Skip to main content
added 2 characters in body
Source Link

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

deleted 2 characters in body
Source Link

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

added 23 characters in body
Source Link

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

/

No way to correctly handle non-answers in First answers

Right now, users are forced to flag the post and then pick "Looks OK".

Could the "First answers" feedback options include something along the lines of "This is not an answer" (such as link-only, "Me too," or "Thanks" answers)? It would allow us to give quick feedback on posts that should be flagged NAA without waiting for the Low Quality Answers queue to get to it—and potentially allow for the answer to be fixed without being deleted, in the case of link-only answers (which I often see fixed in response to comments). Ideally, selecting this would also flag the post as NAA, or at least send it to the low-quality queue.

Feedback dialog for new user answer with "Answer is unclear" and "Answer needs supporting information" options

None of the current options really apply to non-answers. I can flag the answer, but I'm unable to complete the review without saying that it "Looks OK" (when really it has serious issues).

Clarify the issue a bit more
Source Link
Ryan M
  • 28k
  • 9
  • 77
  • 129
Loading
added 133 characters in body
Source Link
Ryan M
  • 28k
  • 9
  • 77
  • 129
Loading
Source Link
Ryan M
  • 28k
  • 9
  • 77
  • 129
Loading