29
votes
Accepted
Why are some elves royalty?
Elf royalty comes from the order in which they woke, proximity and exposure to the Valar, and through descent from other elves who were already established as rulers.
The elves did not all wake up at ...
- 95.3k
17
votes
Accepted
When Éowyn secretly followed Théoden as Dernhelm, who was in charge of the Rohirrim?
Éowyn's departure left Rohan without a representative of the royal family but not without leadership.
Per the Tolkien Gateway (citing "Unfinished Tales") Erkenbrand, was left in charge of ...
- 52.1k
13
votes
Why are some elves royalty?
In the passage of the Similarillion which deals with the Valar's first encounter with the Elves, it describes the three kindreds of the Eldar - Vanyar, Noldor and Teleri. At this point those kindreds ...
- 65.4k
3
votes
Was Gollum the key to destroying the Ring?
Gollum is indeed key. "The pity of Bilbo may rule the fate of many" - no doubt about that.
I have an alternate theory. It was the Ring (rather than Frodo) that threatened Gollum outside of ...
- 31
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible