Skip to main content

Numbers don’t lie: Roku’s streaming spats have given Amazon the edge

For a long time, we’ve thought of Roku as the streaming media king. Not just because its software is so easy to use and its devices so affordable, but also because of its popularity — the company has traditionally enjoyed a much larger share of the streaming market than its competitors. But it looks like the company’s contentious relationships with some of the biggest names in streamed entertainment may be hurting that reputation: Amazon has just announced that its Fire TV platform has hit 50 million monthly active users on its devices globally, a number that comfortably edges out Roku, which reported 46 million monthly active users in November.

It took Roku a number of months to solve its differences with NBCUniversal’s Peacock, but a similar dispute with entertainment giant HBO Max continues, with no end in sight. These spats alone don’t necessarily account for Roku’s slower growth when compared to Amazon’s Fire TV, especially given that both Peacock and HBO Max are U.S.-only services right now. Other factors include the aggressive rollout and pricing of Amazon’s new Fire TV devices, which in some cases deliver more features for less money than the equivalent Roku devices. Amazon’s Alexa is now built into every Fire TV device, as one example.

Indeed, the popularity of Fire TV streaming devices like the Fire TV Cube, Fire TV Stick 4K, Fire TV Stick, and Fire TV Stick Lite must be considerable since Fire TV doesn’t possess Roku’s large presence on smart TVs or smart soundbars.

The Fire TV platform doesn’t offer as many apps as Roku, and it lacks a free-to-watch standalone service like The Roku Channel, which can be accessed on the web without an account.

Nonetheless, Amazon continues to refine the Fire TV offering. Earlier in December, it began to roll out a new version of its user experience, putting a greater emphasis on content discovery and recommendations along with a simpler menu structure.

Amazon also announced that it has added the ability to do two-way video chats on the second-gen Fire TV Cube for those who buy compatible webcams.

NBCUniversal’s Peacock remains unavailable on Fire TV, but HBO Max was added in November, giving Fire TV users the opportunity to watch Wonder Woman 1984 in 4K Dolby Vision and Dolby Atmos when it debuts on the service on December 25. Given that Warner Media recently dropped the bombshell that its entire movie release schedule for 2021 would be going direct-to-consumer via HBO Max, the service’s continued absence from Roku could hurt the streaming device maker even further.

Simon Cohen
Simon Cohen covers a variety of consumer technologies, but has a special interest in audio and video products, like spatial…
Google TV vs. Roku TV: which is the better streaming OS?
Roku Streaming Stick 4K.

Whether you're looking for a new TV or streaming device, two of the leading smart TV platforms and user interfaces you'll be choosing from are Google TV and Roku TV. Both of these content and navigational platforms are excellent options, with many shared pros between them.

For years, Google has provided the building blocks to smart TV brands from Sony to Hisense under that Android TV banner. Presently, the structural framework of the Android TV system is giving way to an all-new Google operating system known as Google TV. You'll find Google's latest OS running on Sony, Hisense, and TCL TVs, as well as first-party Google devices like the Chromecast with Google TV 4K and Chromecast with Google TV (HD).

Read more
Roku and Amazon are so close to making subtitles easy to toggle
The Roku Voice Remote Pro, and the Amazon Alexa Voice Remote Pro.

The idea that remote controls should include a dedicated button for captions is not, in and of itself, a bad one. In fact, it makes a whole lot of sense, whether the remote belongs to a television or a peripheral like Roku or Amazon Fire TV. We acknowledge the fact that it would add complexity and, possibly, cost to a device. (And that it's relatively easy to just flip 'em on and off inside apps as it is.) But we believe it would be worth it.

We didn’t pick Roku and Amazon Fire TV out of thin air in that previous paragraph. They are the two biggest streaming platforms in the world. And as it turns out, they both have remote controls with user-programmable buttons. While that’s not quite the same thing as what we're imploring the likes of Roku, Amazon, Google, Apple, and others to employ, it’s something that’s available now. (Though the remotes in question aren’t shipped by default with every device — you’ll have to spend more to get them.)

Read more
How we test streaming video devices
The box for the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max.

One of the benefits of being Digital Trends is that we get to test a lot of things that simply aren’t easily available or replaceable should they not work out for the average person. That’s why we put so much work into testing TVs, for one example. Or full soundbar setups, for another.

Other times it’s because we’re able to take products for a test drive before they go on sale. Like video games, or computers and phones. That’s good because it helps you make a relatively expensive and important purchase decision.

Read more