Most of you know that I am a vocal opponent of the effort criteria anyway, but I am getting a bit unnerved as of how inconsistent it is applied.
I am posting this as a specific example here only because I am too lazy to dig up others and this one simply is the freshest.
The question I am concerned about is General organic chemistry-most stable structure_conceptual doubt. I am quoting it here as an example in full, but I'm not linking to it to avoid meta effects.
I am just confused between options C and D. Both C and D seem to be stable due to resonance, but I think D should have more resonance as the Oxygen's lone pair in -OH bond will also participate in resonance making it more stable. But the answer is C. Please explain why.
Obviously the post still has some issues, none of which are unfixable (which I will try to do later).
From what I read, I understand exactly where OP is coming from. {S..}he has a problem deciding which structure is more stable and explains h{er..is} reasoning for it. How much more effort would have been necessary not to close it?
(In the first round of review there were 3 leave open votes. Also, this is of course independent of the issue, that the given answer in the solution is absolutely wrong-ish. It depends on the solvent, but that is a discussion to have with the main question.)