This discussion will go on for ages and there will not be an agreement, also not after the testing phase, and after responding to responses of the response...
At the end, this is about
(A) working (of course) compliantly with privacy laws while creating ROI for the ecosystem. Not a single person I have met is questioning this.
(B) What does not matter in all details are questions like this one: Does LookAlike work in the Sandbox? This does not mean it is wrong to discuss in depth. It is right, it is needed to raise awareness and get closer to reality ...
But, in this example - It will take a long time to verify if the aggregationAPI can be used to somehow establish a new concept of LookAlikes as Google now suggests. I personally doubt it in this case ...
But, that also does not matter. Doing this in the Box is at least very different and will come - if at all - at a high cost. This is true for most of the "gray" use cases, they come at a high cost and with uncertainty...
(C) The decisions for / against the Box is ruled by CMA which means this is about competition law, period. This is where the focus must be, the need for privacy compliance is a given, and there is not just one way to Rome. But, if the Sandbox is a level playing field needs to be evaluated. Does it benefit / slot in better in Google's Solution Portfolio than into others, are cost of building it prohibitive, ...
During the testing period, we will answer some questions about the box' performance, for selected use cases, for publisher and advertisers. Adform is happy to contribute to this, extremely curios about the results, and glad to participate.
However, most of the ones in the document will not be touched. How will uncertainty count in the CMA evaluation? Use Case coverage is an aspect here, but also the cost and opportunity cost to build the box with remaining large uncertainties on how to integrate it into modern Advertising technologies and business models. This is ultimately what CMA needs to determine and I believe this is where the cookie or the Box will crumble...
https://bit.ly/3UCjeic
Adform #privacy #sandbox #programmatic #advertising #cma #google #chrome #iabTechLab
Founder & CPO, Anonym, Ex-Meta, Yahoo, Comscore
4wEmily Moskowitz now that the dust has settled a bit, just wanted to once again thank you for your support and belief from the very beginning! You came to us with a fantastic thesis and I'm excited to work with you to make it happen!