Skip to main content
Became Hot Network Question
added 54 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
LogicDictates
  • 124.2k
  • 24
  • 448
  • 544

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By: By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s Lord’s side because I was ordered to.",

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (2005)

WhyI am probably being a bit naive, as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years, but why would Snape say thisthe above to Bellatrix, rather then just not mentioning it.? As now, to Bellatrix/Voldemort, this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters. Yet, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters, from the perspective of Voldemort/Bellatrix, surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, Fromfrom the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Bellatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape;Snape -- through Snape telling him; Snapehim -- is now a Death Eater again, surely. Surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about, as what would Snape now be doing, considering, in theory, Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after, how does Snape continue on the pretensepretence he is a spy for the Death Eaters, if based on what he has told the DEthem, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. 

Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Bellatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretensepretence of being a Spyspy for the DEDeath Eaters on the Order?

PsP.S.: it probably isn't simple terms. Also, this is all from the perspective of the DEDeath Eaters, based on what Snape's told them, as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the orderOrder.

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to Bellatrix rather then just not mentioning it. As now to Bellatrix/Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort/Bellatrix surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Bellatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Bellatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

Snape: By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to,

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (2005)

I am probably being a bit naive, as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years, but why would Snape say the above to Bellatrix, rather then just not mentioning it? As now, to Bellatrix/Voldemort, this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters. Yet, if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters, from the perspective of Voldemort/Bellatrix, surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, from the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Bellatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape -- through Snape telling him -- is now a Death Eater again. Surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about, as what would Snape now be doing, considering, in theory, Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after, how does Snape continue on the pretence he is a spy for the Death Eaters, if based on what he has told them, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. 

Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Bellatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretence of being a spy for the Death Eaters on the Order?

P.S.: it probably isn't simple terms. Also, this is all from the perspective of the Death Eaters, based on what Snape's told them, as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the Order.

added 10 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Eren
  • 79
  • 1
  • 3

Why did Snape tell VoldemortBellatrix about Dumbledore knowing he was returning to the Dark Lord?

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to BeatrixBellatrix rather then just not mentioning it. As now to BeatrixBellatrix/Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort/BeatrixBellatrix surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to BeatrixBellatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/BeatrixBellatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

Why did Snape tell Voldemort about Dumbledore knowing he was returning to the Dark Lord?

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to Beatrix rather then just not mentioning it. As now to Beatrix/Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort/Beatrix surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Beatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Beatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

Why did Snape tell Bellatrix about Dumbledore knowing he was returning to the Dark Lord?

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to Bellatrix rather then just not mentioning it. As now to Bellatrix/Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort/Bellatrix surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Bellatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Bellatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

added 12 characters in body
Source Link
Eren
  • 79
  • 1
  • 3

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to VoldemortBeatrix rather then just not mentioning it. As now to VoldemortBeatrix/Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort/Beatrix surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to VoldemortBeatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Beatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to Voldemort rather then just not mentioning it. As now to Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Voldemort in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Beatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

I am probably being a bit naive as I'm only reading the series again for the first time in a good few years but why, In the HBP:

Snape Says, "By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord’s side because I was ordered to."

Why would Snape say this to Beatrix rather then just not mentioning it. As now to Beatrix/Voldemort this looks like Snape has informed Dumbledore, and Dumbledore is aware Snape is returning to the Death Eaters, yet if Snape is and wants to continue being a spy for the Death Eaters from the perspective of Voldemort/Beatrix surely this would compromise Snape's and Dumbledore's connection and would mean Dumbledore would stop trusting and giving him info, and ultimately fire him.

So in simple terms, From the perspective in which Snape is speaking to Beatrix in, Dumbledore is aware Snape; through Snape telling him; Snape is now a Death Eater again, surely this would lead to Dumbledore not trusting or confiding in Snape, which surely Voldemort would do something about as what would Snape now be doing considering in theory Dumbledore wouldn't be giving him information and he wouldn't have a job there?... Then after how does Snape continue on the pretense he is a spy for the Death Eaters if based on what he has told the DE, Dumbledore is aware he is working with them. Therefore, that would mean he wouldn't be trusted and create the loop of the fact he wouldn't get any information, most likely not work there due to being fired or leaving and would not be able to be a spy. So how doesn't Voldemort/Beatrix pick up on this when questioning Snape and consequently believe/accept his pretense of being a Spy for the DE on the Order?

Ps: it probably isn't simple terms. Also this is all from the perspective of the DE, based on what Snape's told them as we all know in reality Snape is a double agent for the order.

Source Link
Eren
  • 79
  • 1
  • 3
Loading