Theory
It is both. It is the PSU freaking out, which is the expected and planned reaction of hardware pieces. Once in "safety shutdown" mode, you need to either disconnect the PSU for a few seconds or reset a trip switch which is usually on the back1.
Real world
Very cheap PSUs might notnot trip, and just leave the equipment malfunctioning due to insufficient current. This is some manufacturers' interpretation of "improving" the ATX design, reducing the need for resetting the PSU in case of a "temporary" overload. Real ATX supplies will be able to operate at maximum peak for a short time, this peak being above continuous operation spec, without tripping and without being damaged. Everyone wins. Poorly designed units of certain manufacturers that shall not be named simply never trip; when used reasonably, they are identical to real ATX PSUs and cost less.
Worse stillWhen used unreasonably, they might go up in flames, or enter a "spin-up, brown-out, power-down, power-up, spin-up, brown-out..." cycle that occasionally even self-solves and goes on to a proper boot. What is happening here is that the PSU isn't tripping and the equipment is subjected to unplanned wear and tear. In such a case, I'd advise on replacing the PSU altogether. It makes little sense to run through hoops to accommodate what is a misbehaving power supply to begin with. And while you're at replacing the PSU, get a more powerful one, which solves the initial problem.
However, hard disks are a special case, since they are known to have much greater spin-up requirements. So some hard disks (and motherboards) have provisions to handle this by delaying the spin-up, using jumpers that delay the spin-up by a fixed amount of time, or supporting PUIS (also here) or staggered spin-up via backplane signaling. Jumperless solutions require a suitable motherboard, that is capable of sending the appropriate signal to the hard disk (pin 11 of the SATA interface, implemented by WD and others). The software is either left to the user or sometimes implemented in the BIOS.
This has nothing to do with PSUs, but might explain how, in a certain setup, a 350W PSU might not trip when powering eight hard disks whose combined spin-up power is (I'm using a random number) 400W. That's because the full power drain never materializes, and the hard disks go up two at a time, each drawing a huge current for a few fractions of a second before settling to the normal operational current. Replace the motherboard with one that doesn't handle (or hasn't configured) staggered spin-up, and boom.