North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum, a Republican vice presidential contender, has made numerous comments which liken President Joe Biden’s administration to a dictatorship.
On June 23 on CNN’s “State of the Union,” Burgum said “this president, more like any other, has bypassed Congress.”
He implied there is a double standard for Biden in his use of executive orders and that of former President Donald Trump.
Burgum said there is “a nonstop media attack on President Trump saying that, ‘Oh, that he might use executive orders when he takes office.’” He followed by saying “the open borders and the inflation are things that (Biden’s) doing by himself alone, ignoring the other branches of government.”
CNN’s Kaitlan Collins fact-checked Burgum during the interview, pointing out that Trump signed 220 executive orders during his four years in office, while Biden is at 139 so far in his term.
Biden did use executive action at a significantly higher rate than other presidents in his first few days in office, largely a response to the COVID-19 pandemic. But Trump had issued more orders by this time in his presidency — with 169 from January 20, 2017, to July 1, 2020, compared with Biden’s 139, according to a PolitiFact analysis of data provided by the American Presidency Project, a nonprofit source for presidential documents hosted by the University of California, Santa Barbara.
In the CNN interview, Burgum cited Biden’s order on student loan debt relief and federal Environmental Protection Agency regulations on baseload electricity as examples of the president circumnavigating the two other branches of government. He said that Biden “is bypassing the other two branches of government to push an ideological view, whether it’s on economics or whether it’s on climate extremism.” But these both have been through the legal system and Biden has not dismissed the Supreme Court’s rulings on his policies.
A Burgum spokesperson did not respond to PolitiFact’s request for evidence that Biden “bypassed Congress” more than other presidents through executive orders.
According to the American Presidency Project, Collins’ numbers are correct. Trump’s 220 executive orders are the most in a single term since Jimmy Carter issued 320 orders, during his presidency from 1977 to 1981.
Presidents have multiple methods of executive action, including regulations, military orders and proclamations, Kenneth Lowande, a political science and public policy professor at the University of Michigan, said.
Executive orders are the most common and powerful. They are not a perfect metric to see how often presidents have “bypassed Congress,” because of the executive branch’s other available powers. Experts say that executive orders do not necessarily mean a president circumvented the other branches, because these powers are granted to the executive branch in the Constitution. It is also difficult to tell which actions will have the biggest policy effects.
“It takes years to learn which executive actions were really important, and which were bluster, because so much depends on implementation,” Lowande said. “That’s all executive actions are, at the end of the day — orders to bureaucrats.”
“One of the complications we warn about repeatedly is relying simply on counts of specific kinds of Presidential Documents as a summary measure of executive action,” said John Wolley, co-director of the American Presidency Project and an emeritus political science professor at the University of California, Santa Barbara.
Even so, political science experts say there is no evidence to signal that Biden has bypassed the other two branches of government more than other presidents.
“I do not see Biden’s actions as being materially different from his recent predecessors of either party,” said John Frendries, a political science professor at Loyola University Chicago. “Presidents of both parties have relied on EOs to move in certain policy areas.”
“I would hesitate to say which president has more often used executive action because of a desire to bypass Congress,” Woolley said. “I don’t think anybody’s done the careful analysis that would be required to make such a statement.”
In his statement on CNN, Burgum criticized Biden’s action on the border. However, during Trump’s presidential tenure he, too, used an executive order to push immigration policy.
Biden used executive action in an attempt to secure the border, restricting the number of migrants who can seek asylum between official points of entry. Collins pointed out that Republicans including House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., urged Biden to address the border. A proposed bipartisan immigration deal in May failed to advance in the Senate, blocked by Senate Republicans.
Woolley pointed out that Trump had similar issues getting Congressional approval for his proposed border wall. Through executive action, he diverted $3.6 billion from the military budget to fund the wall, but that was challenged in multiple courts. After continuing legal clashes, the Supreme Court declared the case moot in October 2021 because Biden had halted border wall spending.
Biden’s executive order efforts to relieve $430 billion in student loan debt were rejected by the Supreme Court in 2023. But Biden has found other ways to decrease loans by expanding existing regulations within the Department of Education, including the SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) program, which lowers monthly payments for low-income borrowers. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled July 1 to allow that plan to continue in August after a federal judge in Kansas initially blocked the decreased payments.
Although Frendries underscored that Biden’s original executive order on student loan debt relief involved significantly large-dollar sums, he said “these policy changes were litigated, undercutting any ‘dictatorship’ claim.”
Several experts told PolitiFact the Supreme Court ruling July 1 — which gives presidents immunity from prosecution when carrying out “official acts” — could have future implications for presidential power.
This could encourage future presidents to take more executive action than Biden or Trump has.
This fact check was originally published by PolitiFact, which is part of the Poynter Institute. See the sources for this fact check here.
Comments