Skip to main content
replaced http://unix.stackexchange.com/ with https://unix.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

I asked a question while not knowing enough to clearly state my issue. (Here is the question: http://unix.stackexchange.com/q/108842/15010https://unix.stackexchange.com/q/108842/15010 .) I received a couple responses that helped me get on the right track, but they did not actually answer my question. I continued to read and learn, and today I found a solution. I posted my answer here: http://unix.stackexchange.com/a/109011/15010https://unix.stackexchange.com/a/109011/15010 .

However, now that I have a little more clarity, I can see how to massively edit my question to make it much more clear for other readers. This seems like a good thing.

My concern is that a massive edit will remove the context for the two responses I received so far. It might make those prior answers appear less relevant.

Bottom line: it seems somewhat unfair to the two responders to massively edit my question, but doing so will make the question much more useful to future readers. What should I do?

I asked a question while not knowing enough to clearly state my issue. (Here is the question: http://unix.stackexchange.com/q/108842/15010 .) I received a couple responses that helped me get on the right track, but they did not actually answer my question. I continued to read and learn, and today I found a solution. I posted my answer here: http://unix.stackexchange.com/a/109011/15010 .

However, now that I have a little more clarity, I can see how to massively edit my question to make it much more clear for other readers. This seems like a good thing.

My concern is that a massive edit will remove the context for the two responses I received so far. It might make those prior answers appear less relevant.

Bottom line: it seems somewhat unfair to the two responders to massively edit my question, but doing so will make the question much more useful to future readers. What should I do?

I asked a question while not knowing enough to clearly state my issue. (Here is the question: https://unix.stackexchange.com/q/108842/15010 .) I received a couple responses that helped me get on the right track, but they did not actually answer my question. I continued to read and learn, and today I found a solution. I posted my answer here: https://unix.stackexchange.com/a/109011/15010 .

However, now that I have a little more clarity, I can see how to massively edit my question to make it much more clear for other readers. This seems like a good thing.

My concern is that a massive edit will remove the context for the two responses I received so far. It might make those prior answers appear less relevant.

Bottom line: it seems somewhat unfair to the two responders to massively edit my question, but doing so will make the question much more useful to future readers. What should I do?

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackUnix/status/424212251621732352
edited tags
Link
Source Link
MountainX
  • 18.2k
  • 12
  • 3

Is it OK to massively edit a question after receiving a couple responses?

I asked a question while not knowing enough to clearly state my issue. (Here is the question: http://unix.stackexchange.com/q/108842/15010 .) I received a couple responses that helped me get on the right track, but they did not actually answer my question. I continued to read and learn, and today I found a solution. I posted my answer here: http://unix.stackexchange.com/a/109011/15010 .

However, now that I have a little more clarity, I can see how to massively edit my question to make it much more clear for other readers. This seems like a good thing.

My concern is that a massive edit will remove the context for the two responses I received so far. It might make those prior answers appear less relevant.

Bottom line: it seems somewhat unfair to the two responders to massively edit my question, but doing so will make the question much more useful to future readers. What should I do?