Scott Steinhardt’s Post

View profile for Scott Steinhardt, graphic

Head of Communications at Reality Defender

My idea of relaxing over the holiday weekend is researching music streaming platforms and seeing how they compare for both artists and listeners. After trying out a handful of services, here's what I found: -Qobuz has the best royalty payment (nearly 1.5 cents/song) but the clunkiest UI and is missing a few crucial albums (including a favorite From Hüsker Dü). Curation is pretty much non-existent, though they have a killer newsletter. -TIDAL has the second-best royalty payment (nearly 1.0 cents/song) and a Spotify Connect-like interface for smart speakers, but is also missing some key albums (like a few Stereolab favorites) and has some weird design quirks. Also, it appears their curation efforts were more or less curbed after recent layoffs. It's still a fantastic app. -Apple Music pays 2x more than Spotify. It unfortunately has a 100,000 song limit for the user library. For someone who’s been listening to digital music for 25 years and amassed a totally legal library (combined with saved streaming albums), this is unacceptable and something that's been the case for nearly a decade. It’s also missing more albums than any other service I tried (including a few Kim Deal singles). Curation is good, but nowhere near as good as when the service first started, as many of the official playlists I follow haven't been updated in years. -Out of everything I tested, Spotify is the best in terms of music availability, worst in terms of royalty payments to artists, and the best curation/playlists. I do wish I could turn off "made for" playlists for genre playlists as it's constantly feeding me songs I've already heard, and I look to these playlists for discovery rather than reminiscing or nostalgia. (Unless, of course, it's "Songs Like 'Reminiscing' By Little River Band.") They are also missing some Drag City artists like Joanna Newsom (likely due to the artist's choice) and are the only service I tested without a lossless option, though I assume this will change eventually. I've been a Spotify user for a year, making the switch after I hit Apple's 100k library limit. I will likely stick with the service for some time, while simultaneously supporting artists (and getting my Newsom fix) via Bandcamp and live shows. That said, whoever gets Spaceman 3's The Perfect Prescription first is the service I will stick with for life.

Scott Steinhardt

Head of Communications at Reality Defender

1mo

And here's the only fully legal way to currently listen to the aforementioned album: https://s3firerecords.bandcamp.com/album/the-perfect-prescription

Bianca T.

Creativity/Community/Curiosity

1mo

Thanks for this! Curious if YouTube Premium ever entered the chat?

Like
Reply
Paul Mishin

product_(manager•builder•owner)

1mo

You mean 100,000 liked/added songs? That's around 300 days of non-stop music. Mine is 4000 and I rarely see people with more than 1000. Curious how you navigate this ocean.. Do you keep adding more? Thanks for The Perfect Prescription, I didn't know they exist and it's great!

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics