I don't agree with a banner appearing every time one of your edits is rejected, but I could get behind one of the following alternatives.

1. Update Profile » Activity » Suggestions to show which edits were accepted and which were rejected without forcing the user to manually click on each one. I prefer this solution because it is unobtrusive and makes the Suggestions tab more useful, in my opinion.

2. Show a new message in the user's inbox for each rejected edit. I don't really like this solution because it is a bit intrusive, but it's definitely better than a banner.

In general, I agree with Jeff that positive feedback is better than negative feedback. That being said, any feedback at all is better than none.

I don't agree with a banner appearing every time one of your edits is rejected, but I could get behind one of the following alternatives.

1. Update Profile » Activity » Suggestions to show which edits were accepted and which were rejected without forcing the user to manually click on each one. I prefer this solution because it is unobtrusive and makes the Suggestions tab more useful, in my opinion.

   

2. Show a new message in the user's inbox for each rejected edit. I don't really like this solution because it is a bit intrusive, but it's definitely better than a banner.

In general, I agree with Jeff that positive feedback is better than negative feedback. That being said, any feedback at all is better than none.

I don't agree with a banner appearing every time one of your edits is rejected, but I could get behind one of the following alternatives.

1. Update Profile » Activity » Suggestions to show which edits were accepted and which were rejected without forcing the user to manually click on each one. I prefer this solution because it is unobtrusive and makes the Suggestions tab more useful, in my opinion.
2. Show a new message in the user's inbox for each rejected edit. I don't really like this solution because it is a bit intrusive, but it's definitely better than a banner.

In general, I agree with Jeff that positive feedback is better than negative feedback. That being said, any feedback at all is better than none.

I don't agree with a banner appearing every time one of your edits is rejected, but I could get behind one of the following alternatives.

1. Update Profile » Activity » Suggestions to show which edits were accepted and which were rejected without forcing the user to manually click on each one. I prefer this solution because it is unobtrusive and makes the Suggestions tab more useful, in my opinion.

2. Show a new message in the user's inbox for each rejected edit. I don't really like this solution because it is a bit intrusive, but it's definitely better than a banner.

In general, I agree with Jeff that positive feedback is better than negative feedback. That being said, any feedback at all is better than none.