Return to Answer

feature-request

The image with canned reasons for the first questions queue and the one showing a canned reason on an answer both show canned comments that are specific to code. I'm not sure if you're planning on only rolling these out to Stack Overflow or other code-specific sites for now, your post doesn't mention that, so I'm assuming you're planning on rolling out these networkwide (I can't check, but I see the new queues on e.g. IPS, there's nothing in them so I don't know if that means those same canned comments are there).
In that case: Don't show the code-specific feedback reasons in first answers/questions queues on all sites please. There are plenty of sites around where these would be nonsensical to have.
Kristina just confirmed in the comment section that the code specific reasons shouldn't show up on non-code related sites.

So that only leaves me with the bonus point request: Please give each site the option to add their own reasons to this dialog, while we might not need more or less code, but there are other details that we might want to bring attention to. (On request, I've also turned that into a separate question here)

feature-requeststatus-completed

The image with canned reasons for the first questions queue and the one showing a canned reason on an answer both show canned comments that are specific to code. I'm not sure if you're planning on only rolling these out to Stack Overflow or other code-specific sites for now, your post doesn't mention that, so I'm assuming you're planning on rolling out these networkwide (I can't check, but I see the new queues on e.g. IPS, there's nothing in them so I don't know if that means those same canned comments are there).
In that case: Don't show the code-specific feedback reasons in first answers/questions queues on all sites please. There are plenty of sites around where these would be nonsensical to have.
Kristina just confirmed in the comment section that the code specific reasons shouldn't show up on non-code related sites.

So that only leaves me with the bonus point request: Please give each site the option to add their own reasons to this dialog, while we might not need more or less code, but there are other details that we might want to bring attention to. (On request, I've also turned that into a separate question here)

feature-request

The image with canned reasons for the first questions queue and the one showing a canned reason on an answer both show canned comments that are specific to code. I'm not sure if you're planning on only rolling these out to Stack Overflow or other code-specific sites for now, your post doesn't mention that, so I'm assuming you're planning on rolling out these networkwide (I can't check, but I see the new queues on e.g. IPS, there's nothing in them so I don't know if that means those same canned comments are there).
In that case: Don't show the code-specific feedback reasons in first answers/questions queues on all sites please. There are plenty of sites around where these would be nonsensical to have.
Kristina just confirmed in the comment section that the code specific reasons shouldn't show up on non-code related sites.

So that only leaves me with the bonus point request: Please give each site the option to add their own reasons to this dialog, while we might not need more or less code, but there are other details that we might want to bring attention to.

feature-request

The image with canned reasons for the first questions queue and the one showing a canned reason on an answer both show canned comments that are specific to code. I'm not sure if you're planning on only rolling these out to Stack Overflow or other code-specific sites for now, your post doesn't mention that, so I'm assuming you're planning on rolling out these networkwide (I can't check, but I see the new queues on e.g. IPS, there's nothing in them so I don't know if that means those same canned comments are there).
In that case: Don't show the code-specific feedback reasons in first answers/questions queues on all sites please. There are plenty of sites around where these would be nonsensical to have.
Kristina just confirmed in the comment section that the code specific reasons shouldn't show up on non-code related sites.

So that only leaves me with the bonus point request: Please give each site the option to add their own reasons to this dialog, while we might not need more or less code, but there are other details that we might want to bring attention to. (On request, I've also turned that into a separate question here)

feature-request

The image with canned reasons for the first questions queue and the one showing a canned reason on an answer both show canned comments that are specific to code. I'm not sure if you're planning on only rolling these out to Stack Overflow or other code-specific sites for now, your post doesn't mention that, so I'm assuming you're planning on rolling out these networkwide (I can't check, but I see the new queues on e.g. IPS, there's nothing in them so I don't know if that means those same canned comments are there). In that case: Don't show the code-specific feedback reasons in first answers/questions queues on all sites please. There are plenty of sites around where these would be nonsensical to have.

For bonus-points, give each site the option to add their own reasons to this dialog...

feature-request

The image with canned reasons for the first questions queue and the one showing a canned reason on an answer both show canned comments that are specific to code. I'm not sure if you're planning on only rolling these out to Stack Overflow or other code-specific sites for now, your post doesn't mention that, so I'm assuming you're planning on rolling out these networkwide (I can't check, but I see the new queues on e.g. IPS, there's nothing in them so I don't know if that means those same canned comments are there).
In that case: Don't show the code-specific feedback reasons in first answers/questions queues on all sites please. There are plenty of sites around where these would be nonsensical to have.
Kristina just confirmed in the comment section that the code specific reasons shouldn't show up on non-code related sites.

So that only leaves me with the bonus point request: Please give each site the option to add their own reasons to this dialog, while we might not need more or less code, but there are other details that we might want to bring attention to.