IT governance in SMEs
- 2. Agenda
Introduction
Four IT Governance important constructs
Three case studies analysis
Recommendations for IT Governance practices
Summary
Questions and answers
2
- 3. Introduction
Research in 2004 (*). Peter Weill – Jeanne W. Ross
Plus sign: IT Governance helps company increase 20% profit
Minus sign: Only 38% of senior managers know how IT is governed
Study of 300 enterprises – Weill and Ross
There is not a single best formula for governing IT
100% sure: effective ITG doesn‟t happen by accident
Top performing enterprises carefully design governance
Managers make daily decision putting design into practice
PwC research
Most interviewed organizations recognize the importance of IT
Governance
However, a „holistic‟ view that considers all dimensions of IT
Governance is not widely found
Source:
http://www.researchgate.net/publication/228139751_IT_Governance_on_One_Page/file/e0b49518ae03e11409.pdf
http://www.pwc.com/en_mt/mt/publications/assets/it-governance-in-practice-jan-2007.pdf
3
- 4. Introduction
IT Governance
“Specifying the decision rights and accountability framework to
encourage desirable behavior in the use of IT”, Weill and Ross
Align IT strategies/goals/objectives with other activities of the
company to ensure that IT effectively supports the development of
the company.
Small and Medium sized Enterprise
Workers: < 500 (US); < 300 (VN)
Capital: < $50m (US); < $5m (VN)
Source: White paper – SMEs in Vietnam
http://www.economica.vn/Portals/0/MauBieu/70c475bbbf81ecb8d32698a30924e978.pdf
US International Trade Commission
http://www.usitc.gov/publications/332/pub4169.pdf
4
- 5. Introduction
SMEs in Vietnam
2010: 250.000 SMEs
2015: 600.000 (est.)
32% of enterprises
65%
30%
2% 3%
Micro
Small
Medium
Large
Source:
General Statistics Office, Viet Nam’s Enterprises in the first 9 years of 21 century. Statistics Publishing House, Ha Noi, 2010
http://www.economica.vn/Portals/0/MauBieu/70c475bbbf81ecb8d32698a30924e978.pdf
5
- 6. Introduction
Limitation of using IT in SMEs
Financial constraints limit their abilities to invest in IT and to
attract highly capable IT professionals
Enterprise‟s owner/top manager lack IT expertise and experience
Use of IT in SMEs in Vietnam
Only 20% of SMEs use ICT
Only 5% do so for business operations
Source: [World Bank] Vietnam - ICT Development Report
http://www.worldbank.org/projects/P079344/vietnam-ict-development?lang=en
6
- 7. Introduction
How can SMEs optimize IT performance
through governance practices?
7
Source: Rui Huang, Robert W. Zmud, R Leon Price
IT Governance Practices in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises: Recommendations from an Empirical Study
http://ifipwg82.org/sites/ifipwg82.org/files/Ch12-19-IT%20Governance%20Practices%20in%20SME-formatted.pdf
- 8. Four IT Governance
important constructs
Decision structure
Senior management involvement in IT Governance Processes
IT Governance Communication Practices
IT Success
Source: Rui Huang, Robert W. Zmud, R Leon Price
IT Governance Practices in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises: Recommendations from an Empirical Study
http://ifipwg82.org/sites/ifipwg82.org/files/Ch12-19-IT%20Governance%20Practices%20in%20SME-formatted.pdf
8
- 9. Four IT Governance
important constructs
1. Decision structure: How IT decisions are made?
Sub-Category Description
Centralization
Decisions made by corporate-level IT/business
senior managers
Hybrid
Decisions jointly made by corporate and
divisional senior managers
Decentralization Decisions made by divisional senior managers
9
- 10. Four IT Governance
important constructs
2. Senior Management Involvement in IT Governance Processes:
Ensure the alignment b/w business and IT
Sub-Category Description
Formal
Involvement
Active participation of executive managers in
formal IT steering committees
Informal
Involvement
Senior managers, categorized as corporate
senior managers, divisional senior managers or
both, having regular interactions with the CIO
10
- 11. Four IT Governance
important constructs
3. IT Governance Communication Practices: Ensure members
behave correctly with IT-related actions
Sub-Category Description
Number of
Channels
Number (and types) of communication channels
used to communicate IT governance policies,
guidelines and practices throughout the SME.
Primary
Communication
Channel
The primary communication channel used to
communicate IT policies, guidelines and
procedures throughout the SME
11
- 12. Four IT Governance
important constructs
4. IT Success: How the company success in deploying IT?
Sub-Category Description
Efficiency of IT
Use
How efficient the firm has been in its use of IT (a
5-point scale with 5 representing the highest
efficiency; averaged by number of respondents)
Breadth of
current IT use
The number of distinct areas identified,
aggregated across interviewees, where IT is
being appropriately used
Breadth of
potential IT use
The number of distinct work processes identified,
by any interviewees, as being actively
considered or planned for future IT use
12
- 13. Coming up next!
Introduction
Four IT Governance important constructs
Three case studies analysis
Recommendations for SME Governance practices
Summary
Questions and answers
13
- 14. Three case studies analysis *
HealthCare:
Health care management organization
Multiple offices in US
Agriculture:
Provide consultation services in agriculture techniques
Non-profit research foundation
Pharma:
Manufacture subsidiary of an international
pharmaceutical company
Businesses in Asia Pacific, North American, and Europe
(*) Data getting from IT Governance Practices in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise paper
14
- 15. Three case studies analysis
HealthCare Agriculture Pharma
Firm size 182 300 360
IT Group size 12 14 10
Interviewees
CIO
4 Divisional VPs
CIO
2 Divisional
Directors
CIO
Controllers
Divisional
Director
Demographic Information on Research Sites
15
- 16. Three case studies analysis
IT Governance Structure
HealthCare Agriculture Pharma
Structure Centralized Centralized Centralized
Key IT decision
CxOs
(CEO, CIO,..)
CIO CIO
16
- 17. Three case studies analysis
Senior Management Involvement in IT Governance Processes
HealthCare Agriculture Pharma
Formal
Involvement
CIO
Corporate
Executives
N/A
CIO
Divisional
Executives
Informal
Involvement
Corporate
Executives
Divisional
Executives
Divisional
Executives
17
- 18. Three case studies analysis
IT Governance Communication Practices
HealthCare Agriculture Pharma
Communication
channels
Email
Word of mouth
Paper docs
Formal meeting
Word of mouth
Intranet
Paper docs
Formal meeting
Word of mouth
Primary
communication
channel
Email Paper docs Intranet
18
- 19. Three case studies analysis
IT Success
HealthCare Agriculture Pharma
Efficiency of IT
use
3.2
(moderate)
3.3
(moderate)
4.3
(high)
Breadth of
current IT use
3
(moderate)
2
(limited)
5
(high)
Breadth of
potential IT use
3
(moderate)
1
(limited)
1
(limited)
19
- 20. Recommendations for SMEs
Senior Management Involvement in IT Governance Processes
Recommendation 1: In order to enhance performance of IT use
(as indicated by efficiency and breadth of IT use) in SMEs, senior
management should be involved through joint formal and informal
IT governance interactions
Recommendation 2: In order to improve the breadth of potential
IT use in SMEs, corporate executives should be involved in IT
governance processes
Recommendation 3: In order to improve the breadth of current IT
use in SMEs, operational executives should be involved in IT
governance processes.
20
- 21. Recommendations for SMEs
IT Governance Communication Practices
Recommendation 4: In order to improve the performance of IT use
(as indicated by efficiency and breadth of IT use) in SMEs, IT
governance policies, guidelines and practices should be
communicated through a number of channels
Recommendation 5: In order to improve the performance of IT use
(as indicated by efficiency and breadth of IT use) in SMEs, IT
governance policies, guidelines and practices should be
communicated through accessible channels
21
Editor's Notes
- (*) IT Governance on One page.- Companies with effective IT governance have profits that are 20% higher than other companies pursuing similar strategies. One explanation for this differential is that IT governance helps companies align their IT investments with their business priorities.
- “IT governance is the set of processes that specify decision rights and accountability to encourage desirable behavior in the use of IT.Effective IT governance encourages and leverages the ingenuity of all the enterprise's people in using IT, not just the leaders, while ensuring compliance with the enterprise's overall vision and principles” (Source: Weill, P.)At its core, governance is about alignment and value. For IT governance, we want to align the strategies, goals and objectives of IT with those of the enterprise to ensure that IT effectively supports and drives the entity.Number of workers is diff in countries: German = 255, 200, 100.
- http://www-wds.worldbank.org/external/default/WDSContentServer/WDSP/SDN/2013/01/04/090224b081856516/1_0/Rendered/PDF/Vietnam000Viet0Report000Sequence010.pdf