Edit2: Control Panel resolutions are matching. Display scaling settings are matching but the image below shows the difference.
Edit: Thanks for all the help. Have made several changes based on the comments. I updated the screenshot here. It shows that there is some kind of zoom going on. Screen size and True size are different on this machine but match at 1600x900 on the other with (as far as I know) the same settings.
I am trying to make my resolution 1600x900 but it won't let me get it that high. In computer resolution setting it shows that I am at 1600x900 but when I run a resolution test online it says otherwise. Also I have 2 of the exact same machines and monitors set up side by side so it's got to be solvable. Has anyone ever seen anything like this before and have suggestions?
I have up-to-date graphics and monitor drivers, not sure what else to do.