Skip to main content
replaced http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/ with https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Definitely not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

More importantly, there have been studies on whether anaechoic chambers and darkness give hallucinations or psychotic states. This is the subject of this other answerthis other answer, which finds that there is an increase in the incidence of such occurrences.

That said, the subjects in at least one experiment were subjected to three hours of isolation in an anaechoic chamber. I think this debunks the claim thoroughly.

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation, R. Vosburg, et al., AMA Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1960;2(3):356-357. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1960.03590090112016.

Definitely not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

More importantly, there have been studies on whether anaechoic chambers and darkness give hallucinations or psychotic states. This is the subject of this other answer, which finds that there is an increase in the incidence of such occurrences.

That said, the subjects in at least one experiment were subjected to three hours of isolation in an anaechoic chamber. I think this debunks the claim thoroughly.

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation, R. Vosburg, et al., AMA Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1960;2(3):356-357. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1960.03590090112016.

Definitely not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

More importantly, there have been studies on whether anaechoic chambers and darkness give hallucinations or psychotic states. This is the subject of this other answer, which finds that there is an increase in the incidence of such occurrences.

That said, the subjects in at least one experiment were subjected to three hours of isolation in an anaechoic chamber. I think this debunks the claim thoroughly.

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation, R. Vosburg, et al., AMA Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1960;2(3):356-357. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1960.03590090112016.

added 766 characters in body
Source Link
Sklivvz
  • 78.8k
  • 29
  • 323
  • 429

Almost certainly notDefinitely not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

More importantly, there have been studies on whether anaechoic chambers and darkness give hallucinations or psychotic states. This is the subject of this other answer, which finds that there is an increase in the incidence of such occurrences.

That said, the subjects in at least one experiment were subjected to three hours of isolation in an anaechoic chamber. I think this debunks the claim thoroughly.

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation, R. Vosburg, et al., AMA Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1960;2(3):356-357. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1960.03590090112016.

Almost certainly not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

Definitely not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

More importantly, there have been studies on whether anaechoic chambers and darkness give hallucinations or psychotic states. This is the subject of this other answer, which finds that there is an increase in the incidence of such occurrences.

That said, the subjects in at least one experiment were subjected to three hours of isolation in an anaechoic chamber. I think this debunks the claim thoroughly.

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation

Imagery Sequence in Sensory Deprivation, R. Vosburg, et al., AMA Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1960;2(3):356-357. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1960.03590090112016.

Rollback to Revision 2
Source Link
Sklivvz
  • 78.8k
  • 29
  • 323
  • 429

Almost certainly not, and in my personal opinion: no.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

Almost certainly not, and in my personal opinion: no.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

Almost certainly not.

Here's a video of a science reporter, Veritasium, staying in an anaechoic chamber for one hour, in the dark. Not only they do so at the first attempt, but they come out of it convinced they could have stayed indefinitely -- that there was no "driving crazy effect".

Clearly this is weak evidence by scientific standards, but the evidence those links give is no better, and this is actually on film/tape. Also, claiming that something extraordinary happens should be backed by stronger evidence than... nothing happens.

veritasium in anaechoic chamber

deleted 1 character in body
Source Link
Sklivvz
  • 78.8k
  • 29
  • 323
  • 429
Loading
Rollback to Revision 1
Source Link
Sklivvz
  • 78.8k
  • 29
  • 323
  • 429
Loading
Removed "personal opinion" - feel free to rollback if you don't like this edit.
Source Link
Online User
  • 30.3k
  • 14
  • 131
  • 136
Loading
Source Link
Sklivvz
  • 78.8k
  • 29
  • 323
  • 429
Loading