Fate of nitrogen in French human excreta: current waste and agronomic opportunities for the future
Authors:
Thomas Starck,
Tanguy Fardet,
Fabien Esculier
Abstract:
Nitrogen (N) is essential for plant growth and protein synthesis but global reactive N losses, mainly from food systems, induce strong environmental impacts.N losses after human excretion are often overlooked because, in Western societies, they partly occur as inert N2, following denitrification in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP), and losses in waters are often small compared to diffuse agricul…
▽ More
Nitrogen (N) is essential for plant growth and protein synthesis but global reactive N losses, mainly from food systems, induce strong environmental impacts.N losses after human excretion are often overlooked because, in Western societies, they partly occur as inert N2, following denitrification in wastewater treatment plants (WWTP), and losses in waters are often small compared to diffuse agricultural emissions.Yet N from human excretions could be used for crop fertilization, potentially with very high recycling rates via source separation.In this study we use unique operational data from the ~20,000 French WWTPs to produce a N mass-balance of excretions in the French sanitation system.Even though 75% of WWTPs' sludge is spread on crops, only 10% of the excreted N is recycled and 50% of N is lost to the atmosphere, mainly through WWTP nitrification-denitrification.The remaining 40% ends up in water or in diffuse losses in the ground, of which about half is lost outside of the WWTPs' discharge system, through sewers storm water and individual autonomous systems.While WWTPs removal efficiency increased in the 2000s, it has been followed by a decade of stagnation, reaching 70% at the national level.This national average hides regional discrepancies, from 60 to 85% in the 6 French water agencies basins.These differences closely correlate with the classification as ''N sensitive areas'' and is mainly due to large WWTPs which handle most of the N load.Recycling all N in excretions could supply 10% of domestic protein consumption in the current French food system, and up to 30% if it is prioritized towards crop production for human consumption.Redesigning the food system (decrease of nutrient losses, more plant-based diets) could further increase this contribution
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
Phosphorus recycling from human excreta in French agroecosystems and potential for food self-sufficiency
Authors:
Thomas Starck,
Tanguy Fardet,
Fabien Esculier
Abstract:
Phosphorus (P) is an essential constituent of life but large P losses from agroecosystems and sanitation systems are a major source of eutrophication in water bodies.These losses are doubly detrimental as P in human excretions can be used for crop fertilization.Through a unique dataset of 20,000 French WasteWater Treatment Plants (WWTPs) operational measurements over two decades and a P mass balan…
▽ More
Phosphorus (P) is an essential constituent of life but large P losses from agroecosystems and sanitation systems are a major source of eutrophication in water bodies.These losses are doubly detrimental as P in human excretions can be used for crop fertilization.Through a unique dataset of 20,000 French WasteWater Treatment Plants (WWTPs) operational measurements over two decades and a P mass balance, we assess the fate of human excretions and their agricultural potential.Despite 75% of French WWTPs sludge being spread on crops, only 50% of the excreted P makes it back to agroecosystems. This is among the highest rate in Western countries where assessments have been made.Meanwhile, another 35% of the excreted P ends up in surface waters or the environment through WWTP discharge, individual autonomous systems diffuse losses, and sewers leaks.The remaining 15% is incinerated or sent to landfills.Moreover, while WWTP removal efficiency increased in the 2000s, reaching an 80% national average, it has been followed by a decade of stagnation in every French basin.The final removal efficiency for each basin, from 65% to 85%, closely matches whether the area was defined as P-sensitive in the European directive.Our results suggest that recycling all P in excretions could help supply 7 to 34% of French food supply without changing the current food system.Reshaping agricultural systems (shifting to more plant-based diets, decreasing P losses and food waste) would enable to go even further on the road to food sufficiency.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2024; v1 submitted 10 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
