As a new user myself (just 22 days old), I feel as if the downvoting policy needs a major rejig.
I agree to the fact that downvotes must be anonymous - as if the person who is downvoting is known, then revenge downvoting may be rampant. But the point is when we come across new contributors who are unaware / don't know the policy of ChemSE, we have to try and make an inclusive environment for them as well.
In the Stack Overflow, I have seen that new users are taken through a good-enough tutorial while posting their first question. They ask the motivation of the user for the question, why he/she thinks it is relevant, what is his understanding of the question etc...
We need to introduce a similar culture in ChemSE also.
Whenever we are filling out the form to ask a question, we need to start subdividing as:
- Title
- The OP's question
- What are the underlying concepts and his understanding
- Why is he/she not able to solve the question and where is he/she stuck
- What could be the motivation of his/her/their problem (will use it for experiments, research, hypothesis etc.)
- Finally tagging and duplicate checking.
This will help reduce the number of downvotes and as a result bans, and also will create a major difference in the culture of ChemSE as we know that EVERY QUESTION has been indirectly scrutinised through this process.
I feel that this should not apply only for first-timers, but for every question.
This may have been raised before but it's high time it's raised again. What is the community's say on my opinion?