I have a prepint paper uploaded with open access on arxiv.org. My university also has an open access repository and we are encouraged to upload our prepints also there. Now my question is whether it is allowed to upload the paper from arxiv.org (with the arxiv title page) also to another repository? Do you have any idea? I'd appreciate every comment.
16
-
Of course it is allowed.– darij grinbergCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:05
-
1By "open access", do you mean the preprint was submitted under one of the Creative Commons licenses?– AnyonCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:18
-
Yes it is open access with a CC license– PeterBeCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:18
-
3arXiv expects you to upload the latex source files when available, and pdf only if not. So if you have the source files, you could just compile it yourself, and if not, you have the pdf in its state before the upload anyway. So why do you need to upload the version with the arXiv title page?– GoodDeedsCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 20:01
-
4@DanielHatton "ND" stands for no derivatives. I'd be surprised if there was a CC license not letting users copy the work (would seem to go against their whole ethos), but in any case I only intended the statement to apply to licenses supported by ArXiv: arxiv.org/help/license– AnyonCommented Sep 16, 2021 at 16:54
|
Show 11 more comments
2 Answers
You still hold copyright to things uploaded to arXiv. You have granted them a non-exclusive license only. You retain all other rights. So, yes, the paper is yours to use as you wish.
However, you can't terminate the license you have already given since it is perpetual, so you can't now give an "exclusive" license to someone else. If you transfer copyright to another (such as publishing in a journal) you need to inform them of any license(s) you have already granted, since the new holder will also be bound by them.
But, the simple answer is yes. You can do that.
You need to ask arXiv about the title page since they created that. It might be easier to omit that and provide a different one if needed. (Thanks to user Arno for reminding me of this.)
-
This doesn't address whether you can reupload the pdf obtained from the arXiv, which includes arXiv-formatting.– ArnoCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:11
-
@Arno, is the formatting considered a creative contribution? I doubt that is the case. But you are correct that I was referring to the content, not the specific formatted version.– BuffyCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:14
-
Thanks Buffy for your answer. To be totally honest, I do not understand your explanations about abrogating the license. In fact the prepint is currently also under review at a journal and (hopefully) it will be published there. If I understood you correctly in that case I am not allowed to upload the arxiv article in the other repository unless I inform the other repository about a new license whenever the article is published at a journal?– PeterBeCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:17
-
@Buffy I don't know whether the arXiv would have a case for objecting. I'm pretty sure the arXiv doesn't object. But the OP explicitly mentions uploading the copy from the arXiv, rather than an independently compiled version of the same content. Your edit addresses this.– ArnoCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:18
-
1Once you give a license it is permanent. You can't un-give it. You can give other licenses as you choose, but not "exclusive" licenses, since there is already one out there. It is only when you give copyright to a journal that you need to inform them of existing licenses. You don't need to inform everyone when you give a new license. Does that help?– BuffyCommented Sep 15, 2021 at 14:20
Of course, there is absolutely no harm in that. The idea is to get the attention of other researchers. And using multiple platforms will help materialise that better.
In the traditional system, a submitted manuscript receives feedback from 2 or 3 peer reviewers before publication. With a preprint, other researchers can discover your work sooner, potentially pointing out critical flaws or errors, suggest new studies or data that strengthen your argument or even recommend a collaboration that could lead to publication in a more prestigious journal.
-
Thanks Firdous for your answer. Do normally arXiv publications have a DOI? I somehow can't find a DOI on our paper. A DOI would be the best because then I could just use the DOI in my university's repository and not upload the file itself (uploading the file is not as straight forward as one can think because I have to deal with licensing issues as buffy indicated in his/her answer)– PeterBeCommented Sep 16, 2021 at 16:33
-
$PeterBe, kindly go through this: academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62480/… Commented Sep 16, 2021 at 17:04