Skip to main content
Notice removed Canonical answer required by Kernel
Bounty Ended with Sextus Empiricus's answer chosen by Kernel
edited body
Source Link
User1865345
  • 9.4k
  • 11
  • 23
  • 38

If $y_1$, $y_2$, and $y_3$ are time series such that:

$$y_1=y_2+y_3$$

Suppose all those variables were regressed against index $x$, so we get coefficients $r_{y_1}$, $r_{y_2}$, and $r_{y_3}$. In general, it should then hold that:

$$r_{y_1}=r_{y_2}+r_{y_2}$$$$r_{y_1}=r_{y_2}+r_{y_3}$$

I expect they should not equate since variance itself is not additive, as discussed in this post here. If so, does that mean that regression is not a linear operator?

If $y_1$, $y_2$, and $y_3$ are time series such that:

$$y_1=y_2+y_3$$

Suppose all those variables were regressed against index $x$, so we get coefficients $r_{y_1}$, $r_{y_2}$, and $r_{y_3}$. In general, it should then hold that:

$$r_{y_1}=r_{y_2}+r_{y_2}$$

I expect they should not equate since variance itself is not additive, as discussed in this post here. If so, does that mean that regression is not a linear operator?

If $y_1$, $y_2$, and $y_3$ are time series such that:

$$y_1=y_2+y_3$$

Suppose all those variables were regressed against index $x$, so we get coefficients $r_{y_1}$, $r_{y_2}$, and $r_{y_3}$. In general, it should then hold that:

$$r_{y_1}=r_{y_2}+r_{y_3}$$

I expect they should not equate since variance itself is not additive, as discussed in this post here. If so, does that mean that regression is not a linear operator?

added 9 characters in body
Source Link
Kernel
  • 117
  • 9

If $y_1$, $y_2$, and $y_3$ are time series such that:

$$y_1=y_2+y_3$$

Suppose all those variables were regressed against index $x$, so we get coefficients $ry_1$$r_{y_1}$, $ry_2$$r_{y_2}$, and $ry_3$$r_{y_3}$. In general, it should then hold that:

$$ry_1=ry_2+ry_2$$$$r_{y_1}=r_{y_2}+r_{y_2}$$

I expect they should not equate since variance itself is not additive, as discussed in this post here. If so, does that mean that regression is not a linear operator?

If $y_1$, $y_2$, and $y_3$ are time series such that:

$$y_1=y_2+y_3$$

Suppose all those variables were regressed against index $x$, so we get coefficients $ry_1$, $ry_2$, and $ry_3$. In general, it should then hold that:

$$ry_1=ry_2+ry_2$$

I expect they should not equate since variance itself is not additive, as discussed in this post here. If so, does that mean that regression is not a linear operator?

If $y_1$, $y_2$, and $y_3$ are time series such that:

$$y_1=y_2+y_3$$

Suppose all those variables were regressed against index $x$, so we get coefficients $r_{y_1}$, $r_{y_2}$, and $r_{y_3}$. In general, it should then hold that:

$$r_{y_1}=r_{y_2}+r_{y_2}$$

I expect they should not equate since variance itself is not additive, as discussed in this post here. If so, does that mean that regression is not a linear operator?

Notice added Canonical answer required by Kernel
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Kernel
edited tags
Link
Kernel
  • 117
  • 9
fixed formatting and added some tags and title fix
Source Link
Shawn Hemelstrand
  • 15.9k
  • 6
  • 29
  • 79
Loading
Source Link
Kernel
  • 117
  • 9
Loading