How long does it take to get used to a hard saddle?

Question

I recently "upgraded" to a Romin Comp Gel saddle from a soft racing saddle because my old one, while extremely comfortable on long road rides, wasn't working for the TT position I'm now practicing for an upcoming Ironman.

I've been professionally fit with the seat, so I think things are lined up well. I've ridden nearly 200 miles over the last week with it and the problem is: it still freaking hurts. It's not chafing; it's pressure right in that, uh, under-area that's supposed to sit in the gap of the saddle.

Can I expect it to get awesome any time soon, or should I try another saddle at this point?

Edit:

Regarding seat position, I have my current seat all the way forward, which is where I've been steadily moving it over the last two weeks since my professional fitting. Moving it forward did help, but now I'm stuck again (and I have one of those bent seatposts that is pointing forward as well).

Answer 1

Take it back and get a different one. A decent bike shop will let you do this. I went through 3 saddles the last time.

The goal is that the "saddle fits you", and not, "you fit the saddle".

It really doesn't take weeks.

to determine whether a saddle is right or not! A long ride will do.

An anecdotal note... My current road bike saddle would qualify as a "hard leather saddle". At the time I bought the bike, I didn't like the original saddle, then tried a Specialized, then a Fizik, and then settled on a Selle Italia. I'm not knocking either Specialized or Fizik or any other brand; it's just that the Selle Italia saddle worked for my anatomy, and I often spend an entire day+ sitting on that saddle. Saddles are like shoes, they have to fit the wearer. A 30 mile ride told me which saddle to get.

Answer 2

It can take a few weeks to get used to a new saddle, or other components, but if adjusted properly they should be 'uncomfortable', not 'freaking hurts' painful.

When it comes to saddles, even after a professional fit you may need to make adjustments at home. Using a grease pencil or other means of marking the position you can start by doing two things likely to help:

1. Decrease the nose angle a few degrees. This could be especially helpful since in a time-trial position most riders are inclined closer to horizontal an this can significantly increase the pressure on the perineum.
2. Move the saddle a few millimeters forward. This compensates for the tendency to slide slightly forward when in the drops or on your aero-bars, and helps keep the saddle pressure on your sit bones.

Finally, you may want to use a small plumb bob to make sure that the nose is centered left to right over the top tube. Again, in a TT position small deviations can make a big difference.

Answer 3

This question was answered by a suggestion to slide the saddle forwards on the seat post. You could give that a try.

I doubt you'll get used to an existing, uncomfortable saddle position. I don't think that part of your anatomy will 'toughen up'.

Answer 4

That saddle is unlikely to adjust to you. Man-made materials generally don't budge. You may want to try a Brooks or other leather saddle. If you do, apply the saddle dressing that should come with it, and don't do long rides on it for a few weeks. I've found that two or three weeks of commuting (25 km round-trip) usually does the job.

If you are a woman, your pelvic bones are probably wider, and you'll want a saddle designed for women. Presumably the bike shop already took that into consideration, but I've seen a shop or two where the staff didn't know about this basic issue.

Answer 5

I dont't know that saddle model but, as always, the answer is really subjective. It could also be forever.

My suggestion is to try a saddle before buying and buy always the better shorts you can afford.

Answer 6

Having your saddle straight ahead is not always best either. Every body is different - I'd urge you to set up your bike to fit your actual body, not some aesthetic ideal of "supposed to be__. "

Answer 7

It's vital to adjust your bike to fit your body from the start if you want to keep appropriate alignment and avoid physical difficulties. This will also help you stay comfortable during your bike ride. Setting your bike seat to the same height as your hip bones is a good idea.