bit.ly/LIL01
2.What are the impacts of IL on society?
https://bit.ly/LIL02
3.How can we increase the impact of IL?
https://bit.ly/LIL03
? ?
?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 23
24. Discussion question 1
1.How do you define ‘IL impact’
in your work or practice?
https://bit.ly/LIL01
? ?
?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 24
25. Discussion question 2
2. What are the impacts of IL on society?
https://bit.ly/LIL02
? ?
?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 25
26. Discussion question 3
3. How can we increase the impact of IL?
https://bit.ly/LIL03
? ?
?
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 26
27. Thank you!
Bruce Ryan
b.ryan@napier.ac.uk
@bruce_research
Marina Milosheva
m.milosheva@napier.ac.uk
mari-milo.github.io
Peter Cruickshank
p.cruickshank@napier.ac.uk
@spartakan
https://blogs.napier.ac.uk/social-informatics
Report is online: https://bit.ly/ILSoc
Bruce Ryan, Peter Cruickshank, Marina Milosheva 27
28. Dr Bruce Ryan
Senior Research Fellow
Edinburgh Napier University
Email: b.ryan@napier.ac.uk
Telephone: withheld
Twitter: @bruce_research
Report is online: https://bit.ly/ILSoc
Read more about what we do:
blogs.napier.ac.uk/social-informatics
Thank you!
Marina Milosheva
PhD student
Edinburgh Napier University
Email:
m.milosheva@napier.ac.uk
Telephone: withheld
Web: mari-milo.github.io
Dr Peter Cruickshank
Associate Professor
Edinburgh Napier University
Email:
p.cruickshank@napier.ac.uk
Telephone: withheld
Twitter: @spartakan