SlideShare a Scribd company logo
DevOps
delivering changes for
applications and databases
Quem somos
Eduardo Piairo, DevOps Engineer @ Basecone
@EdPiairo
https://pt.linkedin.com/in/jesuspiairo
eduardopiairo@outlook.com
http://www.eduardopiairo.com/
Quem Somos
Miguel Alho, Software Engineer @ Faro
@MytyMyky
https://pt.linkedin.com/in/miguelalho-982331
alho@miguelalho.com
http://www.miguelalho.pt/
Chapter 1: Introduction
1. The “DevOps” context
2. The problem that we want to fix
3. The database challenge
4. Infrastructure
5. Collaboration & Culture
6. Continuous Integration
7. Continuous Delivery
Chapter 2: Application
1. Microservice repository creation
2. Creating the first functionality with TDD
3. Implement a build job / CI pipeline
Chapter 3: Infrastructure
1. Physical machines
2. Virtual machines
3. Platform as a Service
4. Serverless
5. Infrastructure as Code
6. Provision and deployment for our microservice
Chapter 4: Database
1. The special case of the database
2. Database automation
3. Migrations vs State
4. Flyway
5. Database integration into our microservice
Chapter 5: Managing Changes
1. Business requirements changes
2. How interaction is important to determine how to move forward
3. Versioning strategies
4. Deployment strategies
5. Implementing changes in our Microservice
Chapter 6: DevOps engineering
1. Deployment pipeline
2. Why DevOps
3. DevOps contract
Chapter 1
Because everything starts with a problem...
The DevOps context
Chapter 1
Stakeholders
Sponsors / Customers
Product Owner / Project Manager
Coaches and Scrum Masters
Business Stakeholders
Architects, Leads and Developers
Quality Assurance Engineers
Release Engineers
DBAs
IT Operations
Development Stakeholders
User
Business stakeholders want...
Working software
Software that fix the customer's problems
Software that add value
New features and fast
Incremental features
Frequent changes (Continuous Change)
Business development and continuity
Sponsors / Costumers
Product Owner / Project Manager
Coaches and Scrum Masters
Business Stakeholders
Sponsors / Customers
Product Owner / Project Manager
Coaches and Scrum Masters
Business Stakeholders
Development stakeholders want...
Development Stakeholders
Develop quality solutions
Secure and stable solutions
Avoid bugs and midnight calls
Few obstacles
Architects, Leads and Developers
Quality Assurance Engineers
Release Engineers
DBAs
IT Operations
There is a problem
that we need to fix
Chapter 1
Dichotomy of interests
Traditionally there is collision of interests.
Devops intends to break this collision with communication, empathy and
collaboration improvement, along with useful technical practices, principally
automation
New features
Corrections and improvements
Optimizations
Stability
Security
Troubleshooting
Operations Devs
Delivery of new features quickly
Devs must be able to make changes to software quickly to integrate new features
Software should be developed in order to integrate changes, instead of simply
passing the tests
Requires:
● Use of adequate design patterns
● Automation of the build process
● Testing in different environments/levels
● Fast functionality validation
● Regression prevention
● Quality measurement
Software delivery consistently
Putting software in production should not be a headache
Requires:
● Continuous Integration
● Continuous Delivery
● Process automation – consistency guarantee
● Visibility – quality and metrics
Scalability
Rapidly answer to new needs for delivery as well as users load requirements
Requires:
● Provisioning automation
● Deployment automation
● Instance generation simplification
● Monitoring
The database
challenge
Chapter 1
Database as bottleneck
● Databases traditionally are out of pace with application development
● Easy target to blame
● Lack of traceability of databases changes (changes history)
● Manual database processes prevent CI and CD
Database as bottleneck
Requires:
● Automation
● Source Control database changes (1st step for db deployment pipeline)
● Synchronization between application and database
Infrastructure
Chapter 1
Infrastructure
How can you have the required consistency without including infrastructure?
If you practice (development) and play (production) in different fields, why do you
expect the same behavior/performance?
Collaboration
Not everything is possible to
solve with technical solutions
Chapter 1
DevOps change
Collaborative culture
Respect
Continuous learning
Consensus
Non-violent communication
Disposal of “Command and control” attitudes
It clearly can not be this:
TEAM creation/building
Investigation
Culture is key…
… but technical aspects do
matter
Chapter 1
Workshop: Delivering chnages for applications and databases
( )
http://www.slideshare.net/DougSeven/continuous-delivery-28357633
Knight(Mare)
● Knight Capital Group
● 3.3 billion trades daily
● $21.5 billion traded daily
● $365M cash & equivalents
-----
● NYSE launches Retail Liquidity Program on August 1, 2012, an automated
routing system for equity orders
● Group updates software to comply and repurpose 8-year old feature flag
Knight(mare)
“During the deployment of the new code, however, one of Knight’s technicians
did not copy the new code to one of the eight SMARs computer servers.”
SEC Filing | Release No. 70694 | October 16, 2013 ( http://tinyurl.com/Devops-Knightmare )
Knight(mare)
● 9:30 AM - Market Opens
● 212 small retail “parent-orders”
● 7 servers processing “child-orders” correctly.
● 8th server using the old feature flag code failed to recognize parent-orders
were fulfilled.
● 8th server sent cumulative child.-orders in rapid succession.
Knight(mare)
● No automated fail-safe
● No procedures for how to react
● Knight uninstalled the correct SMARS code from the seven servers where
it had been deployed correctly
● 9:30 AM to 10:15
● 4 million executions in 154 stocks
● 357 million shares
DevOps changes in Technical Practices
● Continuous Integration
● Continuous Delivery
● Provisioning (Infrastructure as Code)
● Containerization
● Microservices
● Database migrations
Continuous
Integration
Chapter 1
Continuous Integration
Increases your opportunities feedback (fast) feedback
Build software at every change
Features:
A connection to a version control repository
A build script
A feedback mechanism
A process for integrating the source code changes
Continuous Integration
To implement it, we need:
● Source Control - Git, Hg, Svn, TFS, ...
● Build System
○ Scripting - Cake, Psake, FAKE, Gulp …
○ Compiler and tools - MsBuild, Node/npm, GitVersion, …
○ Build Server - VSTS, TeamCity, AppVeyor, CircleCi
● Testing Framework - nUnit, xUnit, Fixie, tSQLt, ...
● Packaging mechanism - Nuget, Docker container, zip file…
Continuous Delivery
Chapter 1
Continuous Delivery
Deployment Pipeline
Automated implementation of the application’s build, deploy, test, and release
processes
Chapter 2
Application, the logical world
Here’s what we are going to do:
● Create a project in VSTS
● Create a repository for a Microservice, with in memory data
● Implement the microservice using TDD
● Create a basic build job for our microservice in VSTS
● Se this whole setup run
Chapter 3
Infrastructure (as code)
Physical machines
High hardware cost
High human cost
Very low flexibility
Virtual Machines
In the cloud
Upfront cost
First step to IaC
Requires configuration management
Platform as a Service (PaaS)
Very flexible approach
Costs grow with the application
Fast and simple development
Bring infrastructure/operations closer to the
development
Serverless (FaaS)
Azure Functions
AWS Lambda
Pay what you use
Infrastructure as Code (IaC)
Thank you Virtualization!!
Managing and provisioning infrastructure
Is not simply writing scripts
Allows to apply proven software development practices
Version control, testing, small deployments
Chapter 4
Database development
What’s so special about the database?
What’s so special about the database?
Database Lifecycle Management (DLM)
Data management and data migration
Data monitoring
Data recovery
Database challenges
Databases are out of pace with application development
Lack of traceability of database changes (changes history)
Manual databases processes prevent the CI and CD utilization
Lack of testability
Database setup time for new environments
Bugs in production
Database challenges
Databases becoming a
bottleneck in an agile delivery
process
Workshop: Delivering chnages for applications and databases
Why database automation?
Enable control over database development
Increase speed of response to change
Keep a versioned “history” of database states and changes
Reliability of the release process
Increase release frequency though repeatability of processes
Reduce time spent fixing bugs - automated tests
Remove/reduce human intervention in the release process
Why database automation?
Fearless database changes
1st Step: Source Control
First step in your database deployment pipeline
Traceability through change history
SQL as documentation
Shared code-base and shared process
Enforceable standards to reduce conflicts
1st Step: Source Control
Fundamental resource:
SQL Script
Migrations vs State
State based solutions
Script represents the current database state
Your source of truth is how the database should be
Migrations based solutions
Script represents a migration
Migration represents how to transition to the next database version
Your source of truth is how the database should change
Flyway
Flyway – “Database Migrations made Easy”
http://flywaydb.org/
Open source database migration tool
Flyway command-line enabled
Simplicity: easy to setup, no need to install
Zero dependencies (java + jdbc)
Scripts are written in SQL
Flyway: How it works
Flyway commands:
migrate, clean, info, validate, baseline, repair
Metadata table:
Used to track the state of the database
If the database is empty, flyway won’t find it and will create it
Flyway scans the migrations directory and check migrations against the metadata table
Migrations are sorted based on their version number and applied in order
Version Control System
Two components
Database scripts repo (git)
Flyway - database migrations
Rule 1: Script version (timestamp)
Rule 2: Operation type
Rule 3: Object type
Rule 4: Object name Example: V20160728.1100__Create_TB_MyTable.sql
Time to add a database to our service
● Provision development Database
● Add test project in Code
● Implement database features in our microservice
● Test
● Add steps in our build system to support this
● Deploy changes
Chapter 5
Managing changes...
Change is unavoidable
Businesses change naturally
● competitive advantage requires enhancements
● products need to move towards customer’s real needs
● social and economic context affects how business is done
Software NEEDS to change to enable this!
Change is not easy in software
Ideally, changes contained in one component should NOT break all the others!
Unfortunately, this is not always possible
● more than one app consumes a service
● more than one app consumes a database
● binary data contracts (dlls) need to be updated everywhere
● environment variables and changes affect program’s expected behaviour
● lack of tests brings uncertainty to change outcome
Many of these are anti-patterns!
Collaboration is key
● Need for change needs to be communicated
● Risk of change needs to be analysed
● Effects need to be listed to prepare for possible problems and avoid fire-
fighting
● Teams need to announce how changes will impact existing processes and
work.
● Teams need to determine if the change is done in a single step or in multiple
iterations.
Versioning strategies
● Versioning allows team to tag artifacts to a specific state
● Collaborating components can assert their validity based on versions
○ component A requires B version X or higher
● Semantic versioning gives meaning to number
○ prefer SemVer
● Automate versioning as much as possible
○ tooling and commit messages can be enough to indicate the type of change
● Important part of a CI pipeline - end result of a build is a specific version of an
SemVer
1.3.5-beta0003
major
minor patch
prerelease
increment on a
breaking change
increment on a
feature addition
increment on a
bug fix
increment while
unreleased
GitFlow
0.1.1-beta0001
0.1.1 0.2.0
Versioning is not easy
● But it is extremely important
● Semantics matter
○ minors and patches mean clients shouldn’t have to change anything, only update
○ Majors are breaking so clients need to take some maintenance and realignment action
● It’s also automatic documentation
Deployment strategies
You choose based on what your context is (traffic volume, working hours, SLAs)
● Single Server or service
○ Stop service, upgrade, restart
● Multiple Servers
○ Stop service, upgrade, restart
○ Blue-Green deployment
○ Canary Deployment
Whatever the scenario, automation is key
Deployments with DBs make things harder
● Database’s data is mutable. It’s super hard to rollback!
○ How do you rollback changes that delete a column of data?
● Application is typically immutable. It’s way easier to rollback
○ Just need the database schema to be compatible
This means that we typically need to make changes in multiple steps to avoid
breaking the service. Schema should valid for backward compatible to at least 1
version of the application. Marking things as deprecated can / should make a
difference.
Chapter 6
DevOps as engineering practice...
What we just saw
Why DevOps
Developing software is not enough, you have to deliver it
Communication framework for change management
You can not stop change, but you can control it
Perspectives
Need for speed (time-to- market) (management people)
Need for control (error control) (operations people)
DevOps: contract for collaboration and communication
Contract - change communication management tool
Change description (Source Control)
Change validation (Continuous Integration)
Change implementation (Continuous Delivery)
Applications, databases, infrastructure
DevOps advices
Operations requirements in Backlog
Operations engineers in Product Team
Shared goals Shared responsibilities
Devs monitor apps
Devs deploy apps
Reading material
Workshop: Delivering chnages for applications and databases
Links
Demo application “Purchases-DbMigration-sample”
https://github.com/MiguelAlho/Purchases-DbMigration-sample
Flyway
https://flywaydb.org/
DbUp
http://dbup.github.io/
Octopus Deploy
https://octopus.com/
http://docs.octopusdeploy.com/display/OD/Deploying+ASP.NET+Core+Web+Applications
Visual Studio
https://www.visualstudio.com/
Final Q&A

More Related Content

Workshop: Delivering chnages for applications and databases

  • 2. Quem somos Eduardo Piairo, DevOps Engineer @ Basecone @EdPiairo https://pt.linkedin.com/in/jesuspiairo eduardopiairo@outlook.com http://www.eduardopiairo.com/
  • 3. Quem Somos Miguel Alho, Software Engineer @ Faro @MytyMyky https://pt.linkedin.com/in/miguelalho-982331 alho@miguelalho.com http://www.miguelalho.pt/
  • 4. Chapter 1: Introduction 1. The “DevOps” context 2. The problem that we want to fix 3. The database challenge 4. Infrastructure 5. Collaboration & Culture 6. Continuous Integration 7. Continuous Delivery
  • 5. Chapter 2: Application 1. Microservice repository creation 2. Creating the first functionality with TDD 3. Implement a build job / CI pipeline
  • 6. Chapter 3: Infrastructure 1. Physical machines 2. Virtual machines 3. Platform as a Service 4. Serverless 5. Infrastructure as Code 6. Provision and deployment for our microservice
  • 7. Chapter 4: Database 1. The special case of the database 2. Database automation 3. Migrations vs State 4. Flyway 5. Database integration into our microservice
  • 8. Chapter 5: Managing Changes 1. Business requirements changes 2. How interaction is important to determine how to move forward 3. Versioning strategies 4. Deployment strategies 5. Implementing changes in our Microservice
  • 9. Chapter 6: DevOps engineering 1. Deployment pipeline 2. Why DevOps 3. DevOps contract
  • 10. Chapter 1 Because everything starts with a problem...
  • 12. Stakeholders Sponsors / Customers Product Owner / Project Manager Coaches and Scrum Masters Business Stakeholders Architects, Leads and Developers Quality Assurance Engineers Release Engineers DBAs IT Operations Development Stakeholders User
  • 13. Business stakeholders want... Working software Software that fix the customer's problems Software that add value New features and fast Incremental features Frequent changes (Continuous Change) Business development and continuity Sponsors / Costumers Product Owner / Project Manager Coaches and Scrum Masters Business Stakeholders Sponsors / Customers Product Owner / Project Manager Coaches and Scrum Masters Business Stakeholders
  • 14. Development stakeholders want... Development Stakeholders Develop quality solutions Secure and stable solutions Avoid bugs and midnight calls Few obstacles Architects, Leads and Developers Quality Assurance Engineers Release Engineers DBAs IT Operations
  • 15. There is a problem that we need to fix Chapter 1
  • 16. Dichotomy of interests Traditionally there is collision of interests. Devops intends to break this collision with communication, empathy and collaboration improvement, along with useful technical practices, principally automation New features Corrections and improvements Optimizations Stability Security Troubleshooting Operations Devs
  • 17. Delivery of new features quickly Devs must be able to make changes to software quickly to integrate new features Software should be developed in order to integrate changes, instead of simply passing the tests Requires: ● Use of adequate design patterns ● Automation of the build process ● Testing in different environments/levels ● Fast functionality validation ● Regression prevention ● Quality measurement
  • 18. Software delivery consistently Putting software in production should not be a headache Requires: ● Continuous Integration ● Continuous Delivery ● Process automation – consistency guarantee ● Visibility – quality and metrics
  • 19. Scalability Rapidly answer to new needs for delivery as well as users load requirements Requires: ● Provisioning automation ● Deployment automation ● Instance generation simplification ● Monitoring
  • 21. Database as bottleneck ● Databases traditionally are out of pace with application development ● Easy target to blame ● Lack of traceability of databases changes (changes history) ● Manual database processes prevent CI and CD
  • 22. Database as bottleneck Requires: ● Automation ● Source Control database changes (1st step for db deployment pipeline) ● Synchronization between application and database
  • 24. Infrastructure How can you have the required consistency without including infrastructure? If you practice (development) and play (production) in different fields, why do you expect the same behavior/performance?
  • 25. Collaboration Not everything is possible to solve with technical solutions Chapter 1
  • 27. Collaborative culture Respect Continuous learning Consensus Non-violent communication Disposal of “Command and control” attitudes
  • 28. It clearly can not be this:
  • 31. Culture is key… … but technical aspects do matter Chapter 1
  • 34. Knight(Mare) ● Knight Capital Group ● 3.3 billion trades daily ● $21.5 billion traded daily ● $365M cash & equivalents ----- ● NYSE launches Retail Liquidity Program on August 1, 2012, an automated routing system for equity orders ● Group updates software to comply and repurpose 8-year old feature flag
  • 35. Knight(mare) “During the deployment of the new code, however, one of Knight’s technicians did not copy the new code to one of the eight SMARs computer servers.” SEC Filing | Release No. 70694 | October 16, 2013 ( http://tinyurl.com/Devops-Knightmare )
  • 36. Knight(mare) ● 9:30 AM - Market Opens ● 212 small retail “parent-orders” ● 7 servers processing “child-orders” correctly. ● 8th server using the old feature flag code failed to recognize parent-orders were fulfilled. ● 8th server sent cumulative child.-orders in rapid succession.
  • 37. Knight(mare) ● No automated fail-safe ● No procedures for how to react ● Knight uninstalled the correct SMARS code from the seven servers where it had been deployed correctly ● 9:30 AM to 10:15 ● 4 million executions in 154 stocks ● 357 million shares
  • 38. DevOps changes in Technical Practices ● Continuous Integration ● Continuous Delivery ● Provisioning (Infrastructure as Code) ● Containerization ● Microservices ● Database migrations
  • 40. Continuous Integration Increases your opportunities feedback (fast) feedback Build software at every change Features: A connection to a version control repository A build script A feedback mechanism A process for integrating the source code changes
  • 41. Continuous Integration To implement it, we need: ● Source Control - Git, Hg, Svn, TFS, ... ● Build System ○ Scripting - Cake, Psake, FAKE, Gulp … ○ Compiler and tools - MsBuild, Node/npm, GitVersion, … ○ Build Server - VSTS, TeamCity, AppVeyor, CircleCi ● Testing Framework - nUnit, xUnit, Fixie, tSQLt, ... ● Packaging mechanism - Nuget, Docker container, zip file…
  • 43. Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline Automated implementation of the application’s build, deploy, test, and release processes
  • 44. Chapter 2 Application, the logical world
  • 45. Here’s what we are going to do: ● Create a project in VSTS ● Create a repository for a Microservice, with in memory data ● Implement the microservice using TDD ● Create a basic build job for our microservice in VSTS ● Se this whole setup run
  • 47. Physical machines High hardware cost High human cost Very low flexibility
  • 48. Virtual Machines In the cloud Upfront cost First step to IaC Requires configuration management
  • 49. Platform as a Service (PaaS) Very flexible approach Costs grow with the application Fast and simple development Bring infrastructure/operations closer to the development
  • 50. Serverless (FaaS) Azure Functions AWS Lambda Pay what you use
  • 51. Infrastructure as Code (IaC) Thank you Virtualization!! Managing and provisioning infrastructure Is not simply writing scripts Allows to apply proven software development practices Version control, testing, small deployments
  • 53. What’s so special about the database?
  • 54. What’s so special about the database?
  • 55. Database Lifecycle Management (DLM) Data management and data migration Data monitoring Data recovery
  • 56. Database challenges Databases are out of pace with application development Lack of traceability of database changes (changes history) Manual databases processes prevent the CI and CD utilization Lack of testability Database setup time for new environments Bugs in production
  • 57. Database challenges Databases becoming a bottleneck in an agile delivery process
  • 59. Why database automation? Enable control over database development Increase speed of response to change Keep a versioned “history” of database states and changes Reliability of the release process Increase release frequency though repeatability of processes Reduce time spent fixing bugs - automated tests Remove/reduce human intervention in the release process
  • 61. 1st Step: Source Control First step in your database deployment pipeline Traceability through change history SQL as documentation Shared code-base and shared process Enforceable standards to reduce conflicts
  • 62. 1st Step: Source Control Fundamental resource: SQL Script
  • 63. Migrations vs State State based solutions Script represents the current database state Your source of truth is how the database should be Migrations based solutions Script represents a migration Migration represents how to transition to the next database version Your source of truth is how the database should change
  • 64. Flyway Flyway – “Database Migrations made Easy” http://flywaydb.org/ Open source database migration tool Flyway command-line enabled Simplicity: easy to setup, no need to install Zero dependencies (java + jdbc) Scripts are written in SQL
  • 65. Flyway: How it works Flyway commands: migrate, clean, info, validate, baseline, repair Metadata table: Used to track the state of the database If the database is empty, flyway won’t find it and will create it Flyway scans the migrations directory and check migrations against the metadata table Migrations are sorted based on their version number and applied in order
  • 66. Version Control System Two components Database scripts repo (git) Flyway - database migrations Rule 1: Script version (timestamp) Rule 2: Operation type Rule 3: Object type Rule 4: Object name Example: V20160728.1100__Create_TB_MyTable.sql
  • 67. Time to add a database to our service ● Provision development Database ● Add test project in Code ● Implement database features in our microservice ● Test ● Add steps in our build system to support this ● Deploy changes
  • 69. Change is unavoidable Businesses change naturally ● competitive advantage requires enhancements ● products need to move towards customer’s real needs ● social and economic context affects how business is done Software NEEDS to change to enable this!
  • 70. Change is not easy in software Ideally, changes contained in one component should NOT break all the others! Unfortunately, this is not always possible ● more than one app consumes a service ● more than one app consumes a database ● binary data contracts (dlls) need to be updated everywhere ● environment variables and changes affect program’s expected behaviour ● lack of tests brings uncertainty to change outcome Many of these are anti-patterns!
  • 71. Collaboration is key ● Need for change needs to be communicated ● Risk of change needs to be analysed ● Effects need to be listed to prepare for possible problems and avoid fire- fighting ● Teams need to announce how changes will impact existing processes and work. ● Teams need to determine if the change is done in a single step or in multiple iterations.
  • 72. Versioning strategies ● Versioning allows team to tag artifacts to a specific state ● Collaborating components can assert their validity based on versions ○ component A requires B version X or higher ● Semantic versioning gives meaning to number ○ prefer SemVer ● Automate versioning as much as possible ○ tooling and commit messages can be enough to indicate the type of change ● Important part of a CI pipeline - end result of a build is a specific version of an
  • 73. SemVer 1.3.5-beta0003 major minor patch prerelease increment on a breaking change increment on a feature addition increment on a bug fix increment while unreleased
  • 76. Versioning is not easy ● But it is extremely important ● Semantics matter ○ minors and patches mean clients shouldn’t have to change anything, only update ○ Majors are breaking so clients need to take some maintenance and realignment action ● It’s also automatic documentation
  • 77. Deployment strategies You choose based on what your context is (traffic volume, working hours, SLAs) ● Single Server or service ○ Stop service, upgrade, restart ● Multiple Servers ○ Stop service, upgrade, restart ○ Blue-Green deployment ○ Canary Deployment Whatever the scenario, automation is key
  • 78. Deployments with DBs make things harder ● Database’s data is mutable. It’s super hard to rollback! ○ How do you rollback changes that delete a column of data? ● Application is typically immutable. It’s way easier to rollback ○ Just need the database schema to be compatible This means that we typically need to make changes in multiple steps to avoid breaking the service. Schema should valid for backward compatible to at least 1 version of the application. Marking things as deprecated can / should make a difference.
  • 79. Chapter 6 DevOps as engineering practice...
  • 81. Why DevOps Developing software is not enough, you have to deliver it Communication framework for change management You can not stop change, but you can control it Perspectives Need for speed (time-to- market) (management people) Need for control (error control) (operations people)
  • 82. DevOps: contract for collaboration and communication Contract - change communication management tool Change description (Source Control) Change validation (Continuous Integration) Change implementation (Continuous Delivery) Applications, databases, infrastructure
  • 83. DevOps advices Operations requirements in Backlog Operations engineers in Product Team Shared goals Shared responsibilities Devs monitor apps Devs deploy apps
  • 86. Links
  • 87. Demo application “Purchases-DbMigration-sample” https://github.com/MiguelAlho/Purchases-DbMigration-sample Flyway https://flywaydb.org/ DbUp http://dbup.github.io/ Octopus Deploy https://octopus.com/ http://docs.octopusdeploy.com/display/OD/Deploying+ASP.NET+Core+Web+Applications Visual Studio https://www.visualstudio.com/