I have an external HDD that, when I plug it into my Windows 7 laptop, always initializes with the "do you want to scan and fix" message. I've run it a few times, but the built in Windows scanner never finds any problems. Additionally, the "access" light on the HDD is almost always on when I have it plugged into the computer, and I can never get Windows to "safely remove" the hard drive. I've never had any issues reading or writing to the HDD.
So, what tools are out there to better diagnose and fix this issue? Or is it not a real issue with the HDD? I was thinking of backing up and reformatting, but I'd like to try some other diagnostics first.