Skip to main content
Updated news. The party's over.
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update moved to an answer.January 2021 update: Alas, the phosphine is no more. It appears to have been sulfur dioxide all along.

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update moved to an answer.

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

January 2021 update: Alas, the phosphine is no more. It appears to have been sulfur dioxide all along.

Have we finally found something?
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update: moved to an answer.

October is 2020: It appears this barrier has been crossed with the identification of glycine in the atmosphere of Venus. This link provides an abstract from which the pdf may be downloaded without a paywall.

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update:

October is 2020: It appears this barrier has been crossed with the identification of glycine in the atmosphere of Venus. This link provides an abstract from which the pdf may be downloaded without a paywall.

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update moved to an answer.

Have we finally found something?
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update:

October is 2020: It appears this barrier has been crossed with the identification of glycine in the atmosphere of Venus. This link provides an abstract from which the pdf may be downloaded without a paywall.

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

There has been much speculation in recent news about the finding of phosphine on Venus, and what may be producing it.

At the same time, when we look for clues of life elsewhere in the Solar System, we look for and have found at least some of the organic compounds associated with such life (as we know it). But what about such organic chemistry on/above Venus? While engineers from the Los Alamos National Laboratory are working on a probe to find organic compounds on Venus, for now I am unaware of any current evidence except, maybe, carbonyl sulfide.

So am I missing something? Is more extensive organic chemistry already known (not just speculated) on Venus?

Note: an accepted answer will indicate, with references if available, that either no organic compounds have yet been found or that they are known, directly aming the clouds of Venus as they are on Mars and other life candidates.

Update:

October is 2020: It appears this barrier has been crossed with the identification of glycine in the atmosphere of Venus. This link provides an abstract from which the pdf may be downloaded without a paywall.

Clarification.
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
Wikipedia removed its passage about the possible disproportionation of phosphorus(iii). Therefore I delete the quotation, but the question of organic compounds remains
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
Modified in response to a comment.
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
Modified in response to comments.
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
deleted though
Source Link
Cornelis
  • 7.5k
  • 2
  • 27
  • 77
Loading
added 1 character in body
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
Tweeted twitter.com/StackSpaceExp/status/1305884093759082496
Added a reference and elaboration.
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
I could swear I typed those spaces. Why did they not show the first time?
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading
Source Link
Oscar Lanzi
  • 8.5k
  • 1
  • 31
  • 56
Loading