Skip to main content
added 54 characters in body
Source Link
Hans
  • 9.9k
  • 3
  • 19
  • 51

There are many ways to come up with this answer, but here’s one that makes sense to me. For ease of explanation we’ll say that I’m the first person to sit down and you’re the last. Also if you sit in your own seat then you “win”, otherwise you “lose”.

Let’s say that there are only two seats, yours and mine. If I sit in my own seat, you win. If I sit in your seat, you lose. So you have a 50%$50\%$ chance of winning.

Now let’s go back to 100$100$ seats. The previous paragraph still holds true: you have a 50%$50\%$ chance of winning if we only consider your seat and mine. Now if I sit anywhere else, I’m just postponing the decision. Let’s say I sit in the seat of the person who’s 13th in line. Persons 2$2$ through 12$12$ will sit in their own seats, then when person 13$13$ comes in he can either sit in my original seat (and you win) or yours (and you lose). Or of course he could sit anywhere else and postpone the decision again.

If this keeps going, then eventually there are only two seats left and person 99$99$ is forced to choose either your seat or mine, again with 50% chance. There are only two seats that matter throughout the game: yours and mine. Any sitting in other seats is just postponing the decision of which of the two interesting seats gets sat in first. Note also that you’ll only ever end up in your seat or mine, no one else’s.

It’s a bit like flipping a coin, except that you can postpone flipping, but not indefinitely. What’s the chance of coming out heads? Well 50%$50\%$, the postponement doesn’t change that.

Here’s a mathematical way to see it. Define f(n)$f(n)$ to be the chance that the last person in an airplane of n seats will get his own seat. It can be defined recursively like this:

**f(n)=(1/n)*1+((n−2)/n)f(n−1) + (1/n)0 $$f(n)=\frac1n\cdot1+\frac{n−2}n\cdot f(n−1) + \frac1n\cdot 0$$

The first term is the chance that the first person will sit in his own seat (1/n)$\frac1n$ multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will sit in his own (1)$1$. The last term is the chance that the first person will sit in the last person’s seat (1/n)$\frac1n$ multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will get his own seat (0)$0$. The middle term counts every other seat. There are n−2$n−2$ other seats, and there’s a 1/n$\frac1n$ chance of each, and they all simplify to the f(n−1)$f(n−1)$ case. Also:

f(2)=0.5 $f(2)=0.5$.

If you plug in 0.5$0.5$ for the f(n−1)$f(n−1)$ term, you find that f(n)=0.5$f(n)=0.5$, so it’s true for any n>1$n>1$.

There are many ways to come up with this answer, but here’s one that makes sense to me. For ease of explanation we’ll say that I’m the first person to sit down and you’re the last. Also if you sit in your own seat then you “win”, otherwise you “lose”.

Let’s say that there are only two seats, yours and mine. If I sit in my own seat, you win. If I sit in your seat, you lose. So you have a 50% chance of winning.

Now let’s go back to 100 seats. The previous paragraph still holds true: you have a 50% chance of winning if we only consider your seat and mine. Now if I sit anywhere else, I’m just postponing the decision. Let’s say I sit in the seat of the person who’s 13th in line. Persons 2 through 12 will sit in their own seats, then when person 13 comes in he can either sit in my original seat (and you win) or yours (and you lose). Or of course he could sit anywhere else and postpone the decision again.

If this keeps going, then eventually there are only two seats left and person 99 is forced to choose either your seat or mine, again with 50% chance. There are only two seats that matter throughout the game: yours and mine. Any sitting in other seats is just postponing the decision of which of the two interesting seats gets sat in first. Note also that you’ll only ever end up in your seat or mine, no one else’s.

It’s a bit like flipping a coin, except that you can postpone flipping, but not indefinitely. What’s the chance of coming out heads? Well 50%, the postponement doesn’t change that.

Here’s a mathematical way to see it. Define f(n) to be the chance that the last person in an airplane of n seats will get his own seat. It can be defined recursively like this:

**f(n)=(1/n)*1+((n−2)/n)f(n−1) + (1/n)0

The first term is the chance that the first person will sit in his own seat (1/n) multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will sit in his own (1). The last term is the chance that the first person will sit in the last person’s seat (1/n) multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will get his own seat (0). The middle term counts every other seat. There are n−2 other seats, and there’s a 1/n chance of each, and they all simplify to the f(n−1) case. Also:

f(2)=0.5

If you plug in 0.5 for the f(n−1) term, you find that f(n)=0.5, so it’s true for any n>1.

There are many ways to come up with this answer, but here’s one that makes sense to me. For ease of explanation we’ll say that I’m the first person to sit down and you’re the last. Also if you sit in your own seat then you “win”, otherwise you “lose”.

Let’s say that there are only two seats, yours and mine. If I sit in my own seat, you win. If I sit in your seat, you lose. So you have a $50\%$ chance of winning.

Now let’s go back to $100$ seats. The previous paragraph still holds true: you have a $50\%$ chance of winning if we only consider your seat and mine. Now if I sit anywhere else, I’m just postponing the decision. Let’s say I sit in the seat of the person who’s 13th in line. Persons $2$ through $12$ will sit in their own seats, then when person $13$ comes in he can either sit in my original seat (and you win) or yours (and you lose). Or of course he could sit anywhere else and postpone the decision again.

If this keeps going, then eventually there are only two seats left and person $99$ is forced to choose either your seat or mine, again with 50% chance. There are only two seats that matter throughout the game: yours and mine. Any sitting in other seats is just postponing the decision of which of the two interesting seats gets sat in first. Note also that you’ll only ever end up in your seat or mine, no one else’s.

It’s a bit like flipping a coin, except that you can postpone flipping, but not indefinitely. What’s the chance of coming out heads? Well $50\%$, the postponement doesn’t change that.

Here’s a mathematical way to see it. Define $f(n)$ to be the chance that the last person in an airplane of n seats will get his own seat. It can be defined recursively like this: $$f(n)=\frac1n\cdot1+\frac{n−2}n\cdot f(n−1) + \frac1n\cdot 0$$

The first term is the chance that the first person will sit in his own seat $\frac1n$ multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will sit in his own $1$. The last term is the chance that the first person will sit in the last person’s seat $\frac1n$ multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will get his own seat $0$. The middle term counts every other seat. There are $n−2$ other seats, and there’s a $\frac1n$ chance of each, and they all simplify to the $f(n−1)$ case. Also $f(2)=0.5$.

If you plug in $0.5$ for the $f(n−1)$ term, you find that $f(n)=0.5$, so it’s true for any $n>1$.

Source Link
cur10us
  • 329
  • 2
  • 8

There are many ways to come up with this answer, but here’s one that makes sense to me. For ease of explanation we’ll say that I’m the first person to sit down and you’re the last. Also if you sit in your own seat then you “win”, otherwise you “lose”.

Let’s say that there are only two seats, yours and mine. If I sit in my own seat, you win. If I sit in your seat, you lose. So you have a 50% chance of winning.

Now let’s go back to 100 seats. The previous paragraph still holds true: you have a 50% chance of winning if we only consider your seat and mine. Now if I sit anywhere else, I’m just postponing the decision. Let’s say I sit in the seat of the person who’s 13th in line. Persons 2 through 12 will sit in their own seats, then when person 13 comes in he can either sit in my original seat (and you win) or yours (and you lose). Or of course he could sit anywhere else and postpone the decision again.

If this keeps going, then eventually there are only two seats left and person 99 is forced to choose either your seat or mine, again with 50% chance. There are only two seats that matter throughout the game: yours and mine. Any sitting in other seats is just postponing the decision of which of the two interesting seats gets sat in first. Note also that you’ll only ever end up in your seat or mine, no one else’s.

It’s a bit like flipping a coin, except that you can postpone flipping, but not indefinitely. What’s the chance of coming out heads? Well 50%, the postponement doesn’t change that.

Here’s a mathematical way to see it. Define f(n) to be the chance that the last person in an airplane of n seats will get his own seat. It can be defined recursively like this:

**f(n)=(1/n)*1+((n−2)/n)f(n−1) + (1/n)0

The first term is the chance that the first person will sit in his own seat (1/n) multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will sit in his own (1). The last term is the chance that the first person will sit in the last person’s seat (1/n) multiplied by the chance, then, that the last person will get his own seat (0). The middle term counts every other seat. There are n−2 other seats, and there’s a 1/n chance of each, and they all simplify to the f(n−1) case. Also:

f(2)=0.5

If you plug in 0.5 for the f(n−1) term, you find that f(n)=0.5, so it’s true for any n>1.