4

Emacs is one of several editors particularly suited to software development. As such, many Emacs questions are a good and natural fit to Stack Overflow. Specifically, topics such as

  • Writing Emacs Lisp functions
  • Language-specific programming modes
  • Compilation mode
  • Integration with version control tools

are all well-received here.

However, there's a substantial number of questions that don't really belong:

  • Editing plain text or other non-programming files
  • Changing standard configuration variables
  • Finding commands and binding them to keystrokes
  • Installing and using extensions

I've proposed edits to the tag wiki and its excerpt to clarify my understanding of what's on topic and thus improve the guidance to those with questions.

I have voted to close some of the most obvious non-programming questions with

Questions about using programs such as Emacs are off-topic for Stack Overflow unless they are specific to programming modes; you may be able to get help on Emacs or Super User. If your question is about programming Emacs, then please [edit] to include a Minimal, Complete, and Verifiable example of the Lisp or C code you're having trouble with.

Am I doing the right thing here? And should I trawl through questions looking for more questions which don't belong?

1
  • 1
    The general advise is to fix things you find, don't go find things to fix.
    – Gimby
    Commented Nov 10, 2017 at 11:58

1 Answer 1

5

Voting to close off topic questions is always a good thing, so if you are so inclined to spend your close votes this way, go ahead. There's a daily limit to stop you from going haywire.

Generally though, there isn't much use in closing abandoned old low view questions with a specific tag. Generally, it's better for you to browse as normal and close / vote on the posts you find that way, naturally.

But as long as the individual moderation actions (like close votes) are proper, I don't think it's such a negative if you do this. Maybe stagger it though and limit yourself to a couple a day to avoid burning out or filling the close vote queue with old stuff.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .