Showing 1–29 of 29 results for author: Thorngren, D P

Surviving in the Hot Neptune Desert: The Discovery of the Ultra-Hot Neptune TOI-3261b

Authors: Emma Nabbie, Chelsea X. Huang, Jennifer A. Burt, David J. Armstrong, Eric E. Mamajek, Vardan Adibekyan, Sérgio G. Sousa, Eric D. Lopez, Daniel P. Thorngren, Jorge Fernández, Gongjie Li, James S. Jenkins, Jose I. Vines, João Gomes da Silva, Robert A. Wittenmyer, Daniel Bayliss, César Briceño, Karen A. Collins, Xavier Dumusque, Keith D. Horne, Marcelo F. Keniger, Nicholas Law, Jorge Lillo-Box, Shang-Fei Liu, Andrew W. Mann , et al. (23 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The recent discoveries of Neptune-sized ultra-short period planets (USPs) challenge existing planet formation theories. It is unclear whether these residents of the Hot Neptune Desert have similar origins to smaller, rocky USPs, or if this discrete population is evidence of a different formation pathway altogether. We report the discovery of TOI-3261b, an ultra-hot Neptune with an orbital period… ▽ More The recent discoveries of Neptune-sized ultra-short period planets (USPs) challenge existing planet formation theories. It is unclear whether these residents of the Hot Neptune Desert have similar origins to smaller, rocky USPs, or if this discrete population is evidence of a different formation pathway altogether. We report the discovery of TOI-3261b, an ultra-hot Neptune with an orbital period $P$ = 0.88 days. The host star is a $V = 13.2$ magnitude, slightly super-solar metallicity ([Fe/H] $\simeq$ 0.15), inactive K1.5 main sequence star at $d = 300$ pc. Using data from the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite and the Las Cumbres Observatory Global Telescope, we find that TOI-3261b has a radius of $3.82_{-0.35}^{+0.42}$ $R_{\oplus}$. Moreover, radial velocities from ESPRESSO and HARPS reveal a mass of $30.3_{-2.4}^{+2.2}$ $M_{\oplus}$, more than twice the median mass of Neptune-sized planets on longer orbits. We investigate multiple mechanisms of mass loss that can reproduce the current-day properties of TOI-3261b, simulating the evolution of the planet via tidal stripping and photoevaporation. Thermal evolution models suggest that TOI-3261b should retain an envelope potentially enriched with volatiles constituting $\sim$5% of its total mass. This is the second highest envelope mass fraction among ultra-hot Neptunes discovered to date, making TOI-3261b an ideal candidate for atmospheric follow-up observations. △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: 20 pages, 11 figures, accepted to AJ

A warm Neptune's methane reveals core mass and vigorous atmospheric mixing

Authors: David K. Sing, Zafar Rustamkulov, Daniel P. Thorngren, Joanna K. Barstow, Pascal Tremblin, Catarina Alves de Oliveira, Tracy L. Beck, Stephan M. Birkmann, Ryan C. Challener, Nicolas Crouzet, Néstor Espinoza, Pierre Ferruit, Giovanna Giardino, Amélie Gressier, Elspeth K. H. Lee, Nikole K. Lewis, Roberto Maiolino, Elena Manjavacas, Bernard J. Rauscher, Marco Sirianni, Jeff A. Valenti

Abstract: Observations of transiting gas giant exoplanets have revealed a pervasive depletion of methane, which has only recently been identified atmospherically. The depletion is thought to be maintained by disequilibrium processes such as photochemistry or mixing from a hotter interior. However, the interiors are largely unconstrained along with the vertical mixing strength and only upper limits on the CH… ▽ More Observations of transiting gas giant exoplanets have revealed a pervasive depletion of methane, which has only recently been identified atmospherically. The depletion is thought to be maintained by disequilibrium processes such as photochemistry or mixing from a hotter interior. However, the interiors are largely unconstrained along with the vertical mixing strength and only upper limits on the CH$_4$ depletion have been available. The warm Neptune WASP-107 b stands out among exoplanets with an unusually low density, reported low core mass, and temperatures amenable to CH$_4$ though previous observations have yet to find the molecule. Here we present a JWST NIRSpec transmission spectrum of WASP-107 b which shows features from both SO$_2$ and CH$_4$ along with H$_2$O, CO$_2$, and CO. We detect methane with 4.2$σ$ significance at an abundance of 1.0$\pm$0.5 ppm, which is depleted by 3 orders of magnitude relative to equilibrium expectations. Our results are highly constraining for the atmosphere and interior, which indicate the envelope has a super-solar metallicity of 43$\pm$8$\times$ solar, a hot interior with an intrinsic temperature of T$_{\rm int}$=460$\pm$40 K, and vigorous vertical mixing which depletes CH4 with a diffusion coefficient of Kzz = 10$^{11.6\pm0.1}$ cm$^2$/s. Photochemistry has a negligible effect on the CH$_4$ abundance, but is needed to account for the SO$_2$. We infer a core mass of 11.5$_{-3.6}^{+3.0}$ M$_{\odot}$, which is much higher than previous upper limits, releasing a tension with core-accretion models. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Published in Nature at this URL, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07395-z . This is the authors version of the manuscript, 20 pages including Methods. Data from Figs. 1, 2, and 3 are available at this URL, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10891400

Giant Outer Transiting Exoplanet Mass (GOT `EM) Survey. V. Two Giant Planets in Kepler-511 but Only One Ran Away

Authors: Yayaati Chachan, Paul A. Dalba, Daniel P. Thorngren, Stephen R. Kane, Eve J. Lee, Edward W. Schwieterman, Howard Isaacson, Andrew W. Howard, Matthew J. Payne

Abstract: Systems hosting multiple giant planets are important laboratories for understanding planetary formation and migration processes. We present a nearly decade-long Doppler spectroscopy campaign from the Keck-I telescope to characterize the two transiting giant planets orbiting Kepler-511 on orbits of 27 days and 297 days. The radial velocity measurements yield precise masses for both planets, which w… ▽ More Systems hosting multiple giant planets are important laboratories for understanding planetary formation and migration processes. We present a nearly decade-long Doppler spectroscopy campaign from the Keck-I telescope to characterize the two transiting giant planets orbiting Kepler-511 on orbits of 27 days and 297 days. The radial velocity measurements yield precise masses for both planets, which we use to infer their bulk heavy element content. Both planets contain approximately 30 Earth masses of heavy elements, but their bulk metallicities (i.e., the ratio between metal mass and total mass) are drastically different ($0.86 \pm 0.04$ and $0.22 \pm 0.04$ respectively). Envelope mass loss cannot account for this difference due to the relatively large orbital distance and mass of the inner planet. We conclude that the outer planet underwent runaway gas accretion while the inner planet did not. This bifurcation in accretion histories is likely a result of the accretion of gas with very different metallicities by the two planets or the late formation of the inner planet from a merger of sub-Neptunes. Kepler-511 uniquely demonstrates how giant planet formation can produce strikingly different outcomes even for planets in the same system. △ Less

Submitted 17 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: submitted to AAS journals, comments welcome

The Hot Jupiter Radius Anomaly and Stellar Connections

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren

Abstract: The extremely close proximity of hot Jupiters to their parent stars has dramatically affected both their atmospheres and interiors, inflating them to up to twice the radius of Jupiter. The physical mechanism responsible for this inflation remains unknown, though many proposals have been put forward. I will review the known hot Jupiter population, the proposed inflation mechanisms, and the evidence… ▽ More The extremely close proximity of hot Jupiters to their parent stars has dramatically affected both their atmospheres and interiors, inflating them to up to twice the radius of Jupiter. The physical mechanism responsible for this inflation remains unknown, though many proposals have been put forward. I will review the known hot Jupiter population, the proposed inflation mechanisms, and the evidence for and against them collected thus far. In doing so, I will cover the ways that hot Jupiter interiors may be simulated computationally in detail, and present some useful formulas for estimating their radii, heating, intrinsic temperature, and tentative magnetic field strength. I will also cover the related issues of hot Jupiter intrinsic temperatures and radiative-convective boundaries, the potential connection with planetary magnetic fields, and the effects of stellar tides on the planet. Finally, I conclude with the suggestion that more than one mechanism may be operating in concert with each other and propose various avenues for future progress in understanding these objects. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2024; v1 submitted 8 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: To be published in: Handbook of Exoplanets, 2nd Edition, Hans Deeg and Juan Antonio Belmonte (Eds. in Chief), Springer International Publishing AG, part of Springer Nature. This revision implements minor fixes to resolve missing words and an incorrect citation

Helium in the Extended Atmosphere of the Warm Super-Puff TOI-1420b

Authors: Shreyas Vissapragada, Michael Greklek-McKeon, Dion Linssen, Morgan MacLeod, Daniel P. Thorngren, Peter Gao, Heather A. Knutson, David W. Latham, Mercedes López-Morales, Antonija Oklopčić, Jorge Pérez González, Morgan Saidel, Abigail Tumborang, Stephanie Yoshida

Abstract: Super-puffs are planets with exceptionally low densities ($ρ\lesssim 0.1$~g~cm$^{-3}$) and core masses ($M_c \lesssim 5 M_\oplus$). Many lower-mass ($M_p\lesssim10M_\oplus$) super-puffs are expected to be unstable to catastrophic mass loss via photoevaporation and/or boil-off, whereas the larger gravitational potentials of higher-mass ($M_p\gtrsim10M_\oplus$) super-puffs should make them more stab… ▽ More Super-puffs are planets with exceptionally low densities ($ρ\lesssim 0.1$~g~cm$^{-3}$) and core masses ($M_c \lesssim 5 M_\oplus$). Many lower-mass ($M_p\lesssim10M_\oplus$) super-puffs are expected to be unstable to catastrophic mass loss via photoevaporation and/or boil-off, whereas the larger gravitational potentials of higher-mass ($M_p\gtrsim10M_\oplus$) super-puffs should make them more stable to these processes. We test this expectation by studying atmospheric loss in the warm, higher-mass super-puff TOI-1420b ($M = 25.1M_\oplus$, $R = 11.9R_\oplus$, $ρ= 0.08$~g~cm$^{-3}$, $T_\mathrm{eq} = 960$~K). We observed one full transit and one partial transit of this planet using the metastable helium filter on Palomar/WIRC and found that the helium transits were $0.671\pm0.079\%$ (8.5$σ$) deeper than the TESS transits, indicating an outflowing atmosphere. We modeled the excess helium absorption using a self-consistent 1D hydrodynamics code to constrain the thermal structure of the outflow given different assumptions for the stellar XUV spectrum. These calculations then informed a 3D simulation which provided a good match to the observations with a modest planetary mass-loss rate of $10^{10.82}$~g~s$^{-1}$ ($M_p/\dot{M}\approx70$~Gyr). Super-puffs with $M_p\gtrsim10M_\oplus$, like TOI-1420b and WASP-107b, appear perfectly capable of retaining atmospheres over long timescales; therefore, these planets may have formed with the unusually large envelope mass fractions they appear to possess today. Alternatively, tidal circularization could have plausibly heated and inflated these planets, which would bring their envelope mass fractions into better agreement with expectations from core-nucleated accretion. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 18 pages, 8 figures, accepted to AJ

Giant Outer Transiting Exoplanet Mass (GOT 'EM) Survey. IV. Long-term Doppler Spectroscopy for 11 Stars Thought to Host Cool Giant Exoplanets

Authors: Paul A. Dalba, Stephen R. Kane, Howard Isaacson, Benjamin Fulton, Andrew W. Howard, Edward W. Schwieterman, Daniel P. Thorngren, Jonathan Fortney, Noah Vowell, Corey Beard, Sarah Blunt, Casey L. Brinkman, Ashley Chontos, Fei Dai, Steven Giacalone, Michelle L. Hill, Molly Kosiarek, Jack Lubin, Andrew W. Mayo, Teo Mocnik, Joseph M. Akana Murphy, Erik A. Petigura, Malena Rice, Ryan A. Rubenzahl, Judah Van Zandt , et al. (7 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Discovering and characterizing exoplanets at the outer edge of the transit method's sensitivity has proven challenging owing to geometric biases and the practical difficulties associated with acquiring long observational baselines. Nonetheless, a sample of giant exoplanets on orbits longer than 100 days has been identified by transit hunting missions. We present long-term Doppler spectroscopy for… ▽ More Discovering and characterizing exoplanets at the outer edge of the transit method's sensitivity has proven challenging owing to geometric biases and the practical difficulties associated with acquiring long observational baselines. Nonetheless, a sample of giant exoplanets on orbits longer than 100 days has been identified by transit hunting missions. We present long-term Doppler spectroscopy for 11 such systems with observation baselines spanning a few years to a decade. We model these radial velocity observations jointly with transit photometry to provide initial characterizations of these objects and the systems in which they exist. Specifically, we make new precise mass measurements for four long-period giant exoplanets (Kepler-111 c, Kepler-553 c, Kepler-849 b, and PH-2 b), we place new upper limits on mass for four others (Kepler-421 b, KOI-1431.01, Kepler-1513 b, and Kepler-952 b), and we show that several "confirmed" planets are in fact not planetary at all. We present these findings to complement similar efforts focused on closer-in short-period giant planets, and with the hope of inspiring future dedicated studies of cool giant exoplanets. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 35 pages, 24 figures, 11 tables. Accepted for publication in ApJ Supplement

TESS Spots a Super-Puff: The Remarkably Low Density of TOI-1420b

Authors: Stephanie Yoshida, Shreyas Vissapragada, David W. Latham, Allyson Bieryla, Daniel P. Thorngren, Jason D. Eastman, Mercedes López-Morales, Khalid Barkaoui, Charles Beichmam, Perry Berlind, Lars A. Buchave, Michael L. Calkins, David R. Ciardi, Karen A. Collins, Rosario Cosentino, Ian J. M. Crossfield, Fei Dai, Victoria DiTomasso, Nicholas Dowling, Gilbert A. Esquerdo, Raquel Forés-Toribio, Adriano Ghedina, Maria V. Goliguzova, Eli Golub, Erica J. Gonzales , et al. (29 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present the discovery of TOI-1420b, an exceptionally low-density ($ρ= 0.08\pm0.02$ g cm$^{-3}$) transiting planet in a $P = 6.96$ day orbit around a late G dwarf star. Using transit observations from TESS, LCOGT, OPM, Whitin, Wendelstein, OAUV, Ca l'Ou, and KeplerCam along with radial velocity observations from HARPS-N and NEID, we find that the planet has a radius of $R_p$ = 11.9 $\pm$ 0.3… ▽ More We present the discovery of TOI-1420b, an exceptionally low-density ($ρ= 0.08\pm0.02$ g cm$^{-3}$) transiting planet in a $P = 6.96$ day orbit around a late G dwarf star. Using transit observations from TESS, LCOGT, OPM, Whitin, Wendelstein, OAUV, Ca l'Ou, and KeplerCam along with radial velocity observations from HARPS-N and NEID, we find that the planet has a radius of $R_p$ = 11.9 $\pm$ 0.3 $R_\Earth$ and a mass of $M_p$ = 25.1 $\pm$ 3.8 $M_\Earth$. TOI-1420b is the largest-known planet with a mass less than $50M_\Earth$, indicating that it contains a sizeable envelope of hydrogen and helium. We determine TOI-1420b's envelope mass fraction to be $f_{env} = 82^{+7}_{-6}\%$, suggesting that runaway gas accretion occurred when its core was at most $4-5\times$ the mass of the Earth. TOI-1420b is similar to the planet WASP-107b in mass, radius, density, and orbital period, so a comparison of these two systems may help reveal the origins of close-in low-density planets. With an atmospheric scale height of 1950 km, a transmission spectroscopy metric of 580, and a predicted Rossiter-McLaughlin amplitude of about $17$ m s$^{-1}$, TOI-1420b is an excellent target for future atmospheric and dynamical characterization. △ Less

Submitted 18 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

uGMRT observations of the hot-Saturn WASP 69b: Radio-Loud Exoplanet-Exomoon Survey II (RLEES II)

Authors: Mayank Narang, Apurva V. Oza, Kaustubh Hakim, P. Manoj, Himanshu Tyagi, Bihan Banerjee, Arun Surya, Prasanta K. Nayak, Ravinder K. Banyal, Daniel P. Thorngren

Abstract: Exomoons have so far eluded ongoing searches. Several studies have exploited transit and transit timing variations and high-resolution spectroscopy to identify potential exomoon candidates. One method of detecting and confirming these exomoons is to search for signals of planet-moon interactions. In this work, we present the first radio observations of the exomoon candidate system WASP 69b. Based… ▽ More Exomoons have so far eluded ongoing searches. Several studies have exploited transit and transit timing variations and high-resolution spectroscopy to identify potential exomoon candidates. One method of detecting and confirming these exomoons is to search for signals of planet-moon interactions. In this work, we present the first radio observations of the exomoon candidate system WASP 69b. Based on the detection of alkali metals in the transmission spectra of WASP-69b, it was deduced that the system might be hosting an exomoon. WASP 69b is also one of the exoplanet systems that will be observed as part of JWST cycle-1 GTO. This makes the system an excellent target to observe and follow up. We observed the system for 32 hrs at 150 MHz and 218 MHz using the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (uGMRT). Though we do not detect radio emission from the systems, we place strong $3σ$ upper limits of 3.3 mJy at 150 MHz and 0.9 mJy at 218 MHz. We then use these upper limits to estimate the maximum mass loss from the exomoon candidate. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: Accepted in MNRAS, 8 pages, 4 Figures

JWST/NIRCam discovery of the first Y+Y brown dwarf binary: WISE J033605.05$-$014350.4

Authors: Per Calissendorff, Matthew De Furio, Michael Meyer, Loïc Albert, Christian Aganze, Mohamad Ali-Dib, Daniella C. Bardalez Gagliuffi, Frederique Baron, Charles A. Beichman, Adam J. Burgasser, Michael C. Cushing, Jacqueline Kelly Faherty, Clémence Fontanive, Christopher R. Gelino, John E. Gizis, Alexandra Z. Greenbaum, J. Davy Kirkpatrick, Sandy K. Leggett, Frantz Martinache, David Mary, Mamadou N'Diaye, Benjamin J. S. Pope, Thomas L Roellig, Johannes Sahlmann, Anand Sivaramakrishnan , et al. (3 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We report the discovery of the first brown dwarf binary system with a Y dwarf primary, WISE J033605.05$-$014350.4, observed with NIRCam on JWST with the F150W and F480M filters. We employed an empirical point spread function binary model to identify the companion, located at a projected separation of 84 milliarcseconds, position angle of 295 degrees, and with contrast of 2.8 and 1.8 magnitudes in… ▽ More We report the discovery of the first brown dwarf binary system with a Y dwarf primary, WISE J033605.05$-$014350.4, observed with NIRCam on JWST with the F150W and F480M filters. We employed an empirical point spread function binary model to identify the companion, located at a projected separation of 84 milliarcseconds, position angle of 295 degrees, and with contrast of 2.8 and 1.8 magnitudes in F150W and F480M, respectively. At a distance of 10$\,$pc based on its Spitzer parallax, and assuming a random inclination distribution, the physical separation is approximately 1$\,$au. Evolutionary models predict for that an age of 1-5 Gyr, the companion mass is about 4-12.5 Jupiter masses around the 7.5-20 Jupiter mass primary, corresponding to a companion-to-host mass fraction of $q=0.61\pm0.05$. Under the assumption of a Keplerian orbit the period for this extreme binary is in the range of 5-9 years. The system joins a small but growing sample of ultracool dwarf binaries with effective temperatures of a few hundreds of Kelvin. Brown dwarf binaries lie at the nexus of importance for understanding the formation mechanisms of these elusive objects, as they allow us to investigate whether the companions formed as stars or as planets in a disk around the primary. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures, 1 table. Accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters

The effect of interior heat flux on the atmospheric circulation of hot and ultra-hot Jupiters

Authors: Thaddeus D. Komacek, Peter Gao, Daniel P. Thorngren, Erin M. May, Xianyu Tan

Abstract: Many hot and ultra-hot Jupiters have inflated radii, implying that their interiors retain significant entropy from formation. These hot interiors lead to an enhanced internal heat flux that impinges upon the atmosphere from below. In this work, we study the effect of this hot interior on the atmospheric circulation and thermal structure of hot and ultra-hot Jupiters. To do so, we incorporate the p… ▽ More Many hot and ultra-hot Jupiters have inflated radii, implying that their interiors retain significant entropy from formation. These hot interiors lead to an enhanced internal heat flux that impinges upon the atmosphere from below. In this work, we study the effect of this hot interior on the atmospheric circulation and thermal structure of hot and ultra-hot Jupiters. To do so, we incorporate the population-level predictions from evolutionary models of hot and ultra-hot Jupiters as input for a suite of General Circulation Models (GCMs) of their atmospheric circulation with varying semi-major axis and surface gravity. We conduct simulations with and without a hot interior, and find that there are significant local differences in temperature of up to hundreds of Kelvin and in wind speeds of hundreds of m s$^{-1}$ or more across the observable atmosphere. These differences persist throughout the parameter regime studied, and are dependent on surface gravity through the impact on photosphere pressure. These results imply that the internal evolution and atmospheric thermal structure and dynamics of hot and ultra-hot Jupiters are coupled. As a result, a joint approach including both evolutionary models and GCMs may be required to make robust predictions for the atmospheric circulation of hot and ultra-hot Jupiters. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: Accepted at ApJL, 17 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 941:L40 (12pp), 2022 December 20

Removal of Hot Saturns in Mass-Radius Plane by Runaway Mass Loss

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Eve J. Lee, Eric D. Lopez

Abstract: The hot Saturn population exhibits a boundary in mass-radius space, such that no planets are observed at a density less than $\sim$0.1 g cm$^{-3}$. Yet, planet interior structure models can readily construct such objects as the natural result of radius inflation. Here, we investigate the role XUV-driven mass-loss plays in sculpting the density boundary by constructing interior structure models tha… ▽ More The hot Saturn population exhibits a boundary in mass-radius space, such that no planets are observed at a density less than $\sim$0.1 g cm$^{-3}$. Yet, planet interior structure models can readily construct such objects as the natural result of radius inflation. Here, we investigate the role XUV-driven mass-loss plays in sculpting the density boundary by constructing interior structure models that include radius inflation, photoevaporative mass loss and a simple prescription of Roche lobe overflow. We demonstrate that planets puffier than $\sim$0.1 g cm$^{-3}$ experience a runaway mass loss caused by adiabatic radius expansion as the gas layer is stripped away, providing a good explanation of the observed edge in mass-radius space. The process is also visible in the radius-period and mass-period spaces, though smaller, high-bulk-metallicity planets can still survive at short periods, preserving a partial record of the population distribution at formation. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2023; v1 submitted 21 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 5 figures, Accepted to ApJ Letters. This revision includes the effect of orbital evolution resulting from Roche lobe overflow; the overall conclusions are the same

Radio-Loud Exoplanet-Exomoon Survey (RLEES): GMRT Search for Electron Cyclotron Maser Emission

Authors: Mayank Narang, Apurva V. Oza, Kaustubh Hakim, Manoj Puravankara, Ravinder K. Banyal, Daniel P. Thorngren

Abstract: We conducted the first dedicated search for signatures of exoplanet-exomoon interactions using the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) as part of the radio-loud exoplanet-exomoon survey (RLEES). Due to stellar tidal heating, irradiation, and subsequent atmospheric escape, candidate `exo-Io' systems are expected to emit up to $10^6$ times more plasma flux than the Jupiter-Io DC circuit. This can… ▽ More We conducted the first dedicated search for signatures of exoplanet-exomoon interactions using the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) as part of the radio-loud exoplanet-exomoon survey (RLEES). Due to stellar tidal heating, irradiation, and subsequent atmospheric escape, candidate `exo-Io' systems are expected to emit up to $10^6$ times more plasma flux than the Jupiter-Io DC circuit. This can induce detectable radio emission from the exoplanet-exomoon system. We analyze three `exo-Io' candidate stars: WASP-49, HAT-P 12, and HD 189733. We perform 12-hour phase-curve observations of WASP-49b at 400 MHz during primary $\&$ secondary transit, as well as first $\&$ third quadratures achieving a 3$σ$ upper-limit of 0.18 mJy/beam averaged over four days. HAT-P~12 was observed with GMRT at 150 and 325 MHz. We further analyzed the archival data of HD 189733 at 325 MHz. No emission was detected from the three systems. However, we place strong upper limits on radio flux density. Given that most exo-Io candidates orbit hot Saturns, we encourage more multiwavelength searches (in particular low frequencies) to span the lower range of exoplanet B-field strengths constrained here. △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 3 figures, accepted for publication in The Astronomical Journal

Creating the Radius Gap without Mass Loss

Authors: Eve J. Lee, Amalia Karalis, Daniel P. Thorngren

Abstract: The observed exoplanet population features a gap in the radius distribution that separates the smaller super-Earths ($\lesssim$1.7 Earth radii) from the larger sub-Neptunes ($\sim$1.7--4 Earth radii). While mass loss theories can explain many of the observed features of this radius valley, it is difficult to reconcile them with potentially rising population of terrestrials beyond orbital periods o… ▽ More The observed exoplanet population features a gap in the radius distribution that separates the smaller super-Earths ($\lesssim$1.7 Earth radii) from the larger sub-Neptunes ($\sim$1.7--4 Earth radii). While mass loss theories can explain many of the observed features of this radius valley, it is difficult to reconcile them with potentially rising population of terrestrials beyond orbital periods of $\sim$30 days. We investigate the ability of gas accretion during the gas-poor phase of disk evolution to reproduce both the location of the observed radius gap and the existence of long-period terrestrial planets. Updating the analytic scaling relations of gas accretion rate accounting for the shrinking of the bound radius by hydrodynamic effects and deriving a more realistic disk temperature profile, we find that the late-stage gas accretion alone is able to carve out the observed radius gap, with slopes $R_{\rm gap} \propto P^{-0.096}$ and $R_{\rm gap} \propto M_\star^{0.15}$ for top-heavy; and $R_{\rm gap} \propto P^{-0.089}$ and $R_{\rm gap} \propto M_\star^{0.22}$ for bottom-heavy core mass distributions, in good agreement with observations. The general morphology of the primordial radius gap is stable against a range of disk gas density and disk accretion rate with the latter affecting mostly the population of large planets ($\gtrsim$3--4$R_\oplus$). The peaks and valleys in the radius distribution were likely set in place primordially while post-formation mass loss further tunes the exoplanetary population. We provide potential observational tests that may be possible with TESS, PLATO and Roman Space Telescope. △ Less

Submitted 23 October, 2022; v1 submitted 24 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: ApJ in press

The TESS-Keck Survey. VIII. Confirmation of a Transiting Giant Planet on an Eccentric 261 day Orbit with the Automated Planet Finder Telescope

Authors: Paul A. Dalba, Stephen R. Kane, Diana Dragomir, Steven Villanueva Jr., Karen A. Collins, Thomas Lee Jacobs, Daryll M. Lacourse, Robert Gagliano, Martti H. Kristiansen, Mark Omohundro, Hans M. Schwengeler, Ivan A. Terentev, Andrew Vanderburg, Benjamin Fulton, Howard Isaacson, Judah Van Zandt, Andrew W. Howard, Daniel P. Thorngren, Steve B. Howell, Natalie M. Batalha, Ashley Chontos, Ian J. M. Crossfield, Courtney D. Dressing, Daniel Huber, Erik A. Petigura , et al. (50 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We report the discovery of TOI-2180 b, a 2.8 $M_{\rm J}$ giant planet orbiting a slightly evolved G5 host star. This planet transited only once in Cycle 2 of the primary Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission. Citizen scientists identified the 24 hr single-transit event shortly after the data were released, allowing a Doppler monitoring campaign with the Automated Planet Finder teles… ▽ More We report the discovery of TOI-2180 b, a 2.8 $M_{\rm J}$ giant planet orbiting a slightly evolved G5 host star. This planet transited only once in Cycle 2 of the primary Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission. Citizen scientists identified the 24 hr single-transit event shortly after the data were released, allowing a Doppler monitoring campaign with the Automated Planet Finder telescope at Lick Observatory to begin promptly. The radial velocity observations refined the orbital period of TOI-2180 b to be 260.8$\pm$0.6 days, revealed an orbital eccentricity of 0.368$\pm$0.007, and discovered long-term acceleration from a more distant massive companion. We conducted ground-based photometry from 14 sites spread around the globe in an attempt to detect another transit. Although we did not make a clear transit detection, the nondetections improved the precision of the orbital period. We predict that TESS will likely detect another transit of TOI-2180 b in Sector 48 of its extended mission. We use giant planet structure models to retrieve the bulk heavy-element content of TOI-2180 b. When considered alongside other giant planets with orbital periods over 100 days, we find tentative evidence that the correlation between planet mass and metal enrichment relative to stellar is dependent on orbital properties. Single-transit discoveries like TOI-2180 b highlight the exciting potential of the TESS mission to find planets with long orbital periods and low irradiation fluxes despite the selection biases associated with the transit method. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: Published in AJ

Giant Outer Transiting Exoplanet Mass (GOT 'EM) Survey. II. Discovery of a Failed Hot Jupiter on a 2.7 Year, Highly Eccentric Orbit

Authors: Paul A. Dalba, Stephen R. Kane, Zhexing Li, Mason G. Macdougall, Lee J. Rosenthal, Collin Cherubim, Howard Isaacson, Daniel P. Thorngren, Benjamin Fulton, Andrew W. Howard, Erik A. Petigura, Edward W. Schwieterman, Dan O. Peluso, Thomas M. Esposito, Franck Marchis, Matthew J. Payne

Abstract: Radial velocity (RV) surveys have discovered giant exoplanets on au-scale orbits with a broad distribution of eccentricities. Those with the most eccentric orbits are valuable laboratories for testing theories of high eccentricity migration. However, few such exoplanets transit their host stars thus removing the ability to apply constraints on formation from their bulk internal compositions. We re… ▽ More Radial velocity (RV) surveys have discovered giant exoplanets on au-scale orbits with a broad distribution of eccentricities. Those with the most eccentric orbits are valuable laboratories for testing theories of high eccentricity migration. However, few such exoplanets transit their host stars thus removing the ability to apply constraints on formation from their bulk internal compositions. We report the discovery of Kepler-1704 b, a transiting 4.15 $M_{\rm J}$ giant planet on a 988.88 day orbit with the extreme eccentricity of $0.921^{+0.010}_{-0.015}$. Our decade-long RV baseline from the Keck I telescope allows us to measure the orbit and bulk heavy element composition of Kepler-1704 b and place limits on the existence of undiscovered companions. Kepler-1704 b is a failed hot Jupiter that was likely excited to high eccentricity by scattering events that possibly began during its gas accretion phase. Its final periastron distance was too large to allow for tidal circularization, so now it orbits it host from distances spanning 0.16 - 3.9 au. The maximum difference in planetary equilibrium temperature resulting from this elongated orbit is over 700 K. A simulation of the thermal phase curve of Kepler-1704 b during periastron passage demonstrates that it is a remarkable target for atmospheric characterization from the James Webb Space Telescope, which could potentially also measure the planet's rotational period as the hot spot from periastron rotates in and out of view. Continued characterization of the Kepler-1704 system promises to refine theories explaining the formation of hot Jupiters and cool giant planets like those in the solar system. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2022; v1 submitted 14 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Comments: 27 pages, 16 figures, published in AJ (2021, 162, 154). This version includes updated planet ephemeris (Tables 2, 3, and 4) as described in erratum to be published in AJ

Slow Cooling and Fast Reinflation for Hot Jupiters

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Jonathan J. Fortney, Eric D. Lopez, Travis A. Berger, Daniel Huber

Abstract: The unexpectedly large radii of hot Jupiters are a longstanding mystery whose solution will provide important insights into their interior physics. Many potential solutions have been suggested, which make diverse predictions about the details of inflation. In particular, although any valid model must allow for maintaining large planetary radii, only some allow for radii to increase with time. This… ▽ More The unexpectedly large radii of hot Jupiters are a longstanding mystery whose solution will provide important insights into their interior physics. Many potential solutions have been suggested, which make diverse predictions about the details of inflation. In particular, although any valid model must allow for maintaining large planetary radii, only some allow for radii to increase with time. This reinflation process would potentially occur when the incident flux on the planet is increased. In this work, we examine the observed population of hot Jupiters to see if they grow as their parent stars brighten along the main sequence. We consider the relation between radius and other observables, including mass, incident flux, age, and fractional age (age over main sequence lifetime), and show that main sequence brightening is often sufficient to produce detectable reinflation. We further argue that these provide strong evidence for the relatively rapid reinflation of giant planets, and discuss the implications for proposed heating mechanisms. In our population analysis we also find evidence for a "delayed-cooling effect", wherein planets cool and contract far more slowly than expected. While not capable of explaining the observed radii alone, it may represent an important component of the effect. Finally, we identify a weak negative relationship between stellar metallicity and planet radius which is presumably the result of enhanced planetary bulk metallicity around metal-rich stars and has important implications for planet formation theory. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2021; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures, 1 table. Revision improves clarity, but scientific results are unchanged. Accepted to The Astrophysical Journal Letters

Beyond Equilibrium Temperature: How the Atmosphere/Interior Connection Affects the Onset of Methane, Ammonia, and Clouds in Warm Transiting Giant Planets

Authors: Jonathan J. Fortney, Channon Visscher, Mark S. Marley, Callie E. Hood, Michael R. Line, Daniel P. Thorngren, Richard S. Freedman, Roxana Lupu

Abstract: The atmospheric pressure-temperature profiles for transiting giant planets cross a range of chemical transitions. Here we show that the particular shape of these irradiated profiles for warm giant planets below 1300 K lead to striking differences in the behavior of non-equilibrium chemistry compared to brown dwarfs of similar temperatures. Our particular focus is H$_2$O, CO, CH$_4$, CO$_2$, and NH… ▽ More The atmospheric pressure-temperature profiles for transiting giant planets cross a range of chemical transitions. Here we show that the particular shape of these irradiated profiles for warm giant planets below 1300 K lead to striking differences in the behavior of non-equilibrium chemistry compared to brown dwarfs of similar temperatures. Our particular focus is H$_2$O, CO, CH$_4$, CO$_2$, and NH$_3$ in Jupiter- and Neptune-class planets. We show the cooling history of a planet, which depends most significantly on planetary mass and age, can have a dominant effect on abundances in the visible atmosphere, often swamping trends one might expect based on Teq alone. The onset of detectable CH$_4$ in spectra can be delayed to lower Teq for some planets compared to equilibrium, or pushed to higher Teq. The detectability of NH$_3$ is typically enhanced compared to equilibrium expectations, which is opposite to the brown dwarf case. We find that both CH$_4$ and NH$_3$ can become detectable at around the same Teq (at Teq values that vary with mass and metallicity) whereas these "onset" temperatures are widely spaced for brown dwarfs. We suggest observational strategies to search for atmospheric trends and stress that non-equilibrium chemistry and clouds can serve as probes of atmospheric physics. As examples of atmospheric complexity, we assess three Neptune-class planets GJ 436b, GJ 3470b, and WASP-107, all around Teq=700 K. Tidal heating due to eccentricity damping in all three planets heats the deep atmosphere by thousands of degrees, and may explain the absence of CH$_4$ in these cool atmospheres. Atmospheric abundances must be interpreted in the context of physical characteristics of the planet. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2020; v1 submitted 30 September, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: Accepted to AJ. No additional significant changes

Reflected Light Observations of the Galilean Satellites from Cassini: a testbed for cold terrestrial exoplanets

Authors: L. C. Mayorga, David Charbonneau, D. P. Thorngren

Abstract: For terrestrial exoplanets with thin atmospheres or no atmospheres, the surface contributes light to the reflected light signal of the planet. Measurement of the variety of disk-integrated brightnesses of bodies in the Solar System and the variation with illumination and wavelength is essential for both planning imaging observations of directly imaged exoplanets and interpreting the eventual datas… ▽ More For terrestrial exoplanets with thin atmospheres or no atmospheres, the surface contributes light to the reflected light signal of the planet. Measurement of the variety of disk-integrated brightnesses of bodies in the Solar System and the variation with illumination and wavelength is essential for both planning imaging observations of directly imaged exoplanets and interpreting the eventual datasets. Here we measure the change in brightness of the Galilean satellites as a function of planetocentric longitude, illumination phase angle, and wavelength. The data span a range of wavelengths from 400-950nm and predominantly phase angles from 0-25 degrees, with some constraining observations near 60-140 degrees. Despite the similarity in size and density between the moons, surface inhomogeneities result in significant changes in the disk-integrated reflectivity with planetocentric longitude and phase angle. We find that these changes are sufficient to determine the rotational periods of the moon. We also find that at low phase angles the surface can produce reflectivity variations of 8-36% and the limited high phase angle observations suggest variations will have proportionally larger amplitudes at higher phase angles. Additionally, all the Galilean satellites are darker than predicted by an idealized Lambertian model at the phases most likely to be observed by direct-imaging missions. If Earth-size exoplanets have surfaces similar to that of the Galilean moons, we find that future direct imaging missions will need to achieve precisions of less than 0.1\,ppb. Should the necessary precision be achieved, future exoplanet observations could exploit similar observation schemes to deduce surface variations, determine rotation periods, and potentially infer surface composition. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 21 pages, 7 tables, 15 figures, including machine-readable table, accepted to AJ

Tentative Evidence for Water Vapor in the Atmosphere of the Neptune-Size Exoplanet HD 106315 c

Authors: Laura Kreidberg, Paul Mollière, Ian J. M. Crossfield, Daniel P. Thorngren, Yui Kawashima, Caroline V. Morley, Björn Benneke, Thomas Mikal-Evans, David Berardo, Molly Kosiarek, Varoujan Gorjian, David R. Ciardi, Jessie L. Christiansen, Diana Dragomir, Courtney D. Dressing, Jonathan J. Fortney, Benjamin J. Fulton, Thomas P. Greene, Kevin K. Hardegree-Ullman, Andrew W. Howard, Steve B. Howell, Howard Isaacson, Jessica E. Krick, John H. Livingston, Joshua D. Lothringer , et al. (5 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present a transmission spectrum for the Neptune-size exoplanet HD 106315 c from optical to infrared wavelengths based on transit observations from the Hubble Space Telescope/Wide Field Camera 3, K2, and Spitzer. The spectrum shows tentative evidence for a water absorption feature in the $1.1 - 1.7μ$m wavelength range with a small amplitude of 30 ppm (corresponding to just $0.8 \pm 0.04$ atmosph… ▽ More We present a transmission spectrum for the Neptune-size exoplanet HD 106315 c from optical to infrared wavelengths based on transit observations from the Hubble Space Telescope/Wide Field Camera 3, K2, and Spitzer. The spectrum shows tentative evidence for a water absorption feature in the $1.1 - 1.7μ$m wavelength range with a small amplitude of 30 ppm (corresponding to just $0.8 \pm 0.04$ atmospheric scale heights). Based on an atmospheric retrieval analysis, the presence of water vapor is tentatively favored with a Bayes factor of 1.7 - 2.6 (depending on prior assumptions). The spectrum is most consistent with either enhanced metallicity, high altitude condensates, or both. Cloud-free solar composition atmospheres are ruled out at $>5σ$ confidence. We compare the spectrum to grids of cloudy and hazy forward models and find that the spectrum is fit well by models with moderate cloud lofting or haze formation efficiency, over a wide range of metallicities ($1 - 100\times$ solar). We combine the constraints on the envelope composition with an interior structure model and estimate that the core mass fraction is $\gtrsim0.3$. With a bulk composition reminiscent of that of Neptune and an orbital distance of 0.15 AU, HD 106315 c hints that planets may form out of broadly similar material and arrive at vastly different orbits later in their evolution. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Submitted to AAS journals; 19 pages, 12 figures

Aerosol Composition of Hot Giant Exoplanets Dominated by Silicates and Hydrocarbon Hazes

Authors: Peter Gao, Daniel P. Thorngren, Elspeth K. H. Lee, Jonathan J. Fortney, Caroline V. Morley, Hannah R. Wakeford, Diana K. Powell, Kevin B. Stevenson, Xi Zhang

Abstract: Aerosols are common in the atmospheres of exoplanets across a wide swath of temperatures, masses, and ages. These aerosols strongly impact observations of transmitted, reflected, and emitted light from exoplanets, obfuscating our understanding of exoplanet thermal structure and composition. Knowing the dominant aerosol composition would facilitate interpretations of exoplanet observations and theo… ▽ More Aerosols are common in the atmospheres of exoplanets across a wide swath of temperatures, masses, and ages. These aerosols strongly impact observations of transmitted, reflected, and emitted light from exoplanets, obfuscating our understanding of exoplanet thermal structure and composition. Knowing the dominant aerosol composition would facilitate interpretations of exoplanet observations and theoretical understanding of their atmospheres. A variety of compositions have been proposed, including metal oxides and sulphides, iron, chromium, sulphur, and hydrocarbons. However, the relative contributions of these species to exoplanet aerosol opacity is unknown. Here we show that the aerosol composition of giant exoplanets observed in transmission is dominated by silicates and hydrocarbons. By constraining an aerosol microphysics model with trends in giant exoplanet transmission spectra, we find that silicates dominate aerosol opacity above planetary equilibrium temperatures of 950 K due to low nucleation energy barriers and high elemental abundances, while hydrocarbon aerosols dominate below 950 K due to an increase in methane abundance. Our results are robust to variations in planet gravity and atmospheric metallicity within the range of most giant transiting exoplanets. We predict that spectral signatures of condensed silicates in the mid-infrared are most prominent for hot (>1600 K), low-gravity (<10 m s$^{-2}$) objects. △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 32 pages, 4 main text figures, 7 supplementary figures, 4 supplementary tables, published in Nature Astronomy

Re-inflation of warm and hot Jupiters

Authors: Thaddeus D. Komacek, Daniel P. Thorngren, Eric D. Lopez, Sivan Ginzburg

Abstract: Understanding the anomalous radii of many transiting hot gas giant planets is a fundamental problem of planetary science. Recent detections of re-inflated warm Jupiters orbiting post-main-sequence stars and the re-inflation of hot Jupiters while their host stars evolve on the main-sequence may help constrain models for the anomalous radii of hot Jupiters. In this work, we present evolution models… ▽ More Understanding the anomalous radii of many transiting hot gas giant planets is a fundamental problem of planetary science. Recent detections of re-inflated warm Jupiters orbiting post-main-sequence stars and the re-inflation of hot Jupiters while their host stars evolve on the main-sequence may help constrain models for the anomalous radii of hot Jupiters. In this work, we present evolution models studying the re-inflation of gas giants to determine how varying the depth and intensity of deposited heating affects both main-sequence re-inflation of hot Jupiters and post-main-sequence re-inflation of warm Jupiters. We find that deeper heating is required to re-inflate hot Jupiters than is needed to suppress their cooling, and that the timescale of re-inflation decreases with increasing heating rate and depth. We find a strong degeneracy between heating rate and depth, with either strong shallow heating or weak deep heating providing an explanation for main-sequence re-inflation of hot Jupiters. This degeneracy between heating rate and depth can be broken in the case of post-main-sequence re-inflation of warm Jupiters, as the inflation must be rapid to occur within post-main-sequence evolution timescales. We also show that the dependence of heating rate on incident stellar flux inferred from the sample of hot Jupiters can explain re-inflation of both warm and hot Jupiters. TESS will obtain a large sample of warm Jupiters orbiting post-main-sequence stars, which will help to constrain the mechanism(s) causing the anomalous radii of gas giant planets. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2021; v1 submitted 10 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 13 figures, updated to reflect published version

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, 893:36, 2020 April 10

An Empirical Mass-Radius Relation for Cool Giant Planets

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Mark S. Marley, Jonathan J. Fortney

Abstract: Probabilistic relationships between the mass and radius of planets are useful for a variety of purposes, including estimating the yields of planet discovery efforts and the radii of discovered planets given their masses. Previous work on giant planets often do not make the important distinction between cool and (inflated) hot giants. This can lead to needlessly large uncertainties and overestimate… ▽ More Probabilistic relationships between the mass and radius of planets are useful for a variety of purposes, including estimating the yields of planet discovery efforts and the radii of discovered planets given their masses. Previous work on giant planets often do not make the important distinction between cool and (inflated) hot giants. This can lead to needlessly large uncertainties and overestimated radii for the cooler objects. Using hierarchical bayesian modeling and the AIC model selection criterion, we identify an empirical mass-radius relationship for cool giant planets above 15 Earth masses. It takes the form of a quadratic function in log mass, with a power-law dispersion. Parametric uncertainties from MCMC are provided, and we compare our results with the outputs of interior structure models and the radii of the solar system giant planets, which fit comfortably within our relation. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: Two pages, one figure

Investigating Trends in Atmospheric Compositions of Cool Gas Giant Planets Using Spitzer Secondary Eclipses

Authors: Nicole L. Wallack, Heather A. Knutson, Caroline V. Morley, Julianne I. Moses, Nancy H. Thomas, Daniel P. Thorngren, Drake Deming, Jean-Michel Désert, Jonathan J. Fortney, Joshua A. Kammer

Abstract: We present new 3.6 and 4.5 micron secondary eclipse measurements for five cool (less than approximately 1000 K) transiting gas giant planets: HAT-P-15b, HAT-P-17b, HAT-P-18b, HAT-P-26b, and WASP-69b. We detect eclipses in at least one bandpass for all planets except HAT-P-15b. We confirm and refine the orbital eccentricity of HAT-P-17b, which is also the only planet in our sample with a known oute… ▽ More We present new 3.6 and 4.5 micron secondary eclipse measurements for five cool (less than approximately 1000 K) transiting gas giant planets: HAT-P-15b, HAT-P-17b, HAT-P-18b, HAT-P-26b, and WASP-69b. We detect eclipses in at least one bandpass for all planets except HAT-P-15b. We confirm and refine the orbital eccentricity of HAT-P-17b, which is also the only planet in our sample with a known outer companion. We compare our measured eclipse depths in these two bands, which are sensitive to the relative abundances of methane versus carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, respectively, to predictions from 1D atmosphere models for each planet. For planets with hydrogen-dominated atmospheres and equilibrium temperatures cooler than approximately 1000 K, this ratio should vary as a function of both atmospheric metallicity and the carbon-to-oxygen ratio. For HAT-P-26b, our observations are in good agreement with the low atmospheric metallicity inferred from transmission spectroscopy. We find that all four of the planets with detected eclipses are best matched by models with relatively efficient circulation of energy to the nightside. We see no evidence for a solar-system-like correlation between planet mass and atmospheric metallicity, but instead identify a potential (1.9 sigma) correlation between the inferred methane/(carbon monoxide + carbon dioxide) ratio and stellar metallicity. Our ability to characterize this potential trend is limited by the relatively large uncertainties in the stellar metallicity values. Our observations provide a first look at the brightness of these planets at wavelengths accessible to the James Webb Space Telescope, which will be able to resolve individual methane, carbon monoxide, and carbon dioxide bands and provide much stronger constraints on their atmospheric compositions. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 24 pages, 25 figures, accepted for publication in AJ

The Intrinsic Temperature and Radiative-Convective Boundary Depth in the Atmospheres of Hot Jupiters

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Peter Gao, Jonathan J. Fortney

Abstract: In giant planet atmosphere modelling, the intrinsic temperature $T_\mathrm{int}$ and radiative-convective boundary (RCB) are important lower boundary conditions. Often in one-dimensional radiative-convective models and in three-dimensional general circulation models it is assumed that $T_\mathrm{int}$ is similar to that of Jupiter itself, around 100 K, which yields a RCB around 1 kbar for hot Jupi… ▽ More In giant planet atmosphere modelling, the intrinsic temperature $T_\mathrm{int}$ and radiative-convective boundary (RCB) are important lower boundary conditions. Often in one-dimensional radiative-convective models and in three-dimensional general circulation models it is assumed that $T_\mathrm{int}$ is similar to that of Jupiter itself, around 100 K, which yields a RCB around 1 kbar for hot Jupiters. In this work, we show that the inflated radii, and hence high specific entropy interiors, of hot Jupiters suggest much higher $T_\mathrm{int}$ values. Assuming the effect is primarily due to current heating (rather than delayed cooling), we derive an equilibrium relation between $T_\mathrm{eq}$ and $T_\mathrm{int}$, showing that the latter can take values as high as 700 K. In response, the RCB moves upward in the atmosphere. Using one-dimensional radiative-convective atmosphere models, we find RCBs of only a few bars, rather than the kilobar typically supposed. This much shallower RCB has important implications for the atmospheric structure, vertical and horizontal circulation, interpretations of phase curves, and the effect of deep cold traps on cloud formation. △ Less

Submitted 15 January, 2020; v1 submitted 17 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures, accepted to ApJ Letters. This version corrects the constants in equation 3; our calculations used the form in equation 2, so none of our other results are changed. An corresponding erratum has been submitted to ApJ Letters

Connecting Giant Planet Atmosphere and Interior Modeling: Constraints on Atmospheric Metal Enrichment

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Jonathan J. Fortney

Abstract: Atmospheric characterization through spectroscopic analysis, an essential tool of modern exoplanet science, can benefit significantly from the context provided by interior structure models. In particular, the planet's bulk metallicity $Z_p$ places an upper limit on potential atmospheric metallicity. Here we construct interior structure models to derive $Z_p$ and atmospheric metallicity upper limit… ▽ More Atmospheric characterization through spectroscopic analysis, an essential tool of modern exoplanet science, can benefit significantly from the context provided by interior structure models. In particular, the planet's bulk metallicity $Z_p$ places an upper limit on potential atmospheric metallicity. Here we construct interior structure models to derive $Z_p$ and atmospheric metallicity upper limits for 403 known transiting giant exoplanets. These limits are low enough that they can usefully inform atmosphere models. Additionally, we argue that comparing $Z_p$ to the observed atmospheric metallicity gives a useful measure of how well-mixed metals are within the planet. This represents a new avenue for learning about planetary interiors. To aid in the future characterization of new planet discoveries we derive analytic prior predictions of atmosphere metallicity as a function of planet mass, and evaluate the effectiveness of our approach on Jupiter and Saturn. We we include log-linear fits for approximating the metallicities of planets not in our catalog. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2019; v1 submitted 28 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: Submitted to ApJ. Revision includes more planets and clarity improvements, scientific results unchanged

Phantom Inflated Planets in Occurrence Rate Based Samples

Authors: L. C. Mayorga, Daniel P. Thorngren

Abstract: The recently launched Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) is expected to produce many new exoplanet discoveries which will be especially amenable to follow-up study. Assessments of the planet discovery yield of TESS, such as Sullivan et al. (2015) and Barclay et al. (2018), will be important for planning follow-up work. Analyzing these predicted planet samples, however, we find that giant… ▽ More The recently launched Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) is expected to produce many new exoplanet discoveries which will be especially amenable to follow-up study. Assessments of the planet discovery yield of TESS, such as Sullivan et al. (2015) and Barclay et al. (2018), will be important for planning follow-up work. Analyzing these predicted planet samples, however, we find that giant planet radii derived from the current bulk transiting planet sample have been used at all potential orbits without accounting for the temperature dependence of radius inflation. These phantom inflated planets (PIPs) make up just over 1.1% of the Sullivan et al. (2015) predicted population and about 8% of the Barclay et al. (2018) sample. Similar population predictions for direct imaging studies should likewise take care not to include inflated planets at large separations as such planets will appear larger and, depending on assumed albedo, brighter and more easily detectable than physically possible. Despite their high false positive rate, giant planets are the testbeds for atmospheric characterization techniques and care should be taken to understand and account for potential contaminating factors in this population. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: Accepted to RNAAS

Estimating the magnetic field strength in hot Jupiters

Authors: Rakesh K. Yadav, Daniel P. Thorngren

Abstract: A large fraction of known Jupiter like exoplanets are inflated as compared to Jupiter. These "hot" Jupiters orbit close to their parent star and are bombarded with intense starlight. Many theories have been proposed to explain their radius inflation and several suggest that a small fraction of the incident starlight is injected in to the planetary interior which helps to puff up the planet. How wi… ▽ More A large fraction of known Jupiter like exoplanets are inflated as compared to Jupiter. These "hot" Jupiters orbit close to their parent star and are bombarded with intense starlight. Many theories have been proposed to explain their radius inflation and several suggest that a small fraction of the incident starlight is injected in to the planetary interior which helps to puff up the planet. How will such energy injection affect the planetary dynamo? In this Letter, we estimate the surface magnetic field strength of hot Jupiters using scaling arguments that relate energy available in planetary interiors to the dynamo generated magnetic fields. We find that if we take into account the energy injected in the planetary interior that is sufficient to inflate hot Jupiters to observed radii, then the resulting dynamo should be able generate magnetic fields that are more than an order of magnitude stronger than the Jovian values. Our analysis highlights the potential fundamental role of the stellar light in setting the field strength in hot Jupiters. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2017; v1 submitted 17 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: Accepted in Astrophysical Journal Letters

Bayesian Analysis of Hot Jupiter Radius Anomalies: Evidence for Ohmic Dissipation?

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Jonathan J. Fortney

Abstract: The cause of hot Jupiter radius inflation, where giant planets with $T_{\rm eq}$ $>1000$ K are significantly larger than expected, is an open question and the subject of many proposed explanations. Rather than examine these models individually, this work seeks to characterize the anomalous heating as a function of incident flux, $ε(F)$, needed to inflate the population of planets to their observed… ▽ More The cause of hot Jupiter radius inflation, where giant planets with $T_{\rm eq}$ $>1000$ K are significantly larger than expected, is an open question and the subject of many proposed explanations. Rather than examine these models individually, this work seeks to characterize the anomalous heating as a function of incident flux, $ε(F)$, needed to inflate the population of planets to their observed sizes. We then compare that result to theoretical predictions for various models. We examine the population of about 300 giant planets with well-determined masses and radii and apply thermal evolution and Bayesian statistical models to infer the anomalous power as a function of incident flux that best reproduces the observed radii. First, we observe that the inflation of planets below about $M=0.5 \;\rm{M}_\rm{J}$ appears very different than their higher mass counterparts, perhaps as the result of mass loss or an inefficient heating mechanism. As such, we exclude planets below this threshold. Next, we show with strong significance that $ε(F)$ increases with $T_{\rm{eq}}$ towards a maximum of $\sim 2.5\%$ at $T_{\rm{eq}} \approx 1500$ K, and then decreases as temperatures increase further, falling to $\sim0.2\%$ at $T_\rm{eff}= 2500$ K. This high-flux decrease in inflation efficiency was predicted by the Ohmic dissipation model of giant planet inflation but not other models. We also explicitly check the thermal tides model and find that it predicts far more variance in radii than is observed. Thus, our results provide evidence for the Ohmic dissipation model and a functional form for $ε(F)$ that any future theories of hot Jupiter radii can be tested against. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2018; v1 submitted 13 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, 14 figures, accepted to The Astronomical Journal. This revision revises the description of statistical methods for clarity, but the conclusions remain the same

The Mass-Metallicity Relation for Giant Planets

Authors: Daniel P. Thorngren, Jonathan J. Fortney, Ruth A. Murray-Clay, Eric D. Lopez

Abstract: Exoplanet discoveries of recent years have provided a great deal of new data for studying the bulk compositions of giant planets. Here we identify 47 transiting giant planets ($20 M_\oplus < M < 20 M_{\mathrm{J}}$) whose stellar insolation is low enough ($F_* < 2\times10^8\; \text{erg}\; \text{s}^{-1}\; \text{cm}^{-2}$, or roughly $T_\text{eff} < 1000$) that they are not affected by the hot Jupite… ▽ More Exoplanet discoveries of recent years have provided a great deal of new data for studying the bulk compositions of giant planets. Here we identify 47 transiting giant planets ($20 M_\oplus < M < 20 M_{\mathrm{J}}$) whose stellar insolation is low enough ($F_* < 2\times10^8\; \text{erg}\; \text{s}^{-1}\; \text{cm}^{-2}$, or roughly $T_\text{eff} < 1000$) that they are not affected by the hot Jupiter radius inflation mechanism(s). We compute a set of new thermal and structural evolution models and use these models in comparison with properties of the 47 transiting planets (mass, radius, age) to determine their heavy element masses. A clear correlation emerges between the planetary heavy element mass $M_z$ and the total planet mass, approximately of the form $M_z \propto \sqrt{M}$. This finding is consistent with the core accretion model of planet formation. We also study how stellar metallicity [Fe/H] affects planetary metal-enrichment and find a weaker correlation than has been previously reported from studies with smaller sample sizes. We confirm a strong relationship between the planetary metal-enrichment relative to the parent star $Z_{\rm planet}/Z_{\rm star}$ and the planetary mass, but see no relation in $Z_{\rm planet}/Z_{\rm star}$ with planet orbital properties or stellar mass. The large heavy element masses of many planets ($>50$ $M_{\oplus}$) suggest significant amounts of heavy elements in H/He envelopes, rather than cores, such that metal-enriched giant planet atmospheres should be the rule. We also discuss a model of core-accretion planet formation in a one-dimensional disk and show that it agrees well with our derived relation between mass and $Z_{\rm planet}/Z_{\rm star}$. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2016; v1 submitted 24 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: Accepted to The Astrophysical Journal. This revision adds a substantial amount of discussion; the results are the same