Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with aventurin's answer chosen by CommunityBot
Tweeted twitter.com/StackChemistry/status/740563355426017280
Notice added Draw attention by Dissenter
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by Dissenter
added 84 characters in body
Source Link
Dissenter
  • 19k
  • 51
  • 181
  • 343

We are using TAA to form metal sulfides. What is the effect of sodium acetate on sulfide ion concentration?

The procedures instruct me to add sodium acetate and to heat the test tube with the metal ion if no precipitate forms after the initial addition of TAA.

From the equilibrium given below, it seems that addition of sodium acetate would actually reduce sulfide ion concentration by driving the equilibrium to the left! That would be antithetical to sulfide salt formation.

However, this cannot be the case; the instructions clearly tell me to add sodium acetate if no precipitate has formed; the instructions are clearly suggesting that sodium acetate helps a precipitate form.

Thinking about it some more, could it be that the addition of sodium acetate basicifies the system by forming hydroxide ion, thereby driving the equilibirum to the right? This seems to make sense, because the addition of sodium acetate is to be accompanied by heating, and wouldn't heating drive the formation of acetic acid and hydroxide ion from acetate ion? And acetic acid is rather volatile, so it'll just leave the solution and not interfere by making the solution too acidic. Am I correct in my thinking? How can I predict the effect of heat on an acid-base reaction? I know heating ammonium chloride causes the ammonium ion to lose its proton. Will heating acetate ion in the presence of water cause it to gain a proton? enter image description here

We are using TAA to form metal sulfides. What is the effect of sodium acetate on sulfide ion concentration?

The procedures instruct me to add sodium acetate and to heat the test tube with the metal ion if no precipitate forms after the initial addition of TAA.

From the equilibrium given below, it seems that addition of sodium acetate would actually reduce sulfide ion concentration by driving the equilibrium to the left! That would be antithetical to sulfide salt formation.

However, this cannot be the case; the instructions clearly tell me to add sodium acetate if no precipitate has formed; the instructions are clearly suggesting that sodium acetate helps a precipitate form.

Thinking about it some more, could it be that the addition of sodium acetate basicifies the system by forming hydroxide ion, thereby driving the equilibirum to the right? This seems to make sense, because the addition of sodium acetate is to be accompanied by heating, and wouldn't heating drive the formation of acetic acid and hydroxide ion from acetate ion? And acetic acid is rather volatile, so it'll just leave the solution and not interfere by making the solution too acidic. Am I correct in my thinking? How can I predict the effect of heat on an acid-base reaction? I know heating ammonium chloride causes the ammonium ion to lose its proton. Will heating acetate ion in the presence of water cause it to gain a proton?

We are using TAA to form metal sulfides. What is the effect of sodium acetate on sulfide ion concentration?

The procedures instruct me to add sodium acetate and to heat the test tube with the metal ion if no precipitate forms after the initial addition of TAA.

From the equilibrium given below, it seems that addition of sodium acetate would actually reduce sulfide ion concentration by driving the equilibrium to the left! That would be antithetical to sulfide salt formation.

However, this cannot be the case; the instructions clearly tell me to add sodium acetate if no precipitate has formed; the instructions are clearly suggesting that sodium acetate helps a precipitate form.

Thinking about it some more, could it be that the addition of sodium acetate basicifies the system by forming hydroxide ion, thereby driving the equilibirum to the right? This seems to make sense, because the addition of sodium acetate is to be accompanied by heating, and wouldn't heating drive the formation of acetic acid and hydroxide ion from acetate ion? And acetic acid is rather volatile, so it'll just leave the solution and not interfere by making the solution too acidic. Am I correct in my thinking? How can I predict the effect of heat on an acid-base reaction? I know heating ammonium chloride causes the ammonium ion to lose its proton. Will heating acetate ion in the presence of water cause it to gain a proton? enter image description here

Source Link
Dissenter
  • 19k
  • 51
  • 181
  • 343

Role of acetate ion in formation of hydrogen sulfide ion from thioacetamide

We are using TAA to form metal sulfides. What is the effect of sodium acetate on sulfide ion concentration?

The procedures instruct me to add sodium acetate and to heat the test tube with the metal ion if no precipitate forms after the initial addition of TAA.

From the equilibrium given below, it seems that addition of sodium acetate would actually reduce sulfide ion concentration by driving the equilibrium to the left! That would be antithetical to sulfide salt formation.

However, this cannot be the case; the instructions clearly tell me to add sodium acetate if no precipitate has formed; the instructions are clearly suggesting that sodium acetate helps a precipitate form.

Thinking about it some more, could it be that the addition of sodium acetate basicifies the system by forming hydroxide ion, thereby driving the equilibirum to the right? This seems to make sense, because the addition of sodium acetate is to be accompanied by heating, and wouldn't heating drive the formation of acetic acid and hydroxide ion from acetate ion? And acetic acid is rather volatile, so it'll just leave the solution and not interfere by making the solution too acidic. Am I correct in my thinking? How can I predict the effect of heat on an acid-base reaction? I know heating ammonium chloride causes the ammonium ion to lose its proton. Will heating acetate ion in the presence of water cause it to gain a proton?