What do you think?
Rate this book
Star Wars: X-Wing #3
The Krytos Trap
The brave pilots of Rogue Squadron face the impossible as the sinister Ysanne Isard wreaks havoc on a fragile Coruscant.
The Rebels have taken the Imperial headquarters world of Coruscant, but their problems are far from over.A killer virus called Krytos is spreading among the population and fomenting a counterrevolution at the heart of the New Republic. At the same time, Rebel hero Tycho Celchu is on trial for treason, accused of murdering his comrade and fellow pilot Corran Horn.Corran, however, is still alive, trapped in the secret, inescapable prison of Ysanne Isard, the imperial officer whose reputation for torture and cruelty have earned her the moniker Iceheart. As he fights for his freedom, the pilot discovers an extraordinary power in himself—the power of the Force!
384 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 3, 1996
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 231 reviews
May 28, 2024
It's easy to see why the X-Wing novels are among the best-loved in the Star Wars Expanded Universe. With a convoluted plot and an engaging writing style, this one is just how I like my space operas.
August 4, 2016
2,5 stars.
Ah, Stackpole. You are ridiculous.
You do get a little better, though, I’ll give you that.
In the third instalment of the “Rogue One” series, the New Republic must do battle on many fronts. The Krytos virus, engineered on Ysanne Isard’s orders, is attacking the non-human population of Coruscant, and the death toll is staggering. Simultaneously, Kirtan Loor, secreted away in the city, is striking at the New Republic with his Palpatine Counter-insurgency Front, destroying, among other things, bacta reserves, invaluable in curing the Krytos virus. On a third front Warlord Zsinj is making his bid for power, striking at their convoys.
In other words, this instalment is rife with excitement, and it has been the most enjoyable of Stackpole’s books so far. In earlier instalments, perhaps particularly the first book, he had a tendency of diffusing all tension by basically skipping all the most exciting parts and summarising them after the fact. Thankfully, this is a technique he has (largely) put behind him, so that the reader actually gets to experience things as they are happening.
This book was actually so exciting at times that, had it not been for Stackpole’s continued and obvious ignorance of basic human interaction, I might have been tempted to give this an even three stars.
I’ve expounded on the problems with Stackpole’s characterisation in previous reviews, so I will only summarise here:
1. Stackpole has three descriptive terms for the female physique, and they are “trim”, “lithe” and “slender”. Other female body types do not exist. Women are also consistently described in terms of how much their male colleagues and friends may or may not wish to have sex with them. This gets really irritating after a while.
2. Stackpole does not know how human beings (and/or aliens) relate to one another. The most ridiculous example in this instalment is when (MILD SPOILER) Wedge contemplates asking out Iella Wessiri. He imagines a whole relationship in his head, having only just developed an attraction to her, and when he discovers her husband is alive, he realises that this man he does not know (AT ALL) is obviously a much better fit for her than he could be.
Characters have a sorry tendency of jumping to conclusions in this way, of betraying more knowledge and foresight than they could possibly have at a particular juncture. Stackpole confuses the narrating voice with that of his characters. The narrator can, of course, be omniscient, and can therefore make these kinds of judgments. His characters must, however, travel the slow path if their thoughts and actions are to be considered even remotely believable.
3. Stackpole insists on pairing everyone off and creating a bunch of romantic angles that simply aren’t interesting, largely because he has no skill in writing them. He should stop.
4. Stackpole’s vocabulary and syntax betray that he lacks quite a bit in the English department, and there are parts where I wonder if his writing has actually gone through any kind of editing process.
5. He creates this huuuuuge tense vacuum surrounding the identity of the spy in Rogue Squadron. I’ve known who it is since the first book. Lol.
Ok, this review is already longer than I had intended, and seems very negative. And there is a lot to nitpick at when it comes to Stackpole’s writing, but this book really is better than its predecessors. If Stackpole can just avoid the interpersonal relationshippy stuff in the next instalment, who knows but that he might receive three stars at last?
Ah, Stackpole. You are ridiculous.
You do get a little better, though, I’ll give you that.
In the third instalment of the “Rogue One” series, the New Republic must do battle on many fronts. The Krytos virus, engineered on Ysanne Isard’s orders, is attacking the non-human population of Coruscant, and the death toll is staggering. Simultaneously, Kirtan Loor, secreted away in the city, is striking at the New Republic with his Palpatine Counter-insurgency Front, destroying, among other things, bacta reserves, invaluable in curing the Krytos virus. On a third front Warlord Zsinj is making his bid for power, striking at their convoys.
In other words, this instalment is rife with excitement, and it has been the most enjoyable of Stackpole’s books so far. In earlier instalments, perhaps particularly the first book, he had a tendency of diffusing all tension by basically skipping all the most exciting parts and summarising them after the fact. Thankfully, this is a technique he has (largely) put behind him, so that the reader actually gets to experience things as they are happening.
This book was actually so exciting at times that, had it not been for Stackpole’s continued and obvious ignorance of basic human interaction, I might have been tempted to give this an even three stars.
I’ve expounded on the problems with Stackpole’s characterisation in previous reviews, so I will only summarise here:
1. Stackpole has three descriptive terms for the female physique, and they are “trim”, “lithe” and “slender”. Other female body types do not exist. Women are also consistently described in terms of how much their male colleagues and friends may or may not wish to have sex with them. This gets really irritating after a while.
2. Stackpole does not know how human beings (and/or aliens) relate to one another. The most ridiculous example in this instalment is when (MILD SPOILER) Wedge contemplates asking out Iella Wessiri. He imagines a whole relationship in his head, having only just developed an attraction to her, and when he discovers her husband is alive, he realises that this man he does not know (AT ALL) is obviously a much better fit for her than he could be.
Characters have a sorry tendency of jumping to conclusions in this way, of betraying more knowledge and foresight than they could possibly have at a particular juncture. Stackpole confuses the narrating voice with that of his characters. The narrator can, of course, be omniscient, and can therefore make these kinds of judgments. His characters must, however, travel the slow path if their thoughts and actions are to be considered even remotely believable.
3. Stackpole insists on pairing everyone off and creating a bunch of romantic angles that simply aren’t interesting, largely because he has no skill in writing them. He should stop.
4. Stackpole’s vocabulary and syntax betray that he lacks quite a bit in the English department, and there are parts where I wonder if his writing has actually gone through any kind of editing process.
5. He creates this huuuuuge tense vacuum surrounding the identity of the spy in Rogue Squadron. I’ve known who it is since the first book. Lol.
Ok, this review is already longer than I had intended, and seems very negative. And there is a lot to nitpick at when it comes to Stackpole’s writing, but this book really is better than its predecessors. If Stackpole can just avoid the interpersonal relationshippy stuff in the next instalment, who knows but that he might receive three stars at last?
August 13, 2010
"Great risk is necessary to defeat great evil"
Corran is captured in Isard's feared Lusankya. Tycho Celchu is being convicted of Corran's murder and treason. And the Krytos Virus, a deadly virus that affects only non-humans, threatens to destroy the New Republic. Will Corran return? Will Tycho be released of charges? And can the New Republic get enough bacta to reverse the affects of the virus?
NOTE: Based on audiobook and novel.
I Liked:
This has to be my most favorite of the X-Wing novels. It has everything I love in books: torture, trials, insidious villains, smart plots, and daring heroics!
Firstly, I loved the trial of Tycho Celchu. It was an awesome way of bringing Law & Order into Star Wars and to show off Nawara Ven's skills as an attorney. Plus, we don't know...maybe Tycho *is* the bad guy!
Wedge and Iella have a nice little romance blossoming, one that puts to shame the "romance" between Wedge and Qui Xux. I thought it was a very interesting development, how Iella was married and how he returned.
Corran's capture on Lusankya was also very well done. I've read some bad torture sequences or ones that just don't have me buying it, but this one was interesting. We learn more about Corran and see how he really knows nothing of importance (something that made me chuckle: too often, an author tends to make his/her pet character the best at everything, so this is one thing that Corran lacks). I loved Corran's escape, the reintroduction of Jan Dodonna, and how Corran learns about his Jedi Medallion. Stackpole adds to the Jedi lore, and I thought he did a great job. Sure, it "conflicts" with recent materials, but how was Stackpole supposed to know that back in 1996?
Stackpole also makes some really great, memorable villains. Kirtan Loor is a favorite, obviously, and I liked how he gets himself worked into a corner. Moff Flurry Vorru is really getting interesting in my eyes, starting out ingratiating himself to the New Republic, who freed him, but is slowly worming his way into his own agenda. Even Isard is getting a little more backbone and creepiness. Her releasing of the Krytos Virus to bring down the New Republic is very deft and interesting. This novel is a good example of a well-done bio-weapon.
I Didn't Like:
Lord, this is a hard one.
Dogfights continue to be challenging to work through. The mourning ceremony for Corran was a bit cringe-inducing (random pilot #46886 gets a big, fancy ceremony?).
Dialogue/Sexual Situation/Violence:
Same as the previous.
The Bothan pilot (can't remember her name) has a relationship with Gavin Darklighter. Wedge has feelings for Iella. Erisi has the hots for Corran.
Overall:
This novel is pure brilliance. Great characters, great action, great story. The characters grew and developed, the story handled the well-worn bioweapon/superweapon plot well, and we get to learn more about Jedi! 5 brilliant stars.
Corran is captured in Isard's feared Lusankya. Tycho Celchu is being convicted of Corran's murder and treason. And the Krytos Virus, a deadly virus that affects only non-humans, threatens to destroy the New Republic. Will Corran return? Will Tycho be released of charges? And can the New Republic get enough bacta to reverse the affects of the virus?
NOTE: Based on audiobook and novel.
I Liked:
This has to be my most favorite of the X-Wing novels. It has everything I love in books: torture, trials, insidious villains, smart plots, and daring heroics!
Firstly, I loved the trial of Tycho Celchu. It was an awesome way of bringing Law & Order into Star Wars and to show off Nawara Ven's skills as an attorney. Plus, we don't know...maybe Tycho *is* the bad guy!
Wedge and Iella have a nice little romance blossoming, one that puts to shame the "romance" between Wedge and Qui Xux. I thought it was a very interesting development, how Iella was married and how he returned.
Corran's capture on Lusankya was also very well done. I've read some bad torture sequences or ones that just don't have me buying it, but this one was interesting. We learn more about Corran and see how he really knows nothing of importance (something that made me chuckle: too often, an author tends to make his/her pet character the best at everything, so this is one thing that Corran lacks). I loved Corran's escape, the reintroduction of Jan Dodonna, and how Corran learns about his Jedi Medallion. Stackpole adds to the Jedi lore, and I thought he did a great job. Sure, it "conflicts" with recent materials, but how was Stackpole supposed to know that back in 1996?
Stackpole also makes some really great, memorable villains. Kirtan Loor is a favorite, obviously, and I liked how he gets himself worked into a corner. Moff Flurry Vorru is really getting interesting in my eyes, starting out ingratiating himself to the New Republic, who freed him, but is slowly worming his way into his own agenda. Even Isard is getting a little more backbone and creepiness. Her releasing of the Krytos Virus to bring down the New Republic is very deft and interesting. This novel is a good example of a well-done bio-weapon.
I Didn't Like:
Lord, this is a hard one.
Dogfights continue to be challenging to work through. The mourning ceremony for Corran was a bit cringe-inducing (random pilot #46886 gets a big, fancy ceremony?).
Dialogue/Sexual Situation/Violence:
Same as the previous.
The Bothan pilot (can't remember her name) has a relationship with Gavin Darklighter. Wedge has feelings for Iella. Erisi has the hots for Corran.
Overall:
This novel is pure brilliance. Great characters, great action, great story. The characters grew and developed, the story handled the well-worn bioweapon/superweapon plot well, and we get to learn more about Jedi! 5 brilliant stars.
June 27, 2023
A Random Thought: When things go sideways on Coruscant millions gets crushed in the rubble, I guess?
A very '90s bizarre mix of a courtroom drama and a prison escape adventure, with espionage elements and juuuust enough dogfighting to still qualify as an "X-Wing" book, this one basically serves as a logical endpoint for a lot of the plot points introduced throughout the first 2 books.
A very '90s bizarre mix of a courtroom drama and a prison escape adventure, with espionage elements and juuuust enough dogfighting to still qualify as an "X-Wing" book, this one basically serves as a logical endpoint for a lot of the plot points introduced throughout the first 2 books.
January 5, 2021
Out of the first three X-Wing books, this is the one I enjoyed most during my re-read.
Also, this quote right here is very 2020:
"Kirtan Loor would have been trembling with outrage, but the lethargy of despair had a higher priority."
But.
BUT... (skip this paragraph if you don't enjoy sarcasm and take the fandom too seriously)
"A railing had even been set up to prevent prisoners from accidentally falling[...]"
Really? See, this is the kind of content I don't understand. How can they just let clueless new people take over Star Wars and allow them to introduce things that are completely unrealistic in this world? I mean, everybody, everybody knows there are no railings in Star Wars! With railings, the deaths of countless characters don't make sense in retrospect anymore! Just stop butchering my Star Wars with this kind of stuff!
(Yes, I am still angry about what this fandom has become, thank you for asking. And yes, I am fully aware of the fact that there were railings on the second Death Star. That's part of my point here.)
Back to the review.
In my review of Wedge's Gamble I expressed a wish for the characters to be more fleshed out. Well, this book did exactly that, at least for a lot of them. I enjoyed the mix of action and non-action (or rather, other kind of action), the mix of scenery and the various points of view. The story was fun, entertainingly written, pacing was good - everything I want from my Star Wars books.
There was a bit too much plot armor and convenience in it for me to give it five stars - I don't mind a little of that, this is Star Wars and those people are heroes, after all. But specially Corran Horn was just too much of a Gary Stu to keep my suspension of disbelief going, complete with the "he released a breadth he didn't know he was holding" line.
And I will just leave this quote from New Republic Hero Wedge Antilles' inner monologue here for all the people who complain about how "in the Good Old Days(TM) we didn't need to talk about sexism and racism and all that, so why do we have to do it now?":
"By seeing her as being so seductive and beautiful, and reacting to her on a physiological level, it was very easy for him to forget she was a living, thinking creature. That made it deceptively simple for him to see how the Imperials found objectifying and dehumanizing other races justifiable[...]"
Also, this quote right here is very 2020:
"Kirtan Loor would have been trembling with outrage, but the lethargy of despair had a higher priority."
But.
BUT... (skip this paragraph if you don't enjoy sarcasm and take the fandom too seriously)
"A railing had even been set up to prevent prisoners from accidentally falling[...]"
Really? See, this is the kind of content I don't understand. How can they just let clueless new people take over Star Wars and allow them to introduce things that are completely unrealistic in this world? I mean, everybody, everybody knows there are no railings in Star Wars! With railings, the deaths of countless characters don't make sense in retrospect anymore! Just stop butchering my Star Wars with this kind of stuff!
(Yes, I am still angry about what this fandom has become, thank you for asking. And yes, I am fully aware of the fact that there were railings on the second Death Star. That's part of my point here.)
Back to the review.
In my review of Wedge's Gamble I expressed a wish for the characters to be more fleshed out. Well, this book did exactly that, at least for a lot of them. I enjoyed the mix of action and non-action (or rather, other kind of action), the mix of scenery and the various points of view. The story was fun, entertainingly written, pacing was good - everything I want from my Star Wars books.
There was a bit too much plot armor and convenience in it for me to give it five stars - I don't mind a little of that, this is Star Wars and those people are heroes, after all. But specially Corran Horn was just too much of a Gary Stu to keep my suspension of disbelief going, complete with the "he released a breadth he didn't know he was holding" line.
And I will just leave this quote from New Republic Hero Wedge Antilles' inner monologue here for all the people who complain about how "in the Good Old Days(TM) we didn't need to talk about sexism and racism and all that, so why do we have to do it now?":
"By seeing her as being so seductive and beautiful, and reacting to her on a physiological level, it was very easy for him to forget she was a living, thinking creature. That made it deceptively simple for him to see how the Imperials found objectifying and dehumanizing other races justifiable[...]"
March 26, 2011
The thing that strikes me the most about the expanded universe novels I've been reading since starting this little project is how books in the grand scheme of things, and even on a smaller scale within the context of their own saga, can jump from genre to genre with such amazing frequency. The first novel in the "X-Wing" series was a straight up military adventure story, a sort of Top Gun for Star Wars in many ways. I had anticipated the rest of the novels following a similar structure. The second novel, Wedge's Gamble, took a different turn altogether, playing itself out as a spy/espionage thriller that read in many ways like a James Bond novel set to a sci-fi setting. Once again the series hops genres and this time plays itself as a John Grisham courtroom drama mixed with a little bit of The Great Escape thrown in for good measure. Incidentally, I found it to be the most engaging novel in the series thus far, with the twists and turns of the courtroom drama moving at such a brisk pace and in a manner that invited a great deal of speculation on the part of the reader. At the end of the previous novel, we are left wondering about the guilt of Tycho Celchu's involvement with the supposed death of a Rogue Squadron member, and the revelation that he was captured and not killed by Ysanne Isard in the epilogue of book two does nothing to sway opinion either way, so the court case is handled with the reader not having concrete evidence either way, making the drama around the proceedings all the more potent.
With the secondary plot of the supposedly dead pilot trapped in the infamous Lusankya prison, the tone is evocative of films like The Great Escape, with our rebel pilot having a twinge of Steve McQueen in his character from the get-go, the comparison is more than adequate. His escape attempt, in which we learn that he is in fact descended from Jedi stock could have been considered a bit cliche if not for the fact that hints had been dropped since the first book in the series that this might be the case. There is of course a tendency to want to tie things to the Jedi in the Star Wars universe, and the revelation could have come out like badly written fan fiction if the writer had decided out of the blue to make one of his main characters a Jedi on whim, instead we get a major plot point that informs the climax of the novel and sets up the next installment. The choice of either becoming a Jedi and abandoning Rogue Squadron or remaining with the team and making good on promises made earlier in the narrative becomes the crux of the denouement here and leaves the reader energized to read the next installment, almost knowing that things that have been building over the course of three books and 1,000 pages worth of story will seemingly get a final payoff.
The next book in the series is the last for the author and the saga is taken over by perennial Star Wars writer Aaron Allston for books five through seven, so there is an expectation of closure with The Bacta War. Whether that holds true is yet to be seen, as it could be much as it was with the Republic Commando series and only leads further down the rabbit hole.
With the secondary plot of the supposedly dead pilot trapped in the infamous Lusankya prison, the tone is evocative of films like The Great Escape, with our rebel pilot having a twinge of Steve McQueen in his character from the get-go, the comparison is more than adequate. His escape attempt, in which we learn that he is in fact descended from Jedi stock could have been considered a bit cliche if not for the fact that hints had been dropped since the first book in the series that this might be the case. There is of course a tendency to want to tie things to the Jedi in the Star Wars universe, and the revelation could have come out like badly written fan fiction if the writer had decided out of the blue to make one of his main characters a Jedi on whim, instead we get a major plot point that informs the climax of the novel and sets up the next installment. The choice of either becoming a Jedi and abandoning Rogue Squadron or remaining with the team and making good on promises made earlier in the narrative becomes the crux of the denouement here and leaves the reader energized to read the next installment, almost knowing that things that have been building over the course of three books and 1,000 pages worth of story will seemingly get a final payoff.
The next book in the series is the last for the author and the saga is taken over by perennial Star Wars writer Aaron Allston for books five through seven, so there is an expectation of closure with The Bacta War. Whether that holds true is yet to be seen, as it could be much as it was with the Republic Commando series and only leads further down the rabbit hole.
February 15, 2023
I understand now why they chose to rename the Essential Legends edtion from X-Wing to the Rogue Squadron series. Just as the previous book, X-Wing flying and space combat takes the backseat, giving it more of a political spy thriller vibe. And it worked alot better in this one than in Wedges Gamble.
I have grown to like the Rogue crew alot over the few books and I like a series thats more about normal people and not just about Jedi and Sith. Also with minimal involvement of the normal main characters like Luke, Leia and so on.
Overall I enjoyed this one and I am excited to read whats next in store for the crew.
I have grown to like the Rogue crew alot over the few books and I like a series thats more about normal people and not just about Jedi and Sith. Also with minimal involvement of the normal main characters like Luke, Leia and so on.
Overall I enjoyed this one and I am excited to read whats next in store for the crew.
March 9, 2024
A 4.5 star out of 5 for a phenomenal book from Stackpole
Book three of the X-Wing series was not a disappointment. Similar to Wedges Gamble, this was much more of a espionage, boots on the ground take and Top Gun in Space but it was far better executed that book two.
We pick up immediately where Wedge’s Gamble left off with the New Republic picking up the pieces from Iceheart releasing the Krytos Virus to the alien population of Coruscant. There is a deal of political tension and racial/species tension due to the virus. We deal with the aftermath of Corran’s “death”, Captain Celchu’s implication in his death and the curing of the fatal disease.
We see a lot of Law and Order in space with Nawara dealing with Celchu’s trial and I actually thought these were some of the more interesting parts of the book, I wish more was written about the trial because it was so engrossing.
Stackpole does a really good job pulling the wool over our eyes that Celchu COULD have been a spy while also intricately laying the ground work for Ersi’s role as the traitor. We also (finally) get the revelation that Corran comes from a line of Jedi and has the potential to be a Jedi, though he declines Luke’s offer to train in order to free Thyferra from Icehearts clutches after she takes over after escaping from Coruscant.
I am very interested in seeing how the New Republics deal with the Rogues disbanding and the impending Bacta War. I am also excited to see if Corran makes good on his promise to rescue Jan. I’m fascinated to learn if Jan is General Jan Dordonna who was inexplicably name dropped earlier in the novel.
Looking forward to Stackpole’s book four!
Book three of the X-Wing series was not a disappointment. Similar to Wedges Gamble, this was much more of a espionage, boots on the ground take and Top Gun in Space but it was far better executed that book two.
We pick up immediately where Wedge’s Gamble left off with the New Republic picking up the pieces from Iceheart releasing the Krytos Virus to the alien population of Coruscant. There is a deal of political tension and racial/species tension due to the virus. We deal with the aftermath of Corran’s “death”, Captain Celchu’s implication in his death and the curing of the fatal disease.
We see a lot of Law and Order in space with Nawara dealing with Celchu’s trial and I actually thought these were some of the more interesting parts of the book, I wish more was written about the trial because it was so engrossing.
Stackpole does a really good job pulling the wool over our eyes that Celchu COULD have been a spy while also intricately laying the ground work for Ersi’s role as the traitor. We also (finally) get the revelation that Corran comes from a line of Jedi and has the potential to be a Jedi, though he declines Luke’s offer to train in order to free Thyferra from Icehearts clutches after she takes over after escaping from Coruscant.
I am very interested in seeing how the New Republics deal with the Rogues disbanding and the impending Bacta War. I am also excited to see if Corran makes good on his promise to rescue Jan. I’m fascinated to learn if Jan is General Jan Dordonna who was inexplicably name dropped earlier in the novel.
Looking forward to Stackpole’s book four!
April 25, 2023
These books are just really fun reads.
4.25 stars
4.25 stars
April 20, 2011
Since when is Admiral Ackbar qualified to rule on trial procedure? "Objection Sustained, the question is a Trap"
November 26, 2023
Co prawda długo to czytałam, ale było fajnie.
Podejrzewałam, że ktoś inny jest zdrajcą; mądrze rozegrane.
Końcówka piękna. Tak piękna, jak żarty na temat Huttów trenujących free falling ;)
Podejrzewałam, że ktoś inny jest zdrajcą; mądrze rozegrane.
Końcówka piękna. Tak piękna, jak żarty na temat Huttów trenujących free falling ;)
January 18, 2019
The Krytos Trap, the third Michael A. Stackpole novel in the Star Wars Legends X-Wing series, picks up directly where its predecessor, Wedge’s Gamble, left off: the Rebels have taken Coruscant, Ysanne Isard has fled, a plague is ravaging the non-human inhabitants of the planet, and Corran Horn is MIA.
Although still thoroughly an X-Wing novel, this book adds some variation to the formula.
Interestingly, much of the character-based action takes the form of a courtroom drama, with Twi’lek pilot Nawara Ven performing a defence of another pilot from Rogue Squadron who has been accused of treason, leading up to Corran’s death.
The other main venue for the story is the Imperial prison of Lusankya, where Ysanne Isard uses psychological torture and manipulation to turn prisoners into mentally conditioned sleeper agents as weapons against her enemies.
Of course, the space battles continue, with Warlord Zsinj making another off-page demonstration of his might, the effects of which confront Rogue Squadron. (Zsinj is an ever-present background threat in these novels, which acts as a great entrée before the main anti-Zsinj narrative of the Wraith Squadron novels.)
I think that one of the things I most enjoy about the X-wing books is the fact that they deal with much more ordinary inhabitants of the Star Wars universe - people seldom dwelt upon in the other novels (which are often too occupied with flashing lightsabres and escalating Force powers).
The description of the hideous effects of the Krytos plague (and in particular the case of the noble Gamorrean who kept his family safe by quarantining himself) is macabre yet fascinating It really helps to raise the stakes whilst at the same time keeping it at a personal level that makes pale by comparison any number of blown-up planets in the Hosnian system. I felt more for that green pig-guy than I felt for any of the anonymous people wiped out in a flash by Starkiller Base.
The rest of the characters gain a lot more fleshing out, Corran in particular, and there is even a brief cameo from Luke Skywalker towards the end. Still, the series still does lack a hilarious double-act like Face and Ton Phanan from the Wraith Squadron books - Stackpole plays it much straighter than Allston.
Sadly, aside from a very brief mention at the very beginning of the novel, we get to hear no more of the adventures of Portha the Trandoshan.
Nonetheless, despite these (minor) missed opportunities, I still really enjoy these books and feel they take me into the Star Wars universe like no others. There is an action sequence towards the end of the book that contains some passages that I really like, helping me to really visualise a Star Destroyer pummelling its way through a planetary shield in the midst of a starfighter battle in a way that really captures the essence of Star Wars for me.
I’m off to read the fourth book in the series, which the “available in all good bookshops” page of my paperback assures me is called X-Wing: Rogues Unbound, and is forthcoming (sometime in 1997). Perhaps it has been renamed by now?
Although still thoroughly an X-Wing novel, this book adds some variation to the formula.
Interestingly, much of the character-based action takes the form of a courtroom drama, with Twi’lek pilot Nawara Ven performing a defence of another pilot from Rogue Squadron who has been accused of treason, leading up to Corran’s death.
The other main venue for the story is the Imperial prison of Lusankya, where Ysanne Isard uses psychological torture and manipulation to turn prisoners into mentally conditioned sleeper agents as weapons against her enemies.
Of course, the space battles continue, with Warlord Zsinj making another off-page demonstration of his might, the effects of which confront Rogue Squadron. (Zsinj is an ever-present background threat in these novels, which acts as a great entrée before the main anti-Zsinj narrative of the Wraith Squadron novels.)
I think that one of the things I most enjoy about the X-wing books is the fact that they deal with much more ordinary inhabitants of the Star Wars universe - people seldom dwelt upon in the other novels (which are often too occupied with flashing lightsabres and escalating Force powers).
The description of the hideous effects of the Krytos plague (and in particular the case of the noble Gamorrean who kept his family safe by quarantining himself) is macabre yet fascinating It really helps to raise the stakes whilst at the same time keeping it at a personal level that makes pale by comparison any number of blown-up planets in the Hosnian system. I felt more for that green pig-guy than I felt for any of the anonymous people wiped out in a flash by Starkiller Base.
The rest of the characters gain a lot more fleshing out, Corran in particular, and there is even a brief cameo from Luke Skywalker towards the end. Still, the series still does lack a hilarious double-act like Face and Ton Phanan from the Wraith Squadron books - Stackpole plays it much straighter than Allston.
Sadly, aside from a very brief mention at the very beginning of the novel, we get to hear no more of the adventures of Portha the Trandoshan.
Nonetheless, despite these (minor) missed opportunities, I still really enjoy these books and feel they take me into the Star Wars universe like no others. There is an action sequence towards the end of the book that contains some passages that I really like, helping me to really visualise a Star Destroyer pummelling its way through a planetary shield in the midst of a starfighter battle in a way that really captures the essence of Star Wars for me.
I’m off to read the fourth book in the series, which the “available in all good bookshops” page of my paperback assures me is called X-Wing: Rogues Unbound, and is forthcoming (sometime in 1997). Perhaps it has been renamed by now?
April 28, 2023
Much Better
It felt like this books was more intriguing and focused. It wrapped up some storylines established in the first book and wrapped up others from the second. I wish there was more X-Wing action but maybe we will get there at some point
It felt like this books was more intriguing and focused. It wrapped up some storylines established in the first book and wrapped up others from the second. I wish there was more X-Wing action but maybe we will get there at some point
August 25, 2018
I've forgotten how good these books are. This one lives up to the intrigue of the first book in my mind.
May 11, 2016
the last chapter of this book is all I needed to confirm that Luke/Wedge used to be canon *GREATJOB*
![Profile Image for [boredom.is.overrated].](https://cdn.statically.io/img/i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1393269879i/29013992._UY200_CR3,0,200,200_.jpg)
July 19, 2020
So far, this has been the best of the 10 book series.
The great: The character development is allowed to occur because we now know most of the main characters. Stackpole does a good job of not relying on Star Wars film tropes, such as constant namedropping of Han/Luke/Leia and reusing film dialogue. This entry had a lot of twists that were enjoyable. The main one (in my opinion, the identity of the Imperial spy) was very predictable, but the other twists were more interesting and surprising as they came up. My favorite bits were what I will call the “space court case” and the “gravity prison.” As a kid, I don’t think I understand how great these were. As an adult, 20 years later, these are fun additions to a story that could’ve been a bunch of space battles but were elevated by the overall humanism and creativity of Stackpole.
The needs-more-polishing: Some of the fight scenes were a bit confusing. For example, near the end of the book; did the lightsaber her pushed through the wall into an adversary or did the main character duck out from behind the wall? I reread the same paragraph four times and still can’t tell you. Another time a character was hit by a shovel and I had to reread to determine what was happening. Stackpole does a good job picking new words to keep his action from becoming stale but sometimes the actual action gets lost in the literary shuffle.
The speech: I haven’t decided if I’m annoyed or impressed but Stackpole took a page out of Tolkien’s Fellowship and turned an entire chapter into a single speech. You don’t see writing like that in Star Wars books often. It was a bit dry but fit the character making the speech. At least it wasn’t three chapters of Elrond talking about Mt. Doom.
I give it 4.5 ugly fighters out of 5. :)
The great: The character development is allowed to occur because we now know most of the main characters. Stackpole does a good job of not relying on Star Wars film tropes, such as constant namedropping of Han/Luke/Leia and reusing film dialogue. This entry had a lot of twists that were enjoyable. The main one (in my opinion, the identity of the Imperial spy) was very predictable, but the other twists were more interesting and surprising as they came up. My favorite bits were what I will call the “space court case” and the “gravity prison.” As a kid, I don’t think I understand how great these were. As an adult, 20 years later, these are fun additions to a story that could’ve been a bunch of space battles but were elevated by the overall humanism and creativity of Stackpole.
The needs-more-polishing: Some of the fight scenes were a bit confusing. For example, near the end of the book; did the lightsaber her pushed through the wall into an adversary or did the main character duck out from behind the wall? I reread the same paragraph four times and still can’t tell you. Another time a character was hit by a shovel and I had to reread to determine what was happening. Stackpole does a good job picking new words to keep his action from becoming stale but sometimes the actual action gets lost in the literary shuffle.
The speech: I haven’t decided if I’m annoyed or impressed but Stackpole took a page out of Tolkien’s Fellowship and turned an entire chapter into a single speech. You don’t see writing like that in Star Wars books often. It was a bit dry but fit the character making the speech. At least it wasn’t three chapters of Elrond talking about Mt. Doom.
I give it 4.5 ugly fighters out of 5. :)
July 15, 2021
I absolutely loved this book. I was wondering where they had left to go after the Rebels took Coruscant, but the directions Stackpole takes this book in are so cool. Characters other than Corran are given more time to shine, which is great, but the also develop him in a really great way that sets up future storylines. The political intrigue surrounding the trial was one of my favorite parts of the book, it actually manages to make all the courtroom scenes fascinating. The main antagonist essentially disappears from the narrative, but it's so busy and there's a decent replacement anyway, so she's not quite missed, but the way she and the Rogues are set up for the last book in this arc is awesome and I can't wait to read it. This was my favorite X-Wing so far, and with Corran being separated from the rest of the squadron I didn't expect to feel that way. I could hardly put this book down. Fantastic.
July 14, 2017
2.5 Stars You know what the Krytos Trap really was? Having a 2nd straight book about Rogue Squadron almost completely planet-bound. There are a few bookend battle scenes, but the middle is quite dull. Granted, I have read this multiple times, but most of the twists are pretty well telegraphed. You know Tycho won't be found guilty. The twist about the prison being upside down was cool, but Corran's escape from the prison was laughably easy. I will say the revelation about Lusankya is one of the cooler scenes in a Star Wars book, but not enough in the end. One thing that really started to bug me was how little several of the characters have been fleshed out. We are book 3 now and several of the pilots are still cardboard thin characters. You might as well put a red-shirt on them because they are doomed to be cannon fodder.
October 15, 2021
Personally I think this is the strongest entry in the Rogue Squadron series so far. I still want more space combat but the trial of Tycho was quite exciting and Corrans escape from Lusankya equally so. It's amazing that this book having released over 20 years ago managed to keep the secret from me of having the SSD buried on Coruscant. I can understand why so many people who began their EU Legends journey in the 90s were saddened by the loss of these novels. The Zahn books and Stackpole stuff really was top tier. It's a shame that later ers stuff wasn't able to produce the same level of quality at all times.
August 12, 2021
I had to force myself to finish this book...and I think I've reached the end of my journey with the "Rogue Squadron" series. While I still love the political machinations of the fledgling New Republic (those Bothans are outrageous), the rest of the novel and its characters just makes me yawn. Like the Hutts and their milieu, this isn't the corner of the Lucasverse that makes me excited. Consider this rounded up from 2.5 stars.
May 28, 2014
Advances the plot nicely. Was easy to read (3 sittings, two of which were over 100 pages apiece). I knew that Erisi was the traitor, and was satisfied that my detective work was accurate. Loved the Jedi stuff at the end, and I can’t wait for I, Jedi and the development of Corran Horn as a Knight of the New Republic.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 26, 2009
3.5. Half way through i realized I had read this book before. A long time ago. Not quite "Long, long ago ..." but pretty near.
Anyway. Good story; good storytelling.
Anyway. Good story; good storytelling.
January 24, 2024
I enjoyed this one quite a bit. I liked the legal drama a lot :)
August 2, 2020
For 2020, I decided to reread (in publication order) all the Bantam-era Star Wars books that were released between 1991 and 1999; that shakes out to 38 adult novels and 5 anthologies of short stories & novellas.
This week’s focus: the third X-Wing book, The Krytos Trap by Michael A. Stackpole.
SOME (PERSONAL) HISTORY:
After watching the Special Editions in 1997, I immediately wanted to know what happened next. So I walked into a bookstore and bought my first two Star Wars books: The Truce at Bakura by Kathy Tyers and The Krytos Trap by Michael A. Stackpole. Truce is an understandable purchase: the cover itself proclaims that “as Return of the Jedi ends, an exciting new saga begins…” But The Krytos Trap? It says “Book 3 in an exciting series” right on the cover. I guess I was intrigued by all those spaceships. More so than Rogue Squadron or Wraith Squadron or any of the other X-Wing books, this is the one that I remember the most. The Krytos Trap made it to number fifteen on the New York Times paperback bestseller list for two straight weeks: from the week of September 29 to the week of October 6, 1996.
MY RECOLLECTION OF THE BOOK:
Compared to Rogue Squadron and Wedge's Gamble, this felt extremely familiar. I had retained most of Tycho Celchu’s trial, as well as Corran Horn’s imprisonment, but was a little more hazy on the movements of the rest of the Rogues.
A BRIEF SUMMARY:
The New Republic desperately needs to find a cure to the deadly Krytos Virus, and Rogue Squadron has been dispatched to steal some bacta back from Warlord Zsinj. But all the focus is on the trial of Tycho Celchu for murder and treason--except that Corran Horn is very much alive, and actively scheming to escape from Isard’s Lusankya prison.
THE CHARACTERS:
I really feel like I’ve come full-circle on Corran Horn in these books. Rereading Rogue Squadron, he was the most obnoxious character, and I was not looking forward to reading about him for 3/4/5 more books. I was surprised, then, to find that Corran’s prison escape was my favorite plotline in this book! I wasn’t too keen on the beginning, when Isard’s trying to brainwash him in the flight simulators, but after she gave up on him and dumped him in prison I was hooked. I loved how he figured out the twist with the prison--that they were upside down, so anyone who tried to escape would just head further and further down. I thought his escape was pretty thrilling, if perhaps too coincidental (the secret tunnel let him out right in the Jedi Museum? Really?)
I think it goes without saying that I love Wedge, so I enjoyed his parts. Wedge’s interest in Iella came a bit out of nowhere, but I like how it was addressed: he’s interested in this lady, but her husband has miraculously reappeared. And yet Wedge is still friendly with both of them. His concern about Tycho’s trial also felt very believable--he wants it to be dismissed out of hand, he trusts Tycho absolutely, and he’s devastated when his testimony is used to possibly incriminate Tycho further.
On the whole, though, Tycho’s trial didn’t 100% work for me. I think I was expecting something different (military trial in space!), but instead we got a generic episode of Law & Order. Nawara is the defense attorney, and he and the prosecutor keep yelling “objection!” like it’s an Ace Attorney game. I’m also confused as to Cracken’s game plan here; if he knew that Tycho wasn’t THE spy, why go to all this effort? And the trial is resolved with the most overused trope ever: Corran Horn showing up to proclaim, “Tycho didn’t kill me because I’m ALIVE!” I also felt like Tycho’s character development stalled out in this one, and he spent the whole book long-suffering. If I were wrongly accused, you can bet that I’d be a lot more angry about it!
Mirax is grieving Corran, and then she apparently dies when Zsinj ambushes the bacta convoy. This was one place where my prior knowledge of these books either helped or hindered me, because I immediately went “but she marries Corran.” Wedge’s lack of response, then, to her supposed death feels like a big giveaway to her continued existence. She’s like a sister to him, they’ve known each other since childhood, and he’d only behave this way if something was up. Then at the end, after the trial and the spy’s escape, Mirax returns and Stackpole gives us a huge infodump about where she’d been and what she’d been up to. This would have felt more natural if that information was slowly revealed to us, instead of being withheld until the end.
Kirtan Loor goes through a lot in this book. At the end of Wedge's Gamble, Isard made him the head of the Palpatine Counter-Insurgency Front. (They mostly just blow things up.) But Loor wants to become a power in his own right, instead of being ordered around by Isard or Moff Vorru. So he defects to the New Republic, promises them loads of information, and is promptly killed, mistaken for Derricote. What a fitting ending! I do wish, however, that his feud/hatred of Corran had played a role in his death, because it seemed to be his driving motivation.
Isard is still a shadowy presence. We see her a few times, but she’s basically the archvillain in a Bond film: sending out sub-villains to do all the dirty work. Hopefully we’ll see a lot more of her in book 4. Derricote was thrown in Lusankya, which really? If Isard imprisoned everyone who disappointed her, her prison would be entirely populated by her former minions. He ends up being the source of mistaken identity twice over--Isard thinks he escaped and is planning to testify, when it’s really Corran and Loor respectively.
ISSUES:
I liked the plotline with all the Rogues, and the dogfights continue to be especially thrilling, but it felt like there were parts missing. Wedge and the Rogues are sent to Ryloth to acquire ryll for the special bacta, and we get a lot of worldbuilding about the Twi’lek culture. I’m wondering if this is from the Star Wars Omnibus: X-Wing Rogue Squadron, Vol. 1 comic? Because we get so much information on the clans, and their dress, but then it all boils down to 1) they attend a party, 2) Wedge talks to a warrior who gives them all the ryll, and 3) they head back to Coruscant. That’s it??
Similarly, when the Rogues come upon the remains of the bacta convoy in the Alderaan system, Wedge sends Gavin to hire a freighter so they can take the remains back to Coruscant. It cuts to the next chapter, and they’re already back on Coruscant and Gavin is telling Wedge that he should grieve about Mirax. I thought that I was missing a section, so I borrowed the ebook from my library, but nope, that was it. (Maybe there’s a scene in another X-Wing book where Gavin goes to Tatooine?)
I also felt like the Krytos subplot was resolved both too easily and too offscreen. It’s a deadly virus, it’s in the water supply, it’s going to raise human/nonhuman tensions...but then we find out that the Rogue’s thunderstorm at the end of book 2 burned off most of the virus in the water supply, it actual transmits too quickly to start a pandemic, and the New Republic just stumbles upon a bacta blend that treats it. I expected a more active approach to combating the virus instead of this haphazard treatment.
And maybe the Rogue Squadron spy could have been handled a little better? Erisi played a pretty important part in books 1 and 2, only to completely fall off the radar in book 3. Corran finds out who the spy is, and Erisi rejoins her boss in the most obvious way possible. I’m sure that Stackpole is holding stuff back for book 4, but the resolution here felt rushed.
I love how Stackpole kept it hidden that the Lusankya was really a SHIP, and what an amazing scene when it appeared (can we see something like that in one of the animated or live action TV shows?), but how probable is it really? I’m meant to believe that the Emperor built a Super Star Destroyer on Coruscant, then built a bunch of buildings over it, for...some profit? Highly improbable, but makes for an awesome exit scene.
IN CONCLUSION:
Like Wedge's Gamble, I found the action scenes very thrilling--especially Corran’s prison escape--but Tycho’s trial felt like a weak point. There were issues I could pick apart there, and once I started being critical I couldn’t stop. So ultimately exciting yet slightly illogical.
Next up: a standalone! The New Rebellion by Kristine Kathryn Rusch.
My YouTube review: https://youtu.be/Lyl0BFH8H7c
Ryshcate attempt #2: https://youtu.be/ThNSJ7Mg28I
This week’s focus: the third X-Wing book, The Krytos Trap by Michael A. Stackpole.
SOME (PERSONAL) HISTORY:
After watching the Special Editions in 1997, I immediately wanted to know what happened next. So I walked into a bookstore and bought my first two Star Wars books: The Truce at Bakura by Kathy Tyers and The Krytos Trap by Michael A. Stackpole. Truce is an understandable purchase: the cover itself proclaims that “as Return of the Jedi ends, an exciting new saga begins…” But The Krytos Trap? It says “Book 3 in an exciting series” right on the cover. I guess I was intrigued by all those spaceships. More so than Rogue Squadron or Wraith Squadron or any of the other X-Wing books, this is the one that I remember the most. The Krytos Trap made it to number fifteen on the New York Times paperback bestseller list for two straight weeks: from the week of September 29 to the week of October 6, 1996.
MY RECOLLECTION OF THE BOOK:
Compared to Rogue Squadron and Wedge's Gamble, this felt extremely familiar. I had retained most of Tycho Celchu’s trial, as well as Corran Horn’s imprisonment, but was a little more hazy on the movements of the rest of the Rogues.
A BRIEF SUMMARY:
The New Republic desperately needs to find a cure to the deadly Krytos Virus, and Rogue Squadron has been dispatched to steal some bacta back from Warlord Zsinj. But all the focus is on the trial of Tycho Celchu for murder and treason--except that Corran Horn is very much alive, and actively scheming to escape from Isard’s Lusankya prison.
THE CHARACTERS:
I really feel like I’ve come full-circle on Corran Horn in these books. Rereading Rogue Squadron, he was the most obnoxious character, and I was not looking forward to reading about him for 3/4/5 more books. I was surprised, then, to find that Corran’s prison escape was my favorite plotline in this book! I wasn’t too keen on the beginning, when Isard’s trying to brainwash him in the flight simulators, but after she gave up on him and dumped him in prison I was hooked. I loved how he figured out the twist with the prison--that they were upside down, so anyone who tried to escape would just head further and further down. I thought his escape was pretty thrilling, if perhaps too coincidental (the secret tunnel let him out right in the Jedi Museum? Really?)
I think it goes without saying that I love Wedge, so I enjoyed his parts. Wedge’s interest in Iella came a bit out of nowhere, but I like how it was addressed: he’s interested in this lady, but her husband has miraculously reappeared. And yet Wedge is still friendly with both of them. His concern about Tycho’s trial also felt very believable--he wants it to be dismissed out of hand, he trusts Tycho absolutely, and he’s devastated when his testimony is used to possibly incriminate Tycho further.
On the whole, though, Tycho’s trial didn’t 100% work for me. I think I was expecting something different (military trial in space!), but instead we got a generic episode of Law & Order. Nawara is the defense attorney, and he and the prosecutor keep yelling “objection!” like it’s an Ace Attorney game. I’m also confused as to Cracken’s game plan here; if he knew that Tycho wasn’t THE spy, why go to all this effort? And the trial is resolved with the most overused trope ever: Corran Horn showing up to proclaim, “Tycho didn’t kill me because I’m ALIVE!” I also felt like Tycho’s character development stalled out in this one, and he spent the whole book long-suffering. If I were wrongly accused, you can bet that I’d be a lot more angry about it!
Mirax is grieving Corran, and then she apparently dies when Zsinj ambushes the bacta convoy. This was one place where my prior knowledge of these books either helped or hindered me, because I immediately went “but she marries Corran.” Wedge’s lack of response, then, to her supposed death feels like a big giveaway to her continued existence. She’s like a sister to him, they’ve known each other since childhood, and he’d only behave this way if something was up. Then at the end, after the trial and the spy’s escape, Mirax returns and Stackpole gives us a huge infodump about where she’d been and what she’d been up to. This would have felt more natural if that information was slowly revealed to us, instead of being withheld until the end.
Kirtan Loor goes through a lot in this book. At the end of Wedge's Gamble, Isard made him the head of the Palpatine Counter-Insurgency Front. (They mostly just blow things up.) But Loor wants to become a power in his own right, instead of being ordered around by Isard or Moff Vorru. So he defects to the New Republic, promises them loads of information, and is promptly killed, mistaken for Derricote. What a fitting ending! I do wish, however, that his feud/hatred of Corran had played a role in his death, because it seemed to be his driving motivation.
Isard is still a shadowy presence. We see her a few times, but she’s basically the archvillain in a Bond film: sending out sub-villains to do all the dirty work. Hopefully we’ll see a lot more of her in book 4. Derricote was thrown in Lusankya, which really? If Isard imprisoned everyone who disappointed her, her prison would be entirely populated by her former minions. He ends up being the source of mistaken identity twice over--Isard thinks he escaped and is planning to testify, when it’s really Corran and Loor respectively.
ISSUES:
I liked the plotline with all the Rogues, and the dogfights continue to be especially thrilling, but it felt like there were parts missing. Wedge and the Rogues are sent to Ryloth to acquire ryll for the special bacta, and we get a lot of worldbuilding about the Twi’lek culture. I’m wondering if this is from the Star Wars Omnibus: X-Wing Rogue Squadron, Vol. 1 comic? Because we get so much information on the clans, and their dress, but then it all boils down to 1) they attend a party, 2) Wedge talks to a warrior who gives them all the ryll, and 3) they head back to Coruscant. That’s it??
Similarly, when the Rogues come upon the remains of the bacta convoy in the Alderaan system, Wedge sends Gavin to hire a freighter so they can take the remains back to Coruscant. It cuts to the next chapter, and they’re already back on Coruscant and Gavin is telling Wedge that he should grieve about Mirax. I thought that I was missing a section, so I borrowed the ebook from my library, but nope, that was it. (Maybe there’s a scene in another X-Wing book where Gavin goes to Tatooine?)
I also felt like the Krytos subplot was resolved both too easily and too offscreen. It’s a deadly virus, it’s in the water supply, it’s going to raise human/nonhuman tensions...but then we find out that the Rogue’s thunderstorm at the end of book 2 burned off most of the virus in the water supply, it actual transmits too quickly to start a pandemic, and the New Republic just stumbles upon a bacta blend that treats it. I expected a more active approach to combating the virus instead of this haphazard treatment.
And maybe the Rogue Squadron spy could have been handled a little better? Erisi played a pretty important part in books 1 and 2, only to completely fall off the radar in book 3. Corran finds out who the spy is, and Erisi rejoins her boss in the most obvious way possible. I’m sure that Stackpole is holding stuff back for book 4, but the resolution here felt rushed.
I love how Stackpole kept it hidden that the Lusankya was really a SHIP, and what an amazing scene when it appeared (can we see something like that in one of the animated or live action TV shows?), but how probable is it really? I’m meant to believe that the Emperor built a Super Star Destroyer on Coruscant, then built a bunch of buildings over it, for...some profit? Highly improbable, but makes for an awesome exit scene.
IN CONCLUSION:
Like Wedge's Gamble, I found the action scenes very thrilling--especially Corran’s prison escape--but Tycho’s trial felt like a weak point. There were issues I could pick apart there, and once I started being critical I couldn’t stop. So ultimately exciting yet slightly illogical.
Next up: a standalone! The New Rebellion by Kristine Kathryn Rusch.
My YouTube review: https://youtu.be/Lyl0BFH8H7c
Ryshcate attempt #2: https://youtu.be/ThNSJ7Mg28I
May 5, 2024
Happy May the 4th!
For the holiday, I read Book 3 of Michael Stackpole’s initial “X-Wing” books which has a lot going on. “The Krytos Trap” sees the New Republic simultaneously setting up on Coruscant while trying to contain the Krytos plague, Rogue Squadron has to go on missions while trying to prove one of their number (Tycho Celchu) isn’t a spy/traitor, and Corran Horn is trying to survive becoming Ysanne Isard’s newest brainwashed sleeper agent. There’s also plenty of dogfights for fans who just like Star Wars when things go boom and plenty of political dealings and schemes to make prequel-era George Lucas drool.
After really liking the last book (“Wedge’s Gamble”), in at least the first half of Krytos Trap, the novel was borderline good and borderline underwhelming . The last book felt like a war/spy novel, whereas Krytos Trap does spend a fair amount of time as a legal drama. It’s an interesting choice for a book series meant to be “Top Gun in Space” to become “A Few Good Men in Space” (not really but I wanted to keep the Tom Cruise movie analogy going). There’s good moments throughout the trial, I just found overall it dragged the book down a bit. Otherwise, the book does suffer a bit from once again having a few too many POV characters (luckily only for brief sections though), weakish villains (Isard keeps on barely appearing in these books which is weird IMO since she’s the squadron), and subplots/side quests that take up a chapter and then barely are followed up on until the end.
Luckily The Krytos Trap does pick up significantly in the second half, right around the time that Corran escapes from prison. We’re at the point of the series where I’ve started to come around to Corran. I still find him grating and he’s nowhere near my not my favorite Rebel/Star Wars protagonist (him having Jedi heritage is a bit much too IMO) but putting him on the backfoot as he is tortured and trying to escape from prison made him a lot more engaging. Otherwise the climax where both the Imperial spy is finally revealed (identity felt like a certain class of James Bond villains and their motivation felt like something out of Dune) and an accompanying dogfight in the skies of Coruscant are thrilling. The most exciting/creative part of the climax though was a sequence I’d say is the opposite of what happened to Vader’s flagship in Return of the Jedi, creating a cool and horrifying mental picture. Beyond that, the closing chapter (featuring a cameo from Luke!) was a good showcase of Rogue Squadron’s camaraderie, something I didn’t feel at the start of Stackpole’s books, but now I fully believe in. This group dynamic and their accompanying decision to literally go rogue will make for an interesting Book 4.
“The Krytos Trap” isn’t as good as “Wedge’s Gamble” IMO but it ultimately did turn into a solidly entertaining novel. Long term I don’t how much I’ll remember it (minus that one climatic scene), preventing it from truly being a favorite Star Wars book of mine. But still it was fun to read.
For the holiday, I read Book 3 of Michael Stackpole’s initial “X-Wing” books which has a lot going on. “The Krytos Trap” sees the New Republic simultaneously setting up on Coruscant while trying to contain the Krytos plague, Rogue Squadron has to go on missions while trying to prove one of their number (Tycho Celchu) isn’t a spy/traitor, and Corran Horn is trying to survive becoming Ysanne Isard’s newest brainwashed sleeper agent. There’s also plenty of dogfights for fans who just like Star Wars when things go boom and plenty of political dealings and schemes to make prequel-era George Lucas drool.
After really liking the last book (“Wedge’s Gamble”), in at least the first half of Krytos Trap, the novel was borderline good and borderline underwhelming . The last book felt like a war/spy novel, whereas Krytos Trap does spend a fair amount of time as a legal drama. It’s an interesting choice for a book series meant to be “Top Gun in Space” to become “A Few Good Men in Space” (not really but I wanted to keep the Tom Cruise movie analogy going). There’s good moments throughout the trial, I just found overall it dragged the book down a bit. Otherwise, the book does suffer a bit from once again having a few too many POV characters (luckily only for brief sections though), weakish villains (Isard keeps on barely appearing in these books which is weird IMO since she’s the squadron), and subplots/side quests that take up a chapter and then barely are followed up on until the end.
Luckily The Krytos Trap does pick up significantly in the second half, right around the time that Corran escapes from prison. We’re at the point of the series where I’ve started to come around to Corran. I still find him grating and he’s nowhere near my not my favorite Rebel/Star Wars protagonist (him having Jedi heritage is a bit much too IMO) but putting him on the backfoot as he is tortured and trying to escape from prison made him a lot more engaging. Otherwise the climax where both the Imperial spy is finally revealed (identity felt like a certain class of James Bond villains and their motivation felt like something out of Dune) and an accompanying dogfight in the skies of Coruscant are thrilling. The most exciting/creative part of the climax though was a sequence I’d say is the opposite of what happened to Vader’s flagship in Return of the Jedi, creating a cool and horrifying mental picture. Beyond that, the closing chapter (featuring a cameo from Luke!) was a good showcase of Rogue Squadron’s camaraderie, something I didn’t feel at the start of Stackpole’s books, but now I fully believe in. This group dynamic and their accompanying decision to literally go rogue will make for an interesting Book 4.
“The Krytos Trap” isn’t as good as “Wedge’s Gamble” IMO but it ultimately did turn into a solidly entertaining novel. Long term I don’t how much I’ll remember it (minus that one climatic scene), preventing it from truly being a favorite Star Wars book of mine. But still it was fun to read.
March 30, 2024
Continuing story one of the X wing pilots gets accused of being a traitor after being captured and Brainwashed by the Empire.
Coran Horn is feared dead top pilot in combat on Coruscant and fellow pilot suspected of betrayal.
Battle ensues between Rebels and Warlord trying to steal precious Bacta from Rebels with consistent conflict to gain upper hand in controlling Bacta supply due to release of virus on Coruscant as Empire retreats.
Disagreements within alliance of how Bacta should be distributed and using former imperials within the civilian society along with infiltration of criminal networks for Bacta supply.
Loor imperial agent continue operations on Coruscant after planet liberation causing havoc whilst using criminals to steal profiting from supply issues.
Hidden Super Star Destroyer appears leaving in a hurry and Mon Mothma makes speech about how Empires can only take power and not give it.
Coran Horn discovers from well known Jedi about his family’s ability after he appears later in the story and traitor on trail by the rebels is attempt to expose spies within the ranks.
Interesting story about deliberate release of virus during the Imperial retreat trying to bankrupt rebels and brainwashing people for use as spies.
Coran Horn is feared dead top pilot in combat on Coruscant and fellow pilot suspected of betrayal.
Battle ensues between Rebels and Warlord trying to steal precious Bacta from Rebels with consistent conflict to gain upper hand in controlling Bacta supply due to release of virus on Coruscant as Empire retreats.
Disagreements within alliance of how Bacta should be distributed and using former imperials within the civilian society along with infiltration of criminal networks for Bacta supply.
Loor imperial agent continue operations on Coruscant after planet liberation causing havoc whilst using criminals to steal profiting from supply issues.
Hidden Super Star Destroyer appears leaving in a hurry and Mon Mothma makes speech about how Empires can only take power and not give it.
Coran Horn discovers from well known Jedi about his family’s ability after he appears later in the story and traitor on trail by the rebels is attempt to expose spies within the ranks.
Interesting story about deliberate release of virus during the Imperial retreat trying to bankrupt rebels and brainwashing people for use as spies.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 5, 2024
Okay, I did not expect a significant portion of this book to be a courtroom drama, but I was so here for it. My early prediction of the Rogue traitor finally proved true, and overall I think the twists leading up to it (especially regarding Lusankya) and reveals were well-handled. Also I love to see Borsk get shut down.
One critique that holds for this series is that sometimes Stackpole skips scenes that I think would be important for further developing characters, scenes of big emotion so to speak. I wonder if part of that is because of the tradition of military sci-fi these fall into, which has a tendency towards being overly clinical. It feels wrong we didn't get to SEE Rogue Squadron's reunion at the end.
One critique that holds for this series is that sometimes Stackpole skips scenes that I think would be important for further developing characters, scenes of big emotion so to speak. I wonder if part of that is because of the tradition of military sci-fi these fall into, which has a tendency towards being overly clinical. It feels wrong we didn't get to SEE Rogue Squadron's reunion at the end.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 24, 2023
It's my favorite out of the three rogue squadron books I've read so far. Following the trial of Celchu was intriguing, and the way the trial was positioned throughout the chapters and book made the story have nice and enjoyable pacing. From chapter 21 and onward, the book really picks up, and a lot of jarring and unbelievable things are revealed. Plus, the cameo of a certain original trilogy character in the final chapter was amazing.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 22, 2024
Such a huge step up in quality from the first two books in the series. The politics, scheming, and character work are on another level. I’m so glad to have come across this series.
April 1, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2
A thrilling read, and the best of the Rogue Squadron series so far.
The New Republic have taken Coruscant, however, Ysanne Isard has escaped and left the New Republic with the Krytos Virus. This virus only affects non-humans and quickly spreads, becoming a deadly epidemic on the newly captured planet. All the while, Tycho Celchu is on trial for treason and the murder of Corran Horn. Wedge is doing all he can to prove Tycho’s innocence while Rogue Squadron also balances missions to stop the spread of the Krytos virus.
The last 100 pages are brilliant, with constantly escalating stakes, perfectly setting up the final book in Stackpole’s series of X-Wing novels.
A thrilling read, and the best of the Rogue Squadron series so far.
The New Republic have taken Coruscant, however, Ysanne Isard has escaped and left the New Republic with the Krytos Virus. This virus only affects non-humans and quickly spreads, becoming a deadly epidemic on the newly captured planet. All the while, Tycho Celchu is on trial for treason and the murder of Corran Horn. Wedge is doing all he can to prove Tycho’s innocence while Rogue Squadron also balances missions to stop the spread of the Krytos virus.
The last 100 pages are brilliant, with constantly escalating stakes, perfectly setting up the final book in Stackpole’s series of X-Wing novels.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 231 reviews