Skip to main content
Bounty Ended with 200 reputation awarded by Pavel Janicek
added 2 characters in body
Source Link
kingledion
  • 85.6k
  • 29
  • 283
  • 484
  • The larger the lake, the most stable the flow out of it. Also, it helps that the lake be in a temperate environment, oo water input into the lake doesn't vary too much. The lake can freeze over, as can the outlet river, without really affecting flow much; this happens in the case of the example.

  • Example - Saint MaryMary's River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie. Other good examples are the Rhone downstream of Lake Geneva, and the Neva downstream of Lake Ladoga.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

  • Con - In many cases, these outlet rivers are steep and un-navigable.

  • The larger the lake, the most stable the flow out of it. Also, it helps that the lake be in a temperate environment, oo water input into the lake doesn't vary too much. The lake can freeze over, as can the outlet river, without really affecting flow much; this happens in the case of the example.

  • Example - Saint Mary River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie. Other good examples are the Rhone downstream of Lake Geneva, and the Neva downstream of Lake Ladoga.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

  • Con - In many cases, these outlet rivers are steep and un-navigable.

  • The larger the lake, the most stable the flow out of it. Also, it helps that the lake be in a temperate environment, oo water input into the lake doesn't vary too much. The lake can freeze over, as can the outlet river, without really affecting flow much; this happens in the case of the example.

  • Example - Saint Mary's River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie. Other good examples are the Rhone downstream of Lake Geneva, and the Neva downstream of Lake Ladoga.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

  • Con - In many cases, these outlet rivers are steep and un-navigable.

deleted 1 character in body
Source Link
kingledion
  • 85.6k
  • 29
  • 283
  • 484

River downstream of a large lakeslake

  • There are two large lakesThe larger the lake, the most stable the flow out of it. There isAlso, it helps that the lake be in a river connecting themtemperate environment, probably shortoo water input into the lake doesn't vary too much. Your city is on thatThe lake can freeze over, as can the outlet river, without really affecting flow much; this happens in the case of the example.

  • Example - Saint Mary River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie. Other good examples are the Rhone downstream of Lake Geneva, and the Neva downstream of Lake Ladoga.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

  • Con - The only examples ofIn many cases, these outlet rivers in the real world are short, and they are generally steep and un-navigable. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

River downstream of a large lakes

  • There are two large lakes. There is a river connecting them, probably short. Your city is on that river.

  • Example - Saint Mary River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations

  • Con - The only examples of these rivers in the real world are short, and they are generally steep and un-navigable. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

River downstream of a large lake

  • The larger the lake, the most stable the flow out of it. Also, it helps that the lake be in a temperate environment, oo water input into the lake doesn't vary too much. The lake can freeze over, as can the outlet river, without really affecting flow much; this happens in the case of the example.

  • Example - Saint Mary River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie. Other good examples are the Rhone downstream of Lake Geneva, and the Neva downstream of Lake Ladoga.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

  • Con - In many cases, these outlet rivers are steep and un-navigable.

Source Link
kingledion
  • 85.6k
  • 29
  • 283
  • 484

Rivers with stable flow (with data source)

River downstream of a large lakes

  • There are two large lakes. There is a river connecting them, probably short. Your city is on that river.

  • Example - Saint Mary River (between Lake Superior and Lake Huron in US/Canada) at Sault Ste. Marie.

  • Pro - Very stable flow rate, year round (assuming the lakes don't freeze). Low ratio and magnitude of seasonal fluctuations

  • Con - The only examples of these rivers in the real world are short, and they are generally steep and un-navigable. When improved with canals and locks, this makes for a great trading city.

enter image description here

Extreme high flow       3590
Expected annual high    2385
Average flow            2142
Excess over expect high 1205
Excess over average     1448
Ratio over expect high  0.51
Ratio over average      0.68

(Note, all units are in cubic meters per second, except ratio)

Large tropical river

  • A large tropical river where half of the river basin is in each hemisphere. As the monsoon rains are pushed by the Intertropical Convergence Zone back and forth between the hemispheres, you will end up with relatively stable rainfall throughout the year.

  • Example - Congo River measured at Kinshasa.

  • Pros - Very low seasonal flow variance. Also, an enormous basin for river-borne trade with the city.

  • Cons - Very high magnitude of flow variance. When the river is this big, even a little bit of flooding is a big deal.

enter image description here

Extreme high flow       80832
Expected annual high    56081
Average flow            39536
Excess over expect high 24751
Excess over average     41296
Ratio over expect high  0.44
Ratio over average      1.04

A temperate river with little snowmelt

  • The next best scenario is a river with a small basin with constant, low level rainfall, and little snow accumulation.

  • Example - Seine River at Paris.

  • Pro - Despite being a big enough river for a truly large city, the magnitude of highest recorded flood to average winter high water is not large.

  • Con - Large seasonal fluctuations, can be difficult to navigate in summer time due to low water levels.

enter image description here

Extreme high flow       1284
Expected annual high    560
Average flow            268
Excess over expect high 724
Excess over average     1016
Ratio over expect high  1.29
Ratio over average      3.79

Examples of bad rivers

Continental river with large, dry basin

Example Arkansas River in the US, measured at Little Rock. In the interior US, random thunderstorms lasting for a few days can cause serious flooding, usually in spring or early summer.

Extreme high flow       8220
Expected annual high    2044
Average flow            1066
Excess over expect high 6176
Excess over average     7145
Ratio over expect high  3.02
Ratio over average      6.71

Continental river with enormous spring snowmelt

Example - Tom River measured at Tomsk, in Siberia. While the high river levels with snowmelt is relatively predictable, it is still very large compared to regular river levels.

Extreme high flow       7500
Expected annual high    4622
Average flow            1047
Excess over expect high 2878
Excess over average     6453
Ratio over expect high  0.62
Ratio over average      6.16

River in Monsoon area

Example - Vijayawada river in southern India measured at its mouth. While the timing of the monsoon is predictable, its magnitude is not. An erratic monsoon can produce spectacular flooding.

Extreme high flow       16555 
Expected annual high    6266 
Average flow            1642 
Excess over expect high 10289 
Excess over average     14913 
Ratio over expect high  1.64 
Ratio over average      9.08