I ended up using this article to update my Macro.
http://www.howto-outlook.com/howto/replyinhtml.htm
Sub ForceReplyInHTML()
'=================================================================
'Description: Outlook macro to reply to a message in HTML
' regardless of the current message format.
' The reply will use your HTML signature as well.
'
'author : Robert Sparnaaij
'version: 1.0
'website: http://www.howto-outlook.com/howto/replyinhtml.htm
'=================================================================
Dim objOL As Outlook.Application
Dim objSelection As Outlook.Selection
Dim objItem As Object
Set objOL = Outlook.Application
'Get the selected item
Select Case TypeName(objOL.ActiveWindow)
Case "Explorer"
Set objSelection = objOL.ActiveExplorer.Selection
If objSelection.Count > 0 Then
Set objItem = objSelection.Item(1)
Else
Result = MsgBox("No item selected. " & _
"Please make a selection first.", _
vbCritical, "Reply in HTML")
Exit Sub
End If
Case "Inspector"
Set objItem = objOL.ActiveInspector.CurrentItem
Case Else
Result = MsgBox("Unsupported Window type." & _
vbNewLine & "Please make a selection" & _
" or open an item first.", _
vbCritical, "Reply in HTML")
Exit Sub
End Select
Dim olMsg As Outlook.MailItem
Dim olMsgReply As Outlook.MailItem
Dim IsPlainText As Boolean
'Change the message format and reply
If objItem.Class = olMail Then
Set olMsg = objItem
If olMsg.BodyFormat = olFormatPlain Then
IsPlainText = True
End If
olMsg.BodyFormat = olFormatHTML
Set olMsgReply = olMsg.Reply
If IsPlainText = True Then
olMsg.BodyFormat = olFormatPlain
End If
olMsg.Close (olSave)
olMsgReply.Display
'Selected item isn't a mail item
Else
Result = MsgBox("No message item selected. " & _
"Please make a selection first.", _
vbCritical, "Reply in HTML")
Exit Sub
End If
'Cleanup
Set objOL = Nothing
Set objItem = Nothing
Set objSelection = Nothing
Set olMsg = Nothing
Set olMsgReply = Nothing
End Sub
I recreated the macro three times, one for forward, one for reply, one for reply all, I renamed them at the top Sub ForceReplyInHTML
to create the three differing Macros.
I also used the related articles in that link to create myself buttons and sign my macros. In the final stage I used the Modify button to change the icons of my Macros to make it easier to remember which one did which.