Skip to main content
Question Protected by CommunityBot
replaced http://scifi.stackexchange.com/ with https://scifi.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Gene Roddenberry died in 1991 halfway through Star Trek: The Next Generation. He'd been sick for a while and, according to Rick Berman, his "hands-on involvement in The Next Generation diminished greatly after the first season".

Did the post-Roddenberry TNG differ from his initial vision? Did Berman violate any of the rules that Roddenberry had laid out for the series? Were there any general themes that became less emphasized after his death? Did Berman make hire or fire decisions contrary to Gene’s known preferences?


Well researched answers with definite changes are preferred, especially if backed up by contemporary sources. Possible changes can either be on or off camera, and specific ("Dr. Crusher came back") or broad ("more personal drama/fewer stories with an 'exploring the unknown' theme").

For example:

  • Berman didn't like the music direction, and started using subdued orchestral tracks, rather than sticking with Ron Jones.

  • Gene was convinced by his staff to replace Gates McFadden but Berman opposed the decision. Did Gene’s reduced involvement or death influence the decision to bring her back?

  • People had trouble working with Gene, and there was a high writer turnover. From Wikipedia:

    Tracy Tormé described the first few seasons of The Next Generation under Roddenberry as an "insane asylum" ...Franchise writers Fontana and David Gerrold... left the series under acrimonious circumstances...

    Did Gene’s reduced involvement persuade anyone to stay?

Answers should only address his influence on TNG. The influence that he did or didn't have on DS9 and Voyager is addressed by this questionthis question.

Gene Roddenberry died in 1991 halfway through Star Trek: The Next Generation. He'd been sick for a while and, according to Rick Berman, his "hands-on involvement in The Next Generation diminished greatly after the first season".

Did the post-Roddenberry TNG differ from his initial vision? Did Berman violate any of the rules that Roddenberry had laid out for the series? Were there any general themes that became less emphasized after his death? Did Berman make hire or fire decisions contrary to Gene’s known preferences?


Well researched answers with definite changes are preferred, especially if backed up by contemporary sources. Possible changes can either be on or off camera, and specific ("Dr. Crusher came back") or broad ("more personal drama/fewer stories with an 'exploring the unknown' theme").

For example:

  • Berman didn't like the music direction, and started using subdued orchestral tracks, rather than sticking with Ron Jones.

  • Gene was convinced by his staff to replace Gates McFadden but Berman opposed the decision. Did Gene’s reduced involvement or death influence the decision to bring her back?

  • People had trouble working with Gene, and there was a high writer turnover. From Wikipedia:

    Tracy Tormé described the first few seasons of The Next Generation under Roddenberry as an "insane asylum" ...Franchise writers Fontana and David Gerrold... left the series under acrimonious circumstances...

    Did Gene’s reduced involvement persuade anyone to stay?

Answers should only address his influence on TNG. The influence that he did or didn't have on DS9 and Voyager is addressed by this question.

Gene Roddenberry died in 1991 halfway through Star Trek: The Next Generation. He'd been sick for a while and, according to Rick Berman, his "hands-on involvement in The Next Generation diminished greatly after the first season".

Did the post-Roddenberry TNG differ from his initial vision? Did Berman violate any of the rules that Roddenberry had laid out for the series? Were there any general themes that became less emphasized after his death? Did Berman make hire or fire decisions contrary to Gene’s known preferences?


Well researched answers with definite changes are preferred, especially if backed up by contemporary sources. Possible changes can either be on or off camera, and specific ("Dr. Crusher came back") or broad ("more personal drama/fewer stories with an 'exploring the unknown' theme").

For example:

  • Berman didn't like the music direction, and started using subdued orchestral tracks, rather than sticking with Ron Jones.

  • Gene was convinced by his staff to replace Gates McFadden but Berman opposed the decision. Did Gene’s reduced involvement or death influence the decision to bring her back?

  • People had trouble working with Gene, and there was a high writer turnover. From Wikipedia:

    Tracy Tormé described the first few seasons of The Next Generation under Roddenberry as an "insane asylum" ...Franchise writers Fontana and David Gerrold... left the series under acrimonious circumstances...

    Did Gene’s reduced involvement persuade anyone to stay?

Answers should only address his influence on TNG. The influence that he did or didn't have on DS9 and Voyager is addressed by this question.

deleted 2 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Mithical
  • 39k
  • 17
  • 178
  • 229

Gene Roddenberry died in 1991 halfway through Star Trek: The Next Generation. He'd been sick for a while and, according to Rick Berman, his "hands-on involvement in The Next Generation diminished greatly after the first season".

Did the post-Roddenberry TNG differ from his initial vision? Did Berman violate any of the rules that Roddenberry had laid out for the series? Were there any general themes that became less emphasized after his death? Did Berman make hire or fire decisions contrary to Gene’s known preferences?


Well researched answers with definite changes are preferred, especially if backed up by contemporary sources. Possible changes can either be on or off camera, and specific ("Dr. Crusher came back") or broad ("more personal drama  / fewerfewer stories with an 'exploring the unknown' theme").

For example:

  • Berman didn't like the music direction, and started using subdued orchestral tracks, rather than sticking with Ron Jones.

  • Gene was convinced by his staff to replace Gates McFadden but Berman opposed the decision. Did Gene’s reduced involvement or death influence the decision to bring her back?

  • People had trouble working with Gene, and there was a high writer turnover. From Wikipedia:

    Tracy Tormé described the first few seasons of The Next Generation under Roddenberry as an "insane asylum" ...Franchise writers Fontana and David Gerrold... left the series under acrimonious circumstances...

    Did Gene’s reduced involvement persuade anyone to stay?

Answers should only address his influence on TNG. The influence that he did or didn't have on DS9 and Voyager is addressed by this question.

Gene Roddenberry died in 1991 halfway through Star Trek: The Next Generation. He'd been sick for a while and, according to Rick Berman, his "hands-on involvement in The Next Generation diminished greatly after the first season".

Did the post-Roddenberry TNG differ from his initial vision? Did Berman violate any of the rules that Roddenberry had laid out for the series? Were there any general themes that became less emphasized after his death? Did Berman make hire or fire decisions contrary to Gene’s known preferences?


Well researched answers with definite changes are preferred, especially if backed up by contemporary sources. Possible changes can either be on or off camera, and specific ("Dr. Crusher came back") or broad ("more personal drama  / fewer stories with an 'exploring the unknown' theme").

For example:

  • Berman didn't like the music direction, and started using subdued orchestral tracks, rather than sticking with Ron Jones.

  • Gene was convinced by his staff to replace Gates McFadden but Berman opposed the decision. Did Gene’s reduced involvement or death influence the decision to bring her back?

  • People had trouble working with Gene, and there was a high writer turnover. From Wikipedia:

    Tracy Tormé described the first few seasons of The Next Generation under Roddenberry as an "insane asylum" ...Franchise writers Fontana and David Gerrold... left the series under acrimonious circumstances...

    Did Gene’s reduced involvement persuade anyone to stay?

Answers should only address his influence on TNG. The influence that he did or didn't have on DS9 and Voyager is addressed by this question.

Gene Roddenberry died in 1991 halfway through Star Trek: The Next Generation. He'd been sick for a while and, according to Rick Berman, his "hands-on involvement in The Next Generation diminished greatly after the first season".

Did the post-Roddenberry TNG differ from his initial vision? Did Berman violate any of the rules that Roddenberry had laid out for the series? Were there any general themes that became less emphasized after his death? Did Berman make hire or fire decisions contrary to Gene’s known preferences?


Well researched answers with definite changes are preferred, especially if backed up by contemporary sources. Possible changes can either be on or off camera, and specific ("Dr. Crusher came back") or broad ("more personal drama/fewer stories with an 'exploring the unknown' theme").

For example:

  • Berman didn't like the music direction, and started using subdued orchestral tracks, rather than sticking with Ron Jones.

  • Gene was convinced by his staff to replace Gates McFadden but Berman opposed the decision. Did Gene’s reduced involvement or death influence the decision to bring her back?

  • People had trouble working with Gene, and there was a high writer turnover. From Wikipedia:

    Tracy Tormé described the first few seasons of The Next Generation under Roddenberry as an "insane asylum" ...Franchise writers Fontana and David Gerrold... left the series under acrimonious circumstances...

    Did Gene’s reduced involvement persuade anyone to stay?

Answers should only address his influence on TNG. The influence that he did or didn't have on DS9 and Voyager is addressed by this question.

Post Reopened by user13267, Mazura, Möoz, Null
Trying to avoid the answer being a simple, 'yes'.
Link
Mazura
  • 6k
  • 28
  • 51

Did How did Gene Roddenberry’s death affect the development of Star Trek: The Next Generation?

Attempted to overhaul question so that it isn’t asking us to imagine an alternate history and state it as fact.
Source Link
Paul D. Waite
  • 32.4k
  • 20
  • 133
  • 198
Loading
Post Closed as "Needs more focus" by Lightness Races in Orbit, KutuluMike, Himarm, Radhil, Jason Baker
Add suggestion from comment. Changed example.
Source Link
Z. Cochrane
  • 6.5k
  • 4
  • 37
  • 61
Loading
Add suggestion from comment.
Source Link
Z. Cochrane
  • 6.5k
  • 4
  • 37
  • 61
Loading
Make this less speculative.
Source Link
Z. Cochrane
  • 6.5k
  • 4
  • 37
  • 61
Loading
Source Link
Z. Cochrane
  • 6.5k
  • 4
  • 37
  • 61
Loading