I find that answer delightful. Upon seeing the question I figured it out right away using trig identities. Using the known dimension of the space of solutions for that purpose is ... the reason this site exists.
Every one of the functions $\sin(x), \ldots, \sin(x+n)$ solves the ODE $y'' + y = 0$. But the solution space of a linear (homogeneous) second order ODE is only two-dimensional, which tells you that these sine functions must be linearly dependent if you take at least $3$ of them. That is, there ex...
Curators
Much of the effort towards improving question quality goes towards sanctioning bad questions-- closure, review, etc. There is a lot of room for greater recognition of good questions.
On our site, we have experimented with ways to do this in the form of curators. Curators seek out excepti...
Let $H$ and $N$ be two groups, $\phi$ and $\psi$ be two homomorphisms $H \to \operatorname{Aut}(N)$, and $G_1 = N \rtimes_\phi H$ and $G_2 = N \rtimes_\psi H$ corresponding semidirect products.
What are conditions on $\phi$ and $\psi$ for $G_1 \cong G_2$?
If for some automorphisms $h \in \operato...
@AlexanderGruber @JyrkiLahtonen Thanks for this. My very preliminary idea was to imitate Puzzling SE's style of nominating Best Puzzles of this Quarter in a meta thread where they have rules alleviating unwanted outcomes like excessive self-promotion. Maybe this is something that can be developed into a workable proposal?
@AlexanderGruber One thing I need to do is express my huge gratitude to you and everyone else who's been involved in this. I didn't expect this to be such a collaborative effort -- I don't know if it's the culture here on MSE or if I just got lucky that all the right people got involved, but it's extremely gratifying. And I learned some things about how to manipulate curves that I never learned in school at any level. So, to sum up, thank you! Stay safe!
We remove PSQs and generally unexceptional questions from HNQ, which unfortunately is most of them. For technical reasons, HNQ won't be selected if they have tex in the title, which leaves a pretty small pool for the algorithm to pick from. I think that's why ours tend to be crappy.
Possibly @MartinSleziak. There was a time when the HNQs from Math.SE were not exactly interesting. I guess the situation improved after moderators were given the power to remove entries to HNQ. I simply haven't looked at them lately, so I don't know.
I would like to nominate math.stackexchange.com/questions/3036114/… which I found to be a very natural question and the examples given in the answer by Jeremy Rickard are very nice but non-trivial.
I put a bounty on it, although it doesn't look like many people saw it. I'm willing to put another bounty on it if someone's interested at taking a look.
Consider the following family of polynomials
$$P_n(X)=\sum_{i=0}^n(n+1-i)X^i,\,n\ge 1$$
Let’s write down the first few
$$
\begin{align}
&P_1(X)=X+2\\
&P_2(X)=X^2+2X+3\\
&P_3(X)=X^3+2X^2+3X+4\\
&P_4(X)=X^4+2X^3+3X^2+4X+5
\end{align}
$$
My claim is that this family is a family of irreducible polyno...
Pretty quiet here – so I'll just mention that I spent a bounty here and got several excellent answers in response. I will be difficult to decide to which answer to award the bounty!
@JyrkiLahtonen No that won't do, because you can shrink the cube while keeping the opposite corners on the surface. In fact, I thought you had understood Henning's version but mistyped your example, but I see that maybe you missed something. All 8 corners won't do as I stated in a comment:
Just thought I'd drop a message in here to note that I offered my first bounty recently, mostly because PearlDive put the idea up front in my mind. (It didn't generate any new activity, but I feel good for having worked to advocate for a well written question.)
Hex is a two player abstract strategy board game in which players attempt to connect opposite sides of a hexagonal board. Hex was invented by mathematician and poet Piet Hein in 1942 and independently by John Nash in 1948.
It is traditionally played on an 11×11 rhombus board, although 13×13 and 19×19 boards are also popular. Each player is assigned a pair of opposite sides of the board which they must try to connect by taking turns placing a stone of their color onto any empty space. Once placed, the stones are unable to be moved or removed. A player wins when they successfully connect their...
Yes, to be clear, what I meant is that it is OK to post discussion about questions that are already bountied. But it does have to be discussion, not just advertising (and this applies to unbountied questions as well).
Let $p$ be an odd prime, and let $n_1,\dots,n_{p-2}, m$ be even integers such that $n_1 < n_2 < \dots < n_{p-2}$ and
\begin{equation}
2m > \sum_{i=1}^{p-2} n_i^2.
\end{equation}
Consider the polynomial
\begin{equation}
g(x)=(x^2 + m)(x - n_1) \dots (x - n_{p-2}).
\end{equation}
From Rolle's Theor...
Let $P$ and $Q$ be monic polynomials with integer coefficients and degrees $n$ and $d$ respectively, where $d\mid n$. Suppose there are infinitely many pairs of positive integers $(a,b)$ for which $P(a)=Q(b)$.
I would like to determine if exists a polynomial $R$ with integer coefficients such t...