Skip to main content
Left closed in review as "Original close reason(s) were not resolved" by NotArch, Oblivious Sage
Revived missing citations & removed OP endorsement of any particular answer.
Source Link
ProphetZarquon
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 12

By RAW, attacks can target a creature, object, or location:

By RAW(emphasis mine)

Making an Attack (PHB p193)
Whether you're striking with a melee weapon, firing a weapon at range, or making an attack roll as part of a spell, an attack has a simple structure.

  1. Choose a target. Pick a target within your attack's range: a creature, an object, or a location.

Attacks targeting an object (including doors & walls) are well established, attacks can targetincluding the AC & HP of objects of varying material.

(Some magical structures are given damage ratings; one spell even gives its effect a creature, objectstandard stone AC & HP, orwhile measuring wall area destroyed locationby the inch. Even though)

Attacking objects (whether discrete objects or structures) seems pretty well covered, with multiple examples, & even things like Adamantine weapons that deal critical damage to objects on a hit.

Attacking creatures is of course the rules statemain focus of the game, so there's no shortage of examples for that.

However, even though the rules state that a location can be targeted by an attack... I haven't found any attack that would be relevant to a location!

The only Spell Attacks that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & based on their wording, none of those attack rolls appear to accomplish anything when targeting a location can(unless a creature in a location could be targetedhit by ana spell attack targeting that location)...

Note that specific thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an Attack roll; throwing a Bomb does not entail an Attack roll.

For whatever reason, throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I haven'tmade of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their suggested answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature. (I guess whether that'a a good Answer is for voters to decide.)

I've been looking through magical items & weapons & features, & found any attackabsolutely nothing else that would be relevanttarget a location with an attack.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that.

When an effect applies to creatures or objects within an area, that effect's description defines the terms of its location & extent, and specifies what creatures or objects within the area can be affected and how. There are so many area effects, but none of them involve an attack roll that would target a location!

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location? IE: What is an example of a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll, & what are its use cases?

By RAW, attacks can target a creature, object, or location. Even though the rules state that a location can be targeted by an attack, I haven't found any attack that would be relevant to a location

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

By RAW, attacks can target a creature, object, or location:

(emphasis mine)

Making an Attack (PHB p193)
Whether you're striking with a melee weapon, firing a weapon at range, or making an attack roll as part of a spell, an attack has a simple structure.

  1. Choose a target. Pick a target within your attack's range: a creature, an object, or a location.

Attacks targeting an object (including doors & walls) are well established, including the AC & HP of objects of varying material.

(Some magical structures are given damage ratings; one spell even gives its effect a standard stone AC & HP, while measuring wall area destroyed by the inch.)

Attacking objects (whether discrete objects or structures) seems pretty well covered, with multiple examples, & even things like Adamantine weapons that deal critical damage to objects on a hit.

Attacking creatures is of course the main focus of the game, so there's no shortage of examples for that.

However, even though the rules state that a location can be targeted by an attack... I haven't found any attack that would be relevant to a location!

The only Spell Attacks that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & based on their wording, none of those attack rolls appear to accomplish anything when targeting a location (unless a creature in a location could be hit by a spell attack targeting that location)...

Note that specific thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an Attack roll; throwing a Bomb does not entail an Attack roll.

For whatever reason, throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I made of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their suggested answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature. (I guess whether that'a a good Answer is for voters to decide.)

I've been looking through magical items & weapons & features, & found absolutely nothing else that would target a location with an attack.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that.

When an effect applies to creatures or objects within an area, that effect's description defines the terms of its location & extent, and specifies what creatures or objects within the area can be affected and how. There are so many area effects, but none of them involve an attack roll that would target a location!

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

IE: What is an example of a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll, & what are its use cases?

Cleaned up question to just be the question and removed metacommentary that should be in an answer.
Source Link
NotArch
  • 125.8k
  • 40
  • 515
  • 808

TLDR: I think @Jason_c_o's Answer pretty much sews this up. At least one use case for Attack rolls being allowed to target a location, is to allow a possibility of hitting an unseen creature by targeting its location.
No sign of any other uses for targeting a location: None of the items that target a location, use an Attack roll to do so. Spell Attacks targeting a location, will only do anything if attack rolls targeting a location can hit creatures or objects in that location. At present, it appears that the only efficacious use case for targeting a location with an attack roll, is an attack against an unseen creature/object.

In D&D 5e, a location is effectively a space in a place or a point on a map, as opposed to constituting a discrete object (a location can be a point in midair, for instance). They are defined relative to the plane of travel which that location occupies, such as a particular position on the deck of a ship, or in a cave somewhere on an oblate spheroid. In specific cases, a location might be defined relative to an object or creature, but mechanically speaking, each location is a space, not necessarily what's in the space.

By RAW, attacks can target a creature, object, or location:

(emphasis mine)

Making an Attack (PHB p193)
Whether you're striking with a melee weapon, firing a weapon at range, or making an attack roll as part of a spell, an attack has a simple structure.

  1. Choose a target. Pick a target within your attack's range: a creature, an object, or a location.

Attacks targeting an object (including doors & walls) are well establishedBy RAW, including the AC & HP of objects of varying material.

(Some magical structures are given damage ratings; one spell even gives its effectattacks can target a standard stone AC & HP, while measuring wall area destroyed by the inch.)

Attacking objects (whether discrete objects or structures) seems pretty well coveredcreature, with multiple examplesobject, & even things like Adamantine weapons that deal critical damage to objects on a hit.

Attackingor creatureslocation is of course the main focus of the game, so there's no shortage of examples for that.

However, even though the rules state that a location can be targeted by an attack... I haven't found any attack that would be relevant to a location!

The only Spell Attacks Even though the rules state that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & based on their wording, none of those attack rolls appear to accomplish anything when targeting a location (unless a creature in a location couldcan be hittargeted by a spellan attack targeting that location)...

Note that specific thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an Attack roll; throwing a Bomb does not entail an Attack roll.

For whatever reason, throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I made of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature.

I've been looking through magical items & weapons & features, &haven't found absolutely nothing else that would target a location with an attack.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that.

When an effect applies to creatures or objects within an area, that effect's description defines the terms of its location & extent, and specifies what creatures or objects within the area can be affected and how. There are so many area effects, but none of them involve anany attack roll that would targetbe relevant to a location!

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

(There is one use case; see @Jason_c_o's Answer below.)

IE: What is an example of a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll, & what are its use cases?What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

TLDR: I think @Jason_c_o's Answer pretty much sews this up. At least one use case for Attack rolls being allowed to target a location, is to allow a possibility of hitting an unseen creature by targeting its location.
No sign of any other uses for targeting a location: None of the items that target a location, use an Attack roll to do so. Spell Attacks targeting a location, will only do anything if attack rolls targeting a location can hit creatures or objects in that location. At present, it appears that the only efficacious use case for targeting a location with an attack roll, is an attack against an unseen creature/object.

In D&D 5e, a location is effectively a space in a place or a point on a map, as opposed to constituting a discrete object (a location can be a point in midair, for instance). They are defined relative to the plane of travel which that location occupies, such as a particular position on the deck of a ship, or in a cave somewhere on an oblate spheroid. In specific cases, a location might be defined relative to an object or creature, but mechanically speaking, each location is a space, not necessarily what's in the space.

By RAW, attacks can target a creature, object, or location:

(emphasis mine)

Making an Attack (PHB p193)
Whether you're striking with a melee weapon, firing a weapon at range, or making an attack roll as part of a spell, an attack has a simple structure.

  1. Choose a target. Pick a target within your attack's range: a creature, an object, or a location.

Attacks targeting an object (including doors & walls) are well established, including the AC & HP of objects of varying material.

(Some magical structures are given damage ratings; one spell even gives its effect a standard stone AC & HP, while measuring wall area destroyed by the inch.)

Attacking objects (whether discrete objects or structures) seems pretty well covered, with multiple examples, & even things like Adamantine weapons that deal critical damage to objects on a hit.

Attacking creatures is of course the main focus of the game, so there's no shortage of examples for that.

However, even though the rules state that a location can be targeted by an attack... I haven't found any attack that would be relevant to a location!

The only Spell Attacks that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & based on their wording, none of those attack rolls appear to accomplish anything when targeting a location (unless a creature in a location could be hit by a spell attack targeting that location)...

Note that specific thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an Attack roll; throwing a Bomb does not entail an Attack roll.

For whatever reason, throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I made of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature.

I've been looking through magical items & weapons & features, & found absolutely nothing else that would target a location with an attack.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that.

When an effect applies to creatures or objects within an area, that effect's description defines the terms of its location & extent, and specifies what creatures or objects within the area can be affected and how. There are so many area effects, but none of them involve an attack roll that would target a location!

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

(There is one use case; see @Jason_c_o's Answer below.)

IE: What is an example of a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll, & what are its use cases?

In D&D 5e, a location is effectively a space in a place or a point on a map, as opposed to constituting a discrete object (a location can be a point in midair, for instance). They are defined relative to the plane of travel which that location occupies, such as a particular position on the deck of a ship, or in a cave somewhere on an oblate spheroid. In specific cases, a location might be defined relative to an object or creature, but mechanically speaking, each location is a space, not necessarily what's in the space.

By RAW, attacks can target a creature, object, or location. Even though the rules state that a location can be targeted by an attack, I haven't found any attack that would be relevant to a location

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

Edited for clarity: One question only! "What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?" ANSWERED by Jason_c_o
Added to review
Source Link
ProphetZarquon
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 12

Why can attacks What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

TLDR: I think @Jason_c_o's Answer pretty much sews this up. At least one use case for Attack rolls being allowed to target a location, is to allow a possibility of hitting an unseen creature by targeting its location.
No sign of any other uses for targeting a location: None of the items that target a location, use an Attack roll to do so. Spell Attacks targeting a location, will only do anything if attack rolls targeting a location can hit creatures or objects in that location. At present, it appears that the only efficacious use case for targeting a location with an attack roll, is an attack against an unseen creature/object.

In D&D 5e, a location is effectively a space in a place or a point on a map, as opposed to constituting a discrete object (a location can be a point in midair, for instance). They are defined relative to the plane of travel which that location occupies, such as a particular position on the deck of a ship, or in a cave somewhere on an oblate spheroid. In specific cases, a location might be defined relative to an object or creature, but mechanically speaking, each location is a space, not necessarily what's in the space.

The only Spell Attacks that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & based on their wording, none of those attack rolls appear to accomplish anything when targeting a location (unless a creature in a location could be hit by a spell attack targeting that location)... do they?

Note that specific thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an attackAttack roll; throwing a Bomb does not entail an Attack roll.

ThrowingFor whatever reason, throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I made of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that?.

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

Is there any canonical example of any attack that targets a location?(There is one use case; see @Jason_c_o's Answer below.)


 

IE: What is an example of a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll, & what are its use cases?

Why can attacks target a location?

In D&D 5e, a location is effectively a space in a place or a point on a map, as opposed to constituting a discrete object (a location can be a point in midair, for instance). They are defined relative to the plane of travel which that location occupies, such as a particular position on the deck of a ship, or in a cave somewhere on an oblate spheroid. In specific cases, a location might be defined relative to an object or creature, but mechanically speaking, each location is a space, not necessarily what's in the space.

The only Spell Attacks that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & none of those attack rolls accomplish anything when targeting a location... do they?

Note that thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an attack roll.

Throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I made of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that?

Is there any canonical example of any attack that targets a location?


 

What is a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll?

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

TLDR: I think @Jason_c_o's Answer pretty much sews this up. At least one use case for Attack rolls being allowed to target a location, is to allow a possibility of hitting an unseen creature by targeting its location.
No sign of any other uses for targeting a location: None of the items that target a location, use an Attack roll to do so. Spell Attacks targeting a location, will only do anything if attack rolls targeting a location can hit creatures or objects in that location. At present, it appears that the only efficacious use case for targeting a location with an attack roll, is an attack against an unseen creature/object.

In D&D 5e, a location is effectively a space in a place or a point on a map, as opposed to constituting a discrete object (a location can be a point in midair, for instance). They are defined relative to the plane of travel which that location occupies, such as a particular position on the deck of a ship, or in a cave somewhere on an oblate spheroid. In specific cases, a location might be defined relative to an object or creature, but mechanically speaking, each location is a space, not necessarily what's in the space.

The only Spell Attacks that aren't specifically limited to targeting creatures & objects, are Magic Stone, Flame Blade, Acid Arrow, Scorching Ray, & Mordenkainen's Sword, & based on their wording, none of those attack rolls appear to accomplish anything when targeting a location (unless a creature in a location could be hit by a spell attack targeting that location)...

Note that specific thrown items such as a Bomb, Dynamite stick, & other items with effects that target a location, use an Action, not an Attack roll; throwing a Bomb does not entail an Attack roll.

For whatever reason, throwing a Net at a location to hit a creature in that location, is disputed (see the mess I made of this question), although as @Jason_c_o has noted in their answer below, the 5e OpenSRD mentions targeting a location in order to hit an unseen creature.

The only thing I could think of was using an item ≥10ft across to attack multiple creatures in an area, but it seems there's just no RAW to support that.

What are some use cases for attack rolls that target a location?

(There is one use case; see @Jason_c_o's Answer below.)

IE: What is an example of a situation wherein there is mechanical reason to target a location with an attack roll, & what are its use cases?

Post Closed as "Needs more focus" by MivaScott, Thomas Markov, Jason_c_o, Mołot, NotArch
Don’t obsolete answers by moving the goal posts after the fact in the question.
Source Link
Thomas Markov
  • 152.1k
  • 30
  • 856
  • 1.2k
Loading
Noting that @Jason_c_o has now at least partially answered this question, but their answer currently contains factual errors.
Source Link
ProphetZarquon
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 12
Loading
edited title
Link
Eddymage
  • 31.6k
  • 3
  • 82
  • 166
Loading
Citing PHB rule stating that attacks can target a location, per clarification request. (Thanks!)
Source Link
ProphetZarquon
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 12
Loading
Source Link
ProphetZarquon
  • 1.1k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 12
Loading