Questions tagged [tolkiens-legendarium]
For questions about any works in J.R.R. Tolkien's Legendarium - The Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit, The Silmarillion, and other works set in the same universe - or about that universe as a whole. Questions about movies, games, or other media set in the same universe should also use this tag. Questions about Tolkien himself or works by him which are not part of the Middle-earth universe should NOT use this tag use [j-r-r-tolkien] instead.
3,215
questions
494
votes
18
answers
84k
views
Would the One Ring even work for anyone but Sauron?
The temptation of the One Ring, we quickly learn, is always tied up with power: each character's fantasies of possessing it seem to be about what they would do with great power. Even Sam, as I recall, ...
- 38.6k
453
votes
16
answers
107k
views
Who or what was Tom Bombadil?
The most iconic of Middle-earth questions:
Who or what was Tom Bombadil?
Was he an elf? Was he akin to Gandalf, and one of the wizardly stock? Was he something… else?
- 10.7k
350
votes
23
answers
136k
views
Why didn't Gandalf or Frodo Fly to Mount Doom?
Why didn't Gandalf use his eagles to fly over Mount Doom and drop the ring? I know he feared what he would do if the ring overpowered him, so why not just give Frodo an eagle?
And, if there would be ...
- 12.2k
214
votes
5
answers
252k
views
Did Tolkien really explicitly consider Sam the true hero of The Lord of the Rings?
Quoting from Crouching Moron Hidden Badass: Literature on TVTropes (TVTropes link alert!!! Don't tell me I didn't warn you!):
Perhaps even more aptly: Samwise Gamgee. His name roughly translates to ...
- 343k
188
votes
6
answers
34k
views
Was Aragorn's claim to the throne legitimate?
In a recent post to The Toast, Austin Gilkeson argues that Aragorn, son of Arathorn's claim to Gondor's throne is invalid. The author goes into various details, but the core argument is:
Gondor’s ...
user1027
183
votes
9
answers
222k
views
What does Gandalf mean by "Secret Fire", "Flame of Anor" and "Flame of Udûn"?
In Moria, when Gandalf confronts the Balrog on the bridge of Khazad-dûm, Gandalf says the following:
I am a servant of the Secret Fire, wielder of the flame of Anor. You cannot pass! The dark fire ...
- 14.4k
164
votes
13
answers
99k
views
Why didn't Sauron become invisible while wearing the One Ring?
I'm curious as to why Sauron is the only being/person shown wearing the One Ring who does not become invisible?
Isildur, Gollum, Bilbo, Frodo, and Samwise all become invisible while wearing the One ...
- 165k
151
votes
11
answers
31k
views
What is the significance of Saruman's Ring?
At the council of Elrond, Gandalf tells of his encounter with Saruman.
But I rode to the foot of Orthanc, and came to the stair of Saruman; and there he met me and led me up to his high chamber. ...
- 10.3k
141
votes
14
answers
33k
views
Why is Shelob considered evil?
Shelob is an "evil thing in spider form," according to Tolkien. Now, we know that she is the "last child of Ungoliant to trouble the unhappy world," we know that she is fairly deficient in charm, and ...
- 13.3k
140
votes
4
answers
31k
views
Who created the Secret Stairs as a way into Mordor and for what purpose?
Given how there were Orcs guarding the Tower of Círith Ungol at the top of the stairs, we can infer that the existence of these stairways was definitely not a secret. Perhaps the path was meant to ...
- 5,095
132
votes
7
answers
56k
views
Why is Sauron called "the Necromancer"?
During the time period of The Hobbit, a character is mentioned called the Necromancer. Radagast even (in the movie) specifically states that the Necromancer can "summon the spirits of the dead." (It'...
- 38.6k
126
votes
2
answers
23k
views
What did Frodo mean by "He told me the true story"?
I'm re-reading the Lord of the Rings saga since 10 to 12 years ago, but something striked me as odd in The Fellowship of the Ring's first chapter: A Long-Expected Party (emphasis is mine):
‘She ...
- 1,703
125
votes
11
answers
27k
views
Why were the Elves so great at archery?
It seems that there is an underlying assumption (I don't know of an explicit quote to confirm) that Elves in Middle-earth are exceptional archers, compared to other races.
Am I correct in that ...
- 343k
117
votes
5
answers
44k
views
Why was Gandalf involved with the Dwarves' quest to rob Smaug?
From what I understand, the Istari were sent in to help the peoples of Middle-earth get through the third age. Why then, did Gandalf help the Dwarves along (and get Bilbo involved) in their quest to ...
- 1,321
116
votes
5
answers
21k
views
How many axes did Gimli bring on the quest of the Fellowship?
In the LotR movies, Gimli leaves Rivendell with the Fellowship directly following the Council of Elrond. Yet he seems to have an absurd number of axes with him. One is destroyed when he tries to ...
- 70.1k
116
votes
7
answers
21k
views
Tolkien calls Sauron Morgoth's Greatest Servant - But does he ever really earn that with his actions?
Alright, so there is a great, incredibly well informed community here so let me ask a question that's been bothering me since I finished the Silmarillion. I'll lay out my reasoning for why it's a ...
- 1,273
111
votes
10
answers
30k
views
Which seven kings does Saruman think Gandalf wants to control?
Just before Gandalf breaks his staff and casts him out of the order of Wizards, Saruman has a minor meltdown in which he accuses Gandalf of grabbing power. He makes specific reference to a handful of ...
- 164k
109
votes
6
answers
55k
views
Did Eru Ilúvatar trip Gollum?
The Fandom LOTR wiki lists four times Eru Ilúvatar intervened in the history of Arda:
creating Elves and Men
removing Aman from the spherical Earth
resurrecting Gandalf
making Gollum trip
In a ...
- 5,123
109
votes
9
answers
13k
views
How well-known is the theology of Middle-earth, in Middle-earth?
One thing that is notably absent in Middle-earth is any mention of temples, churches, priests or religious rites. There are passing mentions of Men who would "worship" Sauron, but generally the world ...
- 38.6k
108
votes
8
answers
114k
views
Why was Gandalf afraid of the Balrog of Morgoth?
As depicted in the film, Gandalf appeared to be shaken and in fear of the Balrog of Morgoth, even just as Saruman mentioned it. Why was this so? Did they have any previous encounters?
- 2,599
108
votes
3
answers
63k
views
Who is / was the "Lord of the Rings"?
Who is the Lord, as referred to in the title? Frodo? Sauron? Someone else? Or is it more of an abstract title, not referring to a single person, like "He who wields the One Ring"?
- 1,583
108
votes
7
answers
35k
views
Why not let a dwarf carry the One Ring to Mount Doom, since their will cannot be dominated by the rings of power?
As we know, the dwarves did not succumb to the seven rings as men did to the nine - it merely made them even more greedy, stubborn and wrathful:
For the Dwarves had proved untameable by this means. ...
- 6,055
104
votes
5
answers
19k
views
How is Shelob's name known?
In Tolkien's world, there are quite a few "magical" beasts that have proper names: dragons for example, like Smaug. One can assume that their names are known either because their creator was ...
- 3,933
104
votes
6
answers
75k
views
Why Does Samwise Gamgee Call Frodo Baggins 'Mr. Frodo'?
I haven't finished my re-read of the Lord of the Rings trilogy (I just finished The Two Towers), but, at least in the movies, Samwise Gamgee consistently refers to Frodo Baggins as "Mr. Frodo."
Why ...
- 165k
103
votes
9
answers
34k
views
Why is invisibility the power granted by the One Ring?
Why is non-optional invisibility the one active supernatural power granted to non-Sauron wearers of the One Ring?
I'm looking for an answer explaining authorial intent, not an in-universe answer. ...
- 1,598
103
votes
14
answers
32k
views
Why didn't Saruman take Narya from Gandalf?
We know that Gandalf was given Narya, the Ring of Fire (one of the Elven three), by Círdan the Shipwright.
When Saruman imprisoned Gandalf, why did he not attempt to take the ring from him? It would ...
- 5,965
103
votes
7
answers
58k
views
Did Peter Jackson ever explain why he left out the Scouring of the Shire?
In the book, while Frodo and the Fellowship were on their quest, the Shire was exploited and almost ruined by Saruman and his cronies. Jackson left this and the triumphant return of Frodo, Sam, and ...
- 63.6k
102
votes
8
answers
25k
views
Why didn't Frodo take a map with him?
As the Fellowship departed from the Rivendell, all the seasoned adventurers knew they will not follow Frodo to Mount Doom. So, the optimistic version is Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin going to the Mount ...
- 1,267
98
votes
5
answers
28k
views
Why weren't the Three Rings for the Elven-kings destroyed as well?
At the end of The Return of the King, after the One Ring is destroyed in the fires of Mount Doom, the rings were carried out of Middle-Earth.
IIRC it may have been Elrond, Galadriel, and Gandalf ...
- 6,372
97
votes
6
answers
25k
views
Does Aragorn wear pants?
Back when I was reading LOTR in Russian, I remember fans arguing over the issue of whether Aragorn wore pants (or rather, using the British term, trousers), or not - what I later learned was a major ...
- 343k
96
votes
9
answers
132k
views
What are Gandalf's powers?
Gandalf is a wizard. He is also the Tolkien equivalent of a mortal angel (if I understand what the Maiar are correctly.) What are his powers though? Specifically what magics does he use in The Hobbit ...
- 11.7k
96
votes
6
answers
17k
views
The use of the word "guns" in The Hobbit
In Chapter XVIII - The Return Journey of the book 'The Hobbit', Tolkien uses the word "guns".
'The roar of his voice was like drums and guns; and he tossed
wolves and goblins from his path ...
- 1,010
95
votes
6
answers
19k
views
How does Gandalf (or anyone) know how to destroy the Ring?
The only way to destroy the Ring is by throwing it into the fire of Orodruin. This fact doesn't seem to be common knowledge and many people in the story (like Gimli) only learn about it at the council ...
- 1,994
94
votes
10
answers
18k
views
Why aren't there any sieges in Lord of The Rings?
In the few cases a fortification is attacked (Helm's Deep, Minas Tirith), the attackers don't besiege them, they start an assault as soon as they arrive.
In real life, assaults were only done when, ...
- 12k
94
votes
14
answers
80k
views
Are orcs and goblins really the same thing?
Are orcs and goblins really the same in The Hobbit and LotR, and where does it say that? Are they variant sub-races or something, explaining the different physical attributes? Or is my assumption they ...
- 1,418
94
votes
4
answers
19k
views
What was Sauron's plan for a Middle-earth conquered and ruled by him?
I have watched only the movies, but this question is about Sauron in the books.
Sauron is said to be an aggressor who wants to conquer Middle-Earth and bring all the people living in it under his ...
- 48.1k
94
votes
6
answers
21k
views
What does Gandalf intend to chat with Tom Bombadil about?
Close to the end of The Return of the King, Gandalf tells one of the Hobbits that it's time for him to go and have a long talk with Tom Bombadil. Was there anything significant to this talk? Does ...
- 5,629
94
votes
6
answers
171k
views
How is Gandalf the White a "significantly more powerful figure" than Gandalf the Gray?
After his fight with the Balrog of Moria, Gandalf changed:
Gandalf was sent back as a significantly more powerful figure; Gandalf the White.
- "Gandalf - Gandalf the White", Wikipedia
What are ...
- 96.1k
93
votes
3
answers
15k
views
Why would Shelob own Sauron?
In Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, in the chapter Shelob’s Lair, there is a rather lengthy description of Shelob, the last remaining child of Ungoliant in Middle-Earth. In this, there is also a ...
- 14.1k
92
votes
7
answers
364k
views
In what order should Tolkien's writings on Middle-earth be read?
I've already read The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, which I assume would be the best start in any case. I also got about halfway through The Silmarillion several years ago and am quite familiar ...
- 7,565
92
votes
8
answers
90k
views
Which are the Two Towers in The Lord of the Rings?
I always wondered which are the two towers that are referred to in The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers. My memory is a bit hazy right now but there are at least 5 Towers that are mentioned in the ...
- 2,235
91
votes
6
answers
257k
views
Is there a hidden significance behind the fact Galadriel gave 3 hairs to Gimli instead of one?
I just saw an interesting interpretation of Galadriel's gift to Gimli on Reddit today, I retraced the source of the image to this tumblr post:
If you’ve read the Silmarillion, you know who Fëanor was....
- 96.1k
89
votes
8
answers
31k
views
Why didn't Sauron guard Mount Doom?
This fact had always bugged me. When Frodo finally goes to the Cracks of Doom he is met with practically no resistance. This seems uncharacteristic of Sauron which in my humble opinion makes it a tiny ...
- 2,235
89
votes
8
answers
183k
views
What is the true origin of the Orcs?
There are a bunch of theories about the true origin of the Orcs. Tolkien tried out a few different origins for his Orcs throughout his life but died before he could fully revise The Silmarillion with ...
- 1,219
89
votes
7
answers
21k
views
Why did the Fellowship not choose to pass the Misty Mountains further north or south?
At the Council of Elrond, it is known that:
Saruman is a traitor, thus it’s not possible for the Ring to pass through the gap of Rohan
Nobody has heard any news of Balin and Moria for a long time; ...
- 6,055
88
votes
4
answers
22k
views
Why Does Gandalf Think Rohan Should "Stand and Fight"?
In the Two Towers film adaptation (it has been about a decade since I read the book, so if there are differences, I'd like to know about them), Gandalf derisively sneers:
They flee to the mountains ...
- 1,837
87
votes
3
answers
29k
views
How did Sauron feed the armies of Mordor?
According to TolkienGateway.net, Mordor's troops consisted of some 18,000 Easterlings and Haradrim, several Haradrim war Oliphaunts, and tens of thousands of Orcs just for the Battle of the Pelennor ...
- 38.7k
87
votes
7
answers
337k
views
Why didn't Gimli know Moria had fallen?
Between Gandalf's fear of Moria, and the amount of time that has obviously passed (due to the condition of the remains of the dwarves in Moria), why is Gimli so unaware of the fall of his kin?
At ...
- 8,226
86
votes
7
answers
64k
views
Was the "Eye of Sauron" Sauron's actual physical form?
During the time frame of The Lord of the Rings, was the Eye of Sauron Sauron's actual physical form? If not, what form did he have?
- 63.6k
86
votes
11
answers
135k
views
Did the Ring Bearers and Gimli die in Valinor?
A comment on a recent question stated
The Undying Lands doesn't prevent mortals from dying so, in fact, [Frodo] died... maybe sixty years (or more, if his life was prolonged) after the end of the ...
- 30.9k