1
$\begingroup$

1)The expression for $Mean$ $Free$ $Path$ (ie) ,

$$λ=\dfrac{1}{πd²\dfrac{n}{V}}$$ is derived under the assumption that the particles except the one( let's consider it as particle $A$) you're considering are at rest .Now this assumption is wrong for obvious reasons .

So the correction involves finding the relative velocity of any two particles (ie) the relative velocity between particle $A$ and the particle that is going to collide at the moment with $A$ ,let it be $B$ .

Now $\vec v_{BA}$=$\vec v_{B}$-$\vec v_{A}$.

Velocity of B with respect to A is $\vec v_{BA}$ .

Velocity of B and A with respect to the earth frame is $v_{B}$ & $v_{A}$ .

Now initially we have considered $\vec v_B$ to be 0.

So $\vec v_{BA}$ becomes -$\vec v_{A}$.

Now if $\vec v_{B} \ne 0$.

Then $\vec v_{BA}$=$v_b$-$v_a$

Squaring on both sides we get ,

$$\vec v_{BA}^2=(\vec v_{B}-\vec v_{A})(\vec v_{B}-\vec v_{A})$$.

$$\vec v_{BA}^2=\vec v_{A}^2 +\vec v_{B}^2-2\vec v_A.\vec v_B$$.

Now $\vec v_A.\vec v_B$ vansihes because there are a large number of particles and the velocity distribution of particles look like a bell curve ,so for every possible $\vec v_A.\vec v_B$ ,there exists - $\vec v_A.\vec v_B$,therefore on average $\vec v_A.\vec v_B$ has to be zero .

$\implies$ $\vec v_{BA}^2=\vec v_{A}^2 +\vec v_{B}^2-2\vec v_A.\vec v_B$.

becomes ,

$\vec v_{BA}^2=\vec v_{A}^2 +\vec v_{B}^2$.

Now $\vec v_{A(avg)}^2$=$\vec v_{B(avg)}^2=\vec v_{avg}^2$,as they have the same velocity distributions,so they should have same average values .

Therefore ,

$\vec v_{relative}^2$=2$\vec v_{(avg)}^2$.

$\vec v_{relative}$=√2$\vec v_{avg}$.

My questions are

  1. Is my reasoning for $\vec v_{A}.\vec v_{B}$ being 0 correct ?

  2. Is my reasoning for $\vec v_{A(avg)}^2$=$\vec v_{B(avg)}^2=\vec v_{avg}^2$ correct ?

  3. Why does a factor of √2 in average Velocity decrease the mean free path by a factor of √2 ? I can kind of understand it ,but I don't know how to put it in proper words

$\endgroup$
1
  • $\begingroup$ Assumption on stationary model also depends how you choose unit cell to be like, if you assume sphere-like cell then you miss some free volume for a particle. I suppose better would be to model cell as a cube, then in an optimistic scenario, mean free path of particle will be a cube body diagonal : $\lambda=(3V/ N)^{1/3}$, where N - particle number in a volume. $\endgroup$ Commented Sep 20, 2022 at 7:43

0

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.