IN THEORY joining the right professional community can be a career inflection point. But the truth is a lot of them suck.
I’ve spent 6 months building one of my own (now w/ 60+ paying members). And I’ve been on the other side, a member of a bad community, countless times.
Here are 5 questions to ask before joining a community to make sure it’s worth the investment. (Shoutout David Spinks for these questions).
Who is it for & (who is it NOT for!)
Is the focus of the community specific?
The best communities are hyper-specific. Specificity is hard, especially for bigger companies using communities as “MQL” drivers, but it’s essential. The more specific, the more confident you can be that the other members are similar enough to you to have solved similar problems.
The second piece to this equation is, who is it NOT for. Who can’t get let in. Make sure they have a good answer and that it aligns with what you’re looking for.
What do members DO?
This might sound elementary, but what are the rituals that bring members together & do they align with what you want?
At Demand Collective we focus on bringing people together to have real face-to-face conversations (small group masterminds, 1-1 intros, member mixers) we have an engaged forum, but the focus is facilitating high-fidelity, real conversations. This makes our community meaningfully different from one that’s just a slack group.
Neither is better or worse per se, but you should know what the rituals of engagement look like and if they align with what you want.
How do members connect to each other?
Does the community help connect members or is it up to you? Everyone in a community wants to meet other awesome people, but having a community manager facilitate those interactions makes everyone’s lives easier. 1-1 intros are a great way to do this.
What’s the barrier to entry?
The bigger the barrier to entry, the more engaged & valuable the community. People pay attention to what they pay for. Whether it’s money, time, or reputation, the best communities have a meaningful barrier to entry.
Do I have the time & energy?
If you’re going to commit to a community that’s worth committing to, you need to ask yourself first, “how much time do I really have for this”. If the answer is, not much, then it may not make sense to join.
That being said, if a community does the above perfectly, you could be finding yourself spending an hour a month having incredibly thoughtful and rewarding conversations with peers who you’ll stay connected with forever.
Did I miss anything? If you’ve spent time in good or bad communities, what questions do you wish you asked before joining?
P.S.
If you're a demand marketer w/ 3.5+ YOE and you want to get access to a private vetted community of your peers, you should consider applying to join Demand Collective! Link in comments.