SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Commercially Confidential
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
ESRI USER CONFERENCE 2014
Presented by John Allan & Ben Tilley
Commercially Confidential
Who are we?
2
 A spin off company from Cambridge
Consultants Ltd
 Developers of a high precision, three
dimensional surveillance radar called
Holographic RadarTM
 We are solving the problems of wind turbine
interference on Air Traffic Control radar
(amongst other things!)
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
What is the problem?
3
 Wind Turbines interfere with Air Traffic Control
Radar
 Wind Farms can create “no-go” areas around
airports – not good for business or for safety!
 To meet UK Government renewable energy
targets for 2020, the problem has to be solved
 According to industry body RenewableUK, more than half of UK wind farm applications are
subject to objections from the aviation sector, mainly over issues relating to radar interference.
 RenewableUK is still analysing the latest research for 2013 applications, but preliminary results
suggest that 4-5GW of onshore wind and 7-8GW of offshore could be freed from the pipeline if
all aviation issues could be immediately resolved.
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Why is it a problem?
4
 Traditional surveillance radars rely on a
rotating antenna
 They tell you “something” is out there,
but very inaccurately and once every four
seconds
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Why so inaccurate?
5
 Traditional radars measure the
distance and bearing of the return
from the radar
 Slant range error introduces
locational errors
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential 6
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Holographic Radar solves the problem
7
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
The Wind Farm Industry…
8
 Currently in the UK
– 720 onshore wind projects in planning
– 866 wind projects consented
– 788 wind projects refused
 50% refused due to aviation interference
 Complex planning process
 Suitable areas for large scale onshore wind
developments diminishing
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Unlocking Potential Areas for Development
9
 133 radar sites located across the UK & Ireland
 Statutory Objection Zone around radar sites
allows stakeholders to object to any developments
within 35km
 Mitigation in these areas could free up over
70,000 square miles of land for development in
the UK & Ireland
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Our Key Goal
10
“To identify wind farm developments in the planning phase, which are likely to or have an
objection from an Airport Navigation Service Provider due to the adverse effect the turbines
would have on their radar.”
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Spatially UNaware – Achieving our goal Pre-ArcGIS
11
 Business opportunities identified by
─ Trawling the web
─ Industry newsletters
─ Direct contact with developers
 Low rate of success moving forward
after lead identification
 Time consuming
 Difficult to understand the scale of
problem
 Not confidence building in the eyes of
customers
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Our GIS Solution…
12
1. Identify
2. Predict
3. Solve
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential 13
RenewableUK wind farm database:
 Contains 3700+ records with details of:
– Planning status (Scoping, Refused
etc.)
– Project power capacity
– Application date
– BNG Eastings, Northings etc.
 Downloaded monthly in .csv format
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Where do we get our data from?
Commercially Confidential
Utilising ArcGIS to make sense of the data…
14
 Using ‘Definition Query’ within ArcMap to display
relevant wind farms based on the following criteria:
– In the planning phase
– NOT operational or under construction
– Large enough to financially support the costs
of radar mitigation
 Helps to narrow search very early on by applying
simple criteria
“The goal is to turn data into
information, and information into
insight.” - Carly Fiorina Former CEO of HP
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Narrowing the search area…
15
 We need to identify:
– Developments which are likely to have
an aviation objection
– Key areas where radar mitigation is
needed
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
The ‘One to Many’ Approach…
16
 Why?
– Airports hold the key to consenting wind farm projects that interfere with radar
– To identify airports with the greatest business potential; i.e. projects with largest power output
capacity
– Opens up discussions for a complete, airport-based wind farm mitigation solution. One Holographic
RadarTM seeing many wind farms means multiple revenue streams
 How?
– By using ‘Spatial Join’ to summarise wind farms and their characteristic around all radar(s)/airport(s)
depending on their location, in this case, within the 35km Statutory Objection Zone
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Not seen, no objection.
17
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Predicting Radar Coverage Using ArcGIS Spatial Analyst…
18
 Why?
– In most cases, an airport will object to a wind
farm development if the turbines are visible to
their radar. We need to know which ones
these are.
 How?
– OS Terrain 50 DTM free dataset
– Visibility’ tool in Spatial Analyst, we can:
– Height of radar above ground
(Observer offset)
– Height of wind turbine (Surface offset)
– Earth’s curvature
– Radio wave refraction coefficient
correction
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Business Opportunities
19
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Providing a Solution – An ArcGIS Success
20
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential 21
Commercially Confidential
A Picture Paints a Thousand Words…
22
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Using ESRI for Further Analysis
23
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Benefits
24
 75% increase in success in moving forward after leads have been identified
 Speed!
 Helps all stakeholders better understand the problem
– Airports
– Developers
– Us!
 Results of analysis stored digitally and can be shared to all those involved
 Dynamic maps give confidence to prospective customers that we understand and
can provide a solution to their problem
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential 25
Questions?
Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
Commercially Confidential
Contact details
Aveillant Ltd
300 Science Park, Milton Road
Cambridge CB4 0XL
United Kingdom
Tel: +44(0)1223 226290
Email: info@aveillant.com
Web: www.aveillant.com
26
© 2014 Aveillant, Aveillant. All rights reserved.
Commercially Confidential This Presentation contains ideas and
information which are proprietary to Aveillant: it is given to you in
confidence. You are authorised to open and view any electronic
copy we send you of this document within your organisation and to
print a single copy. Otherwise the material may not in whole or in
part be copied, stored electronically or communicated to third parties
without the prior written agreement of Aveillant.

More Related Content

Aveillant - GIS, 3D

  • 1. Commercially Confidential Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis ESRI USER CONFERENCE 2014 Presented by John Allan & Ben Tilley
  • 2. Commercially Confidential Who are we? 2  A spin off company from Cambridge Consultants Ltd  Developers of a high precision, three dimensional surveillance radar called Holographic RadarTM  We are solving the problems of wind turbine interference on Air Traffic Control radar (amongst other things!) Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 3. Commercially Confidential What is the problem? 3  Wind Turbines interfere with Air Traffic Control Radar  Wind Farms can create “no-go” areas around airports – not good for business or for safety!  To meet UK Government renewable energy targets for 2020, the problem has to be solved  According to industry body RenewableUK, more than half of UK wind farm applications are subject to objections from the aviation sector, mainly over issues relating to radar interference.  RenewableUK is still analysing the latest research for 2013 applications, but preliminary results suggest that 4-5GW of onshore wind and 7-8GW of offshore could be freed from the pipeline if all aviation issues could be immediately resolved. Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 4. Commercially Confidential Why is it a problem? 4  Traditional surveillance radars rely on a rotating antenna  They tell you “something” is out there, but very inaccurately and once every four seconds Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 5. Commercially Confidential Why so inaccurate? 5  Traditional radars measure the distance and bearing of the return from the radar  Slant range error introduces locational errors Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 6. Commercially Confidential 6 Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 7. Commercially Confidential Holographic Radar solves the problem 7 Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 8. Commercially Confidential The Wind Farm Industry… 8  Currently in the UK – 720 onshore wind projects in planning – 866 wind projects consented – 788 wind projects refused  50% refused due to aviation interference  Complex planning process  Suitable areas for large scale onshore wind developments diminishing Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 9. Commercially Confidential Unlocking Potential Areas for Development 9  133 radar sites located across the UK & Ireland  Statutory Objection Zone around radar sites allows stakeholders to object to any developments within 35km  Mitigation in these areas could free up over 70,000 square miles of land for development in the UK & Ireland Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 10. Commercially Confidential Our Key Goal 10 “To identify wind farm developments in the planning phase, which are likely to or have an objection from an Airport Navigation Service Provider due to the adverse effect the turbines would have on their radar.” Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 11. Commercially Confidential Spatially UNaware – Achieving our goal Pre-ArcGIS 11  Business opportunities identified by ─ Trawling the web ─ Industry newsletters ─ Direct contact with developers  Low rate of success moving forward after lead identification  Time consuming  Difficult to understand the scale of problem  Not confidence building in the eyes of customers Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 12. Commercially Confidential Our GIS Solution… 12 1. Identify 2. Predict 3. Solve Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 13. Commercially Confidential 13 RenewableUK wind farm database:  Contains 3700+ records with details of: – Planning status (Scoping, Refused etc.) – Project power capacity – Application date – BNG Eastings, Northings etc.  Downloaded monthly in .csv format Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis Where do we get our data from?
  • 14. Commercially Confidential Utilising ArcGIS to make sense of the data… 14  Using ‘Definition Query’ within ArcMap to display relevant wind farms based on the following criteria: – In the planning phase – NOT operational or under construction – Large enough to financially support the costs of radar mitigation  Helps to narrow search very early on by applying simple criteria “The goal is to turn data into information, and information into insight.” - Carly Fiorina Former CEO of HP Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 15. Commercially Confidential Narrowing the search area… 15  We need to identify: – Developments which are likely to have an aviation objection – Key areas where radar mitigation is needed Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 16. Commercially Confidential The ‘One to Many’ Approach… 16  Why? – Airports hold the key to consenting wind farm projects that interfere with radar – To identify airports with the greatest business potential; i.e. projects with largest power output capacity – Opens up discussions for a complete, airport-based wind farm mitigation solution. One Holographic RadarTM seeing many wind farms means multiple revenue streams  How? – By using ‘Spatial Join’ to summarise wind farms and their characteristic around all radar(s)/airport(s) depending on their location, in this case, within the 35km Statutory Objection Zone Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 17. Commercially Confidential Not seen, no objection. 17 Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 18. Commercially Confidential Predicting Radar Coverage Using ArcGIS Spatial Analyst… 18  Why? – In most cases, an airport will object to a wind farm development if the turbines are visible to their radar. We need to know which ones these are.  How? – OS Terrain 50 DTM free dataset – Visibility’ tool in Spatial Analyst, we can: – Height of radar above ground (Observer offset) – Height of wind turbine (Surface offset) – Earth’s curvature – Radio wave refraction coefficient correction Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 20. Commercially Confidential Providing a Solution – An ArcGIS Success 20 Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 22. Commercially Confidential A Picture Paints a Thousand Words… 22 Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 23. Commercially Confidential Using ESRI for Further Analysis 23 Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 24. Commercially Confidential Benefits 24  75% increase in success in moving forward after leads have been identified  Speed!  Helps all stakeholders better understand the problem – Airports – Developers – Us!  Results of analysis stored digitally and can be shared to all those involved  Dynamic maps give confidence to prospective customers that we understand and can provide a solution to their problem Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 25. Commercially Confidential 25 Questions? Realising the Value of Spatial Analysis
  • 26. Commercially Confidential Contact details Aveillant Ltd 300 Science Park, Milton Road Cambridge CB4 0XL United Kingdom Tel: +44(0)1223 226290 Email: info@aveillant.com Web: www.aveillant.com 26 © 2014 Aveillant, Aveillant. All rights reserved. Commercially Confidential This Presentation contains ideas and information which are proprietary to Aveillant: it is given to you in confidence. You are authorised to open and view any electronic copy we send you of this document within your organisation and to print a single copy. Otherwise the material may not in whole or in part be copied, stored electronically or communicated to third parties without the prior written agreement of Aveillant.