SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The True Significance of Panda and
             Penguin
       You Ain’t Seen Nothin’ Yet
First Off... Who Am I?

 Co-author: The Art of SEO
 President: Stone Temple Consulting
  25+ person SEO and PPC firm
 Trainer: Instant E-Training
 Founder: Web Site Publishing Companies
  Publish web sites, grow them, then sell them
  2 significant exits so far
 Twitter: @stonetemple
 Google Plus: +Eric Enge


          @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
SEOs Created Garbage Content




   @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
SEOs Focused on Tricks




@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
But What About Users?




@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
The User is Central to the Google Algo


                             “that is a part of what
                             our algorithm does:
                             work to find quality
                             diverse results that
                             help solve problems
                             for users.”
Google’s Matt Cutts



          @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Bad Link Building Practices




 @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Bought Links




@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Matt Cutts on “Link Building”



                     “It segments you into a
                     mindset, and people
                     get focused on the
                     wrong things”




  @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
First Panda


                        Feb 23, 2011
                        Attacked poor
                         content sites
                        Many updates
                         since then (on
                         version 3.9)



@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Then Penguin

                  April 24, 2012
                  Speculation is that this
                   targeted:
                        Bad anchor text mix
                        Comment spam
                        Paid guest posts
                        Article marketing sites




@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Panda/Penguin Algorithm Structure
     Questionable SEO /
     Link Building Tactic               Ranking
          Identified                   Adjustment
                                          Score


No         Can we
           Write an                   Penguin/Panda
           Algo to                    Algo Scheduler
           Flag it?

                 Yes
                                         Master
       Create the Algo                   Google
        Run the Algo                      Index


         @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Why is This Important?

 Many potential spam detection algorithms are
  very compute intensive
   Too much computing time to include in the main
    algo
 Key component is the ability plug in a ranking
  adjustment score from an external database




            @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Matt Cutts on Panda/Penguin



                     “… you are right that
                     these algorithms do
                     represent new types of
                     capabilities for us.”




  @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Article Directory Example (My Theory)
                  Extract List of      Calculate
                      Sites             Quality
                  Participating       Adjustment




                                       Put in DB
                Build List of Sites    For Main
                With Large % of          Algo
                 Link Juice from
                    Art. Dirs.


      @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Article Directory Example
            Extract List of      Calculate
                Sites             Quality
            Participating       Adjustment




                                 Put in DB
          Build List of Sites    For Main
          With Large % of          Algo
           Link Juice from
              Art. Dirs.


@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
So What’s Next?




  (Speculation Ahead!)


@stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Thin Content Pages with Too Many Links




       @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Bad PR Balance
Quantity




                         PageRank

           @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Bad PR Balance
Quantity




                                  No Trusted Links


                         PageRank

           @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Matt Cutts on Panda/Penguin - Infographics


                            “I would not be surprised
                            if at some point in the
                            future we did not start to
                            discount these
                            infographic-type links to
                            a degree.”




         @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Low Relevance Infographic Links




   @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Low Relevance Blog Posts

        Travel to New Zealand

New Zealand is a wonderful place to
visit. There are many different types of
customs used. Cars can be rented if you
want to create your own travel
itinerary.
Still Low Relevance

     How to Make Cotton Candy

Cotton Candy is a treat beloved by
many children. You can make at home,
and you do not need to do remodel
your kitchen to do so. All you need to
do is get yourself a $4,327.45 device …
Try to Cover Your Tracks?

Wikipedia page All About Mortgages       Your shameless
                                         money page
     Mortgages are the biggest financial
     commitment most people make. You
     can get the best mortgage rates by Fhfa.gov page
     getting multiple quotes. Some great
     information is available from the
     Federal Housing Financial Agency.
Does Your Anchor Text Look Like This?


       6% 12%
 10%
                   11%
11%

 13%             23%
       14%




        @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Or, Like This?



Domain


   Brand Name




     @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Highly Commercial Term Results Manual Review




 Take the Top 500
    Commercial Spaces
 Review Results by
    Hand



             @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Thin Geographic Pages

   Seattle Pizza            Boston Pizza

We offer the best        We offer the best
pizza in Seattle.        pizza in Boston.
Using only local         Using only local
Seattle ingredients,     Boston ingredients,
we help create jobs      we help create jobs
Matt Cutts on Thin Geographic Pages

                         “Where people get into
                         trouble here is that they
                         fill these pages with the
                         exact same content on
                         each page. ‘Our
                         handcrafted pizza is
                         lovingly made with the
                         same methods we have
                         been using for more than
                         50 years …’ ”


      @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
Thank You!



Eric Enge
  eenge@stonetemple.com
  @stonetemple
  + Eric Enge
  (508) 485-7751
  www.stonetemple.com

More Related Content

SMX East 2012: Pandas and Penguins 09-15-2012

  • 1. The True Significance of Panda and Penguin You Ain’t Seen Nothin’ Yet
  • 2. First Off... Who Am I?  Co-author: The Art of SEO  President: Stone Temple Consulting 25+ person SEO and PPC firm  Trainer: Instant E-Training  Founder: Web Site Publishing Companies Publish web sites, grow them, then sell them 2 significant exits so far  Twitter: @stonetemple  Google Plus: +Eric Enge @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 3. SEOs Created Garbage Content @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 4. SEOs Focused on Tricks @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 5. But What About Users? @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 6. The User is Central to the Google Algo “that is a part of what our algorithm does: work to find quality diverse results that help solve problems for users.” Google’s Matt Cutts @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 7. Bad Link Building Practices @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 9. Matt Cutts on “Link Building” “It segments you into a mindset, and people get focused on the wrong things” @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 10. First Panda  Feb 23, 2011  Attacked poor content sites  Many updates since then (on version 3.9) @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 11. Then Penguin  April 24, 2012  Speculation is that this targeted:  Bad anchor text mix  Comment spam  Paid guest posts  Article marketing sites @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 12. Panda/Penguin Algorithm Structure Questionable SEO / Link Building Tactic Ranking Identified Adjustment Score No Can we Write an Penguin/Panda Algo to Algo Scheduler Flag it? Yes Master Create the Algo Google Run the Algo Index @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 13. Why is This Important?  Many potential spam detection algorithms are very compute intensive  Too much computing time to include in the main algo  Key component is the ability plug in a ranking adjustment score from an external database @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 14. Matt Cutts on Panda/Penguin “… you are right that these algorithms do represent new types of capabilities for us.” @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 15. Article Directory Example (My Theory) Extract List of Calculate Sites Quality Participating Adjustment Put in DB Build List of Sites For Main With Large % of Algo Link Juice from Art. Dirs. @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 16. Article Directory Example Extract List of Calculate Sites Quality Participating Adjustment Put in DB Build List of Sites For Main With Large % of Algo Link Juice from Art. Dirs. @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 17. So What’s Next? (Speculation Ahead!) @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 18. Thin Content Pages with Too Many Links @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 19. Bad PR Balance Quantity PageRank @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 20. Bad PR Balance Quantity No Trusted Links PageRank @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 21. Matt Cutts on Panda/Penguin - Infographics “I would not be surprised if at some point in the future we did not start to discount these infographic-type links to a degree.” @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 22. Low Relevance Infographic Links @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 23. Low Relevance Blog Posts Travel to New Zealand New Zealand is a wonderful place to visit. There are many different types of customs used. Cars can be rented if you want to create your own travel itinerary.
  • 24. Still Low Relevance How to Make Cotton Candy Cotton Candy is a treat beloved by many children. You can make at home, and you do not need to do remodel your kitchen to do so. All you need to do is get yourself a $4,327.45 device …
  • 25. Try to Cover Your Tracks? Wikipedia page All About Mortgages Your shameless money page Mortgages are the biggest financial commitment most people make. You can get the best mortgage rates by Fhfa.gov page getting multiple quotes. Some great information is available from the Federal Housing Financial Agency.
  • 26. Does Your Anchor Text Look Like This? 6% 12% 10% 11% 11% 13% 23% 14% @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 27. Or, Like This? Domain Brand Name @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 28. Highly Commercial Term Results Manual Review  Take the Top 500 Commercial Spaces  Review Results by Hand @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 29. Thin Geographic Pages Seattle Pizza Boston Pizza We offer the best We offer the best pizza in Seattle. pizza in Boston. Using only local Using only local Seattle ingredients, Boston ingredients, we help create jobs we help create jobs
  • 30. Matt Cutts on Thin Geographic Pages “Where people get into trouble here is that they fill these pages with the exact same content on each page. ‘Our handcrafted pizza is lovingly made with the same methods we have been using for more than 50 years …’ ” @stonetemple / + Eric Enge
  • 31. Thank You! Eric Enge eenge@stonetemple.com @stonetemple + Eric Enge (508) 485-7751 www.stonetemple.com