SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Session 3B: Cyber Security for Distributed Renewable Generation
                        and Smart Grids

   Moderator: Ralph Martinez, Director, Regional Cyber and Energy
          Security Center, The University of Texas at El Paso
• Angel Avila, Cyber Specialist, Defensive Network Security
  Consultants, LLC
• Charles Hamilton, Protective Security Advisor, Department of
  Homeland Security
• Gene Rodriquez, Energy and Utilities Industry Solutions
  Executive, IBM
Definitions for Cyber and Energy Security

                 Cyber                                                     Energy
                Security                                                   Security
• Cyber security measures and prevents                      • Energy security allows
endangerment to energy system cyber                         government, industry and civil institutions
infrastructure due to external and internal                 to:
agents.
                                                              • Prevent loss of access to power and fuel
• External Agents:                                              sources (surety)
 •   industrial espionage                                     • Ensure resilience in energy systems
 •   international crime groups                                 (survivability)
 •   terrorist groups                                         • Provide access to alternative and
 •   natural disasters                                          renewable energy sources available on
                                                                installations (supply)
• Internal Agents:                                            • Provide adequate power for critical
 • disgruntled employees
                                                                missions (sufficiency)
 • user errors
                                                              • Promote support for the customer’s
 • equipment failures
                                                                mission, its community, and the
• Agents can alter the infrastructure at                        environment (sustainability).
different levels (network, system, individual                 • Promote the adoption of distributed
component) to destabilize it to                                 renewable generation, such as solar PV
unpredictable conditions.                                       and wind.


                                  Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso                           2
Recent Cyber and Energy Security
              Incidents

Cyber Security Incidents:
• Insider Security Threats to Utilities
• Security Incidents Rise In Industrial Control Systems
• Spike In Power Grid Attacks Likely In Next 12 Months

CBS 60 Minutes Video on Cyber and Energy Security of the U.S. Power
  Grid
• http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=6578069n

Energy Security Incidents:
• One Electrical Worker Blamed for Leaving Millions Without Power in
  California, Arizona and Mexico, September 2011
• Arizona Wildfire Forces Evacuations as Texas, New Mexico Face
  Power Outages
• January’s freeze still has the Sun City shivering
                     Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso   3
Steps to Achieving a Security and Reliable
                    Power Grid in RCES Center
• RCES Center Core Capabilities
  • Derived from DOE/DoD WGs                                                                 Sustain
                                                                               Year 5-6
  • Product and Services test and              Cyber                                      Cyber Security
    certification                             Test &
                                                                                            Systems
  • VARM                                    Certification

                                                                                             Manage
• Ancillary RCES Center Capabilities Interoperability                          Year 4-5     Incidents
  • Solar PV Market Acceleration          With Electric
                                         Grid Standards                                     & Training
  • Cyber Security/Power Degrees
  • Workforce Training                                                                    Develop Test
  • Professional Engineer training Cyber Security Architecture                 Year 3-4   & Certification
  • Technology Transfer            And Requirements for Region                            Methodology
  • Educational Workshops

                                  Conceptual Cyber Security                    Year 2-3     Assess &
                               Reference Model for Electric Grids                          Monitor Risk


                                                                                            Build Cyber
                                    Regional Business and Public               Year 1
                                        Policy Requirements
                                                                                          Security & Solar
                                                                                              Culture

                              Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso                      4
*

               * NIST/EPRI Smart Grid Interim Roadmap Report, June 2009


Seven Smart Grid
    Domains




                                         Cyber Security
                                          Everywhere




     Physical and
     Operational
       Security
     For Domains


                           Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso       5
Cyber Security
                                                  Everywhere


Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso                    6
Session 3B: Cyber Security for
             Distributed Renewable Generation and
             Smart Grids

• Angel Avila, Cyber Specialist, Defensive Network Security
  Consultants, LLC
• Charles Hamilton, Protective Security Advisor, Department of
  Homeland Security
• Gene Rodriquez, Energy and Utilities Industry Solutions
  Executive, IBM
• Panel Discussion




                     Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso   7

More Related Content

2012 Reenergize the Americas 3B: Ralph Martinez

  • 1. Session 3B: Cyber Security for Distributed Renewable Generation and Smart Grids Moderator: Ralph Martinez, Director, Regional Cyber and Energy Security Center, The University of Texas at El Paso • Angel Avila, Cyber Specialist, Defensive Network Security Consultants, LLC • Charles Hamilton, Protective Security Advisor, Department of Homeland Security • Gene Rodriquez, Energy and Utilities Industry Solutions Executive, IBM
  • 2. Definitions for Cyber and Energy Security Cyber Energy Security Security • Cyber security measures and prevents • Energy security allows endangerment to energy system cyber government, industry and civil institutions infrastructure due to external and internal to: agents. • Prevent loss of access to power and fuel • External Agents: sources (surety) • industrial espionage • Ensure resilience in energy systems • international crime groups (survivability) • terrorist groups • Provide access to alternative and • natural disasters renewable energy sources available on installations (supply) • Internal Agents: • Provide adequate power for critical • disgruntled employees missions (sufficiency) • user errors • Promote support for the customer’s • equipment failures mission, its community, and the • Agents can alter the infrastructure at environment (sustainability). different levels (network, system, individual • Promote the adoption of distributed component) to destabilize it to renewable generation, such as solar PV unpredictable conditions. and wind. Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso 2
  • 3. Recent Cyber and Energy Security Incidents Cyber Security Incidents: • Insider Security Threats to Utilities • Security Incidents Rise In Industrial Control Systems • Spike In Power Grid Attacks Likely In Next 12 Months CBS 60 Minutes Video on Cyber and Energy Security of the U.S. Power Grid • http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=6578069n Energy Security Incidents: • One Electrical Worker Blamed for Leaving Millions Without Power in California, Arizona and Mexico, September 2011 • Arizona Wildfire Forces Evacuations as Texas, New Mexico Face Power Outages • January’s freeze still has the Sun City shivering Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso 3
  • 4. Steps to Achieving a Security and Reliable Power Grid in RCES Center • RCES Center Core Capabilities • Derived from DOE/DoD WGs Sustain Year 5-6 • Product and Services test and Cyber Cyber Security certification Test & Systems • VARM Certification Manage • Ancillary RCES Center Capabilities Interoperability Year 4-5 Incidents • Solar PV Market Acceleration With Electric Grid Standards & Training • Cyber Security/Power Degrees • Workforce Training Develop Test • Professional Engineer training Cyber Security Architecture Year 3-4 & Certification • Technology Transfer And Requirements for Region Methodology • Educational Workshops Conceptual Cyber Security Year 2-3 Assess & Reference Model for Electric Grids Monitor Risk Build Cyber Regional Business and Public Year 1 Policy Requirements Security & Solar Culture Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso 4
  • 5. * * NIST/EPRI Smart Grid Interim Roadmap Report, June 2009 Seven Smart Grid Domains Cyber Security Everywhere Physical and Operational Security For Domains Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso 5
  • 6. Cyber Security Everywhere Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso 6
  • 7. Session 3B: Cyber Security for Distributed Renewable Generation and Smart Grids • Angel Avila, Cyber Specialist, Defensive Network Security Consultants, LLC • Charles Hamilton, Protective Security Advisor, Department of Homeland Security • Gene Rodriquez, Energy and Utilities Industry Solutions Executive, IBM • Panel Discussion Copyright @ The University of Texas at El Paso 7