I was pondering the close reason today and I can't think of an instance where a question that is on-topic for Code Review is too broad.
When is a question too broad? How could a too-broad question be edited to be acceptable?
I was pondering the close reason today and I can't think of an instance where a question that is on-topic for Code Review is too broad.
When is a question too broad? How could a too-broad question be edited to be acceptable?
I have been using the "Too Broad" close reason for questions which ask for reviews of multiple different things--posts asking for two different reviews.
Generally, these questions could be fixed by splitting them into multiple questions.
For example, if you have an iOS app that talks to a webserver that you also wrote, if you post some code from the iOS app and some code from the web server in the same question, I will vote to close as too broad. If you remove one or the other from the original question, I'll retract my close vote and cast a reopen vote.