The ongoing Israel-Hamas war results in a much higher number of Palestinian casualties than previous conflicts: nearly 19,000 Palestinians are killed (according to the Hamas run Gaza Health Ministry), of which about one third is Hamas fighters (according to the IDF.) In comparison, the previous episodes of fighting resulted in:
- Gaza war 2008-2009 resulted in 1,400+ killed (about 600 of them Hamas fighters)
- 2014 Gaza war resulted 2,300+ killed (about 70% civilians)
(There have been also a number of smaller clashes since 2007 Hamas coup takeover of Gaza.)
Superficially, this is not unexpected - in the previous rounds of fighting Israeli army aimed mostly at destroying the rocket launchers, arms storage facilities, and tunnels - to deprive Hamas from its ability to attack Israeli population. The goal of the current war is uprooting Hamas (or at least its military branch), which probably means that there are more military targets, and they are more difficult to deal with; it also likely means larger scale of military operations. The question is what are these additional targets? What specifically accounts for the rapid rise of the number of casualties in this war?
Remarks
- There are claims that Israel has been indiscriminately and/or deliberately attacking civilians. Since these claims are highly controversial and are unlikely to be decisively confirmed or denied before the end of the relevant investigations, please cite the government or the international agency on whose authority the claim is made.
- (brought up in comments): In the past, when bombing buildings, IDF practiced calling residents on their cell phones and telling them to leave, or force evacuating the building via Roof knocking. It is not clear to what extent these practices are applied in the current conflict.
- (brought up in comments): For comparison relevant examples of fighting in densely populated civilian areas are battle of Mosul and battle of Raqqa during the Iraq War.