-
Observation of quantum effects on radiation reaction in strong fields
Authors:
E. E. Los,
E. Gerstmayr,
C. Arran,
M. J. V. Streeter,
C. Colgan,
C. C. Cobo,
B. Kettle,
T. G. Blackburn,
N. Bourgeois,
L. Calvin,
J. Carderelli,
N. Cavanagh,
S. J. D. Dann A. Di Piazza,
R. Fitzgarrald,
A. Ilderton,
C. H. Keitel,
M. Marklund,
P. McKenna,
C. D. Murphy,
Z. Najmudin,
P. Parsons,
P. P. Rajeev,
D. R. Symes,
M. Tamburini,
A. G. R. Thomas
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Radiation reaction describes the effective force experienced by an accelerated charge due to radiation emission. Quantum effects dominate charge dynamics and radiation production[1][2] for charges accelerated by fields with strengths approaching the Schwinger field, $\mathbf{E_{sch}=}$\textbf{\SI[detect-weight]{1.3e18}{\volt\per\metre}[3]. Such fields exist in extreme astrophysical environments su…
▽ More
Radiation reaction describes the effective force experienced by an accelerated charge due to radiation emission. Quantum effects dominate charge dynamics and radiation production[1][2] for charges accelerated by fields with strengths approaching the Schwinger field, $\mathbf{E_{sch}=}$\textbf{\SI[detect-weight]{1.3e18}{\volt\per\metre}[3]. Such fields exist in extreme astrophysical environments such as pulsar magnetospheres[4], may be accessed by high-power laser systems[5-7], dense particle beams interacting with plasma[8], crystals[9], and at the interaction point of next generation particle colliders[10]. Classical radiation reaction theories do not limit the frequency of radiation emitted by accelerating charges and omit stochastic effects inherent in photon emission[11], thus demanding a quantum treatment. Two quantum radiation reaction models, the quantum-continuous[12] and quantum-stochastic[13] models, correct the former issue, while only the quantum-stochastic model incorporates stochasticity[12]. Such models are of fundamental importance, providing insight into the effect of the electron self-force on its dynamics in electromagnetic fields. The difficulty of accessing conditions where quantum effects dominate inhibited previous efforts to observe quantum radiation reaction in charged particle dynamics with high significance. We report the first direct, high significance $(>5σ)$ observation of strong-field radiation reaction on charged particles. Furthermore, we obtain strong evidence favouring the quantum radiation reaction models, which perform equivalently, over the classical model. Robust model comparison was facilitated by a novel Bayesian framework which inferred collision parameters. This framework has widespread utility for experiments where parameters governing lepton-laser collisions cannot be directly measured, including those using conventional accelerators.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
A Bayesian Framework to Investigate Radiation Reaction in Strong Fields
Authors:
E. E. Los,
C. Arran,
E. Gerstmayr,
M. J. V. Streeter,
Z. Najmudin,
C. P. Ridgers,
G. Sarri,
S. P. D Mangles
Abstract:
Recent experiments aiming to measure phenomena predicted by strong field quantum electrodynamics have done so by colliding relativistic electron beams and high-power lasers. In such experiments, measurements of the collision parameters are not always feasible, however, precise knowledge of these parameters is required for accurate tests of strong-field quantum electrodynamics. Here, we present a n…
▽ More
Recent experiments aiming to measure phenomena predicted by strong field quantum electrodynamics have done so by colliding relativistic electron beams and high-power lasers. In such experiments, measurements of the collision parameters are not always feasible, however, precise knowledge of these parameters is required for accurate tests of strong-field quantum electrodynamics. Here, we present a novel Bayesian inference procedure which infers collision parameters that could not be measured on-shot. This procedure is applicable to all-optical non-linear Compton scattering experiments investigating radiation reaction. The framework allows multiple diagnostics to be combined self-consistently and facilitates the inclusion of prior or known information pertaining to the collision parameters. Using this Bayesian analysis, the relative validity of the classical, quantum-continuous and quantum-stochastic models of radiation reaction were compared for a series of test cases, which demonstrate the accuracy and model selection capability of the framework and and highlight its robustness in the event that the experimental values of fixed parameters differ from their values in the models.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Demonstration of tunability of HOFI waveguides via start-to-end simulations
Authors:
S. M. Mewes,
G. J. Boyle,
A. Ferran Pousa,
R. J. Shalloo,
J. Osterhoff,
C. Arran,
L. Corner,
R. Walczak,
S. M. Hooker,
M. Thévenet
Abstract:
In recent years, hydrodynamic optical-field-ionized (HOFI) channels have emerged as a promising technique to create laser waveguides suitable for guiding tightly-focused laser pulses in a plasma, as needed for laser-plasma accelerators. While experimental advances in HOFI channels continue to be made, the underlying mechanisms and the roles of the main parameters remain largely unexplored. In this…
▽ More
In recent years, hydrodynamic optical-field-ionized (HOFI) channels have emerged as a promising technique to create laser waveguides suitable for guiding tightly-focused laser pulses in a plasma, as needed for laser-plasma accelerators. While experimental advances in HOFI channels continue to be made, the underlying mechanisms and the roles of the main parameters remain largely unexplored. In this work, we propose a start-to-end simulation pipeline of the HOFI channel formation and the resulting guiding properties, and use it to explore the underlying physics and the tunability of HOFI channels. This approach is benchmarked against experimental measurements. HOFI channels are shown to feature excellent guiding properties over a wide range of parameters, making them a promising and tunable waveguide option for laser-plasma accelerators.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Proton Radiography in Background Magnetic Fields
Authors:
Christopher Arran,
Christopher P. Ridgers,
Nigel C. Woolsey
Abstract:
Proton radiography has proved increasingly successful as a diagnostic for electric and magnetic fields in high energy density physics experiments. Most experiments use target-normal-sheath-acceleration sources with a wide energy range in the proton beam, as the velocity spread can help differentiate between electric and magnetic fields and provide time histories in a single shot. However, in magne…
▽ More
Proton radiography has proved increasingly successful as a diagnostic for electric and magnetic fields in high energy density physics experiments. Most experiments use target-normal-sheath-acceleration sources with a wide energy range in the proton beam, as the velocity spread can help differentiate between electric and magnetic fields and provide time histories in a single shot. However, in magnetised plasma experiments with strong background fields, the broadband proton spectrum leads to velocity-spread-dependent displacement of the beam and significant blurring of the radiograph. We describe the origins of this blurring and show how it can be removed from the experimental measurement, and we outline the conditions under which such deconvolutions are successful. As an example, we apply this method to a magnetised plasma experiment that used a background magnetic field of 3 T. The strong displacement and energy spread of the proton beam reduced the spatial resolution from tens of microns to a few millimetres. The deconvolution procedure is applied showing the accurate recovery of radiographs with resolutions better than 100 microns, enabling the recovery of more accurate estimates of the path integrated magnetic field. This work extends accurate proton radiography to a class of experiments with significant background magnetic fields, particularly those experiments with an applied external magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Measurement of magnetic cavitation driven by heat flow in a plasma
Authors:
Christopher Arran,
Adam Dearling,
Philip Bradford,
George. S. Hicks,
Saleh Al-Atabi,
Luca Antonelli,
Oliver C. Ettlinger,
Matthew Khan,
Martin P. Read,
Kevin Glize,
Margaret Notley,
Christopher A. Walsh,
Robert J. Kingham,
Zulfikar Najmudin,
Christopher P. Ridgers,
Nigel C. Woolsey
Abstract:
We describe the direct measurement of the expulsion of a magnetic field from a plasma driven by heat flow. Using a laser to heat a column of gas within an applied magnetic field, we isolate Nernst advection and show how it changes the field over a nanosecond timescale. Reconstruction of the magnetic field map from proton radiographs demonstrates that the field is advected by heat flow in advance o…
▽ More
We describe the direct measurement of the expulsion of a magnetic field from a plasma driven by heat flow. Using a laser to heat a column of gas within an applied magnetic field, we isolate Nernst advection and show how it changes the field over a nanosecond timescale. Reconstruction of the magnetic field map from proton radiographs demonstrates that the field is advected by heat flow in advance of the plasma expansion. This changes the dynamics of high energy density plasmas, in which heat flows and fields are strongly coupled, and may disrupt magnetised inertial confinement fusion schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2023; v1 submitted 16 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
The inadequacy of a magnetohydrodynamic approach to the Biermann Battery
Authors:
C. P. Ridgers,
C. Arran,
J. J. Bissell,
R. J. Kingham
Abstract:
Magnetic fields can be generated in plasmas by the Biermann battery when the electric field produced by the electron pressure gradient has a curl. The commonly employed magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model of the Biermann battery breaks down when the electron distribution function is distorted away from Maxwellian. Using both MHD and kinetic simulations of a laser-plasma interaction relevant to inertia…
▽ More
Magnetic fields can be generated in plasmas by the Biermann battery when the electric field produced by the electron pressure gradient has a curl. The commonly employed magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model of the Biermann battery breaks down when the electron distribution function is distorted away from Maxwellian. Using both MHD and kinetic simulations of a laser-plasma interaction relevant to inertial confinement fusion we have shown that this distortion can reduce the Biermann-producing electric field by around 50\%. More importantly, the use of a flux limiter in an MHD treatment to deal with the effect of the non-Maxwellian electron distribution on electron thermal transport leads to a completely unphysical prediction of the Biermann-producing electric field and so results in erroneous predictions for the generated magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Meter-Scale, Conditioned Hydrodynamic Optical-Field-Ionized Plasma Channels
Authors:
A. Picksley,
A. Alejo,
R. J. Shalloo,
C. Arran,
A. von Boetticher,
L. Corner,
J. A. Holloway,
J. Jonnerby,
O. Jakobsson,
C. Thornton,
R. Walczak,
S. M. Hooker
Abstract:
We demonstrate through experiments and numerical simulations that low-density, low-loss, meter-scale plasma channels can be generated by employing a conditioning laser pulse to ionize the neutral gas collar surrounding a hydrodynamic optical-field-ionized (HOFI) plasma channel. We use particle-in-cell simulations to show that the leading edge of the conditioning pulse ionizes the neutral gas colla…
▽ More
We demonstrate through experiments and numerical simulations that low-density, low-loss, meter-scale plasma channels can be generated by employing a conditioning laser pulse to ionize the neutral gas collar surrounding a hydrodynamic optical-field-ionized (HOFI) plasma channel. We use particle-in-cell simulations to show that the leading edge of the conditioning pulse ionizes the neutral gas collar to generate a deep, low-loss plasma channel which guides the bulk of the conditioning pulse itself as well as any subsequently injected pulses. In proof-of-principle experiments we generate conditioned HOFI (CHOFI) waveguides with axial electron densities of $n_\mathrm{e0} \approx 1 \times 10^{17} \; \mathrm{cm^{-3}}$, and a matched spot size of $26 \; \mathrm{μm}$. The power attenuation length of these CHOFI channels is $L_\mathrm{att} = (21 \pm 3) \; \mathrm{m}$, more than two orders of magnitude longer than achieved by HOFI channels. Hydrodynamic and particle-in-cell simulations demonstrate that meter-scale CHOFI waveguides with attenuation lengths exceeding 1 m could be generated with a total laser pulse energy of only $1.2$ J per meter of channel. The properties of CHOFI channels are ideally suited to many applications in high-intensity light-matter interactions, including multi-GeV plasma accelerator stages operating at high pulse repetition rates.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2020; v1 submitted 31 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Automation and control of laser wakefield accelerators using Bayesian optimisation
Authors:
R. J. Shalloo,
S. J. D. Dann,
J. -N. Gruse,
C. I. D. Underwood,
A. F. Antoine,
C. Arran,
M. Backhouse,
C. D. Baird,
M. D. Balcazar,
N. Bourgeois,
J. A. Cardarelli,
P. Hatfield,
J. Kang,
K. Krushelnick,
S. P. D. Mangles,
C. D. Murphy,
N. Lu,
J. Osterhoff,
K. Põder,
P. P. Rajeev,
C. P. Ridgers,
S. Rozario,
M. P. Selwood,
A. J. Shahani,
D. R. Symes
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Laser wakefield accelerators promise to revolutionise many areas of accelerator science. However, one of the greatest challenges to their widespread adoption is the difficulty in control and optimisation of the accelerator outputs due to coupling between input parameters and the dynamic evolution of the accelerating structure. Here, we use machine learning techniques to automate a 100 MeV-scale ac…
▽ More
Laser wakefield accelerators promise to revolutionise many areas of accelerator science. However, one of the greatest challenges to their widespread adoption is the difficulty in control and optimisation of the accelerator outputs due to coupling between input parameters and the dynamic evolution of the accelerating structure. Here, we use machine learning techniques to automate a 100 MeV-scale accelerator, which optimised its outputs by simultaneously varying up to 6 parameters including the spectral and spatial phase of the laser and the plasma density and length. Most notably, the model built by the algorithm enabled optimisation of the laser evolution that might otherwise have been missed in single-variable scans. Subtle tuning of the laser pulse shape caused an 80% increase in electron beam charge, despite the pulse length changing by just 1%.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2020; v1 submitted 28 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Overcoming the dephasing limit in multiple-pulse laser wakefield acceleration
Authors:
James D. Sadler,
Christopher Arran,
Hui Li,
Kirk A. Flippo
Abstract:
The electric field in laser-driven plasma wakefield acceleration is orders of magnitude higher than conventional radio-frequency cavities, but the energy gain is limited by dephasing between the ultra-relativistic electron bunch and the wakefield, which travels at the laser group velocity. We present a way to overcome this limit within a single plasma stage. The amplitude of the wakefield behind a…
▽ More
The electric field in laser-driven plasma wakefield acceleration is orders of magnitude higher than conventional radio-frequency cavities, but the energy gain is limited by dephasing between the ultra-relativistic electron bunch and the wakefield, which travels at the laser group velocity. We present a way to overcome this limit within a single plasma stage. The amplitude of the wakefield behind a train of laser pulses can be controlled in-flight by modulating the density profile. This creates a succession of resonant laser-plasma accelerator sections and non-resonant drift sections, within which the wakefield disappears and the electrons rephase. A two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulation with four 2.5TW laser pulses produces a 50MeV electron energy gain, four times that obtained from a uniform plasma. Although laser red-shift prevents operation in the blowout regime, the technique offers increased energy gain for accelerators limited to the linear regime by the available laser power. This is particularly relevant for laser-plasma x-ray sources capable of operating at high repetition rates, which are highly sought after.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Low-Density Hydrodynamic Optical-Field-Ionized Plasma Channels Generated With An Axicon Lens
Authors:
R. J. Shalloo,
C. Arran,
A. Picksley,
A. von Boetticher,
L. Corner,
J. Holloway,
G. Hine,
J. Jonnerby,
H. M. Milchberg,
C. Thornton,
R. Walczak,
S. M. Hooker
Abstract:
We demonstrate optical guiding of high-intensity laser pulses in long, low density hydrodynamic optical-field-ionized (HOFI) plasma channels. An axicon lens is used to generate HOFI plasma channels with on-axis electron densities as low as $n_e(0) = 1.5\times 10^{17}\, \mathrm{cm}^{-3}$ and matched spot sizes in the range $ 20 μ\mathrm{m} \lesssim W_M \lesssim 40 μ\mathrm{m}$. Control of these cha…
▽ More
We demonstrate optical guiding of high-intensity laser pulses in long, low density hydrodynamic optical-field-ionized (HOFI) plasma channels. An axicon lens is used to generate HOFI plasma channels with on-axis electron densities as low as $n_e(0) = 1.5\times 10^{17}\, \mathrm{cm}^{-3}$ and matched spot sizes in the range $ 20 μ\mathrm{m} \lesssim W_M \lesssim 40 μ\mathrm{m}$. Control of these channel parameters via adjustment of the initial cell pressure and the delay after the arrival of the channel-forming pulse is demonstrated. For laser pulses with a peak axial intensity of $4 \times 10^{17}\, \mathrm{W\,cm}^{-2}$, highly reproducible, high-quality guiding over more than 14 Rayleigh ranges is achieved at a pulse repetition rate of 5 Hz, limited by the available channel-forming laser and vacuum pumping system. Plasma channels of this type would seem to be well suited to multi-GeV laser wakefield accelerators operating in the quasi-linear regime.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2019; v1 submitted 14 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Optimal Parameters for Radiation Reaction Experiments
Authors:
Christopher Arran,
Jason M. Cole,
Elias Gerstmayr,
Tom G. Blackburn,
Stuart P. D. Mangles,
Christopher P. Ridgers
Abstract:
As new laser facilities are developed with intensities on the scale of 10^22 - 10^24 W cm^-2 , it becomes ever more important to understand the effect of strong field quantum electrodynamics processes, such as quantum radiation reaction, which will play a dominant role in laser-plasma interactions at these intensities. Recent all-optical experiments, where GeV electrons from a laser wakefield acce…
▽ More
As new laser facilities are developed with intensities on the scale of 10^22 - 10^24 W cm^-2 , it becomes ever more important to understand the effect of strong field quantum electrodynamics processes, such as quantum radiation reaction, which will play a dominant role in laser-plasma interactions at these intensities. Recent all-optical experiments, where GeV electrons from a laser wakefield accelerator encountered a counter-propagating laser pulse with a_0 > 10, have produced evidence of radiation reaction, but have not conclusively identified quantum effects nor their most suitable theoretical description. Here we show the number of collisions and the conditions required to accomplish this, based on a simulation campaign of radiation reaction experiments under realistic conditions. We conclude that while the critical energy of the photon spectrum distinguishes classical and quantum-corrected models, a better means of distinguishing the stochastic and deterministic quantum models is the change in the electron energy spread. This is robust against shot-to-shot fluctuations and the necessary laser intensity and electron beam energies are already available. For example, we show that so long as the electron energy spread is below 25%, collisions at a_0 = 10 with electron energies of 500 MeV could differentiate between different quantum models in under 30 shots, even with shot to shot variations at the 50% level.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Reconstructing nonlinear plasma wakefields using a generalized temporally encoded spectral shifting analysis
Authors:
C. Arran,
N. H. Matlis,
R. Walczak,
S. M. Hooker
Abstract:
We generalize the temporally encoded spectral shifting (TESS) analysis for measuring plasma wakefields using spectral interferometry to dissimilar probe pulses of arbitrary spectral profile and to measuring nonlinear wakefields. We demonstrate that the Gaussian approximation used up until now results in a substantial miscalculation of the wakefield amplitude, by a factor of up to two. A method to…
▽ More
We generalize the temporally encoded spectral shifting (TESS) analysis for measuring plasma wakefields using spectral interferometry to dissimilar probe pulses of arbitrary spectral profile and to measuring nonlinear wakefields. We demonstrate that the Gaussian approximation used up until now results in a substantial miscalculation of the wakefield amplitude, by a factor of up to two. A method to accurately measure higher amplitude quasilinear and nonlinear wakefields is suggested, using an extension to the TESS procedure, and we place some limits on its accuracy in these regimes. These extensions and improvements to the analysis demonstrate its potential for rapid and accurate on-shot diagnosis of plasma wakefields, even at low plasma densities.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Hydrodynamic, Optically-Field-Ionized (HOFI) Plasma Channels
Authors:
Robert Shalloo,
Christopher Arran,
Laura Corner,
James Holloway,
Jakob Jonnerby,
Roman Walczak,
Howard Milchberg,
Simon Hooker
Abstract:
We present experiments and numerical simulations which demonstrate that fully-ionized, low-density plasma channels could be formed by hydrodynamic expansion of plasma columns produced by optical field ionization (OFI). Simulations of the hydrodynamic expansion of plasma columns formed in hydrogen by an axicon lens show the generation of \unit[200]{mm} long plasma channels with axial densities of o…
▽ More
We present experiments and numerical simulations which demonstrate that fully-ionized, low-density plasma channels could be formed by hydrodynamic expansion of plasma columns produced by optical field ionization (OFI). Simulations of the hydrodynamic expansion of plasma columns formed in hydrogen by an axicon lens show the generation of \unit[200]{mm} long plasma channels with axial densities of order $n_e(0) = 1 \times 10^{17} cm^{-3}$ and lowest-order modes of spot size $W_M \approx 40 μm$. These simulations show that the laser energy required to generate the channels is modest: of order 1 mJ per centimetre of channel. The simulations are confirmed by experiments with a spherical lens which show the formation of short plasma channels with $1.5 \times 10^{17}cm^{-3} \lesssim n_e(0) \lesssim 1 \times 10^{18} cm^{-3}$ and $61 μm \gtrsim W_M \gtrsim 33 μm$. Low-density plasma channels of this type would appear to be well-suited as multi-GeV laser-plasma accelerator stages capable of long-term operation at high pulse repetition rates.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2019; v1 submitted 2 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Excitation and Control of Plasma Wakefields by Multiple Laser Pulses
Authors:
James Cowley,
Christopher Thornton,
Christopher Arran,
Robert J. Shalloo,
Laura Corner,
Gavin Cheung,
Christopher D. Gregory,
Stuart P. D. Mangles,
Nicholas H. Matlis,
Daniel R. Symes,
Roman Walczak,
Simon M. Hooker
Abstract:
We demonstrate experimentally the resonant excitation of plasma waves by trains of laser pulses. We also take an important first step to achieving an energy recovery plasma accelerator by showing that unused wakefield energy can be removed by an out-of-resonance trailing laser pulse. The measured laser wakefields are found to be in excellent agreement with analytical and numerical models of wakefi…
▽ More
We demonstrate experimentally the resonant excitation of plasma waves by trains of laser pulses. We also take an important first step to achieving an energy recovery plasma accelerator by showing that unused wakefield energy can be removed by an out-of-resonance trailing laser pulse. The measured laser wakefields are found to be in excellent agreement with analytical and numerical models of wakefield excitation in the linear regime. Our results indicate a promising direction for achieving highly controlled, GeV-scale laser-plasma accelerators operating at multi-kilohertz repetition rates. This article was published in Physical Review Letters 119, 044802 on 27 July 2017. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.044802 Copyright 2017 American Physical Society.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Screened Coulomb potential in a flowing magnetized plasma
Authors:
Jan-Philip Joost,
Patrick Ludwig,
Hanno Kählert,
Christopher Arran,
Michael Bonitz
Abstract:
The electrostatic potential of a moving dust grain in a complex plasma with magnetized ions is computed using linear response theory, thereby extending our previous work for unmagnetized plasmas [P. Ludwig et al., New J. Phys. 14, 053016 (2012)]. In addition to the magnetic field, our approach accounts for a finite ion temperature as well as ion-neutral collisions. Our recently introduced code \te…
▽ More
The electrostatic potential of a moving dust grain in a complex plasma with magnetized ions is computed using linear response theory, thereby extending our previous work for unmagnetized plasmas [P. Ludwig et al., New J. Phys. 14, 053016 (2012)]. In addition to the magnetic field, our approach accounts for a finite ion temperature as well as ion-neutral collisions. Our recently introduced code \texttt{Kielstream} is used for an efficient calculation of the dust potential. Increasing the magnetization of the ions, we find that the shape of the potential crucially depends on the Mach number $M$. In the regime of subsonic ion flow ($M<1$), a strong magnetization gives rise to a potential distribution that is qualitatively different from the unmagnetized limit, while for $M>1$ the magnetic field effectively suppresses the plasma wakefield.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.